Faith & Creed · Quran topic
Atheism
الإلحاد · Ilhad
Ilhad as the Quran uses it: swerving from the truth, its forms, causes, refutation and effects
149 verses · 7 parts · 34 min read
Study guide based on
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
«الإلحاد» · Volume 2
At a glance
The paper defines ilhad as leaning away from what is straight, and in technical use as deviation from Islam or from faith. In the Quran the word keeps this linguistic sense of leaning away from the truth. It sets ilhad beside apostasy, disbelief and swerving, and against uprightness, its opposite.
The paper's longest part traces forms of deviation in the Quran: in Allah's divinity, in His names and attributes, in the revealed scriptures, and in the Sacred Precinct, among polytheists, the People of the Book and misguided sects. It then names causes such as denial, wrongdoing and arrogance, ignorance, extremism, rancor, disease of the heart, misleading and enmity toward Allah.
It closes with the Quran's methods of refuting deviation, including persuasive dialogue, proofs, the challenge of the Quran, calling to Allah's oneness and parables, and the effects of deviation on the individual and on society.
Key verses
- Al-A'raf 7:180: The paper cites this verse for deviation in Allah's names, explaining that denying the meanings of His names is among the greatest deviation.
- Al-Hajj 22:25: The paper uses this verse to show that committing or even intending sin in the Sacred Precinct is deviation in it.
- Al-Ma'idah 5:41: The paper cites this verse for the Jews' deviation in distorting and altering Allah's words.
- Al-A'raf 7:138: The paper cites this verse as an example of ignorance of Allah leading to deviation.
- Al-Ma'idah 5:44: The paper cites this verse on suspending scripture's rulings, explaining it as a warning against exchanging Allah's rulings for bribes and rank.
Words to know
- الإلحاد al-ilhad
Deviation: leaning away from what is straight, and technically deviation from Islam or from faith.
Appears 6 times in the Quran.
Most common forms: يُلْحِدُ (3), مُلْتَحَد (2), إِلْحاد (1)
Root: ل ح د
- الردة al-riddah
Apostasy: returning from Islam to disbelief.
- الكفر al-kufr
Disbelief: denial of the divine oneness, prophethood or the law, or all three; ilhad is one of its forms.
Root: ك ف ر
- الزيغ al-zaygh
Swerving: leaning from truth to falsehood and turning from faith to disbelief.
Root: ز ي غ
- الاستقامة al-istiqamah
Uprightness: following the straight path of the upright religion without veering, the opposite of ilhad.
The concept of ilhad (deviation, atheism)
From the paper: «مفهوم الإلحاد»
Linguistic meaning
The root l-h-d means leaning away from what is straight: an arrow veering from its target, a grave pit cut to the side, turning from the truth and bringing into it what is not of it, violating the Sacred Precinct, and, in religion, attacking it, turning from it and disputing it.
The deviator (al-mulhid) is "one who attacks the religion and leans away from it".
Technical meaning
Technically, ilhad is leaning, transgression and deviation from Islam or from faith. Ibn Ashur explains that since a thing's middle is likened to truth, turning from truth to falsehood was called ilhad, and the word came to mean disbelief and corruption. The technical meaning follows the linguistic one, but is restricted to deviation in Islam.
Ilhad in Quranic usage
From the paper: «الإلحاد في الاستعمال القرآني»
The root l-h-d occurs six times in the Quran, four of them in the form alhada. The forms are:
- The present-tense verb, three times, for example Al-A'raf 7:180.
- The verbal noun (ilhad), once, in Al-Hajj 22:25.
In the Quran, ilhad carries its linguistic meaning: leaning away from the truth.
Related terms
From the paper: «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»
Apostasy (al-riddah)
Apostasy: linguistic meaning
From radada, to return; a person apostatizes (irtadda) when he returns himself to disbelief.
Apostasy: technical meaning
"Returning from Islam to disbelief".
Deviation and apostasy
Ilhad is swerving and deviating from the truth, while apostasy is turning back from Islam; both share in disbelief.
Disbelief (al-kufr): linguistic meaning
Covering and concealing: one who covers his armor with a garment has "covered" (kafara) it, and al-mukaffir is a man covered by his weapons; it is the opposite of faith, since it covers the truth.
Disbelief: technical meaning
"Denial of the divine oneness, or prophethood, or the law, or all three".
Deviation and disbelief
Disbelief is rejecting and denying faith, and ilhad is one of its forms.
Swerving (al-zaygh): linguistic meaning
Zaygh is leaning away from straightness; the word is used of people, of the sun past its zenith and of the eye.
Swerving: technical meaning
Leaning from truth to falsehood, and turning from faith to disbelief.
Deviation and swerving
Both share in deviating from the truth and doubting faith and its foundations.
Uprightness (al-istiqamah): linguistic meaning
Balance (al-iʿtidal).
Uprightness: technical meaning
Following the straight path, the upright religion, without veering right or left, which covers doing every act of obedience, outward and inward, and leaving everything forbidden.
Deviation and uprightness
Ilhad is leaving the truth, while uprightness is holding to it constantly; uprightness means balance and ilhad means deviation, so they are opposites.
Forms of deviation in light of the Quran
From the paper: «صور الإلحاد في ضوء القرآن»
The Quran shows many forms of deviation, chiefly disbelief, associating partners with Allah (shirk), apostasy and hypocrisy; deviation is of two kinds, "deviation into associating partners with Allah, and deviation into associating partners through means": the first cancels faith, the second weakens its bonds without cancelling it; all its forms amount to deviation in belief, conduct and worship.
Deviation in divinity (al-uluhiyyah)
The oneness of divinity (tawhid al-uluhiyyah) is Allah's right alone; no servant may associate another with Him, the One most free of need of partners, and deviation in His divinity is a grave wrong against the Creator. Allah says Ta-Ha 20:14. The paper quotes that the first duty of everyone accountable is to know that there is no god but Allah, alone without partner.
It explains the command to worship here as affirming His oneness and worshipping Him without partner, with prayer for His remembrance, or, it is said, prayer whenever one remembers Him. The verse gathers the foundations of the oneness of divinity: singling Allah out in every act of worship He prescribed, of heart and limbs, associating none with Him and acknowledging no worship of another. The most misguided in this deviation, the paper says, are the People of the Book, the polytheists and the misguided sects that left Islam.
The Quran relates the prophets' stories with their peoples, and every prophet and messenger commanded his people to worship Allah alone.
The messengers' calls
- Nuh to his people Al-A'raf 7:59.
- Hud to ʿAd Al-A'raf 7:65.
- Salih to Thamud Al-A'raf 7:73.
- Shuayb to Midian Al-A'raf 7:85.
Their peoples met these calls with obstruction and harm, except those Allah mercifully granted faith, and deviated from them in several ways.
The polytheists' deviation
The paper says the polytheists' minds sank so far in folly that they worshipped stones instead of Allah.
1. Idol worship
Among their greatest deviation was worshipping idols, though they knew the idols could neither benefit nor harm. Allah says Al-Anbiya 21:52. The paper explains this as devotion to idol worship: they kept idols at home and on journeys, Quraysh even set them inside the sanctuary and the Kaaba, and because their deviation was so great Allah said Al-Furqan 25:3.
Allah also says Az-Zumar 39:3. The paper quotes that they affirmed Allah as Creator of the heavens and earth, yet excused their idol worship as this verse records, which it calls the peak of swerving from a truth they knew.
2. Ascribing the angels and the jinn to Allah
The polytheists deviated by ascribing offspring to Allah, calling the angels His daughters and worshipping them to gain intercession with Him, as they claimed. So Allah said As-Saffat 37:158-159. The paper explains that the disbelievers of Quraysh called the angels Allah's daughters, al-jinnah here being a class of angels called al-junah.
3. Worshipping the angels
The polytheists worshipped the angels as intermediaries and intercessors with Allah, and Allah said Ali 'Imran 3:80. The paper explains this as forbidding the worship of angels and prophets: those who called Isa a god worshipped him, and some disbelievers, the Sabians, took the angels as lords.
4. Deviation in acts of worship
They invented a prayer and supplication of clapping and whistling, deviating from what Allah prescribed. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:35. The paper explains their so-called prayer as whistling and clapping, and it is said they circled the House naked; worship in a manner Allah has not permitted is deviation in His divinity.
5. Forbidding and permitting
The polytheists deviated by permitting and forbidding by whim in the slaughter, eating and inheritance of their livestock, with no divine law, and Allah said Al-An'am 6:138-139. The paper explains that they dedicated forbidden livestock and crops to their idols or the idols' attendants, and made what was in the animals' bellies lawful for males only, aggression against Allah's right to permit and forbid.
The deviation of the People of the Book
The deviation of the People of the Book in divinity took many forms, recorded in many verses. Among the forms of deviation of the Jews and Christians are the following.
1. Deifying Uzayr and Isa (peace be upon him)
The Jews deified Uzayr and the Christians Isa, claiming both were sons of Allah, and Allah said At-Tawbah 9:30. On the occasion of its revelation, Ibn Abbas reports that five men (Sallam ibn Mishkam, Nuʿman ibn Awfa, Muhammad ibn Dihya, Shas ibn Qays and Malik ibn al-Sayf) asked the Prophet ﷺ how they could follow him when he had left their qibla and did not hold Uzayr to be the son of Allah, so Allah revealed the verse.
2. Worshipping rabbis and priests
The People of the Book obeyed their rabbis and priests in whatever they made lawful or forbidden, and this was their worship of them. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:31. The paper cites ʿAdi ibn Hatim, who came to the Prophet ﷺ wearing a gold cross; the Prophet ﷺ told him to throw off this idol, recited this verse, and explained that they did not worship their scholars but followed them in what they permitted and forbade.
3. Rejecting Allah's judgment
Suspending and rejecting the Torah's rulings is one form of the Jews' and Christians' deviation, and Allah said Al-Ma'idah 5:50. The paper explains this as asking whether those who leave Allah's commands want the rulings of the Jahiliyyah, which hold no justice and are governed by whim and compromise.
4. Claiming sonship to Allah
The Jews wrongly and falsely claimed sonship to Allah and His special love, and Allah recorded their claim Al-Ma'idah 5:18. The paper says the context exposes the deviation of Jews and Christians together, a claim it calls brazen folly; Allah commanded His Messenger to refute them with the verse's question, which the paper reads as a rebuke and a warning.
Some forms of deviation are particular to the laws of each of the People of the Book.
The Jews' deviation in divinity
The Quran mentions forms of the Jews' deviation in divinity that show their swerving and error.
1. Altering and distorting Allah's words
The Jews distorted and altered Allah's words, as fabrication and turning from the truth, and Allah described them Al-Ma'idah 5:41. The paper explains that people distort only from fear or greed, and the warning means: do not distort My Book from fear of people, kings and nobles, suspending penalties and devising tricks to drop obligations.
2. Worshipping the calf
Allah speaks of the calf al-Samiri made for them, before their eyes, from their jewelry Al-A'raf 7:148. The paper quotes that al-Samiri shaped the jewelry into a lifeless calf and let air pass through it so it lowed like a cow; it calls worshipping a golden body that can neither benefit nor harm an ugly deviation.
For this they deserved rebuke: how could they take as a god a calf with nothing in it. By this deviation they incurred Allah's punishment and wrath, and Allah said Al-A'raf 7:152.
3. Asking for a god
Allah describes their deviation in asking for a god Al-A'raf 7:138. The paper quotes that those idol worshippers were from Lakhm, camped at al-Raqqa, and it is said their idols were statues of cows; the request is likened to ignorant Bedouins who asked the Messenger of Allah for a venerated tree, a Dhat Anwat, like others had.
The Christians' deviation in divinity
The Christians came close to the Jews in error and swerving from the truth.
1. Deifying the Messiah
The Christians deviated by making the Messiah Isa a god besides Allah, and Allah said Al-Ma'idah 5:17. The paper quotes that Allah reports the Christians' disbelief in claiming divinity for the Messiah, son of Maryam, one of His servants and creatures, exalted is Allah far above that.
The paper calls this among the most misguided deviation, misleading their followers, and quotes that even if most Christians do not hold it, belonging to Christianity and its teachings makes them accountable for it, since accepting disbelief is disbelief.
2. Associating partners with Allah
The Christians deviated through the Trinity (Father, Son and Holy Spirit), ascribing a partner to Allah, and Allah mentioned their disbelief Al-Ma'idah 5:73. The paper explains that they meant Allah, Maryam and Isa were three gods, Allah being one of them. Describing Allah this way is clear deviation in divinity, exalted is Allah far above it.
3. Suspending Allah's judgment
Allah commanded the Christians to judge by the Gospel, but they deviated by judging by another way, and Allah said Al-Ma'idah 5:47. The paper quotes that the verse points to soothsayers who took fees and judged by them and by desires.
The misguided sects' deviation in divinity
Islamic history is full of misguided sects: some Batiniyya deified Ali ibn Abi Talib or the Fatimid al-Hakim bi-Amr Allah and others, ruled by the law of the Jahiliyyah, suspended Allah's judgment, and permitted the forbidden and forbade the lawful.
1. Forbidding the lawful and permitting the forbidden
Permitting and forbidding belong to Allah alone; whoever forbids what He made lawful or permits what He forbade has deviated in His divinity. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:87. And He says An-Nahl 16:116. The paper explains that they declared things lawful and forbidden, such as the bahira and the saiba animals, purely from falsehood, then claimed Allah had commanded it.
This includes issuing fatwas without knowledge, or to serve an aim, champion a school or flatter a ruler.
2. Deviation in sovereignty (al-hakimiyyah)
Judgment is among the most particular attributes of divinity, so Allah said Al-Ma'idah 5:49-50. And He said Al-Ma'idah 5:44. The paper sets beside it the parallel ending of Al-Ma'idah 5:45. And that of Al-Ma'idah 5:47. Scholars hold five views on whom these verses concern:
- The Jews in particular.
- The Muslims.
- The Jews and this community in general.
- The Jews and the Christians.
- The first the Muslims, the second the Jews, the third the Christians.
In sum, whoever abandons Allah's revealed law in judging while denying it and knowing Allah revealed it, as the Jews did, is a disbeliever, and whoever abandons it out of whim without denial is a wrongdoer and transgressor. In all these cases, ruling by other than Allah's revelation is deviation from His religion, judgment and law.
Finally, there are many other forms of deviation in divinity, including directing awe, fear, love, hope, vows, sacrifice, bowing and prostration to other than Allah. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:165. The paper explains that ignorance leads some to take rivals besides Allah, leaders and idols they venerate and obey.
3. Deviation in Allah's names and attributes
Allah's most beautiful names and highest attributes are His alone and must be held as beautiful, perfect and majestic, and any negation (taʿtil), modality (takyif), likening (tamthil) or resemblance (tashbih) in them is a kind of deviation. The paper quotes that Allah made deviation in His names a mark of disbelief: denying that He is named with names indicating attributes established for Him.
Allah says Al-A'raf 7:180. The paper quotes that these names express Allah's attributes, of His essence and His acts, and are fixed by revelation (tawqifiyyah), so He is not called by a name absent from the Quran and Sunnah, such as al-Rafiq, al-Sakhi or al-ʿAqil. The paper cites a hadith from Abu Hurayra that Allah has ninety-nine names, and whoever enumerates them enters Paradise.
To enumerate them is to count them, memorize them and reflect on their meanings. Allah named and described Himself Ta-Ha 20:8. And He said Al-An'am 6:103. And He said Ash-Shura 42:11. These texts show Allah naming Himself with names such as al-Latif, al-Khabir, al-Samiʿ and al-Basir, with attributes such as hearing and seeing, and with nothing like Him; any swerving from this is deviation.
Scholars have described this deviation in several ways. Al-Raghib al-Isfahani gives two forms:
- Describing Him with what is not valid for Him.
- Interpreting His attributes in a way unbefitting Him.
Al-Zuhayli gives three:
- Changing them, as the polytheists did, deriving al-Lat from Allah, al-ʿUzza from al-ʿAziz and Manat from al-Mannan for their idols.
- Adding to them, that is likening (tashbih), describing Him with what He did not permit.
- Taking from them, that is negation (taʿtil), stripping Him of His attributes, like ignorant people who invent supplications calling Allah by other than His names.
In sum, this deviation is adding to His names and attributes, reducing, changing or deriving from them. Negation, distortion, likening and modality led the likeners and negators into deviation, since names are beautiful only through their meanings, and for Allah these are perfection and majesty: He needs no other, and every other needs Him.
Denying the meanings of the most beautiful names is among the ugliest deviation in them. Allah says Al-A'raf 7:180. That is, the paper quotes, denying the meanings of Allah's names is among the greatest deviation. Those who deviated in Allah's names and attributes include the People of the Book, the polytheists and others.
First, the polytheists' deviation in Allah's names and attributes. The Quran mentions many forms of it. One is deriving names for their gods from Allah's names. The paper quotes that those who deviate in His names swerve from the truth by deriving names for their gods from them: al-Lat from Allah, al-ʿUzza from al-ʿAziz and Manat from al-Mannan.
On this Allah said An-Najm 53:19-23. The paper quotes that al-Lat was a feminine form of the name Allah, exalted is He above that, while Manat stood at al-Mushallal near Qudayd between Mecca and Medina, venerated by Khuzaʿa, al-Aws and al-Khazraj before Islam, who began their pilgrimage from it.
Denying the name al-Rahman
The polytheists refused to acknowledge Allah's name al-Rahman, claiming they did not know Him by it, and Allah said Al-Furqan 25:60. And He said Ar-Ra'd 13:30. The paper quotes that they disdained describing Allah as al-Rahman al-Rahim, so at al-Hudaybiyya they refused to write the basmala; it is also said Abu Jahl heard the Prophet ﷺ call on Allah and al-Rahman and said he forbade worshipping gods yet called on two, so this verse was revealed, and Al-Isra 17:110.
Second, the Jews' deviation in Allah's names and attributes. The Quran mentions some of its forms, revealing the swerving and error in their hearts.
Describing Allah as poor
Allah describes Himself as al-Ghani (the Self-Sufficient), the Giver and the Generous, yet the Jews called Him poor, and Allah said of their deviation Ali 'Imran 3:181. The paper quotes that it is said this was revealed about Jews who claimed, when Al-Baqarah 2:245 was revealed, that Allah was asking them for a loan out of need.
Describing Allah as miserly
Allah mentioned the Jews' deviation in calling Him miserly, exalted is He far above it, when He is the Generous Giver, so the curse fell upon them. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:64. The paper quotes Ibn Abbas that they did not mean His hand was literally bound, but that He was miserly and withheld what He has.
Third, the misguided sects' deviation in Allah's names and attributes. Some sects claiming Islam deviated by negation or likening; the paper quotes that whoever negates what He named and described Himself with has disbelieved, and whoever likens His names and attributes to those of created beings has disbelieved and associated partners.
One form of deviation by sects claiming Islam is reinterpretation (al-taʾwil). They interpret Allah's rising over the Throne (al-istiwa) as taking control, to avoid ascribing it to Him, and His elevation as dominance, to avoid ascribing direction and location. Allah says Ta-Ha 20:5. And He says Al-A'raf 7:54. The paper quotes that the Muʿtazila interpreted al-istiwa as taking control, while Ahl al-Sunnah hold it an attribute of Allah, without asking how, to be believed while entrusting its knowledge to Allah.
So no one may name or describe Allah with what does not befit Him, and whoever does so has deviated in His names and attributes.
Deviation in the revealed scriptures
The earlier revealed scriptures suffered much distortion, concealment and denial at the hands of the People of the Book. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:79. Out of His mercy to this community Allah sent down the Quran, guaranteed its preservation, and exposed how the People of the Book had deviated in their earlier scriptures.
The polytheists' deviation in Allah's Book
The polytheists deviated in the Quran by casting doubt on it and attacking it.
1. Attributing the Quran to a foreign tongue
The polytheists deviated by attributing the Quran to a foreign Christian who supposedly passed it to the Prophet ﷺ, and Allah refuted them An-Nahl 16:103. The paper quotes that yulhidun here means they swerve from the truth: leaving the truth that it is speech revealed by Allah to claim a human teacher, which is deviation.
They deviate by attributing Allah's speech, which the Prophet recited to them, to a foreign Roman tongue, though it came down in Arabic, as Allah said Az-Zukhruf 43:3. The paper explains that He revealed it in clear, eloquent Arabic to be grasped and pondered, so attributing it to a foreign tongue swerves from its description as an Arabic Quran.
2. Lying against Allah
An example is Al-Ma'idah 5:103. Al-Qurtubi says the verse means that Allah did not name these, set them as a ruling, or make them an act of worship. Fabricating rulings and attributing them to Allah is deviation in legislation. Second, the deviation of the People of the Book in the revealed scriptures.
The Quran exposed how Jews and Christians corrupted their scriptures and deviated in them by distortion, denial or corrupt interpretation, in the following forms.
1. Disbelieving in Allah's signs
Allah mentioned the People of the Book's disbelief in His signs Ali 'Imran 3:98. And He said Al-Baqarah 2:61. The paper explains this as disbelief in the recited scriptures generally, or the Torah, or verses in it such as those describing the Messenger of Allah ﷺ or stoning, or the Quran; linking the signs to Allah's name adds to the condemnation, and their disbelief in His signs is mentioned first as the gravest of all.
2. Distorting words from their places
Exposing what the paper calls some of the Jews' foul hidden deeds, Allah mentions their deviation in distorting His words Al-Ma'idah 5:41. And He said of them again Al-Ma'idah 5:13. The paper explains that they interpreted His words wrongly and altered them after grasping them, knowingly, as in Al-Baqarah 2:75. One example is Al-Baqarah 2:58-59.
The paper explains that Allah commanded them to enter prostrating, as a sign of humility, and to say hitta, asking that their sins be put down, but they entered otherwise and said something else, changing hitta to hinta (wheat) and saying "a grain in a hair"; another of their distortions lies behind Al-Baqarah 2:104.
Their distortion came after they understood and knew the words, an extreme of deviation. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:75. The paper quotes that the question there expresses improbability or rebuking denial, because of their ugly deviation in their scriptures.
3. Hiding and concealing verses and rulings
An example is Ali 'Imran 3:187. The paper explains this image as their disregarding the covenant entirely and paying it no attention.
Another is concealing the verse and ruling of stoning for adultery: the paper cites Ibn Umar's report that Jews told the Prophet ﷺ that a man and woman of theirs had committed adultery; asked what the Torah says on stoning, they said only exposure and flogging; ʿAbdullah ibn Salam said they lied, and when the Torah was opened one of them covered the stoning verse with his hand until told to lift it; they conceded, the Prophet ﷺ ordered the two stoned, and Ibn Umar saw the man bending over the woman to shield her from the stones.
4. Splitting the Book
The People of the Book divided Allah's rulings, accepting what suited their desires and rejecting what opposed them. Allah said Al-Baqarah 2:85. So Allah warned the believers against accepting part of the Book and rejecting part, as the Jews and Christians did Al-Hijr 15:90-91. The paper explains that they divided it, out of stubbornness and enmity, into a true part agreeing with the Torah and Gospel and a false part contradicting them.
Any Muslim who does the same, taking some of the Quran's rulings and leaving others, deviates in the Quran like the Jews and Christians.
5. Denying the prophethood of Muhammad ﷺ
Among these is Ali 'Imran 3:81. The paper explains that the confirming messenger is Muhammad ﷺ, who brought the Quran confirming the Torah's reports and stories; the prophets affirmed their pledge to have faith in and aid him, and Allah told them to witness over themselves and their followers.
It is also said that the covenant bound them to believe in Muhammad ﷺ. Malik ibn al-Sayf swore that no covenant about Muhammad had been made with them, so Allah revealed Al-Baqarah 2:100.
6. Falsifying the writing of scripture
An example is Al-Baqarah 2:79. The paper explains that they wrote the distorted text or deviant interpretations by their own hands; attributing these openly to Allah is worse than the distortion itself, and they did it for a price, the bribes they took for it. This falsification of scripture is clear deviation from the truth revealed by Allah, and includes:
- Suspending scripture's rulings: judging by other than Allah's Book is deviation from it, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:44; the paper explains this as a warning against exchanging His rulings for bribes and rank, and says those who abandon them in contempt and denial are called disbelievers, wrongdoers and transgressors for their contempt and rebellion.
- Twisting the tongue with scripture: inserting into the scriptures what is not of them and twisting their tongues to distort its true meaning, as in Ali 'Imran 3:78; the paper explains that twisting (al-layy) is turning aside, distorting words from their intent.
- The paper also cites An-Nisa 4:46, explaining the twisting there as stubborn turning from the truth.
Third, the misguided sects' deviation in Allah's Book. One form of the misguided sects' deviation is deviant interpretation of Quranic verses. An example is Fussilat 41:40. The paper explains that they swerve from soundness in interpreting the Quran, putting words out of place and distorting the verses that point to His power and wisdom; they are not hidden from Him and He will requite them, a severe warning that calls for caution, and so Allah exposed and warned them.
Deviation in the Sacred Precinct (al-haram)
The Meccan Sacred Precinct is among the places most sacred and honored before Allah. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:97. He blessed this House and placed signs in it for people, saying Ali 'Imran 3:96-97. He made all of Mecca a safe sanctuary in honor of the Sacred House, saying An-Naml 27:91. The paper explains that it is sacred, in law and decree, by His making it so, and cites Ibn Abbas's report that at the opening of Mecca the Prophet ﷺ said Allah made it sacred from the creation of the heavens and earth until the Day of Resurrection, so its thorn trees are not cut nor its game startled.
Allah also says Al-Qasas 28:57. Allah granted them a land that is a safe sanctuary, secure from enemies, and Quraysh traveled and traded in safety because they belonged to the Meccan Precinct.
Forms of deviation in the Sacred Precinct
1. Killing game in the Precinct
The Quran forbids hunting in the Precinct and in the state of consecration (ihram), saying Al-Ma'idah 5:95. And Al-Ma'idah 5:96. Killing game in the Precinct is deviation in it, because it violates its sanctity.
2. Barring people from the Sacred Mosque
Barring people from praying in the Sacred Mosque or making pilgrimage to it is deviation, and Allah warned against it. Allah says Al-Hajj 22:25. Allah censured the Meccans for barring the Prophet ﷺ and his Companions from ʿumrah and the House at al-Hudaybiyya, saying Al-Fath 48:25. The paper quotes that this means the disbelievers of Mecca, who prevented them from circling the House and completing their ʿumrah to leave consecration, and cites Al-Baqarah 2:114.
Those meant there, it quotes, are the polytheists when they barred the Messenger of Allah ﷺ from the House on the day of al-Hudaybiyya.
3. Committing or intending sins in the Precinct
Committing sins, minor or major, in the Precinct, or resolving on them there, is deviation in it and violates its sanctity, so Allah said Al-Hajj 22:25. The paper explains this as turning from the right course, doing wrong, or deliberately resolving there on a major sin, which is particular to the Precinct.
It is also said to mean inclining to wrong and aggression, or major sins; wrongdoing here covers all sins from disbelief to minor ones, and because the place is so sacred, Allah threatened even an evil intention in it. Muslims know that sins are graver in the Precinct, just as good deeds there are multiplied, by the blessing and sanctity of the place.
Causes of deviation
From the paper: «أسباب الإلحاد»
People's deviation in religion has many causes; it runs against sound natural disposition (al-fitrah), and only someone deviant in mind or heart takes its path; its causes include the following.
Denial (al-juhud)
Denial is refusing to believe in the messengers and rejecting the signs they brought, while knowing the messengers are truthful. Allah says of the people of ʿAd Hud 11:59. The paper sums this up as denying their Lord's signs, disobeying His messengers and following tyrants among His servants.
And Allah says Al-An'am 6:33.
Wrongdoing and arrogance
Wrongdoing (al-zulm) is diminishing rights, and arrogance (al-ʿuluw) is pride. An example is An-Naml 27:13-14. The paper quotes that wrongdoing and arrogance were what drove them to their denial. Their deviation belittled the signs and showed pride toward them despite their clarity. Another example is Hud 11:53. That is, the paper quotes, out of persistence in disbelief.
And Allah says Az-Zukhruf 43:31. The paper quotes a report that al-Walid ibn al-Mughira used to say that if what Muhammad said were true it would have been revealed to him or to Abu Masʿud, so Allah said Az-Zukhruf 43:32, meaning prophethood, as if they could place it where they wished.
The paper attributes this to the disease of pride in al-Walid's heart, his wrongdoing and arrogance, which led him to deviation.
Ignorance
Ignorance is lack of knowledge and poor judgment, as in Al-A'raf 7:138. The paper quotes that they were ignorant of Allah's greatness and His due right over them, not knowing that worship is owed to none but Allah, to whom the heavens and earth belong; their ignorance of Allah drove them to deviation.
Extremism (al-ghuluw)
Extremism is going beyond bounds, or neglecting and falling short in what is required, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:77. The paper quotes that they contradicted the truth in their religion, then went to extremes in it by persisting. Extremism is hair-splitting rigidity in religion, excess and neglect.
Rancor and hatred
These are diseases of the heart involving malice and hatred, as in Al-Baqarah 2:109. The paper quotes that though they found Muhammad described as Messenger of Allah in their Torah and Gospel, they disbelieved in him out of envy and aggression because he was not one of them; their rancor aims to turn the believers from Allah's path, strip them of faith's blessings and make them like the Jews in their deviation.
Disease of the heart
This means not a bodily but a spiritual disease, as in Al-Baqarah 2:88. The paper quotes that they claimed their hearts were in coverings and wrappings, as though deviation were a heart disease that veils them from faith.
Deviation through misleading
Misleading is driving people to falsehood, here by commanding them to make idols equal to Allah, which is deviation. An example is Ash-Shu'ara 26:98-99. The paper quotes that the wrongdoers who misled them were their leaders and elders, who led them to equate their gods with the Lord of the Worlds, as in Al-An'am 6:1.
That is, the paper quotes, they set idols equal to their Lord, a deviation by which they strayed and misled others, dictated by the criminal deviators.
Enmity toward Allah, His angels and His messengers
An example is Al-Baqarah 2:98. The paper quotes that this means stubborn opposition to Allah, or enmity to His close servants. The deviator is their enemy, disbelieving in them and opposing them. Through these causes the Quran directs us to check our hearts for diseases such as denial, wrongdoing, arrogance and pride, which lead to deviation; the cure is healing through the Quran, which guides to faith and oneness, and not following whims and desires; safety lies in following the guidance the Prophet ﷺ brought from Allah.
Guidance and faith are blessings from Allah that call for praise, for He protects believers from the deviation that clouds life and lets them live by faith's light.
The Quran's method in refuting deviation
From the paper: «منهج القرآن في إبطال الإلحاد»
The Quran follows many methods to refute deviation, bringing proofs to overturn it and to answer those who deny Allah's existence, among them the following.
Persuasive dialogue
This is arguing in the best way, presenting evidence objectively and rationally to establish the proof against the deviators, and the Quran records many such arguments between Allah's prophets and their peoples and opponents. One is the argument of Ibrahim (peace be upon him) Al-An'am 6:83. The Quran tells of Ibrahim's arguments elsewhere, including his dialogue with Nimrod and the proof established against him Al-Baqarah 2:258.
And his dialogue with his father and his people Ash-Shu'ara 26:69-74. And Al-Anbiya 21:62-67. Despite the clear evidence they deviated and disbelieved; this is the Quran's method of confronting deviation through persuasive dialogue, setting out proofs and establishing the argument. Another is Musa's dialogue with Pharaoh, silencing him with evidence and proof.
Allah says of it Ash-Shu'ara 26:23-33. Dialogue, intellectual, logical and scientific, is one of the Quran's ways of refuting intellectual deviation.
Presenting proofs and evidence
Many verses carry clear proof of Allah's oneness, answering those who deviate in His divinity, denying that He has a child, and showing that the universe would be ruined if He had partners. An example is Al-Mu'minun 23:91. The paper quotes that if there were several gods, each would keep to what it created and existence would not hold together, yet we see it ordered and harmonious, the upper and lower worlds bound together in utmost perfection.
Allah also says Al-Isra 17:42. And Al-Anbiya 21:21-22. The paper quotes that Allah thus sets out examples to make this truth plain by reason and revelation: there is no god but Allah, and taking gods beside Him is false, which answers those who say Uzayr or the Messiah is the son of Allah, or take angels as gods.
This is the Quran's method of refuting deviation with clear proofs.
Challenge and inimitability
The Quran challenged all creation to match it, in whole or in part, and they could not; this lasting challenge is one of its ways of answering the deviators in every time and place. An example is Hud 11:13-14. The paper quotes that they were first challenged to produce the like of the Quran, then ten surahs, then one surah, then even a discourse like it, and could not, and this verse is the second stage, ten surahs.
Another example is Al-Hajj 22:73. The paper explains this as a parable of their helplessness to create even a fly or to recover what it takes from them, weak as it is; they were ignorant in associating partners with Allah, who alone brings all things into being, while statues are the most powerless of things, unable even to fend off a fly.
Creation's inability to meet the Quran's continuing challenge is among the most important ways of refuting deviation, and this inimitability turns the deviators' schemes back on them.
Calling to Allah's oneness
Calling people to Allah is among the Quran's most important ways of guiding them to their Lord and away from deviation, for it lights the path into faith; the Quran's method is to call the polytheists in general to His oneness and worship, and to renew the call to faith for the People of the Book.
An example is Ali 'Imran 3:64. Calling to Allah is a deep-rooted Quranic method of refuting deviation, the path the prophets walked to guide their followers and establish the proof against them on the Day of Resurrection.
Striking parables
Parables are among the most striking ways the Quran brings meanings close to the mind, to persuade people and answer the deviators' doubts and departure from the straight path. An example is An-Nur 24:39-40. The paper quotes that this shows the deeds of the disbelievers and their outcome, since they were not done in faith: their state is likened to someone at sea hoping to reach a goal who finds himself in darkness upon darkness with no way through, an abstract state likened to a sensory one.
These are some of the Quran's means of treating and refuting deviation, guiding people to what sets them right; whoever turns away rejects Allah's proof and goes further in deviation from the path the messengers brought. These methods show us the way: to approach the Quran with an open heart and no prior judgment, to draw on its varied ways of answering the deviators' doubts, and to treat the diseases of their hearts and confusion of their minds; Allah created people on a sound natural disposition, and deviation is acquired and can be treated by calling to Allah.
Effects of deviation on the individual and society
From the paper: «آثار الإلحاد على الفرد والمجتمع»
Deviation harms the life of the individual and society, since it swerves from sound natural disposition; good comes only from holding to Allah's religion, His oneness and His worship as He commanded, and whoever turns from them ruins his worldly life and his Hereafter.
Effects on the individual
Deviation harms the individual's life, self and livelihood.
1. A life of hardship
Allah warns whoever turns from Him and deviates in His religion of a troubled, hard life as its result. Allah says Ta-Ha 20:124. The paper quotes that a life of hardship means the doors of good close on him so he finds his way to none of them, and his living is unlawful gain he runs after.
2. A constricted heart
The believer's heart is opened by faith, while the wide world and his own self close in on the one astray through his disbelief and deviation. Allah says Al-An'am 6:125. The paper quotes that Allah opens the believer's heart to faith and its light, so he believes, does good and finds happiness, while whoever seeks error is given its means, his heart left with no room for faith; this is His way in guiding and leaving astray.
Deviation shows in the deviator as a constricted heart, anxiety and turmoil, because faith is lost.
3. Sealed senses
Allah seals the deviator's senses, so he does not understand, see or hear, because of his denial and swerving. Allah says Al-A'raf 7:179. The paper explains that they do not see the signs of Allah's power with eyes that take lesson, nor hear the verses and admonitions with ears that reflect, and are like livestock in failing to understand, rather, further astray than livestock.
The deviator does not sense the Creator's power spread through the universe, nor heed the verses he hears, for his heart is sealed by his disbelief and deviation.
4. Error and misery
Error and misery are inseparable companions, and the deviator's deviation brings both upon him, so he is not guided, as Allah says Al-A'raf 7:186. And He says Ta-Ha 20:123. The cause of error and lack of guidance is deviation in divinity, as Allah says Al-An'am 6:56. The deviator is not guided to truth and faith, so he is a creature astray and miserable.
5. Confusion, wavering and turmoil
The believer keeps to his path, relying on his Lord, in whose hand is all benefit and harm, while the deviator aims only at his desires, left confused with nothing to rely on. Allah says Al-An'am 6:71. The paper quotes this as asking whether believers should return to disbelief after guidance, robbed of reason and lost; whoever calls on other than Allah is a deviator relying on what can neither harm nor benefit him, left confused with no guide.
6. Stumbling through life
The believer lives a life of light and walks with steady steps, while the deviator stumbles in the darkness of deviation unable to get out, never satisfied by worldly debris. Allah says Al-An'am 6:122. The paper quotes that this is one dead in disbelief whom Allah revived with guidance and the light of faith, unlike the disbeliever stuck in darkness; as faith was made beautiful to believers, disbelief and sins were made attractive to disbelievers.
The deviator is astray, a disbeliever and miserable, and his deviation brings him hardship, stumbling, turmoil and lack of guidance, because deviation has blotted out his senses, disabling his perceiving and responding to what would set him right.
Effects on society
Deviation's effect on society is very grave, leading to its corruption, ruin and destruction.
1. Lost rights
Deviation in sovereignty, ruling by other than Allah's law, wastes rights among people and corrupts their judgments. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:188. The paper explains this as passing wealth to judges as bribes to win a ruling sinfully, meaning by wrong and aggression such as false testimony or a false oath.
2. Corruption of life
The deviators corrupt society's life, as Allah says Al-Anfal 8:73. By their corruption they earn the corruption of their own lives, for the recompense matches the deed. Allah says Al-A'raf 7:133.
3. A torn society
Holding to Allah's Book unites ranks and society, while distance from His way and deviation in it tear society apart. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:103. Not holding to Allah's rope leads to division; the Quran is Allah's rope to His servants on earth, and refusing to hold to it is deviation in His Book.
4. Humiliation and abasement
Allah gave honor and dignity to the believers of piety and righteousness, and humiliation and abasement to the disobedient and the deviators. Allah says Al-An'am 6:124. The paper quotes that these verses describe part of the order of human society: in every setting there are scheming, criminal leaders who obstruct Allah's messengers and those who call to good; the verse warns that they will meet disgrace before Allah.
A society that deviates from what the messengers brought, denying them as messengers from Allah, brings humiliation and disgrace on its members.
5. Destruction of society
Destruction inevitably follows a society's corruption, deviation and disbelief, for Allah does not set right the work of the corrupt, and those who disbelieve and do wrong are destroyed. So Allah says Al-An'am 6:130-131. And Al-Kahf 18:59. Allah's respite should not deceive them, for their time will come; towns are destroyed for wrongdoing, the deviator wrongs his Lord by diminishing His right, and a wrongful, deviating society heads to destruction.
6. Loss of blessings
Of Allah's complete grace is that He does not strip a people of a blessing until they deviate in His blessings and His religion. Allah gave Sheba as an example Saba 34:15-17. The paper quotes that after describing those thankful for His blessings, Allah follows with those who denied them: when they turned from gratitude, He sent a punishment that took away what He had given them.
7. Barred from the Sacred House
Allah forbade the polytheists to enter the Precinct because of their impurity: for their association of partners and deviation, they are barred until they accept Islam. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:28. The paper quotes that this means they may not enter the Precinct, the Sacred Mosque standing for the whole Precinct, and it is said it means they may not perform hajj or ʿumrah after that year.
8. Barred from Paradise
Among the gravest consequences of deviation and denying Allah's signs is that the deviators and criminals are barred from Paradise on the Day of Resurrection. Allah says Al-A'raf 7:40.
9. Trial (fitnah) in society
Deviation in its many varieties scatters society, kindles trial within it and exposes it to punishment. Allah says An-Nur 24:63. The paper quotes that those opposing the command of Allah or His Messenger should beware of trial of any kind, said variously to be killing, earthquakes, a tyrant ruler, or the sealing of hearts.
The effects of deviation are devastating, while faith protects person and society from life's hardship: the guided believer lives by faith's light, the disbelieving deviator is dead in darkness he cannot leave, and deviation corrupts individuals and groups through its crookedness.
Takeaways
Examine the heart
The paper says the causes of deviation direct us to check our hearts for diseases such as denial, wrongdoing and pride, and to seek healing through the Quran.
Follow the Prophet's guidance
Safety from deviation, the paper says, lies in following the guidance the Prophet ﷺ brought from Allah and not following whims and desires.
Speak of Allah only as befits Him
No one may name or describe Allah with what does not befit Him; whoever does so has deviated in His names and attributes.
Do not split the Quran
Taking some of the Quran's rulings and leaving others is, the paper says, deviation in the Quran like that of earlier communities.
Deviation can be treated
Allah created people on a sound natural disposition; the paper holds that deviation is acquired and can be treated by calling to Allah.
Reflect
- Which disease of the heart named in this guide, such as pride or envy, do I most need to watch for in myself?
- Do I accept the parts of the Quran that suit me and quietly set aside the parts that do not?
- How do I speak about Allah's names and attributes, and do I call on Him by them?
- When I meet someone who doubts, do I answer with patient, reasoned dialogue?
Every verse in the paper
All 149 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.
Ilhad in Quranic usage «الإلحاد في الاستعمال القرآني»
Forms of deviation in light of the Quran «صور الإلحاد في ضوء القرآن»
Deviation in divinity (al-uluhiyyah) «أولًا: الإلحاد في الألوهية»
20:14, 7:59, 7:65, 7:73, 7:85, 21:52, 25:3, 39:3, 37:158-159, 3:80, 8:35, 6:138-139, 9:30, 9:31, 5:18, 5:41, 7:148, 7:152, 7:138, 5:17, 5:73, 5:47, 5:87, 16:116, 5:49-50, 5:44, 5:45, 2:165, 7:180, 20:8, 6:103, 42:11, 53:19-23, 25:60, 13:30, 17:110, 3:181, 2:245, 5:64, 20:5, 7:54
Deviation in the revealed scriptures «ثانيًا: الإلحاد في الكتب المنزلة»
2:79, 16:103, 43:3, 5:103, 3:98, 2:61, 5:41, 5:13, 2:75, 2:58-59, 2:104, 3:187, 2:85, 15:90-91, 3:81, 2:100, 5:44, 3:78, 4:46, 41:40
Deviation in the Sacred Precinct (al-haram) «ثالثًا: الإلحاد في الحرم»
5:97, 3:96-97, 27:91, 28:57, 5:95, 5:96, 22:25, 48:25, 2:114
Causes of deviation «أسباب الإلحاد»
Denial (al-juhud) «أولًا: الجحود»
Wrongdoing and arrogance «ثانيًا: الظلم والعلو»
Ignorance «رابعًا: الجهل»
Extremism (al-ghuluw) «خامسًا: الغلو»
Rancor and hatred «سادسًا: الحقد والكراهية»
Disease of the heart «سابعًا: المرض القلبي»
Deviation through misleading «ثامنًا: الإلحاد بالتضليل»
Enmity toward Allah, His angels and His messengers «تاسعًا: العداء لله تعالى وملائكته ورسله»
The Quran's method in refuting deviation «منهج القرآن في إبطال الإلحاد»
Persuasive dialogue «أولًا: الحوار الإقناعي»
6:83, 2:258, 26:69-74, 21:62-67, 26:23-33
Presenting proofs and evidence «ثانيًا: إيراد الأدلة والبراهين»
Challenge and inimitability «ثالثًا: التحدي والإعجاز»
Calling to Allah's oneness «رابعًا: الدعوة إلى التوحيد»
Striking parables «خامسًا: ضرب الأمثال»
Effects of deviation on the individual and society «آثار الإلحاد على الفرد والمجتمع»
Effects on the individual «أولًا: أثر الإلحاد على الفرد»
20:124, 6:125, 7:179, 7:186, 20:123, 6:56, 6:71, 6:122
Effects on society «ثانيًا: أثر الإلحاد على المجتمع»
2:188, 8:73, 7:133, 3:103, 6:124, 6:130-131, 18:59, 34:15-17, 9:28, 7:40, 24:63
About this source
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
- Volume
- 2
- Research paper
- «الإلحاد» (Atheism)
Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.
This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.