Faith & Creed · Quran topic
Loyalty
الولاء · Wala'
Loyalty in the Quran: who guards whom, what each allegiance requires and what follows from it
120 verses · 11 parts · 60 min read
Study guide based on
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
«الولاء» · Volume 18
At a glance
The root w-l-y behind loyalty (al-walaʾ) occurs 232 times in the Quran, 124 of them relevant to the topic. In language it rests on nearness, and in technical use it revolves around love and support. The paper treats support as following necessarily from loyalty, and disavowal as its opposite, consisting of hatred and hostility.
The paper says Allah alone is the Walī, with a general guardianship over all creation and a special one for His chosen believers. It then covers the angels' guardianship of the believers, its reasons and effects, and the believers' guardianship, what makes it due, its effects, and the effects of believers' guardianship of disbelievers and wrongdoers.
It goes on to Satan's guardianship, the attributes of his allies and its effects. It then covers the guardianship of disbelievers, hypocrites and wrongdoers. It ends with the methods the Quran uses in speaking of loyalty and the place of loyalty in the Quran's parables.
Key verses
- At-Tawbah 9:71: The paper cites this verse among those stating what makes the believers guardians of one another. It gives as the first reason the religion they embraced. Next come commanding good and forbidding wrong. Then come prayer with zakat and obedience to Allah and His Messenger. It also gives Allah's mercy on them as the first effect of this guardianship.
- Al-Baqarah 2:286: The paper cites this verse to show that the believers always acknowledge Allah as their walī and mawlā. It explains its supplication clause by clause, and the closing request is for help against the disbelievers, who denied His religion and oneness and worshipped others.
- Al-Ma'idah 5:51: The paper gives this verse as the second effect of believers' guardianship of disbelievers, falling into the circle of disbelief. Al-Saʿdi says complete allegiance requires moving to their religion. It is also an example of the Quran's method of prohibition and of threat.
- Al-Kahf 18:50: The paper quotes this verse among the effects of Satan's guardianship. It is an example of the rhetorical question that denies taking Satan and his offspring as guardians, and the paper explains this denial as a bad exchange of Satan's guardianship for Allah's. It is also an example of loyalty in the Quranic parable.
- Al-An'am 6:14: The paper gives this verse as an example of walī meaning the Lord. In discussing Allah's general guardianship, Allah commands His Prophet ﷺ to address the idolaters with it. The paper explains it as refusing to take a god-walī besides the Originator of the heavens and earth. It is also an example of the rhetorical question.
- Al-Baqarah 2:257: The paper cites this verse to show that Allah chose the people of faith and gave them His care and support. It gives protector and supporter among the meanings of Allah being their walī. Al-Saʿdi explains that He brings them from the darkness of disbelief, disobedience and ignorance to the light of faith, obedience and knowledge.
- Al-Baqarah 2:120: The paper cites this verse under following desire as a cause of deprivation of Allah's guardianship. It explains that the People of the Book will not be pleased until the Prophet ﷺ follows their creed. It adds that true guidance is confined to following what Allah ordered, and a severe warning is addressed to the Prophet ﷺ if he thought of following their desires, with an indirect allusion warning his community.
- Fussilat 41:31: The paper cites this passage for the believers' acknowledgment of Allah's lordship and their steadfastness, which are two reasons for the angels' guardianship. It explains the angels' words as meaning that they take charge of protecting and helping the believers in this world and the next.
- Al-Anfal 8:73: The paper uses this verse for the disbelievers' guardianship of one another. It explains that they cooperate to fight the Muslims and are one group against truth and its people. It says the believers who do not practice their own guardianship will fall into persecution (fitna) and corruption on earth. It is also an example of the method of threat.
- An-Nisa 4:144: The paper gives this verse as an example of the rhetorical question, whose aim is denial and stressing the prohibition of taking disbelievers as guardians instead of believers. It explains that Allah forbids believers to accompany and befriend the disbelievers or to divulge the believers' secrets, and asks if they want to give Allah a proof against them.
- Al-An'am 6:128: The paper uses this verse for a dialogue on the Day of Resurrection between Allah and the jinn and humans, showing the effects of the wrongdoers' guardianship of one another. It explains the humans' words as admitting that their sins happened and they reached their appointed term. It explains Allah's reply as the Fire being their abode forever.
Words to know
- الولاء al-walaʾ
From the root w-l-y, whose basic sense is nearness and closeness. In technical use it revolves around love and support, as al-Barakati defines it.
Appears 232 times in the Quran.
Most common forms: وَلِيّ (86), تَوَلَّى (78), وَلَّى (30), مَوْلَى (18), أَوْلَى (11)
Root: و ل ي
- النصرة al-nusra
Aid, from helping the wronged against his enemy. The paper says it follows necessarily from loyalty.
- التعاون al-taʿāwun
Mutual help, which al-Raghib defines as mutual backing. The paper says whoever is loyal to a person helps him and backs him against his enemy.
Root: ع و ن
- البراء al-barāʾ
Disavowal, distancing oneself from something. The paper says it is the opposite of loyalty, consisting of hatred and hostility, so the two cannot coexist.
Root: ب ر ا
The concept of loyalty
From the paper: «مفهوم الولاء»
Linguistic meaning
The word (al-walaʾ) comes from the root w-l-y, whose basic sense is nearness and closeness. It also means those who are allied to someone, and the walaʾ of a freed slave, meaning the one who freed him is first in inheriting from him if he has no heir from his own lineage.
It is also used for succession, one thing following another. From the same root come taking charge of a task, turning away from something, and turning one's back in flight. The walī is the opposite of the enemy. Wilāya means authority and governance, and also support (nusra), as in people who are united in support.
Technical meaning
The technical meaning matches the linguistic one, revolving around love and support. Al-Barakati defines it as love of Allah, His Messenger, Islam and its Muslim followers, and support of them. Mihmas al-Jalʿud defines allegiance (al-muwalāt) as drawing close and showing affection, in words, deeds and intentions, to one's chosen ally. If aimed at Allah, His Messenger and the believers, it is lawful allegiance, obligatory on every Muslim. If aimed at disbelievers, it is allegiance of disbelief and apostasy.
The paper concludes that loyalty is love, affection, following and support, which Islam wanted rooted in Muslims' hearts.
Loyalty in Quranic usage
From the paper: «الولاء في الاستعمال القرآني»
The root w-l-y occurs 232 times in the Quran, 124 of them relevant to the topic. The paper lists the forms in a table, with an example verse for each.
- Past verb: 3 times, for example Al-Mujadilah 58:14.
- Present verb: 11 times, for example Al-A'raf 7:196.
- Verbal noun: 2 times, for example Al-Kahf 18:44.
- Active participle: once, for example Ar-Ra'd 13:11.
- Passive participle: 21 times, for example Muhammad 47:11.
- Resembling adjective: 86 times, for example Al-An'am 6:70.
Loyalty comes in the Quran in four senses.
- First, the Lord (al-rabb), as in Al-An'am 6:14.
- Second, the child, as in Maryam 19:5.
- Third, the helper, as in Ad-Dukhan 44:41.
- Fourth, the master who frees, as in Al-Ahzab 33:5.
Related terms
From the paper: «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»
Support (al-nusra)
Support in language
Al-nusra comes from the root n-s-r; al-nasr is helping the wronged, as in helping someone against his enemy, and the noun al-nusra is aid.
Support in technical use
Al-Munawi says that al-nasr and al-nusra mean aid.
Relation between support and loyalty
The paper says support follows necessarily from loyalty, since loyalty means love and support. Whoever is loyal to a person loves him, which requires approving his actions, supporting him and defending him when he is wronged or the like.
Cooperation in language
Taʿāwanū means they helped one another, and the muʿwān is the one who gives people good help.
Cooperation in technical use
Al-Raghib says that cooperation (al-taʿāwun) is mutual backing (al-tazāhur).
Relation between cooperation and loyalty
The paper holds without doubt that cooperation and mutual backing also follow necessarily from loyalty, since whoever is loyal to a person helps him and backs him against his enemy.
Disavowal in language
Al-barāʾ comes from the root b-r-ʾ and means distancing oneself from something; from it comes recovery from illness, and the adjectives barāʾ and barī, both used in the Quran. Disavowal (al-barāʾa) can be from faults and dislikes.
Disavowal in technical use
Disavowal is defined as the severing of protection (al-ʿisma). Al-Alusi calls it ending the ruling of security and lifting the restriction that followed the earlier covenant. Muhammad ibn Saʿid al-Qahtani defines it as distance, separation and enmity after notice and warning.
Relation between disavowal and loyalty
The paper says the two are contradictory: disavowal is the opposite of loyalty and consists of hatred and hostility, so the two cannot coexist.
The pairing of the Walī with the Nasīr in the Quran
From the paper: «اقتران الولي بالنصير في القرآن»
Allah's name al-Walī or al-Mawlā is paired with His name al-Naṣīr thirteen times in the Quran, for example An-Nisa 4:45. Another example is Al-Hajj 22:78. Another is Ali 'Imran 3:150. The paper recalls that support follows from loyalty, so the name al-Naṣīr follows from al-Walī or al-Mawlā. Al-Biqaʿi, explaining the pairing in the Nisaʾ verse, says walī means one who is near and does all a caring relative does.
He adds that a walī may have strength to support while a supporter may lack the walī's care, and support is what one most needs from a walī, so the verse singles it out to show both attributes together, repeating the verb and the greatest name for emphasis. Allah is the supporter of whoever is loyal to Him, so no one's enmity harms that person; believers should trust His guardianship and support and mind no one.
Al-Shaʿrawi, on the same verse, says Allah suffices as walī because people only possess the means, while Allah created them and owns what is above them. So He reassures us with At-Talaq 65:2-3. He explains that the walī is the one directly near you, and a near person may not support you, whereas Allah is both. In a battle, Allah in effect warns against saying we seek support from anyone: do what you can, then leave what is beyond it to Allah.
Allah's guardianship of His servants
From the paper: «ولاية الله تعالى لعباده»
Discussing Allah's guardianship (wilāya) requires showing that Allah alone is the Walī. His guardianship has two kinds: a general one over all creation, and a special one for His chosen believers. The paper also explains what entitles them to it, and what causes deprivation of it.
Allah is the Walī
Al-Walī is one of Allah's beautiful names. Al-Zajjaj defines it as derived from loyalty (muwālāt): the walī is the supporter, and Allah is the walī of the believers. He supports and guides them as a child's guardian does, and on the Day of Reckoning takes charge of their reward.
It is also said that the Walī is the one who manages the affairs of the world and its creatures. Another name is al-Wālī, the owner of all things who disposes of them. The paper remarks that guardianship combines management, power and action; if one is missing, the name is not applied.
Only two verses affirm that Allah is the Walī, the first being Ash-Shura 42:9. The second is Ash-Shura 42:28. In the first, the pronoun "he" is a separating pronoun giving emphasis and restriction, confining true guardianship to Allah alone, since the idolaters worshipped others. Ibn ʿAshur says it confirms the restriction, with no exaggeration. The paper says this is clear in the second verse, which restricts the attribute of Walī and praise to Allah alone.
For this reason the believers always acknowledge that Allah is their walī and mawlā, as He says Al-Baqarah 2:286. The paper explains that Allah burdens no one beyond capacity, out of mercy; each soul has the reward of its good and the punishment of its evil. He then guided the believers to a supplication He guaranteed to answer. Asking not to be taken to task for forgetting or erring means not being punished for an obligation left or a forbidden act done through forgetfulness or ignorance of the religious duty. A hadith supports this: Allah has overlooked for the Prophet's ﷺ community error, forgetfulness and coercion.
Asking not to be burdened as earlier peoples were means not being given hard tasks, even within capacity, like the Children of Israel. Muhammad's message brings ease and tolerance, a mercy to all nations. Asking not to be burdened beyond capacity refers to obligations, calamities and trials they cannot bear.
Pardon is for disobedience between them and Allah. Forgiveness is for slips between them and His servants, that He not expose their faults. Mercy is for the future, keeping them from other sins. "You are our Mawlā" means the one who manages our affairs, our owner and supporter, in whom we trust, with no power except through Him.
The disbelievers they seek help against are those who rejected His religion and oneness, denied His Prophet's message, and worshipped others with Him. They ask for the final outcome over them in both worlds. The paper concludes that Allah is the Walī of the believers, supporting, guiding and rewarding them, and manages the world as owner of all things.
General guardianship over all creation
Since Allah alone has true guardianship, He is the most worthy of worship, so He rebuked the idolaters for taking gods besides Him, saying Ash-Shura 42:9. The paper adds that He is the true Walī to whom worship is due alone, for He alone can raise the dead.
Likewise He says Ash-Shura 42:28. The paper explains that Allah sends abundant rain after people think it will not come, spreading His mercy by bringing out food for humans and animals, and they rejoice. He is the Walī who manages His servants in many ways and sets right their religion and worldly life, and He is worthy of praise for His management, given His absolute perfection and favors.
In this sense Allah commands His Prophet ﷺ to address the idolaters with Al-An'am 6:14. The paper explains it as: should I take other than Allah as a god-walī whom I befriend with worship and love, and join with the Originator of the heavens and earth, who is self-sufficient, feeds and is not fed. It adds that Muhammad was commanded to submit wholly to this true God.
The paper concludes that Allah alone is the Walī, and His guardianship is unlike any other. He manages creatures' affairs, owns management, and gave creation what benefits them in religion, this world and the next. This guardianship is for all creation, with no distinction between believer, disbeliever or hypocrite, so it is general.
Special guardianship for His friends, and what entitles to it
Allah chose the people of faith and gave them His care and support, and said of them Al-Baqarah 2:257. Several meanings are given for "Allah is the Walī of those who believe", including protector and supporter. He named Himself walī because He manages creatures' affairs of support, protection and provision, and a human walī is so called because he manages people's affairs. The paper explains that He takes charge of them with support and guidance, and alone brings them from the darkness of misguidance to the light of guidance, or of punishment in the Fire to the light of reward in Paradise.
This is Yusuf's prayer Yusuf 12:101. The paper explains that he called on his Lord, who gave him authority and knowledge of dreams and manages his affairs in both worlds, to take him as a Muslim and join him with the righteous. This guardianship needs requirements, as it is not given to just anyone, and there are three.
Faith
Allah says of His guardianship of the people of faith Ali 'Imran 3:68. The paper explains that those most deserving of Ibrahim's support are those who followed his path, affirming Allah's oneness sincerely, then Muhammad ﷺ, the Emigrants, the Helpers and those who followed them. Likewise Allah will support those who believe in Muhammad and what he brought, against followers of other religions who oppose them.
He also says Muhammad 47:11. The paper explains that Allah is the walī and supporter of the believers, and the verse was revealed after Uhud, when the idolaters shouted "a day for a day", meaning Badr, where the Prophet ﷺ had defeated them, and said they had al-ʿUzza and the believers had none. The Prophet ﷺ told the believers to answer that Allah is their mawlā and the idolaters have none.
In contrast, no one helps the disbelievers against Allah. Al-Saʿdi, on Al-Baqarah 2:257, says it includes their own loyalty to their Lord: they take Him as walī and beloved, seek no substitute, associate no one with Him, befriend His friends and oppose His enemies. So He takes charge of them with His kindness, bringing them out of the darkness of disbelief, disobedience and ignorance to the light of faith, obedience and knowledge. In return He saves them from the darkness of the grave, the gathering and resurrection, to lasting bliss, comfort and joy.
The believers are one nation united by faith in Allah and in all He brought, with no distinction of race, color, nationality or homeland, the highest form of human gathering.
Piety (taqwa)
Allah says of His guardianship of the pious Al-Anfal 8:34. The paper explains that Allah would not punish the idolaters while the Prophet ﷺ was among them but will after he leaves. They bar people from the Sacred Mosque, as they barred the Prophet ﷺ and believers in the year of al-Hudaybiyya, claiming to be its guardians who admit and bar whom they wish. Allah replied that as idolaters they did not deserve to be its guardians; its true guardians are the Muslims. It is also said that the two pronouns refer to Allah.
He also says Al-Jathiyah 45:18-19. The paper explains that this speaks of the Children of Israel, favored with the Scripture, judgment and prophethood, who wronged themselves, differed and followed their desires. They will not avail the Prophet ﷺ against Allah, and there is no guardianship between Him and wrongdoers, while He is the Walī of the pious, whose greatest concern is wisdom, through protections saving them from His anger and punishment.
Righteousness (salah)
Allah says through His Prophet ﷺ Al-A'raf 7:196. The paper explains it as the Prophet ﷺ telling the idolaters he does not care for them or their partners, because his walī is Allah, while their partners cannot even support themselves. It is Allah's custom to take charge of the righteous, support them and not forsake them.
Thus the special guardianship of His friends, the pious and righteous believers, becomes clear.
Effects of Allah's guardianship for the believers
When believers take Allah as beloved and walī, take no other, associate nothing with Him, befriend His friends and disown His enemies, He grants them much of His favor, and the effects of His guardianship appear on them.
Among these effects is Yunus 10:62-64. The paper explains that Allah's friends worship Him sincerely, trust in Him and take no rivals, guardians or intercessors besides Him. They have no fear on the Day of Resurrection of the terrors others fear, and do not grieve at harm or loss, since they seek only Allah's pleasure. Nor have they fear in this life of what disbelievers and the weak in faith fear. This is only for those who combine correct faith in Allah, His angels, books, messengers, the Last Day and destiny, good and bad, with piety. Their glad tidings in this life are victory, a good end, and succession on earth as long as they uphold Allah's law, support His religion and raise His word.
Allah also says Al-An'am 6:126-127. The paper explains that the Quran's exposition, the path of oneness and submitting to Allah, is straight, without excess or neglect in belief, morals and deeds, and without crookedness of looking to others and associating partners. Its rulings and laws are detailed and good is distinguished from evil, but this is only for people who reflect, recalling the truths settled in their nature and being guided by them, since they know and benefit from their knowledge.
Allah prepared for them abundant reward, Paradise, called the abode of peace for being safe from every defect, deficiency, affliction, worry and grief of this world, so its bliss is perfect beyond description, of spirit, heart and body. Allah also manages and nurtures them, is kind to them in all affairs, helps them obey Him in this world and eases every way to His love, all because of their righteous deeds done to please their Lord.
The paper cites a hadith qudsi in which Allah says He has declared war on whoever shows enmity to a walī of His. It adds that the servant draws near to Allah with the obligations and then voluntary deeds until Allah loves him, and Allah gives him what he asks and protects him when he seeks refuge.
The paper draws from it that whoever is hostile to a walī of Allah has challenged Allah to war.
Causes of deprivation of Allah's guardianship
From the verses on the topic, the causes of deprivation of Allah's guardianship are as follows.
Disbelief
How can a person who does not believe in Allah have Him as his walī and supporter in this world and the next, as in Al-Ankabut 29:20-23. The paper explains that Allah commands His Prophet ﷺ to tell the idolaters who deny resurrection to travel the earth and see how He began things from nothing, so bringing them back after perishing is not hard for Him. After this He punishes some for their sins and shows mercy to those who repented, believed and did good. He warns them they cannot escape Him, and will have no walī to manage their affairs, nor supporter if He intends them harm, and none to stop His punishment.
Those who disbelieved in His proofs and denied meeting Him despair of His mercy in the Hereafter when they see the painful punishment prepared for them. He also says Al-Ahzab 33:64-65. The paper explains that Allah cursed the disbelievers, forsook them, banished them from His mercy and prepared Hell for them to stay in forever. There they find no near walī to benefit them, nor supporter to protect them from His punishment.
Hypocrisy
The hypocrite shows the opposite of what he hides, showing Islam and hiding disbelief. The paper says his danger to Islam and Muslims is greater than the disbelievers', since his hostility is not clear, and whoever has this trait deprives himself of Allah's guardianship in this world and the next.
Allah says Al-Ahzab 33:13-17. The paper explains that these verses show the hypocrites at the Battle of the Confederates, urging one another to flee when they thought the Muslims would be defeated and they would get no spoils. They excused themselves with exposed houses and lost property, knowing they lied; cowards wanting only to flee, though they had promised Allah not to turn their backs.
When it became serious, truthfulness failed them, and they forgot that Allah would ask them about their covenants and punish them. Allah commands His Prophet ﷺ to tell them that fleeing from death or killing will not benefit them, since appointed times are neither advanced nor delayed, and if they live, their enjoyment will be little. He also tells them who can protect them from Allah if He wants to harm them or fulfil what they hope for, and who can turn an enemy from them besides Him.
Following desire
Whoever does not obey Allah's commands and avoid His prohibitions exposes himself to deprivation of Allah's guardianship, protection, care and support. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:120. The paper explains that the Prophet ﷺ hoped for the People of the Book to believe before others, so their turning from his call weighed on him. Allah wanted to end his hope for their Islam, so tied their pleasure to something impossible. Their aim is not the signs and hard demands they put to him; even if he brought all they asked out of obstinacy they would not be pleased, and Allah told him they will not be until he enters their religion and follows their creed.
Allah then told him to answer with Al-Baqarah 2:120. The paper explains that true guidance is confined to following what Allah ordered, not their distorted books and abrogated laws. Then Allah followed it with a severe warning to the Prophet ﷺ if he thought of following their desires and trying to please them. The paper notes an allusion to his community, warning them against this, for if they do not obey Allah they will find no walī or supporter against His punishment, since Allah told them the truth about the Jews.
The paper then quotes Al-Baqarah 2:120 again. It quotes a comment that this is the original cause: what they lack is not proof or conviction that he is on the truth, and nothing would satisfy them except that he follows their creed and leaves the truth. The comment calls it the permanent knot, seen in every time and place, which is creed, and the reality of the battle Jews and Christians wage in every land and time against the Muslim community.
Allah also says Ar-Ra'd 13:36-37. There are two views on who is meant by those to whom Allah gave the Scripture. The first is the companions of the Prophet ﷺ, to whom Allah gave the Quran and who rejoice in it, while the factions who banded against the Messenger, the Jews and Christians, deny part of the Quran. The second is Muslims from the Jews, such as ʿAbd Allah ibn Salam and his companions, who were troubled over the mention of the name al-Rahman in the Quran, given how often it occurs in the Torah, and rejoiced when it became frequent in the Quran, so Allah revealed the verse.
The factions are the idolaters of Mecca. When the Prophet ﷺ made the treaty of al-Hudaybiyya with them and wrote "In the name of Allah, the Rahman, the Rahim", they objected that they knew no Rahman but the Rahman of al-Yamama, meaning Musaylima the Liar, though they did not deny the name of Allah.
Allah commands His Prophet ﷺ to say Ar-Ra'd 13:36. The paper explains that as He sent down the Quran and the factions denied it, so He sent down judgment and religion in Arabic, attributed to the Arabs because it came in their language, and the factions denied it. Then Allah warns the Prophet ﷺ that if he followed the desires of the People of the Book in religion after the sound knowledge he received, he would find from Him no supporter or protector.
Misguidance
Misguidance is the opposite of guidance and success, so how could Allah be the walī and supporter of one in misguidance?
Allah says Al-Isra 17:97. The paper explains that those Allah guides are the guided, for whom His judgment of faith preceded, so they must become believers. For those on whom His judgment of misguidance preceded, it is impossible that they turn from it or that anyone turn them from it, when He gathers them on their faces in disgrace, blind and dumb, unable to see or speak, with Hell their abode, which Allah kindles whenever it is about to die down. Their punishment is not eased, and Allah does not wrong them but recompenses their disbelief in His signs and denial of resurrection and of His perfect power.
Allah tells of the Companions of the Cave inside the cave, saying Al-Kahf 18:17. The paper explains that the sun inclined away from their cave to the right when it rose and passed them on the left when it set, an honor from Allah so its heat would not harm them. They lay in a wide space where it did not reach them at the start or end of the day, a sign of Allah's great power. Whoever Allah enables to believe and guides to the path of happiness is truly guided, and whoever He misguides for his evil deeds, you will find none besides Allah to guide him.
The paper notes that these youths were keen on guidance and following Allah's religion, so Allah supported them, did not forsake them or let evil hands reach them, and honored them with this great gift. Whoever is truthful with Allah, Allah is truthful with him, and whoever has no inner readiness for guidance finds no walī or guide to the path of guidance and happiness.
Allah also says Ash-Shura 42:44-46. He informs that He alone has guidance and misguidance, and whoever He misguides is so because he wronged himself with sins, so he has no walī to manage his affair and guide him. His misguidance and lack of guidance became a cause of deprivation of Allah's guardianship, as Allah says Al-Ahqaf 46:32.
Wrongdoing
Allah says Ash-Shura 42:7-8. The paper explains that Allah revealed the Quran to the Prophet ﷺ in Arabic, as divine wisdom required choosing the Arab nation to receive Islam first and spread it among the nations. Had all addressed nations been considered, the Quran would have needed countless languages, but Allah chose the best language, as He chose the best of humans to receive it. It warns the idolaters of Mecca and around it of punishment in this world and the next, and of the Day of Resurrection with its terrors, called the Day of Gathering because creatures are gathered for reckoning, one group in Paradise and another in the Fire.
Allah willed this by creating its causes in His wisdom. Had He willed, He would have decreed the causes of their uniting on one belief of guidance, with the same end in Paradise, but He willed otherwise, according to His wisdom. He created them capable of guidance and misguidance, enabled them to earn their deeds, and made clear good from evil. Among them are the guided, whom He willed to enter His mercy, and the wrongdoers, who wronged themselves by depriving them of guidance and wronged others by transgressing their rights. These have no walī to ward off what befalls them and no supporter to avenge them.
Doing evil
Allah says An-Nisa 4:123. The paper explains that salvation and purification do not come through the wishes of the People of the Book, mere fancies devoid of good deeds, which Allah reported in their saying Al-Baqarah 2:111. Mere affiliation to any religion benefits no one without a good deed proving it.
The word "evil" is comprehensive for any sin, small or great, little or much, worldly or other-worldly. People differ in degrees known only to Allah. Whoever's deeds are all evil, which the paper says applies only to the disbeliever, is recompensed with everlasting painful punishment if he dies without repenting. Then he has no walī to obtain what he wants and no supporter to ward off what he fears except Allah. As for one upright in most states who does righteous deeds and commits some minor sins, the worry, grief or harm that befalls him in himself, wealth or family expiates those sins, which Allah decreed out of kindness.
Allah also warns His servants against play and amusement and wasting life on what does not benefit, let alone evil deeds, and commands His Prophet ﷺ Al-An'am 6:70. The paper explains it as: leave those who took their religion, which they should have followed and been guided by, as play and amusement. Because of this Allah sealed their hearts, and they did not work for the day when neither wealth nor children avail except one who comes with a sound heart.
They wasted their lives on the useless, which is play, and busied themselves from earnest work, which is amusement, and worldly life deceived them. The Prophet ﷺ should turn from them and remind with the Quran those who fear Allah's warning, since they benefit from obeying His commands, lest a soul be given up to destruction for what it earned, before the servant plunges into sins and dares against Allah.
He should remind and admonish the soul so it desists from what does not befit believers. If its sins surround it, it will have no walī or intercessor; no relative or friend benefits it, and none besides Allah manages its affair. Even if it ransoms itself with the earth full of gold, it is not accepted. Those so described destroyed themselves and were deprived of good, and their recompense is boiling water, scalding faces and cutting intestines, and painful punishment for their disbelief.
Arrogance
Arrogance prevents its holder from receiving Allah's guardianship, and Allah says An-Nisa 4:172-173. The paper explains that the Messiah will not disdain to be a servant of Allah, continuing worship per the servanthood with which Allah honored His servants, nor will the angels near to Him. Then, as a threat, Allah shows that whoever disdains obeying Him and seeks greatness without right, He will gather all the disdainful to Him for reckoning.
Those who believed and did good, described as not disdaining, Allah will pay their wages in full and increase them from His bounty manifold, with what no eye has seen, no ear heard and no human heart conceived. Those who disdained and rose above worship of Allah and were arrogant, He will punish with a painful punishment beyond description, and they find no walī to manage their affairs and interests, nor supporter to shield them from His might and save them from His punishment.
The angels' guardianship of the believers
From the paper: «ولاية الملائكة للمؤمنين»
This section discusses the reasons for the angels' guardianship of the believers and its effects.
Reasons for the angels' guardianship
From the verses on the topic, the Quran names three reasons that make the angels guardians of the believers. The first is Allah's favor to His prophets with prophethood, revelation and the message. This applies especially to Muhammad ﷺ. The Quran speaks of the angels' guardianship of him, especially Jibril, the trustee of revelation, in discussing something that happened between the Prophet ﷺ and some of his wives.
Allah says At-Tahrim 66:3-4. The paper explains that the Prophet ﷺ confided something to Hafsa. Ibn ʿAbbas explained that one day Hafsa saw him with Mariya, mother of his son Ibrahim, and he told Hafsa not to tell ʿAisha, adding that her father ʿUmar and ʿAisha's father Abu Bakr would take charge of the caliphate after him. But Hafsa did not keep the secret and told ʿAisha.
Allah informed His Prophet ﷺ, who disclosed part of it and avoided mentioning the rest, and he repaid Hafsa by divorcing her once. ʿUmar said that if there were good in the house of al-Khattab, the Messenger ﷺ would not have divorced her. Jibril told him to take her back and interceded for her. Another report says the Prophet ﷺ meant to divorce her until Jibril told him not to, as she fasts and prays much and is his wife in Paradise, so he did not. When he told Hafsa what Allah had shown him, she asked who told him, thinking ʿAisha had, and he said the All-Knowing told him.
Allah then urged Hafsa and ʿAisha to repent of inclining against what the Prophet ﷺ loved, as their hearts swayed from the truth until they liked what he disliked, avoiding his slave-girl Mariya. Then, as a threat, He told them that if they backed each other against the Prophet ﷺ with disobedience and harm, Allah is his walī and supporter and it cannot harm him. Jibril is his mawlā too, along with the righteous believers and the best of them, and all the angels are his helpers, guardians and aides.
The second reason is the acknowledgment of Allah's lordship and submission to His commands by the believers, who are Allah's friends. The third is the believers' steadfastness on the straight path in knowledge and action. These two reasons appear in Fussilat 41:30-32.
The paper says this is always the believers' state: they say their Lord is Allah alone with no partner, then stay steadfast on this oneness and turn to no other god. The exegetes give several meanings of their steadfastness: sincerity of deed to Allah, obeying Him and avoiding disobedience; staying on the testimony that there is no god but Allah until death; their deeds matching their words; turning from all but Allah; and asceticism in this world with desire for the Hereafter.
Nothing prevents all these meanings from being included in steadfastness.
Effects of the angels' guardianship
The effects are as follows. First, the effects are mentioned where the reasons are, in Fussilat 41:30-32. Believers who acknowledged Allah's lordship and oneness, persisted until death, and obeyed His commands and avoided His prohibitions deserve the angels' guardianship. The paper cites a hadith in which Sufyan al-Thaqafi asked the Prophet ﷺ for something to hold on to, and was told to say his Lord is Allah and then be steadfast. Asked what he feared most for him, the Prophet ﷺ took hold of his tongue and said this.
Second, the angels descend to the believers with what opens their chests and removes fears and griefs. They bring good news of deliverance at death, in the grave and at resurrection, and remove fear of the Hereafter's terrors and grief over lost family and children, bringing tranquility. They also tell them to rejoice at entering the Paradise promised through the prophets, to dwell in forever.
Then Allah reports the angels' words, Fussilat 41:31. The paper explains that they protect and help the believers in this world and the next, driving them to rectitude by Allah's command, urging good and warning off evil. In the Hereafter they comfort their loneliness in the graves, are with them at the blowing of the Trumpet, secure them from fear at the resurrection, and take them over the bridge to the Gardens of Bliss. In Paradise they have all they choose and desire, of pleasures no eye has seen, no ear heard and no human heart conceived.
Whatever they wish they get, prepared as hospitality and favor from Allah, who forgave their sins, enabled their good deeds, and accepted them. By His forgiveness He removed what they feared, by His mercy gave what they sought. Third, the angels firm the believers on the battlefields of jihad, as Allah says Al-Anfal 8:12.
The paper explains it as telling the believers to remember Allah's favor in revealing to the angels that He is with them with help and victory. He ordered the angels to cast courage and desire for jihad into the believers' hearts, while He casts terror into the disbelievers', the believers' greatest soldier.
Then the disbelievers cannot stand against them, Allah gives the believers power over them, and orders them to strike their necks and joints. The paper says this address is either to the angels, which would be evidence they fought at Badr, or to the believers, to encourage them and teach them how to kill the idolaters and show no mercy. This is because they opposed Allah and His Messenger ﷺ, fighting and challenging them with enmity.
The believers' guardianship
From the paper: «ولاية المؤمنين»
Discussing the believers' guardianship requires showing what makes it due among them, its effects on those who hold it, and the effects of believers' guardianship of disbelievers and wrongdoers.
What makes the believers' guardianship due among them
Certain matters or attributes unite the believers and qualify them for guardianship among themselves, or make it obligatory on them, and some Quranic verses mention them. Among them is At-Tawbah 9:71. The paper says this verse is either a report from Allah that the religion these believers embraced and hold to requires guardianship among them, as in Al-Hujurat 49:10.
Or it is a command, Allah ordering the believers to take one another as guardians and not others, as in Al-Mumtahanah 60:1.
Al-Maturidi mentions two kinds of guardianship among the believers, spiritual and personal (nafsaniyya). The first, he says, is guardianship in religion, requiring that the rights arising from the religion that unites them be observed and preserved. The second is guardianship over persons and property, such as in marriage and inheritance. He says this personal guardianship was by kinship and lineage, and when they unite in one religion it becomes due to them. The spiritual guardianship is affection and love, to be observed through the religion, as one speaks of spiritual life and bodily life.
The paper says these believing men and women, who believe in Allah, His Messenger ﷺ and the Quran, are each other's supporters and helpers, with hearts united in affection, love and sympathy.
The reasons are these points. First, the religion they embraced requires guardianship, so they become each other's guardians. Second, they command the good, meaning they command people to believe in Allah, His Messenger ﷺ and what he brought. The good (al-maʿruf) is a comprehensive name for all known good: sound belief, righteous deeds and noble morals, and they command themselves first. Third, they forbid the wrong, all that contradicts the good: false beliefs, foul deeds and vile morals, and they forbid themselves first. Fourth, they perform the prayer perfectly and pay zakat to those entitled. Fifth, they obey Allah and His Messenger ﷺ constantly.
The paper adds that the believer's nature is that of the believing community: unity, mutual responsibility and solidarity in achieving good and repelling evil, which needs guardianship and cooperation, so the community stands in one rank. No causes of division enter it, and its guardianship is directed to commanding good, forbidding evil, raising Allah's word and fulfilling its trusteeship on earth. The prayer is the tie binding them to Allah. The zakat binds the Muslim community together, realizing the material and spiritual form of guardianship and solidarity. In obedience they have no desire but the command of Allah and His Messenger, no constitution but the law of Allah and His Messenger, and no choice once Allah and His Messenger decree. So they unite their method, aim and way, and the paths do not split from the one straight way.
Elsewhere Allah shows who is the walī whose allegiance is obligatory, Al-Ma'idah 5:55. The paper explains that the walī believers must take is Allah, His Messenger ﷺ, and the believers who perform the prayer at its prescribed times perfectly and humbly, and pay zakat to those entitled without arrogance toward the poor.
It is reported as the reason for revelation that ʿAbd Allah ibn Salam came to the Prophet ﷺ and said that people of Qurayza and al-Nadir had separated from them and sworn not to sit with them, the distance of homes kept them from the Prophet's companions, and he complained of what he met from the Jews. The verse was revealed, the Prophet ﷺ recited it to him, and he said they were pleased with Allah, His Messenger and the believers as guardians.
The wording of the verse is a restriction, confining true guardianship to Allah, His Messenger ﷺ and the believers only. Beyond them believers are forbidden to take guardians by friendship, support and cooperation, and must disown them. At the start of the call in Medina, allegiance and brotherhood between the Emigrants and the Helpers rested on mutual inheritance, to root this concept, as Allah says Al-Anfal 8:72. The paper explains that the Emigrants left Mecca out of love for Allah and His Messenger ﷺ and struggled with wealth and selves, and the Helpers sheltered and supported them against their enemies. They inherited from one another by emigration, not kinship, until this was abrogated by Al-Ahzab 33:6.
Effects of the believers' guardianship of one another
After stating what makes the believers' guardianship due, Allah described its effects, in this world and the next. First, Allah's mercy on them, as in At-Tawbah 9:71. The paper says Allah will pour out the effects of His mercy on these men and women. What more do believers seek above His mercy, or after winning His Paradise? He made the way to it easy, the wish of every rational person with the attributes in the verse.
This mercy is not only in the Hereafter but first on this earth. It covers the individual who carries out commanding good, forbidding wrong, prayer and zakat, and the community of such individuals. It is in the heart's tranquility, connection with Allah, protection from trials, and the community's soundness, cooperation and solidarity.
Second, victory, as Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:56. Al-Tabari says this announces to all Allah's servants, both those who cast off the Jews' alliance, content with the guardianship of Allah, His Messenger and the believers, and those who held to the alliance, feared evil turns of fortune and hurried to their allegiance. Whoever trusts Allah and takes Him, His Messenger and the believers as walī, and those like him among Allah's friends, will have victory over those who oppose them, being Allah's party, not Satan's.
Third, success in this world and the next, as Allah says Al-Mujadilah 58:22. The paper explains that you will not find a people who combine belief in Allah and the Last Day with affection for the enemies of Allah and His messengers.
This recommends keeping away from Allah's enemies and guarding against mixing with them, even if they are fathers, sons, brothers or clan, for faith requires forsaking the hostile even if relatives. For those who show them no affection, Allah has established faith in their hearts and strengthened them with His support against their enemy, calling that support a spirit (ruh) as their affair lives through it. On the Day of Resurrection He admits them to gardens with rivers, to stay forever.
Allah is pleased with them and accepts their deeds, and they are pleased with Him and rejoice in what He gave now and later. They are Allah's party and soldiers, who follow His commands, fight His enemies and support His friends, and win happiness in both abodes, perfect in success.
Thus the effects of the believers' guardianship of one another appear in this world and the next.
Believers' guardianship of disbelievers and wrongdoers
Allah warned the believers against taking disbelievers and wrongdoers as guardians instead of believers. True guardianship being confined to guardianship of Allah, His Messenger ﷺ and fellow believers, guardianship of disbelievers and wrongdoers has several effects. First, Allah's disavowal of such a person, as He says Ali 'Imran 3:28. The paper explains that Allah forbids believers to take disbelievers as helpers, allying with them on their religion, backing them against Muslims, and showing them Muslims' weak points and secrets. Whoever does this has disowned Allah and Allah has disowned him, having apostatized into disbelief.
Allah excepted one case, when believers are under the disbelievers' authority and weak, fearing for themselves. Then they show guardianship by the tongue only and hide enmity, neither helping them against a Muslim nor siding with their disbelief. Second, falling into the circle of disbelief, as He says Al-Ma'idah 5:51. The paper explains that Allah forbids taking Jews and Christians as guardians, treating them so in friendship, companionship and support. His reason is that they are guardians of one another, so how can believers take them as guardians.
Jews are guardians of one another, and likewise Christians, backing each other in hostility to the Prophet ﷺ and the Quran. This allegiance is the way of the disbelievers, not the believers, so believers should not do what they do and become like them. So Allah followed it with a severe warning that whoever takes them as guardians is one of them.
Allah then explained that believers fall into disbelief by allying with disbelievers because He does not guide whoever wronged himself with what necessitates disbelief. Al-Saʿdi says Allah, having shown the Jews' and Christians' bad states, guides believers not to take them as guardians, as they support one another as one hand against others. They are the true enemies, sparing no effort to lead believers astray, so only someone like them allies with them.
On Al-Ma'idah 5:51, he says complete allegiance requires moving to their religion, while a little calls for more, gradually, until the servant becomes one of them. The wrongdoers are those whose attribute is wrongdoing, who would not follow you or submit even if you brought every sign.
Third, judgment of straying, as in Al-Mumtahanah 60:1-2. These verses were revealed because of Hatib ibn Abi Balta'a, an Emigrant who had witnessed Badr, with property and children in Mecca. He was not of Quraysh but an ally of ʿUthman. When the Messenger ﷺ resolved to conquer Mecca after Quraysh broke the treaty of al-Hudaybiyya, he ordered preparations and asked Allah to blind them to the news.
Hatib wrote to Quraysh of what the Prophet ﷺ had resolved and sent it with a Qurayshi woman, to gain favor with them. Allah informed His Messenger ﷺ, which the paper says answered his earlier prayer.
The Prophet ﷺ sent ʿAli, al-Zubayr and al-Miqdad after the woman, and at Rawdat Khakh they told her to hand over the letter. She denied it, they threatened to strip her clothes, and she took it from her braids. Hatib told the Prophet ﷺ he was an attached man among Quraysh, not one of them, and the Emigrants had relatives protecting their families in Mecca, so he wanted a favor with them to protect his relatives. He said he did not do it out of disbelief, apostasy or contentment with disbelief after Islam.
The Prophet ﷺ said Hatib had told the truth. ʿUmar asked permission to strike his neck, but the Prophet ﷺ forbade it, since Hatib had witnessed Badr, and perhaps Allah looked on the people of Badr and said to do as they wished, for He had forgiven them. Then Allah revealed the verses.
The paper explains that Allah forbids taking as guardians and friends the idolaters and disbelievers who fight Allah, His Messenger ﷺ and the believers, whose enmity and avoidance He legislated. They expelled the Messenger ﷺ and his companions because they hated their oneness of Allah and sincere worship; the believers' only fault was believing in Allah. If believers left to strive in Allah's cause seeking His pleasure, they should not ally with them, for they are His enemies and theirs, who drove them from homes and wealth out of rancor. If they secretly show affection, Allah knows what is hidden and apparent, and whoever does so has strayed.
If these disbelievers overcame the believers, they would spare no harm of word or deed, and are eager that they get no good, their enmity being hidden and apparent. The paper notes this incites believers against the disbelievers' enmity. The paper's summary is that a believer who allies with disbelievers without an excuse is one of them, has apostatized, is content with disbelief after Islam, has strayed and wronged himself, exposing himself to Allah's punishment in this world and the next.
Satan's guardianship
From the paper: «ولاية الشيطان»
Discussing Satan's guardianship requires explaining the attributes of his allies and then the effects of this guardianship on them.
Attributes of Satan's allies
Satan's allies have attributes that came over them through their allegiance, given by him so they could help him mislead people, and the Quran mentions them.
Idolatry and disbelief
Allah says Al-A'raf 7:27. The paper explains that He warns Adam's children against Satan doing to them what he did to Adam, beautifying disobedience and making it desirable, so Adam obeyed and was sent down with Hawwa from their high place. Satan wants the same for Adam's sons, sparing no effort to turn them from their religion, so believers must beware his entrances. He and his tribe of jinn devils watch them from where they cannot see them. Allah made the devils guardians of those who do not believe, so disbelief requires a pact of guardianship between human and Satan.
As for the believers, Allah reported that He gave Satan no power or way over them, saying An-Nahl 16:99-100. So the idolaters, with their idolatry and disbelief, are Satan's allies.
Deception by falsehood
The paper calls this attribute important on the way of following Satan, which he gives his allies to mislead them. He does not fight the people of truth alone but needs followers and supporters far from truth and faith, which comes only through growing deception by their falsehood, seeing truth only in what they follow. He enters their souls through their weak point, love of self and prominence, whispering that he is right and they are stronger, and that they must fight the believers with all their arrogance and conceit.
This is confirmed by An-Nisa 4:120. Allah explained this attribute in Ali 'Imran 3:175. It means he frightens with his allies, making them seem mighty and fierce. The paper explains that it is Satan who frightened the believers with their enemy's hosts and march, to make them fear the idolaters, his allies. Allah forbade them to fear the idolaters while they obey Him, since He guarantees them victory, and directed that fear be of Him alone, so they do not disobey Him if they believe the Messenger ﷺ.
So Satan makes his allies deceived by falsehood, magnifies them in the believers' eyes and uses them to frighten believers.
Fear of Satan
Having stirred love of self, arrogance and conceit in his allies and used them to fight truth and its people, they become weak before their master, fear him, carry out his orders and disobey none. Allah says An-Nahl 16:99-100. The paper explains that Allah tells the Prophet ﷺ and the believers after him to seek refuge in Him from the accursed Satan when starting to recite the Quran, for Satan has no domination to mislead believers who rely on their Lord, entrusting Him all words and deeds.
So faith in Allah and reliance on Him prevent Satan's whispering, and if he whispers to one of them it has no effect, for they are those of whom Iblis said Al-Hijr 15:40. Allah said of them Al-Hijr 15:42. Allah restricted Satan's domination in misleading to those who take him as walī, obeying his whispers and being idolaters, or idolaters because of his whispering.
Disputing with falsehood
Truth and falsehood contest fiercely until the Day of Judgment. As truth needs helpers to win, falsehood needs helpers to confront truth and its people, now confronting, now plotting against them, beautifying falsehood. This contest needs disputation, as Allah says Al-Hajj 22:3. The paper explains that some people dispute in Allah's religion without proof or knowledge and rebel against Him. Allah explained that their disputation and hostility to truth is revelation to them from Satan, saying Al-An'am 6:121.
Abu Dawud reported as its reason for revelation that the Jews came to the Prophet ﷺ asking why they eat what they kill but not what Allah kills, so Allah revealed it. The paper explains that eating what Allah's name was not mentioned over is disobedience, and the devils inspire their allies to dispute truth's people without knowledge, disputation being pressing one's speech as proof with force. Believers who obeyed them in making it lawful would be idolaters.
Al-Saʿdi says that when the idolaters, who deemed carrion lawful, heard Allah and His Messenger forbid it and permit slaughtered meat, they said, out of obstinacy and disputing without proof, that believers eat what they kill but not what Allah kills. They meant carrion, a corrupt opinion resting on corrupt views, which if truth followed would corrupt the heavens and earth. Woe to whoever puts these minds before Allah's law, which suits public and private interests. No surprise, since such opinions are inspired by their devil allies, who want to lead people astray and call them to be companions of the Blaze.
He explains "if you obey them" as obeying their idolatry and their making the forbidden lawful and the lawful forbidden, and "you are idolaters" because believers would have taken them as guardians besides Allah and agreed with them on what separates them from Muslims, making their path theirs.
Effects of Satan's guardianship
After presenting the attributes of Satan's allies, Allah showed the effects of Satan's guardianship, including the following. Allah says An-Nisa 4:116-121. The paper explains that these verses report that Allah will not forgive Tuʿma ibn Ubayriq, who died an idolater, while for others who did not die idolaters it is up to Allah to forgive or punish. Whoever associates partners with Allah has strayed from guidance, through distance from truth.
Then Allah reported that these idolaters worship only idols that cannot hear, see, speak or reason, and in reality worship only Satan, who called them to worship them. Allah cursed him and expelled him from His mercy for refusing to prostrate to Adam, and Satan, threatening and enraged, said he would take a large number of Allah's servants to worship him, known for disobeying Allah and obeying him.
He went on to say he would mislead them from the path of guidance and give them false hopes while hindering them from obeying Allah, such as that they will meet no punishment or that Allah will forgive them. They would obey him in giving their gods a share of what Allah provided and cutting animals' ears to mark them for the gods, and in changing Allah's creation by innovations and disobedience.
Allah said that whoever takes Satan as walī besides Him has made Him an enemy and suffered the greatest loss, since Satan owns nothing and cannot bring his allies salvation or happiness. Allah announces clearly that those devils and their allies end in the Fire with no escape.
Whoever takes Satan as walī has chosen badly, since Satan orders only indecency and wrong, over the guardianship of the Merciful, in which lie all salvation, happiness and success. He says Al-Kahf 18:50.
He also says Al-A'raf 7:30. The paper explains that Allah guides whoever turns to Him in faith, eases the burden of obedience for him and makes disobedience hateful to him. As for the other group, who defied Allah and did not respond to His guidance, how would He help them? He leaves them in their error with their misguidance. Misguidance was due on them because they took devils as guardians besides Allah, and they think they are guided in sinning, which the paper calls disbelief and insolence against Allah.
So whoever's guardianship of Satan is established, with the attributes of his allies, Allah ordered His believing allies to fight Satan's allies, since fighting is either in Allah's way or in the way of the taghut, so everything other than Allah must be taghut. Allah also showed that Satan's scheme is weak, in An-Nisa 4:76.
Allah supports His allies, and Satan his, but since his scheme is weak his support of his allies is weak too, while Allah will certainly support His. The paper's summary is that among the effects of Satan's guardianship is that misguidance became due on them, so they denied the messengers and claimed their way is the truth saving from all harm, unlike the prophets' calls. Satan beautified their deeds and became their walī in this world, they obeyed him, and so exposed themselves to fighting by the Merciful's allies. They have a painful punishment in the Hereafter because they were pleased with Satan's guardianship, and Allah says An-Nahl 16:63.
The guardianship of disbelievers, hypocrites and wrongdoers
From the paper: «ولاية الكافرين والمنافقين والظالمين»
This topic covers the disbelievers' guardianship of one another, the hypocrites' guardianship of the disbelievers, and the wrongdoers' guardianship of one another, each with its effects.
The disbelievers' guardianship of one another and its effects
The Quran speaks of the disbelievers taking one another as guardians, as Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:78-81. The paper explains that Allah cursed the disbelievers of the Children of Israel, in the Torah, Gospel, Psalms and Quran, for disobeying Him and transgressing against His creation. He described how none forbade another from sins, and blamed them. Commanding good and forbidding wrong is among the greatest religious obligations, so whoever leaves it shares with the sinner and deserves Allah's anger, as happened to the people of the Sabbath: Allah transformed those who did it and those who did not join them into apes and pigs.
Allah mentioned that Jews such as Kaʿb ibn al-Ashraf and his companions allied with idolaters, not of their religion, in love, allegiance and support. He blamed what their souls embellished for them, or the evil they put forward to be punished for on the Day of Resurrection. This causes His anger, clearly an effect of their guardianship of idolaters.
He said that if these Jews believed in Allah, their messenger and the book sent to them, they would not have taken idolaters as guardians, since these forbade it, but most of them are outside Allah's guardianship and faith. The paper says this holds for the Jews in the Prophet's ﷺ time, today and always, and for the other group of the People of the Book in most of the earth today, calling for deep contemplation of the Quran's secrets.
The Jews were those who allied with the idolaters and incited them against the Muslims, as the Quran relates what they said of the disbelievers An-Nisa 4:51. The paper says this appeared fully at the Battle of the Confederates, before and after it, to the present, and that Israel arose in Palestine only through loyalty and cooperation with the new disbelievers, the materialist atheists.
The other group of the People of the Book, it says, cooperates with atheistic materialism, and with idolatrous polytheism, whenever the matter or battle concerns the Muslims, even when the "Muslims" represent nothing of Islam but descent from Muslims. It calls this an unceasing rancor against this religion and its adherents, even those who only claim it, and affirms Allah's truthfulness in Al-Ma'idah 5:80.
Allah says Al-Anfal 8:73. The paper explains that the disbelievers cooperate to fight the Muslims, one group against truth and its people, even if some are hostile to others. In Arabia then there were only Jews and idolaters, and the Jews supported the idolaters against the Prophet ﷺ and broke their covenants, until he fought and expelled them from Khaybar.
Allah then warned the believers that if they do not practice the guardianship legislated among themselves, cooperating and supporting one another against the disbelievers' guardianship, they will fall into persecution (fitna) and corruption on earth. Their abandonment would bring harm, failure, the enemies' victory, and persecution in their religion, as with the weak Muslims in Mecca before the Hijra.
The paper quotes a comment that the verse alludes to Muslims not supporting or allying with disbelievers, implying no inheritance or mutual aid between them and requiring distancing and severing ties even with relatives.
The hypocrites' guardianship of the disbelievers and its effects
The Quran also spoke of the hypocrites' guardianship of the disbelievers and its effects, as Allah says An-Nisa 4:138-145. The paper explains that Allah gives the hypocrites, who showed Islam and hid disbelief, tidings in mockery, painful torment, for taking disbelievers as guardians through love, aid and support while leaving the believers. They seek might from them, but true might is Allah's and lies in allegiance to Him and the believers.
Al-Saʿdi says the hypocrites thought ill of Allah, were weak in certainty of His support for the believers, and noticed some means the disbelievers have, their sight falling short of what lies beyond, so they sought might and help from them. All might is Allah's, and He guaranteed to support His religion and believing servants, even if the believers face some trial and the enemy a turn that does not last, since the end is for the believers. He adds that the verse warns greatly against allying with disbelievers and leaving the believers, which is a hypocrites' attribute, and that faith requires love and allegiance for the believers and hatred and enmity for the disbelievers.
Allah then addresses everyone who shows faith, true believer or hypocrite: if they hear disbelievers deny and mock the Quran's verses, they should not sit with them until they speak of something else, or they would be like them in disbelief. He threatened to gather both groups in Hell, since a person is gathered with whom he loves, a warning against mixing and sitting with them.
The hypocrites lie in wait for the believers: if the believers win spoils, they ask for a share, and if the disbelievers win, they say they could have killed and captured them for the Muslims' benefit but spared them and weakened the Muslims' resolve, so they should give them their share.
Allah explained the fate of both groups: He will judge between them with truth and give the disbelievers no way to destroy the believers, for the end is for the believers in this world and the next. The hypocrites deceive Allah by showing belief in Him and Muhammad ﷺ while being the opposite. Deception is making the deceived see what he likes and concealing what he dislikes, so Allah treated them in kind, showing them what they love and concealing the torment prepared for them.
Allah cannot be deceived, as He knows secrets. When they stand to pray they do so sluggishly, not believing in the Hereafter's reward, show off to the believers so as not to be accused of disbelief, and remember Allah little because faith is not settled in their hearts. They waver between faith and disbelief, neither perfect believers nor perfect disbelievers, a state Allah gives to whom He misguides, with no way to their guidance.
Allah warned the believers not to act as hypocrites do by taking disbelievers as supporters, befriending and advising them, showing them secret affection and divulging the believers' secrets and internal affairs. Allying with disbelievers is a sign of hypocrisy, and the paper asks whether the believers want to give Allah clear proof against their deeds, deserving His punishment.
Allah then explained the hypocrites' punishment, including for their allegiance to the disbelievers: the lowest layer of the Fire, which has seven layers one above another. It is harsher than the disbeliever's own because the hypocrite is like the disbeliever in disbelief and adds mockery of Islam and its people, and they will find no one to save them or lighten it.
The wrongdoers' guardianship of one another and its effects
The Quran also speaks of the wrongdoers' guardianship of one another and its effects. Allah says Al-Jathiyah 45:16-19. The paper explains that Allah shows His favor to the Children of Israel: the Torah, judgment and prophethood in their descendants, good lawful things, and preference over the worlds of their time, so none then was more honored by Allah. He also told them of the sending of Muhammad ﷺ and explained his attributes, time and affair, but they differed, and He will judge between them on the Day of Resurrection.
Then Allah addressed our Prophet ﷺ, set on a way of religion after Musa, ordering him to follow it and not swerve to the disbelievers' desires, as they used to tell him to return to the religion of his fathers, who were better. If he followed their desires, they would avert nothing of Allah's punishment, and the wrongdoers are guardians of one another in love, support and allegiance, while Allah is the walī of the pious, their supporter and backer, a great difference between the two guardianships.
Allah explained the effects of the wrongdoers' guardianship of one another in the dialogue that will take place between Him and the jinn and humans at the gathering on the Day of Resurrection, saying Al-An'am 6:128-129. He will tell the jinn they misled many humans and made them followers in worshipping other than Allah and disobeying Him. The humans who were the jinn's allies will say they helped one another in disobedience and benefited from one another. The jinn enjoys the human's obedience, worship, magnifying and seeking his help, and the human, who worships the jinn, enjoys reaching his aims through the jinn's service in some desires and worldly needs.
The human's words Al-An'am 6:128 mean that the sins that happened have happened and they have reached their term of death and resurrection, so He may do with them what He wills, as the command and judgment are His. It is as if they plead to Allah, but this is not the time.
Allah says Al-An'am 6:128-129, meaning the Fire is their abode forever, as His knowledge and wisdom encompass all things. Then Allah attributed guardianship to Himself.
This shows the guardianship is from Allah, who created its cause from them. As He made the rebellious jinn guardians with power to mislead their human allies, setting a pact of allegiance between them through their own effort, this is His way: He appoints over each wrongdoer one like him, who urges him to evil and repels him from good. This is one of His great punishments with an ugly effect and grave danger. When injustice and corruption spread among servants and they withhold the rights due among themselves, Allah sets over them oppressors who take from them by injustice manifold what they withheld of Allah's rights and His servants' rights. By implication, if the servants' affairs are right and they stand firm on Allah's religion, He makes their rulers leaders of justice and fairness, not of injustice and tyranny.
The Quran's methods in speaking of loyalty
From the paper: «أساليب القرآن في الحديث عن الولاء»
In speaking of loyalty the Quran used a number of methods, including the following.
Prohibition
The Quran used the prohibiting "la" to forbid taking disbelievers, whether idolaters, Jews or Christians, as guardians instead of the believers. One verse using this method is Al-Ma'idah 5:51. Al-Zamakhshari says the meaning is not to take them as guardians whom you support, seek support from, fraternize with, befriend and live with as believers do. The reason follows, that they ally with one another because their creed is united and they gather in disbelief.
Also of this kind is Al-Mumtahanah 60:13. The paper notes that Surah al-Mumtahana began with the prohibition of allying with the disbelievers in general and the Jews in particular, and ended with this prohibition, to stress it and repel Muslims from this guardianship. Allah forbids allying with this people, with whom He is angry and who are cursed, having despaired of the Hereafter's reward because they opposed the Prophet ﷺ while knowing his truthfulness. They despair as the disbelievers despair of those in the graves who died idolaters returning to the world and being met.
Rhetorical questions
This method had the largest share in speaking of loyalty, and its aim is denial, to stress the prohibition of taking disbelievers as guardians instead of believers. Examples are many, among them An-Nisa 4:144. The paper explains that Allah forbids His believing servants to accompany, befriend and advise the disbelievers, show them secret affection, or divulge the believers' secrets and internal affairs. Hence His question whether they want to give Allah a proof to punish them for allying with the disbelievers.
Similar is An-Nisa 4:138-139. Their interpretation was given earlier, and another example is Al-An'am 6:14. The paper explains that Allah commands the Prophet ﷺ to ask the idolaters whether it makes sense for him to take as a god, to take charge of him, other than Allah, who created and originated the heavens and earth and provides for His creatures and, in the paper's words, is not created, when Allah commanded him to be the first of His creatures to submit.
Also of this kind is Al-Kahf 18:50. The paper explains that Allah honored Adam when He created him and commanded the angels to prostrate to him, and they all did but Iblis, who was arrogant and did not carry out the command. Allah denies that people take Satan and his offspring as guardians instead of the believers, as if asking whether they obey him and leave Allah's command when they are enemies to them, a bad exchange of Satan's guardianship for Allah's.
There are other Quranic examples, in which the question particle is clear and aims to deny taking as guardians the devils, disbelievers, hypocrites, Jews and Christians instead of the believers.
Challenge
This method aims to leave the other party unable and show the falsehood of his claim. The Quran used it on loyalty when Allah challenged the Jews, saying Al-Jumu'ah 62:6-7.
The paper explains that the Jews claimed to be Allah's guardians to the exclusion of all people, so Allah commanded the Prophet ﷺ to ask them, if they were truthful, to wish for death, to rest from this world's troubles and move to the comfort and bliss of the Gardens, since Allah does not punish His friends. But Allah knows they will never wish for death because of the sins they committed, and He knows best who wronged himself and made it disbelieve in Him, so the challenge in the verse is clear.
Threat
This method frightens and threatens believers if they ally with the disbelievers, support them and befriend them. One such verse is Al-Ma'idah 5:51. The paper explains that after forbidding allegiance to the Jews and Christians because they are guardians of one another, all harboring hatred and evil for the believers, Allah threatened the believers. Although outwardly different, they agree in hating Islam and the Muslims and scheming against them. A believer who allies with the idolaters is counted among them, and the ruling that applies to them applies to him. The paper says this is Allah's severity and emphasis on the obligation to avoid and withdraw from those who differ in religion.
Also of this method is Al-Anfal 8:73. The paper explains that since the disbelievers agree on disbelief they are guardians of one another, and only a disbeliever like them allies with them. Allah threatened the believers that if they do not ally with fellow believers and show enmity to the disbelievers, unlimited corruption and evil will result, with truth mixed with falsehood and believer with disbeliever, and the dropping of major acts of worship such as jihad and emigration, and of other aims of the religion that are lost if believers do not take one another as guardians.
Another verse using this method is Ali 'Imran 3:28. Its interpretation was given earlier, and similar is At-Tawbah 9:23.
Loyalty in the Quranic parable
From the paper: «الولاء في المثل القرآني»
Loyalty has a share in the Quran's parables, and one aim of the parables is to bring an abstract image near the mind by likening it to a perceptible material thing. One example is Al-Ankabut 29:41-43. The paper explains it as a parable Allah gave for whoever worships idols other than Him to gain might, strength and benefit, though the reality is otherwise, like the spider, a weak insect whose house is among the weakest of houses.
The spider made a house to protect it from heat, cold and pests, but only grew in weakness and frailty. Likewise those who take guardians besides Allah are poor, needy, incapable and weak in every respect, and in taking them they added weakness to their weakness.
They relied on them in many matters for might and help, but these guardians forsook them, gave no benefit, and neither availed nor repelled Allah's punishment when it came. Had they known their reality they would not have taken them and would have turned to Allah, who suffices whoever takes Him as walī and relies on Him in religion and worldly life, and increases his strength in heart, body, state and deeds.
When Allah showed the weakness of the idolaters' gods, that they are nothing but names they gave and delusions they believed and worshipped besides Him, He said of them An-Najm 53:23. He also said of them Yunus 10:66. On investigation the sensible person sees they are not gods, as the strength that subdued all creatures is Allah's, and He is the Wise who puts things in their place.
Allah then explained that He gives these parables only so that people benefit and learn, since they bring a rational matter near the mind through a perceptible one, leaving the human mind unable to reply or dispute. Another example of loyalty in the parable is Al-Kahf 18:50.
The paper explains that Allah denied the idolaters taking devils as guardians instead of the believers, and elsewhere showed the state of Satan after a human takes him as walī and he makes the human disbelieve, saying Al-Hashr 59:16-17. The paper says this parable shows the state of the Jews and hypocrites, who out of extreme cowardice do not face the Muslims in open confrontation or fight them united but from behind forts, trenches and walls. The Muslim and Arab nation felt this in the Jews' wars in Palestine in our time, and Allah expressed their cowardice in Al-Hashr 59:14.
Their wars and enmity among themselves are intense; they seem united but are really divided by severe grudges and spite. They do not grasp Allah's command in which lies the truth, nor that the secret of success in this life is unity, or they would know the truth, follow it, and unite.
The paper says it is fitting for Muslims in this age to be unlike them: united and agreed, one rank with one heart like a solid structure, relying on themselves and not seeking weak solutions from here or there. Allah then mentioned similar states: the hypocrites, when they promised the Jews support in fighting the Muslims, are like Satan who tempted the human to evil and disbelief and made it appealing. When the human complied and disbelieved in Allah, Satan disowned him on the Day of Resurrection, saying in disavowal that he feared Allah's punishment if he supported him.
The paper calls this surely a very bad parable, heavy on the soul, so Allah explained the punishment it requires: Satan who commands disbelief and the human who complied both go to Hell forever. This is the recompense of all disbelievers, including the Jews and hypocrites.
The paper concludes that Allah gives parables in the Quran for exalted matters, high aims and great affairs such as loyalty, and the people of knowledge are more entitled to them, since they alone benefit after reasoning and reflecting.
Takeaways
Allah alone is the Walī
The paper concludes that Allah alone is the Walī and His guardianship is unlike any other. It is general for all creation, with no distinction between believer, disbeliever or hypocrite.
True guardianship is confined
The paper notes that the phrase innamā waliyyukum confines true guardianship to Allah, His Messenger ﷺ and the believers. Beyond them, believers are forbidden to take others as guardians by friendship, support and cooperation, and must disown them.
Allying with disbelievers
The paper's summary is that a believer who allies with disbelievers without an excuse is one of them and has apostatized. The one exception it gives is believers under the disbelievers' authority and weak, fearing for themselves, who show guardianship by the tongue only and hide enmity, neither helping them against a Muslim nor siding with their disbelief.
Satan's support is weak
Allah supports His allies and Satan supports his, but since Satan's scheme is weak, his support is weak, while Allah will certainly support His allies.
Muslims should be united
The paper says it is fitting for Muslims in this age to be united and agreed, one rank with one heart like a solid structure, relying on themselves.
Reflect
- Whom do I turn to first for help and support, and does that reflect trust in Allah as my walī?
- How do I show love and support to fellow believers in practical ways?
- Where might desire, fear or the wish for status be pulling me toward the wrong allegiance?
- How can I keep my allegiance to Allah steady in daily choices?
Every verse in the paper
All 120 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.
Loyalty in Quranic usage «الولاء في الاستعمال القرآني»
58:14, 7:196, 18:44, 13:11, 47:11, 6:70, 6:14, 19:5, 44:41, 33:5
The pairing of the Walī with the Nasīr in the Quran «اقتران الولي بالنصير في القرآن»
Allah's guardianship of His servants «ولاية الله تعالى لعباده»
Allah is the Walī «أولًا: الله تعالى هو الولي»
General guardianship over all creation «ثانيًا: ولاية عامة للخلق جميعًا»
Special guardianship for His friends, and what entitles to it «ثالثًا: ولاية خاصة لأوليائه وأصفيائه وموجباتها»
2:257, 12:101, 3:68, 47:11, 8:34, 45:18-19, 7:196
Effects of Allah's guardianship for the believers «رابعًا: آثار ولاية الله للمؤمنين»
Causes of deprivation of Allah's guardianship «خامسًا: أسباب الحرمان من ولاية الله»
29:20-23, 33:64-65, 33:13-17, 2:120, 13:36-37, 17:97, 18:17, 42:44-46, 46:32, 42:7-8, 4:123, 2:111, 6:70, 4:172-173
The angels' guardianship of the believers «ولاية الملائكة للمؤمنين»
Reasons for the angels' guardianship «أولًا: أسباب ولاية الملائكة للمؤمنين»
Effects of the angels' guardianship «ثانيًا: آثار ولاية الملائكة للمؤمنين»
The believers' guardianship «ولاية المؤمنين»
What makes the believers' guardianship due among them «أولًا: موجبات ولاية المؤمنين بعضهم البعض»
9:71, 49:10, 60:1, 5:55, 8:72, 33:6
Effects of the believers' guardianship of one another «ثانيًا: آثار ولاية المؤمنين لبعضهم»
Believers' guardianship of disbelievers and wrongdoers «ثالثًا: ولاية المؤمنين للكافرين والظالمين»
Satan's guardianship «ولاية الشيطان»
Attributes of Satan's allies «أولًا: صفات أولياء الشيطان»
7:27, 16:99-100, 4:120, 3:175, 15:40, 15:42, 22:3, 6:121
Effects of Satan's guardianship «ثانيًا: آثار ولاية الشيطان»
4:116-121, 18:50, 7:30, 4:76, 16:63
The guardianship of disbelievers, hypocrites and wrongdoers «ولاية الكافرين والمنافقين والظالمين»
The disbelievers' guardianship of one another and its effects «أولًا: ولاية الكافرين بعضهم البعض وآثارها»
The hypocrites' guardianship of the disbelievers and its effects «ثانيًا: ولاية المنافقين للكافرين وآثارها»
The wrongdoers' guardianship of one another and its effects «ثالثًا: ولاية الظالمين لبعض وآثارها»
The Quran's methods in speaking of loyalty «أساليب القرآن في الحديث عن الولاء»
Prohibition «أولًا: النهي»
Rhetorical questions «ثانيًا: الاستفهام»
Challenge «ثالثًا: التحدي»
Threat «رابعًا: التهديد»
Loyalty in the Quranic parable «الولاء في المثل القرآني»
About this source
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
- Volume
- 18
- Research paper
- «الولاء» (Loyalty)
Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.
This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.