Faith & Creed · Quran topic

Disavowal

البراء · Bara'ah

Disavowal in the Quran: its meaning, who declared it, what is disowned, and its fruits

55 verses · 10 parts · 26 min read

Study guide based on

موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم

مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية

«البراء» · Volume 4

At a glance

This paper studies disavowal (al-baraʾ), from a root meaning distancing oneself from a thing. Scholars define it as hating false objects of worship, disbelief and its followers, and opposing them all. It counts 23 relevant occurrences of the root in the Quran and sets disavowal beside related terms, above all allegiance, its exact opposite.

It then traces disavowal through the Quran, beginning with Allah's disavowal of the idolaters, attributed to Him as the Lawgiver. It treats Allah's clearing of Musa of what was said against him. It follows the disavowal declared by Ibrahim and the believers with him and by Nuh. It does the same for Hud and for the Prophet ﷺ. It also covers Satan's disavowal of his followers, and leaders and followers disowning one another on the Day of Resurrection.

The paper closes with the Quran's styles of presenting disavowal. It sets out what is to be disowned, idols and the idolaters including close relatives. Finally it lists the fruits of disavowal in this world and the Hereafter.

Key verses

  1. At-Tawbah 9:1: The paper reads it as concerning the idolaters with whom the Messenger ﷺ made treaties, treaties which counted as the believers' own.
  2. Al-Ahzab 33:69: The paper uses it for Allah clearing Musa of what the Children of Israel said against him.
  3. Al-An'am 6:78: The paper cites it as Ibrahim's open disavowal of his people's polytheism after the setting of the sun.
  4. Al-An'am 6:19: The paper, with al-Razi, takes it as proof of the obligation of affirming Allah's oneness and disavowing polytheism.
  5. Al-Mujadilah 58:22: The paper uses it to show that true believers do not give allegiance to Allah's enemies, even close relatives, and must declare disavowal of them.
  6. Al-Baqarah 2:167: The paper explains the followers' wish to return to the world to disown the leaders who misled them.
  7. Al-Mumtahanah 60:4: The paper presents Ibrahim and the believers with him as the example of disavowing their people and their idols.
  8. At-Tawbah 9:3: The paper quotes al-Razi raising the question of what the repetition adds between this proclamation and the earlier declaration of disavowal. His first answer is that the earlier one announces that disavowal is established, while this one informs all people.
  9. Hud 11:54: The paper explains Hud calling Allah and his people to witness his disavowal of their polytheism.
  10. Yunus 10:41: The paper, with al-Tabari, explains it as the Prophet ﷺ telling those who deny him that each side answers only for its own deeds.
  11. Al-Anfal 8:48: The paper uses it for Iblis turning back and disowning the idolaters when he saw the angels.
  12. At-Tawbah 9:23: The paper explains it as a strict prohibition on taking relatives who prefer disbelief as allies.

Words to know

البراء al-baraʾ

Disavowal: distancing oneself from a thing, disowning it and getting free of it.

Appears 31 times in the Quran.

Most common forms: بَرِيء (12), تَبَرَّأَ (5), بارِئ (3), تُبْرِئُ (2), بَراءَة (2)

Root: ب ر ا

البراءة al-baraʾah

Exoneration, the verbal noun of being clear of something, which the paper says shares the meaning of disavowal.

Root: ب ر ا

براءة baraʾah

In the verse the paper quotes, giving excuse and warning and keeping clear.

Root: ب ر ا

الترك al-tark

Abandonment: leaving a thing, discarding and neglecting it, a meaning close to disavowal.

Root: ت ر ك

الولاء al-walaʾ

Allegiance: nearness, love and support, the exact opposite of disavowal.

The concept of disavowal

From the paper: «مفهوم البراء»

Linguistic meaning

The root b-r-ʾ has two basic senses. The first is creating; the Creator (al-Bariʾ) is Allah, as in Al-Baqarah 2:54. The second is distancing oneself from a thing: disowning, getting free of it, keeping clear of it, renouncing it. Disavowal (al-baraʾ) is a verbal noun, so it does not change for dual, plural or feminine; in At-Tawbah 9:1 it means excuse, warning and keeping clear, and the night of al-baraʾ is the month's first night, when the moon parts from the sun.

Technical meaning

Scholars define disavowal in several ways, including:

  • Distance, getting free, and enmity after excuse and warning.
  • Hating Allah's enemies, hypocrites and disbelievers, opposing them, keeping away, and fighting the hostile ones as able.
  • Hating false deities (taghut), physical or abstract like desires and opinions, and disbelief in every creed and its followers, opposing it all.

Disavowal in Quranic usage

From the paper: «البراء في الاستعمال القرآني»

The root b-r-ʾ occurs 31 times in the Quran, 23 of them relevant to this topic. The forms it takes are these:

In Quranic usage disavowal keeps its linguistic meaning: parting from a thing, distancing oneself from it and separating from it.

Related terms

From the paper: «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»

Exoneration (al-baraʾah)

Exoneration in language

It is the verbal noun of being clear of something and distancing from it, or of giving excuse and warning, as in At-Tawbah 9:1; Ibn al-Aʿrabi says it means being freed of liability.

Exoneration as a technical term

Its technical meaning derives from, and matches, the linguistic one.

Disavowal and exoneration

There is no difference: they share one meaning, exoneration being derived from the root b-r-ʾ, as the definition of disavowal shows.

Abandonment (al-tark)

Abandonment in language

It means leaving a thing, that is, keeping away from it, and abandoning a matter means discarding and neglecting it, a meaning close to disavowal.

Abandonment as a technical term

Its technical meaning matches the linguistic one.

Abandonment and disavowal

The two are largely similar, since disavowal includes the senses of parting, avoidance, destruction and testing.

Allegiance (al-walaʾ)

Allegiance in language

It means nearness, closeness, love and support; al-Raghib al-Isfahani explains that it is two or more things coming together with nothing foreign between them, used figuratively for nearness in place, lineage, religion, friendship, support and belief, while al-wilayah means support.

Allegiance as a technical term

It is drawing near to Allah, the Prophet ﷺ and the believers through love, support, obedience and other expressions of allegiance.

Allegiance and disavowal

Allegiance is the exact opposite of disavowal: disavowal means distance, casting off and hatred, while allegiance means nearness, love and support.

Disavowal attributed to Allah

From the paper: «البراءة في حق الله تعالى»

Allah's disavowal of the idolaters

Allah says At-Tawbah 9:1. The paper explains that it means the idolaters with whom the Messenger ﷺ made treaties, since only he or someone acting on his order concluded them; the believers are addressed because they understood this, and his treaties for his community counted as theirs, as they accepted his acts and submitted to his agreements.

Allah also says At-Tawbah 9:3. This verse is joined by conjunction to At-Tawbah 9:1. "Proclamation" (adhan) stands where "disavowal" stands, informing the idolaters who held treaties that their treaty was dissolved; since the verse lays down a legal ruling and Allah is the Lawgiver, the disavowal is attributed to Him, and the Messenger ﷺ is joined to Him as the one who conveys and carries it out.

Al-Razi asks: if there is no difference between At-Tawbah 9:1 and At-Tawbah 9:3, what does the repetition add? He answers in several ways:

  • First, the earlier statement reports that the disavowal is established, the later informs all people of what has taken place.
  • Second, the earlier is disavowal of the treaty, the later the disavowal opposite to allegiance, serving as rebuke and warning, as the wording shows: "free toward them" first, "free of them" second; at the end of al-Anfal Allah ordered the Muslims to ally with one another, implying they must not ally with the disbelievers but disavow them, and here He shows that as He is the ally of the believers, He disavows the idolaters, censures and curses them, as does the Messenger, which is why repentance, which removes the disavowal, follows.
  • Third, the earlier declares disavowal of idolaters who made and broke treaties, this one of idolaters without any particular description, showing that the cause is their disbelief and polytheism.

Allah clearing Musa

Allah says Al-Ahzab 33:69. The Quran recounts several kinds of harm the Children of Israel did to Musa, among them their words in Al-Baqarah 2:55. Another is their demand in Al-A'raf 7:138.

The paper cites a hadith reported by al-Bukhari from Abu Hurayra: Musa was very modest and kept covered, so some of the Children of Israel claimed he hid a defect such as leprosy or a hernia; Allah willed to clear him, so when he bathed alone a stone ran off with his clothes, and chasing it he reached a group of them who saw him unclothed, of the finest form, cleared of their claim; he struck the stone with his staff, leaving marks, and the Prophet ﷺ linked this to Al-Ahzab 33:69.

Ibn ʿAshur explains that Allah made Musa's innocence openly visible, since he was innocent before their words; Allah showed it afterwards: that Musa had not misled them in ordering them into Jericho, as Allah steadied their hearts and they took it; that he was not mocking them over the cow they were told to slaughter, as the miracle exposed the killer they disputed over; and that he was free of leprosy and hernia when he appeared unclothed after the stone moved.

Ibn ʿAshur adds that Allah cleared him of the content of their words, not of the words themselves, which had been said and had hurt him, just as an insult is called "what was said" (al-qalah). The paper explains that the verse's ending, in Al-Ahzab 33:69, shows why Allah took care to clear Musa: one who is wajih has standing and rank, and Musa had a great standing with Allah; this exposes the folly of those who hurt him with what he was free of, and shows he deserved the clearing because of his standing with Allah.

The paper judges al-Tabari's view soundest: the Children of Israel hurt the prophet of Allah with something he disliked and Allah cleared him; it may have been their claim of leprosy, or their accusing him of killing his brother Harun, or both, since all is reported, and nothing is closer to the truth than what Allah said, that they hurt Musa and Allah cleared him.

The prophets and the righteous disavowing their peoples

From the paper: «براءة الأنبياء والصالحين من أقوامهم»

The disavowal of Ibrahim and the believers with him

Allah says Al-Mumtahanah 60:4. The paper explains that the believers have a fine example in the story of their father Ibrahim and those who believed with him, who boldly declared to their disbelieving people their disavowal of them and their gods, and a lasting enmity until those people believe in Allah alone and leave the worship of others.

The author of al-Kashshaf says theirs was a fine, approved way worth following: they openly showed their disbelieving people enmity and hatred and declared its only cause to be disbelief in Allah; while that cause remains the enmity remains, and if they remove it and believe in Allah alone, enmity turns to allegiance, hatred to affection and loathing to love, an expression of pure sincerity.

The paper notes that Ibrahim and the believers declared, boldly and firmly, their full faith in the truth and their disavowal, dislike and contempt for all who worship other gods with Allah; they did not stop at rejecting wrong in the heart, but declared their enmity to it openly and kept clear of it.

Elsewhere Ibrahim openly declares his disavowal of his people's polytheism, in Al-An'am 6:78. Al-Tabari explains that "greater" means greater than the star and the moon, and that when the sun set Ibrahim declared to his people his disavowal of worshipping gods and idols and calling on a god besides Allah.

The disavowal of Nuh

Allah says Hud 11:32-35.

The paper explains that Nuh's people complained of his long disputing, that is, contending over proofs until one side prevails, and demanded the swift worldly punishment he warned of if he was truthful; Nuh answered that the punishment and its timing are not in his hands but Allah's, who brings it if and when He wills; they cannot escape, being within His power and dominion; his advice and his wish for their good would not help them if Allah had willed their straying and destruction; Allah is their Lord, their Creator who governs their affairs, the just Judge who does no wrong, to whom they return in the Hereafter to be recompensed for their good or evil.

The exegetes differ over the verse in this passage about the charge that he invented it. Al-Tabari says it is an aside within Nuh's story concerning Muhammad ﷺ and the disbelievers of Quraysh, though it may concern Nuh, whose people claimed the punishment he threatened was invented to frighten them.

The quotation continues that the preferred view, as Ibn ʿAbbas said, is that it belongs to Nuh's dialogue with his people, since only Nuh and his people are mentioned before and after it; they claim he invented what he told them of Allah's religion and the punishment of those who turn from it, so the verse is Nuh's explicit declaration that he disowns his people's deeds and polytheism.

Elsewhere Nuh challenges his people, showing he cares nothing for their threats. This is in Yunus 10:71-72. The paper explains Nuh's words: if his standing among them, calling them to worship their Lord and reminding them of Allah's signs, meaning His proofs of His oneness, weighed on them, he relied on Allah alone and would not stop his mission; let them and their idols resolve openly on whatever they would do to him and carry it out without delay, for he neither cares about them nor fears them, as they stand on nothing.

The disavowal of Hud

Allah says Hud 11:53-55. The paper explains that after Hud called his people to worship Allah alone, warned them against turning away, and called them "my people" three times out of affection and kinship, hoping to win them, they replied that he brought no proof of being sent by Allah, would not make them leave their gods, and was not believed; the paper says their answer held four things, all stubbornness, foolishness and arrogance, namely demanding proof and insisting on their gods.

On their claim in Hud 11:54, al-Zamakhshari explains, in summary, that they meant one of their gods had struck him with madness for insulting them, turning people from them and opposing them, so he spoke like the mad and raved like the delirious. He adds that their replies show them coarse and hard-hearted, careless of slander, deaf to advice and unyielding to guidance, and this claim shows extreme ignorance and stupidity, believing stones could take revenge.

The paper explains that Hud then took the stance of one who disowns their polytheism, defies their tyranny and relies on Allah alone, in Hud 11:54: he calls Allah, and them, to witness his disavowal of their polytheism and idols, not because they were fit witnesses but as the utmost affirmation; he did not join both witnessings in one phrase lest they be equated, since calling Allah to witness is sound and affirms His oneness, while calling them only shows contempt for their religion; he declares it openly, tells them and their gods to plot against him together without respite, and entrusts his affair and protection to Allah, his Lord and theirs, who has power over all things.

The paper concludes that Hud's reply contained challenge and a dazzling miracle, indifference to them and their threats, disavowal of their polytheism, calling Allah and them to witness it, inviting them to plot, and no fear of them or their gods.

The disavowal of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ

Allah says Al-An'am 6:19. Al-Tabari explains that the Prophet ﷺ is told to ask the idolaters who deny his prophethood and make others equal to Allah whether they testify that idols are worshipped alongside Him. Al-Razi says the passage shows the obligation of affirming Allah's oneness and disavowing polytheism in three ways:

  • First, the Prophet's refusal to testify to the partners they affirm.
  • Second, the word innama, which restricts, together with the word "one", explicit in affirming oneness and denying partners.
  • Third, the explicit disavowal of affirming partners in Al-An'am 6:19, so the verse establishes the obligation of affirming oneness with the clearest statement and strongest emphasis.

Al-Razi adds that scholars hold it recommended for someone first entering Islam to pronounce the two testimonies of faith and disavow every religion other than Islam. He notes that al-Shafiʿi stated it is recommended to join disavowal to the testimony, because in the verse the disavowal comes right after the declaration of oneness.

Connected to this context is Yunus 10:41. Al-Tabari explains that if the idolaters deny the Prophet ﷺ and his message, he tells them each side has its own religion and deeds, neither harmed by nor answerable for the other's, each recompensed for his own. Ibn Taymiyya says Allah commanded him to disown the deeds of all who deny him, which covers the idolaters and the People of the Book.

The paper explains that in this verse Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to show disavowal of the disbelievers' ugly deeds, rejecting them and showing that one must keep away from them, a meaning set out in Surat al-Kafirun. Among the verses on the Prophet ﷺ warning his kin with disavowal is Ash-Shu'ara 26:214-216.

The paper explains that if his nearest kin disobey him and persist in idol worship and associating others with the Most Merciful, he declares that he disowns their deeds, their idol worship and disobedience to the Creator. This follows from the command in Ash-Shu'ara 26:214: if they disobey, he need only disown their deeds, that is, their disbelief, and he was told to say it aloud to show they deserve it, not merely keep it in his heart.

Satan's disavowal of his followers

From the paper: «براءة الشيطان من أتباعه»

The paper describes Satan as among humanity's fiercest enemies from the start of creation until Allah inherits the earth, having pledged before Allah to mislead the children of Adam, yet a day comes when he declares his disavowal of them; the paper then reviews some such occasions.

Satan's disavowal of the idolaters at Badr

Allah says Al-Anfal 8:48. The paper explains that Satan put it into the idolaters' minds that their numbers and equipment made them unbeatable, and deluded them that following him in what they took for acts of devotion made him their protector, until they prayed for victory for whichever party was better guided; but when the believers and the idolaters met, he fled and declared his disavowal of them, that is, of his pact, protection and support, for he saw the angels descending to support the believers, whom the idolaters could not see, and feared that Allah would punish him before the Day of Resurrection, or harm him through His angels.

Satan's disavowal on the Day of Resurrection of those he called to disbelief

Allah says Ibrahim 14:22.

The paper explains that on that Day Satan takes a stand that breaks the disbelievers' backs and tears their hearts: he makes plain that his worldly promises were false, opposed to Allah's true promise, and that he broke them; that they accepted his word against reason, without the proof a sensible person requires; that he offered only a call empty of any evidence; he rebukes them, rejects their blame and tells them to blame themselves for accepting plain falsehood; he has no help or rescue for them, sharing their calamity; and he declares that he disowns what they believed of him, his being associated with Allah, so their regrets multiply and their misfortunes follow one upon another.

Forms of disavowal on the Day of Resurrection

From the paper: «من صور البراءة يوم القيامة»

Leaders and chiefs disavowing their followers

Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:166. The paper explains that on the Day of Resurrection, with leaders and followers gathered, the chiefs disown those they led as all see the punishment and what awaits them; so their worldly ties are cut, and each side curses and disowns the other.

Al-Tabari says those followed in associating others with Allah disown their followers on seeing His punishment, and since none are singled out, this covers everyone followed in disbelief and misguidance. The paper notes that seeing the punishment in Al-Baqarah 2:166 covers all of them, and that the ties being cut "with them" means cut from them, the preposition used as in Al-Furqan 25:59.

There are four views on what these ties are:

  • Bonds of affection, the view of Ibn ʿAbbas, Mujahid and Qatada.
  • Deeds, reported by al-Suddi from Ibn Masʿud and Ibn ʿAbbas, and the view of Abu Salih and Ibn Zayd.
  • Ties of kinship, reported by Ibn Jurayj from Ibn ʿAbbas.
  • All of these together.

Followers wishing to return to the world to disown their leaders

Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:167. The paper explains that those who followed others in falsehood wish for a return to worldly life, to disown those who misled them as these disowned them on that hard Day, and to vent their rage at them for abandoning them and leading them to ruin and painful punishment; Allah shows them their deeds as regrets, making plain that those deeds left the worst effect on their souls, regret, misery and loss, and then fade away; they will never leave the Fire for the world to vent their anger, as the ending of Al-Baqarah 2:167 confirms, for they abide in it forever.

The Quran's style in presenting disavowal

From the paper: «الأسلوب القرآني في عرض البراء»

The paper notes that the Quran came down in clear Arabic to the most eloquent of the Arabs, as the Messenger's ﷺ greatest miracle, Allah challenging them to produce its like or even one surah; the Muslim stands amazed before its inimitability and its smooth, easy style, and the paper now turns to how it presents disavowal.

The style of request

Requests in Arabic take several forms, including:

1. The command form

Allah says Ash-Shu'ara 26:216. That is, if they refuse his call to Allah's oneness, the Prophet ﷺ is to tell them he disowns their deeds. Allah also says Al-Kafirun 109:1-6. The paper explains that the Prophet ﷺ declares to the disbelievers, and the verse covers every disbeliever on earth, that he will never in any way worship their idols, nor are they, while they persist in polytheism and disbelief, worshippers of the One he worships, Allah alone without partner; these verses deny any sharing in worship, as the utmost emphasis in disavowing their false deities and corrupt worship.

The surah cut off every hope the disbelievers had of a truce with the Prophet ﷺ or his yielding to any of their corrupt demands; he disowns them, their deities and their worship completely. Allah says Yunus 10:41. That is, he tells them that they are not held to account for his deeds nor he for theirs, so each side is free of the other.

2. The prohibition form

Allah says Al-Mumtahanah 60:1. The paper explains that believers in Allah and His Messenger ﷺ must not take the enemy of Allah and their own enemy as helpers, friends and allies, but must disown them and their deeds. The same meaning comes in At-Tawbah 9:23.

The style of statement

Allah says Al-An'am 6:78. After Ibrahim came to know the true God, he told his people that he disowned all the gods they worshipped besides Allah. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:48. That is, it was on seeing the angels that Iblis turned back and declared this, as in Al-Anfal 8:48. Some statements are emphasized with inna, as in Az-Zukhruf 43:26.

That is, Ibrahim disowns the idols they worship, which he does not worship. The same meaning comes in Al-An'am 6:19. Another is At-Tawbah 9:3.

The style of dialogue

The first is Nuh's dialogue with his people. Allah says Hud 11:32-35. The paper repeats its explanation: Nuh's people complained of his long disputing and demanded the worldly punishment he warned of, and he answered that it lies with Allah, who brings it if and when He wills, that they cannot escape His power, that his advice cannot help them if Allah wills their straying and destruction, and that they return to their Lord, the just Judge, to be recompensed for their deeds.

The second is Ibrahim's dialogue with his father and his people. Allah says Al-An'am 6:74-78.

The paper explains that the Prophet is told to recall Ibrahim asking his father Azar how he could take lifeless idols as gods besides Allah, who created them and him and alone deserves worship, and seeing them in plain error, for no error is clearer than worshipping an idol of stone, wood or metal carved by one's own hands; Allah then showed what Ibrahim saw of the dominion of the heavens and the earth, the evidence in their creation of His oneness; when night fell he saw a great star outshining the rest, Jupiter or Venus, and, to draw his people out in debate, proposed as a supposition that it was his Lord.

When it set, Ibrahim said it was no god and that he did not love what vanishes, since God holds sway over the universe and does not disappear; he moved on to the brighter moon, and when it set like the star, he said in his people's hearing that it too was no god, and that without his Lord's guidance he would be among those who stray, missing guidance and worshipping other than Allah.

On seeing the sun rise, the greatest heavenly body we see, he said this was now his Lord, greater in rank and light than the stars and the moon; when it too set, he declared his creed and disowned his people's polytheism, turning his worship to the Creator of the earth, the heavens and these bodies, in whose hand is the dominion of all things; he argued with these examples because his people studied the stars and the heavens.

What is to be disavowed

From the paper: «ما يُتَبَرَأ منه»

Idols and whatever is worshipped besides Allah

Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:256. The paper defines taghut as anything, human, devil or other, that turns people from worshipping Allah, and explains that whoever disowns and casts off rivals to Allah, idols and the worship of others that Satan calls to, and believes in Allah with pure and sincere faith, stands firm on the best path, which never breaks, and holds religion by its strongest bond.

Next Allah shows why Ibrahim and the believers with him disowned their people in that time, in Al-Mumtahanah 60:4. The paper explains that Ibrahim, the Friend of the Most Merciful and father of the prophets, and his believing followers are a fine example: they told their people they disowned them for their disbelief in Allah and disowned the idols and rivals they worshipped besides Allah, rejecting their idols, or their religion, or their deeds, for those idols bring no benefit, being unable to reason, hear or see.

The idolaters in general, and relatives among them in particular

Allah says At-Tawbah 9:114. The paper explains that when Ibrahim's father promised him he would believe, Ibrahim treated him like one whose heart is to be won over, asking forgiveness for him, since he thought him wavering in idol worship when he told him Maryam 19:46. He asked Allah to forgive him, hoping he would reject idol worship, but when he knew for certain that his father persisted in disbelief, he declared his disavowal of him openly and plainly, as At-Tawbah 9:114 shows.

Elsewhere Ibrahim declares his disavowal of his people in general and his father in particular, in Az-Zukhruf 43:26. The paper explains that the Messenger is to remind Quraysh, who imitated their forefathers in idol worship, of Ibrahim disowning the idols of his father Azar and his people, except the worship of the Creator of all, who he said would guide him as before and keep him firm on the truth.

Allah says Al-Mujadilah 58:22. The paper explains that true believers keep away from allegiance to the enemies of Allah and His Messenger even if they are their fathers, sons, blood brothers or clan, and must declare disavowal of them, since faith comes before everything; Allah then praises them in Al-Mujadilah 58:22, faith so pervading their hearts that they love only those who love Allah's religion and hate only those who hate it.

Allah says At-Tawbah 9:23-24. The paper explains that believers must not take fathers and brothers who choose disbelief over faith as allies, supporting them in fighting, backing the disbelievers for their sake, or revealing the Muslims' general or military secrets to them; whoever allies with them wrongs himself and his community, opposing Allah and His Messenger instead of disowning them; and the ending of At-Tawbah 9:23 makes clear that the prohibition is one of strict forbiddance (tahrim), not mere discouragement (tanzih).

Ibn ʿAbbas said such a person is an idolater like them, because he is content with their polytheism, and contentment with disbelief is disbelief, as contentment with sin is sin.

The paper explains that Allah then ordered His Messenger to warn whoever prefers family, relatives and clan over Allah, His Messenger and striving in His cause, opening with "if" (in), which conveys doubt, because believers loving disbelievers is doubtful; what is meant is preferring their love over the love of Allah, while love itself is natural and innate and carries no blame or accountability, since obligation applies to what a person can control, not to innate matters such as love and hatred.

The paper lists eight things, fathers, sons, brothers, spouses, clan (close kin), wealth, trade and dwellings, which, if preferred over love of Allah and His Messenger, meaning obedience to them, and over striving in His cause, which brings eternal happiness in the Hereafter, leave those people to await Allah's punishment, soon or later.

The fruits and results of disavowal

From the paper: «ثمرات البراءة ونتائجها»

The paper describes disavowal as a basic part of the Muslim's creed which, if held to, bears many fruits in this world and the Hereafter, and it sets out the most important of them.

Winning Allah's pleasure and escaping His wrath

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:28. He also says An-Nisa 4:139. Through the creed of disavowal the firmest bonds of faith are fulfilled: the paper cites a hadith of Ibn ʿAbbas in which the Prophet ﷺ asked Abu Dharr which bond of faith is firmest and named allegiance and enmity for the sake of Allah, and love and hatred for His sake.

It cites another hadith in which the Prophet ﷺ said that whoever loves and hates, gives and withholds for Allah has completed faith. Ibn Taymiyya says that fulfilling the testimony that there is no god but Allah requires loving, hating, allying and opposing only for Allah's sake, and loving what Allah loves and hating what He hates.

Safety from strife and corruption in the land

Allah says Al-Anfal 8:73. Ibn Kathir explains that unless the believers keep apart from the idolaters and ally with the believers, strife befalls people, meaning the believers become confused and mixed with the disbelievers, and wide, lasting corruption spreads among people.

Blessings in this world and good renown in both abodes

The paper invites reflection on what Allah says of Ibrahim in Maryam 19:49-50. The paper explains that these verses show what followed Ibrahim's withdrawal from polytheism and its people: when he left his father, his people and their false gods, Allah did not forsake him but honoured him with Ishaq and Yaʿqub to comfort him after parting from them to raise Allah's word, made each a prophet, and gave Ibrahim, Ishaq and Yaʿqub much of His favour, kindness and provision; so withdrawing from polytheism and its people, and from sin and sinners, leads to happiness in religion and in this world.

Belonging to Allah's party and gaining victory over the disbelievers

Allah says Al-Mujadilah 58:22. The paper explains, as before, that true believers keep away from allegiance to the enemies of Allah and His Messenger even if they are their fathers, sons, blood brothers or clan, and must declare disavowal of them, since faith comes before everything. Allah then praises these believers in Al-Mujadilah 58:22, faith so pervading their hearts that they love only those who love Allah's religion and hate only those who hate it.

Guarding the Muslim from submitting to the disbelievers

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:100. The paper explains that Allah warns the believers against obeying the People of the Book and their temptation, after rebuking those for misleading; tying apostasy to obeying even a party of them heightens the warning and requires avoiding their company entirely, just as the general rebuke before it heightens the deterrence.

Allah says Hud 11:113. Inclining (rukun) to someone means one's heart leans to him and one relies on him for one's affairs. Those who do wrong here include the idolaters and other wrongdoers. The paper explains that the believers must beware of inclining toward wrongdoers or settling with them, since that strengthens their side and weakens the side of truth and justice.

Gaining Allah's protecting friendship

Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:120. Al-Tabari explains, in summary, that since the Jews and Christians will never be pleased with the Prophet ﷺ, he should stop seeking what pleases them and seek Allah's pleasure in calling them to the truth he was sent with, the way to unite with him in harmony on the upright religion; he cannot please them by following their religion, for Judaism and Christianity oppose each other and cannot meet in one person at once, so both could be pleased with him only if he were both Jewish and Christian, which can never be; so he should hold to Allah's guidance, the way to unite people in harmony.

Takeaways

  1. Part of the creed

    The paper describes disavowal as a basic part of the Muslim's creed, bearing fruits in this world and the Hereafter.

  2. The firmest bond of faith

    Through disavowal the firmest bonds of faith are fulfilled: allegiance and enmity, love and hatred, for the sake of Allah.

  3. Faith before kinship

    True believers do not give allegiance to the enemies of Allah and His Messenger even if they are close relatives, since faith comes before everything.

  4. Natural love is not blamed

    The paper notes that what is blamed is preferring relatives over Allah, while natural love itself carries no blame, since obligation covers only what a person can control.

  5. Withdrawal brings blessing

    Ibrahim's withdrawal from polytheism and its people was followed by Allah's gifts, so withdrawing from polytheism and sin leads to happiness in religion and this world.

Reflect

  • Is there anything I have placed above my love of Allah and His Messenger?
  • How can I make my love and dislike more truly for the sake of Allah?
  • What does Ibrahim's example teach me about standing firm on the truth when those closest to me disagree?

Every verse in the paper

All 55 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.

The concept of disavowal «مفهوم البراء»

Linguistic meaning «أولًا: المعنى اللغوي»

2:54, 9:1

Disavowal in Quranic usage «البراء في الاستعمال القرآني»

2:167, 12:53, 60:4, 9:1, 24:26

Related terms «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»

Exoneration in language «البراءة لغةً»

9:1

Disavowal attributed to Allah «البراءة في حق الله تعالى»

Allah's disavowal of the idolaters «أولًا: براءة الله عز وجل من المشركين»

9:1, 9:3

Allah clearing Musa «ثانيًا: تبرأة الله لموسى عليه السلام»

33:69, 2:55, 7:138

The prophets and the righteous disavowing their peoples «براءة الأنبياء والصالحين من أقوامهم»

The disavowal of Ibrahim and the believers with him «أولًا: براءة إبراهيم عليه السلام والمؤمنين معه»

60:4, 6:78

The disavowal of Nuh «ثانيًا: براءة نوح عليه السلام»

11:32-35, 10:71-72

The disavowal of Hud «ثالثًا: براءة هود عليه السلام»

11:53-55

The disavowal of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ «رابعًا: براءة رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم»

6:19, 10:41, 26:214-216

Satan's disavowal of his followers «براءة الشيطان من أتباعه»

Satan's disavowal of the idolaters at Badr «أولًا: براءة الشيطان من المشركين في بدر»

8:48

Satan's disavowal on the Day of Resurrection of those he called to disbelief «ثانيًا: براءة الشيطان ممن دعاهم للكفر يوم القيامة»

14:22

Forms of disavowal on the Day of Resurrection «من صور البراءة يوم القيامة»

Leaders and chiefs disavowing their followers «أولًا: براءة الرؤساء والكبراء من أتباعهم»

2:166, 25:59

Followers wishing to return to the world to disown their leaders «ثانيًا: تمني التابعين للرؤساء العودة للدنيا للتبرؤ منهم»

2:167

The Quran's style in presenting disavowal «الأسلوب القرآني في عرض البراء»

The style of request «أولًا: أسلوب الطلب»

26:216, 109:1-6, 10:41, 60:1, 9:23

The style of statement «ثانيًا: أسلوب الخبر»

6:78, 8:48, 43:26, 6:19, 9:3

The style of dialogue «ثالثًا: أسلوب الحوار»

11:32-35, 6:74-78

What is to be disavowed «ما يُتَبَرَأ منه»

Idols and whatever is worshipped besides Allah «أولًا: الأوثان والمعبودون من دون الله»

2:256, 60:4

The idolaters in general, and relatives among them in particular «ثانيًا: المشركون عامة وذوو الأرحام منهم خاصة»

9:114, 19:46, 43:26, 58:22, 9:23-24

The fruits and results of disavowal «ثمرات البراءة ونتائجها»

Winning Allah's pleasure and escaping His wrath «أولًا: الفوز بمرضاة الله، والنجاة من سخط الجبار جل جلاله»

3:28, 4:139

Safety from strife and corruption in the land «ثانيًا: السلامة من الفتن والفساد في الأرض»

8:73

Blessings in this world and good renown in both abodes «ثالثًا: حصول النعم والخيرات في الدنيا، والثناء الحسن في الدارين»

19:49-50

Belonging to Allah's party and gaining victory over the disbelievers «رابعًا: يكون من حزب الله تعالى، ويحقق الغلبة والنصر على الكافرين»

58:22

Guarding the Muslim from submitting to the disbelievers «خامسًا: تحفظ المسلم من الانقياد للكافرين»

3:100, 11:113

Gaining Allah's protecting friendship «سادسًا: نيل ولاية الله»

2:120

About this source

موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم

مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية

Volume
4
Research paper
«البراء» (Disavowal)

Read the full paper (Arabic)

Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.

This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.

Browse all Quran topics