Human Nature · Quran topic
Warfare
الحرب · Harb
A study of warfare in the Quran: its meaning, aims, preparation, conduct and rulings
140 verses · 11 parts · 58 min read
Study guide based on
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
«الحرب» · Volume 6
At a glance
The paper defines warfare as the opposite of peace. Technically it describes warfare as a struggle between two groups, one seeking to destroy or overcome the other. The root occurs six times in the Quran. It carries two senses: fighting, and opposing the Shariah and spreading corruption in the land.
The paper explains the attribution of war to Allah and His Messenger, including Allah's declaration of war on those who persist in usury. It says the disbelievers, atheists and hypocrites, and those who help them, declared war on Allah, His Messenger and the believers. On preparation, it says Allah commanded material and moral preparation, urged consultation, and urged reliance on Him. On the battlefield, it says the Quran set out matters so that the army stays cohesive and is not caught unawares.
After war, it addresses captives and the division of spoils. It finds aims of war such as preserving the creed of oneness and lifting injustice from the oppressed. It describes morals the believing fighter must keep, such as not killing the peaceful and not harming women and children. It ends with principles of war drawn from Surat al-Adiyat as a model of strategy.
Key verses
- Al-Ma'idah 5:33: The paper treats the phrase about fighting Allah and His Messenger in this verse as figurative, since Allah does not fight as people do. The first kind it names are those who come out openly bearing arms for highway robbery and corruption in the land, or to rebel against the Muslim ruler who rules by Allah's law. The second are those who fight Allah's messengers and allies. It calls the verse's penalty a deterrent punishment for anyone who declares war on Allah and His Messenger.
- Al-Ma'idah 5:64: The paper says the verse's words show Allah's power and dominion over the hearts of His creatures, believer and disbeliever. It explains the fire as a metaphor: whenever they stir up evil and agree to fight the Prophet ﷺ or anyone else without right, Allah extinguishes it and subdues them. It reports the majority view that kindling the fire of war is a metaphor for the rage and hatred that inflame the corrupters' hearts against the believers.
- Al-Baqarah 2:279: The paper says its words indicate that the Messenger ﷺ and the rulers must fight usurers who persist, the war from Allah being the Fire on the Day of Resurrection and the war from the Messenger and rulers the sword in this world. It says Allah declared war on those who persist in usury and not on other crimes. It also says Allah commanded fighting those who persist in dealing in usury despite believing in Allah.
- Al-Anfal 8:46: The paper cites it as Allah's warning to the believers against dispute. It defines dispute as differing opinions and the cowardice, defeat, loss of the state and enemy takeover that follow. It says obedience to leadership and not disputing are among the most important requirements of victory.
- At-Tawbah 9:107: The paper cites it for those who help the fighters by paving the way for them. It reports that hypocrites built a mosque to receive Abu Amir, and that Allah commanded His Prophet to demolish it and described them as fighters and liars. It concludes that whoever paves the way for those fighting Allah is himself a fighter who must be fought until he stops his harm.
- At-Tawbah 9:123: The paper explains that here Allah specified those near, since all the polytheists cannot be fought at once. It says fighting the nearer is preferable, because engaging the farther while leaving the nearer gives no safety from the nearer attacking the Muslims' children, women and lands. It says this view of the near enemy has a security significance, weakening them and preserving lands.
- Al-Baqarah 2:193: The paper explains it as fighting those who attack you and your religion until there is no polytheism and worship and obedience are for Allah alone. It says that if they stop their polytheism, those who stopped are not to be attacked. It also cites it after the command to fight those who block the callers from their role.
- An-Nisa 4:102: The paper cites it for praying with caution in fighting: one group prays with the Prophet ﷺ while the other faces the enemy. It explains that the disbelievers wish for the believers to neglect their weapons so they can assault them at once while they pray. It gives as the reason for the fear prayer a report in Muslim from Jabir.
- Al-Baqarah 2:246: The paper cites it for the consultation of a prophet of the Israelites with his people before meeting the enemy. It says the verse tells of a generation conferring with one of their prophets about fighting in Allah's cause to recover their land and wealth. It cites it again among the political aims of war, quoting Ibn Atiyya's comment on their reply that they had been wronged and expelled. It concludes that fighting to recover homes from which a believer was unjustly expelled is fighting in the cause of Allah.
Words to know
- الحرب al-harb
Warfare: the opposite of peace. Technically, a struggle between two groups, one seeking to destroy or overcome the other.
Appears 11 times in the Quran.
Most common forms: حَرْب (4), مِحْراب (4), حارَبَ (2), مَحارِيب (1)
Root: ح ر ب
- القتال al-qital
Fighting: it carries the sense of warring and occurs only between two parties. It is one form of warfare, which is broader, while fighting has only one form.
Root: ق ت ل
- الغزو al-ghazw
Raiding: intent, and marching to fight the enemy. It is one form of warfare, involving marching to meet the enemy in his own land.
- الجهاد al-jihad
Jihad: going to the utmost, exhausting one's capacity in war, or with the tongue, or in whatever one is able. Technically, exhausting one's capacity in defending against the enemy. The paper says it is broader than warfare, since it may also be striving against one's own self.
Root: ج ه د
- السلم al-silm
Peace: the opposite of war. The paper describes it as a psychological state in society, from unity of aims and outlooks, bringing safety and tranquility in all areas of life.
Root: س ل م
The concept of warfare
From the paper: «مفهوم الحرب»
Linguistic meaning
Warfare (al-harb) is the opposite of peace; a brave fighter is called mihrab. Inciting someone against another is also from the same root. It is also said to mean fighting: arrows, then spears, then swords, then grappling when they crowd together.
Technical meaning
Warfare is a struggle between two groups, one seeking to destroy or overcome the other. It may aim at political, economic, ideological or expansionist gains, and is usually politics' last card. This agrees with the linguistic meaning: both mean the opposite of peace.
Warfare in Quranic usage
From the paper: «الحرب في الاستعمال القرآني»
The root h-r-b occurs six times in the Quran. Its forms are as follows.
- The past verb occurs once, as in At-Tawbah 9:107.
- The present verb occurs once, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:33.
- The verbal noun occurs four times, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:64.
Warfare comes in the Quran in two senses. The first is fighting, as in Al-Anfal 8:57, where the paper glosses the word as fighting. The second is opposing the Shariah and spreading corruption in the land, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:33. There, the paper explains, it means opposing the rulings of Allah and His Messenger and striving in the land for corruption.
Related terms
From the paper: «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»
Fighting (al-qital)
Fighting: linguistic meaning
Fighting (qital) and mutual fighting (muqatala) carry the sense of warring, and they occur only between two parties.
Fighting: technical meaning
Qital is an intensive form of killing (qatl). Muqatala is the same as qital and occurs only between two parties.
Relation between fighting and warfare
On this definition, fighting is one form of warfare. Warfare is broader and more inclusive, with many forms, while fighting has only one form; both are carried out against another party.
Raiding: linguistic meaning
Al-ghazw means intent, and also marching to fight the enemy. One who does so is called a ghazi.
Raiding: technical meaning
Al-Isfahani defines al-ghazw as going out to fight the enemy. The paper says warfare and al-ghazw relate as general to specific. Warfare is broader, since al-ghazw involves marching to meet the enemy in his own land and is one form of warfare, while warfare includes al-ghazw and other kinds of war; both are carried out against another party.
Jihad: linguistic meaning
Jihad means going to the utmost, exhausting one's capacity in war, or with the tongue, or in whatever one is able to do. Ijtihad and tajahud mean expending one's capacity and effort.
Jihad: technical meaning
Jihad and mujahada mean exhausting one's capacity in defending against the enemy. Some added to this, and in Shariah usage it came to be used mostly for the call to the true religion.
Relation between warfare and jihad
Jihad is broader than warfare. Every mujahid supporting the religion fights Allah's enemies, but not every fighter is a mujahid, since one may fight for worldly aims. Warfare is a struggle between two parties, whereas jihad may be striving against one's own self, to refine it. In warfare each side tries to defeat the other, while jihad is effort for the religion's good, wishing the other side well and not necessarily overpowering it.
Peace: linguistic meaning
The word for peace (al-silm) is read in three ways, and it is the opposite of war. Most of the root's usage concerns soundness and well-being, and salam means making peace.
Peace: technical meaning
The study is concerned with peace as the opposite of war: a psychological state in society, from unity of aims and outlooks, bringing safety and tranquility in all areas of life.
Relation between warfare and peace
Warfare results from disagreement, and peace from affection and harmony. They are opposite states that neither coexist nor are both absent; when one prevails, it removes the other.
Attributing war to Allah and His Messenger
From the paper: «إسناد الحرب لله تعالى ولرسوله»
Allah permitted His Messenger and the believers to fight the polytheists and their helpers, and undertook to give them victory. Whenever the disbelievers kindle a fire, He undertook to extinguish it; this is a wisdom explained below.
The wisdom of attributing war to Allah and His Messenger
The paper says that among the harshest decisive wars is one between two unequal powers. Allah's declaring war on the disobedient, and the open spreaders of corruption declaring war on Allah, are such a war, making Allah's enemies a lesson through the ages. The first issue is Allah's declaration of war on the disobedient.
Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:279. The paper observes that a side with greater might, equipment, knowledge and skill at deceiving and surprising the other settles the result in its favor. Allah has described Himself in the Quran with every attribute of strength, with encompassing the secrets of the universe, and with everything submitting to His command, will and ordering, so when He declares war on someone He humbles and subdues him; some of these attributes follow.
- The Strong, the Firm: Allah says Adh-Dhariyat 51:58. The paper cites the comment that this shows His greatness and that His dealing with His servants cannot be measured.
- The Mighty, the Compeller: Allah says Al-Hashr 59:23.
- Of severe seizing (batsh): Allah says Al-Buruj 85:12. The paper glosses this as His violence being doubled.
- His forces are beyond counting: Allah says Al-Fath 48:7. He also says Al-Muddaththir 74:31. The paper explains that none but He knows His creatures' hosts, and no creature can reach their realities.
- His seizing is painful and severe: Allah says Hud 11:102.
- He surprises His enemy with punishment: Allah says Al-A'raf 7:97-99. The paper cites the comment that Allah warned them of punishment while utterly heedless, asleep at night or at forenoon.
- He fears no reckoning and pays no heed to His opponent: Allah says Al-Anbiya 21:23.
- Nothing overwhelms Him in His dominion: Allah says Al-An'am 6:18. He also says Fatir 35:44.
- He encompasses everything in knowledge: Allah says At-Talaq 65:12.
- He controls the will and strength of His opponent: Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:64.
Explaining the last, the paper says "whenever they kindle a fire" means they stir up evil and agree to fight the Prophet ﷺ or anyone else without right, against Allah's command; Allah extinguishes it, subdues them and weakens their cause. The fire is a metaphor; Allah repels their plotting and controls their destiny.
The paper concludes that no individual, group or great state can ever fight a party with such strength. It introduces Al-An'am 6:6 as Allah's report of His might over tyrannical wrongdoers. This is some of what Allah reported of His strength, and what is hidden is greater, as He says Al-Muddaththir 74:31. His strength cannot be compared with creatures', nor imagined by the human mind. Allah is the protector and helper of His prophets and messengers, as He says Ghafir 40:51. So whoever turns away from the command of Allah or His Messenger ﷺ exposes himself to a war declared by Allah, and is certainly defeated and subdued.
The paper then turns to the attributing of war to Allah and His Messenger ﷺ in Al-Baqarah 2:278-279. It says this carries great wisdom, threat, warning and deterrence, which should make every sensible person think, as the points below show.
The paper says Allah threatened no wrongdoer as He threatened the persistent consumer of usury. Usury destroys societies, plants rancor and greed, prevents mutual mercy, and makes the rich dominate and enslave ordinary people. It leads to wars between societies and states, not for justice and peace but to keep the enslavement the moneyed wish to impose on the weak. So Allah declared war on those who persist in it, and not on other crimes, because it lays the ground for all the crimes after it.
Allah's declaring war on the disobedient, usurers and others, shows their certain defeat, that His seizing falls on them, and that their end is to vanish. This is plain from His great strength and their weakness before His might.
The third point is the duty to fight those who persist in sins and apply the prescribed punishments to them. The paper says the words quoted from Al-Baqarah 2:279 indicate that the Messenger ﷺ and the rulers must fight usurers who persist in this foul financial dealing. The war from Allah is with the Fire on the Day of Resurrection and the shaking of their souls, and the war from the Messenger and the rulers is by the sword in this world.
The paper says the verse was revealed about Banu Amr ibn Umayr of Thaqif and Banu al-Mughira of Makhzum, who had usury between them in the pre-Islamic period. After they entered Islam, Thaqif asked to collect it and they refused; Attab ibn Usayd, deputy of Mecca, referred it to the Prophet ﷺ, and the verse was revealed. He wrote the verses to Attab, and they said they repented and left all of it.
The paper states that whoever persists in usury and does not desist, the Muslims' imam should call him to repent, and if he does not stop, strike his neck. Qatada said that Allah threatened them with killing, as they hear, and made them bahraj, meaning their blood is forfeit.
The paper says that making "war" indefinite casts awe: a war they cannot withstand and cannot know the nature of. It is not by the sword only but a war on nerves and hearts, on the blessing of ample provision, on the enjoyment of ease, and on happiness and tranquility, leaving the usurer in misery and turmoil. It is a war that casts terror into His enemies' hearts, and the paper points to Al-Baqarah 2:275.
This casts gloom, hardship and loss of tranquility on usurers. Asked why it was not said "the war of Allah and His Messenger", the paper firmly replies that this is more eloquent, since it means a kind of war great with Allah and His Messenger.
The second issue is the disobedient declaring war on Allah and His Messenger. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:33. In light of this verse and the first issue, one who reflects on the disobedient draws several indications, given below. The first point is the ignorance of those who fight Allah of the Creator's greatness. The paper says the Quran describes the tyrannical disbelievers and disobedient as ignorant, and as foolish and lacking reason. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:13. This describes them as foolish and not knowing. He also says Al-Munafiqun 63:8. This describes them as ignorant of might belonging to Allah, His Messenger and the believers; how could they sense it, cut off from its source?
The second point is the duty to punish those who fight Allah and His Messenger. The paper says Allah commanded fighting the corrupters in the land among the Muslims, being harsh with them and giving them a deterrent punishment as an example to those after them. Citing the words of Al-Ma'idah 5:33, it says this orders pursuing the highway robbers among the Muslims, because a polytheist's repentance averts punishment before or after he is overpowered, whereas one who entered the Muslims' ranks and then spread corruption and fought Allah's allies must be taken as he deserves, and his repentance does not remove a prescribed punishment.
Allah made fighting these corrupters among the greatest means of drawing near to Him. Following that verse, Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:35. The paper glosses this as striving in His cause by fighting His enemies, outward and inward, so that they may succeed in reaching Allah and winning His honor.
The third point is disgrace and humiliation in this world. Besides punishment and retribution in this world, Allah threatened those who fight Him and His Messenger with abasement, humiliation and exposure before the witnesses. Quoting part of Al-Ma'idah 5:33, the paper glosses disgrace as evil, shame, exemplary punishment, humiliation and penalty in this world before the Hereafter.
Allah's warning did not stop at this world, but threatened painful punishment on the Day of Resurrection. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:33. This is a punishment on them and shows the greatness of their crime against Allah, His Messenger and His allies. The paper concludes that whoever fights Allah and His Messenger, rebels against His law, spreads corruption, commits highway robbery, and kills Allah's prophets and allies is among those Allah is angry with and fought, and commanded His messengers and allies to fight.
The second heading is the wisdom of attributing the extinguishing of war's fire to Allah. People hold two views about the origin of the fire of war. One group holds that it is a real fire: scouts hid in caves at night to watch armies, and when an army headed for Muslim lands a scout lit a fire seen from afar by another, who lit his own, until it reached the Muslims, who prepared to meet them. It is also said that when gathered for war at night they lit fires for fear of a night attack and sleep, and this is the origin.
The other group, the majority (al-jumhur), holds that kindling the fire of war is a metaphor for what inflames the corrupters' hearts with rage and hatred toward the believers. Whenever they call each other to fight the Muslims, Allah scatters them and casts terror and weakness into their hearts.
The paper says its inclination is to the majority view, because it is broader, has an effect in defeating the fighters, and shows the hatred in their hearts toward the believers. It adds that the origin of the term "fire of war" is closer to the first view.
The paper quotes Al-Ma'idah 5:64. It says this shows that those who kindle wars among nations are in Allah's grasp: He may keep their fire and set it on whichever wrongdoers He wills, as He says Al-An'am 6:129. Or He extinguishes it and returns their plotting to their own necks. Allah alone governs the universe and made His creatures' deeds a veil for His decree. The paper cites a hadith from Imran: asked whether the people of Paradise are known from those of Hell, the Prophet ﷺ said yes; asked why people then act, he said each is made ready for what he was created for. So nothing happens except what He wills; some are created as callers to guidance, others as kindlers of wars, and all are in His grasp.
Some wisdoms of this attribution follow. The first wisdom is that Allah Himself fights the corrupters. The verse shows that Allah Himself fights the corrupters and foils their plans against the believers, entrusting it to none of His creatures, which casts awe on every person of insight. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:30. He also says An-Naml 27:50-52.
The second is Allah's strength and dominion over His creatures' hearts. The words quoted from Al-Ma'idah 5:64 show His power and dominion over the hearts of His creatures, believer and disbeliever. As for the believers, He repels Satan's whispers and plotting from them. Allah says Al-Hijr 15:42. As for the disbelievers, He extinguishes the fire of their war and the rancor in their hearts by casting terror into them, so their defeat comes from within, as He says Al-Hashr 59:2.
Allah does not accept the corrupters' dominion over His believing allies, so He Himself defends them and repels their enemy's plotting. Allah says Al-Ahzab 33:25. After He extinguishes their fire and scatters their affair, you see them only humiliated, weak and receding. Allah undertook to support His allies, as He says Ar-Rum 30:47. Yet the corrupters may have a return against the believers, as a punishment for falling short in obedience or neglecting the means of strength; Allah gives their enemy power over them so that they return to their religion, and if they return He repels the enemy's plotting. Allah says An-Nisa 4:141.
The paper summarizes that Allah confronts His enemies Himself, foils their plotting and scatters their word. They hardly agree on anything without Allah placing in it a harm that returns on them, so the flame of their fire burns their own hearts.
The paper adds a subtle point: before the Aws and Khazraj of Medina met the Prophet ﷺ, the Jews threatened them that a prophet whose time had come would be sent, and that they would follow him and kill them as 'Ad and Iram were killed. When the Prophet ﷺ spoke to some people of Medina in the season and called them to Allah, they said to one another that he was the prophet the Jews had threatened them with and the Jews must not reach him first; they answered his call and accepted Islam.
The Jews' threat kindled fear in the Medinans' hearts of a future promising no good. Allah made it a reason for them to accept his call quickly, before the Jews reached him; Allah extinguished the fire of fear in their hearts and returned the Jews' plotting to their throats.
Those who fight Allah and His Messenger
From the paper: «المحاربون لله ولرسوله»
The disbelievers, atheists and hypocrites, and those who help them, declared war on Allah, His Messenger and the believers; Allah declared war on them and prepared for them a painful punishment in this world and the Hereafter.
Those who fight Allah and His Messenger
Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:33. The paper says fighting Allah and His Messenger in that verse is figurative, since Allah does not fight as people do, and the term covers two kinds of people. The first are those who come out openly bearing arms for highway robbery and corruption in the land, or to rebel against the Muslim ruler who rules by Allah's law. They are so called because their act opposes Allah's law, likened to people who fight.
The second are those who fight Allah's messengers and allies, as Allah says Al-Ahzab 33:57. The paper explains this as harming Allah's allies, and adds that the term may rightly apply to those of great offense who sin openly, even if they are of the faith. The paper lists them as follows.
- Those who bear arms for highway robbery and terrorizing safe people.
- Those who rebel with arms, inside or outside the country, against the Muslim ruler who applies Allah's law over his subjects.
- Those who bear arms to turn people from Allah's religion, prevent their rites, and stop calling to Allah.
- Those who openly commit sins, call to anything other than Islam, Allah's religion on earth, and all who attack Allah's law by changing and distorting it.
Those who help the fighters
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:107. The paper says the enemies of Allah and His Messenger stir up the masses, the foolish and simple, and tempt them with wealth and comfort to follow and obey them. All of these, leaders and soldiers, are fighters against Allah and His Messenger, and, with Allah, wrongdoers and sinners.
Allah says Al-Qasas 28:8. The paper explains that Pharaoh led the war on Allah and His prophet Musa, Haman was his commander, and the soldiers were the retinue and subjects, his tool of oppression; all are sinners in Allah's balance. Al-Tabari says that Pharaoh, Haman and their soldiers were sinful toward their Lord.
Helping the wrongdoers and fighters goes beyond carrying out their orders, in many forms. First, passing information to the fighters and showing them affection. Allah says Al-Mumtahanah 60:1. The paper explains that Allah forbids the believers to pass information to the enemies who fight Allah and His Messenger, and even something less, showing affection, a degree of love. A believer who secretly shows affection to the polytheists has strayed, meaning deviated from the course Allah made the road to Paradise.
Second, paving the way for the fighters. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:107. The paper reports that hypocrites built a mosque to receive Abu Amir, the disbeliever who denied Allah's Prophet and joined the Romans, rallying factions to fight him. He wrote asking them to complete it and prepare weapons to fight the Prophet ﷺ. Allah commanded His Prophet to demolish it, and described them as fighters and as liars in their claim to want good. The paper calls this decisive proof that whoever paves the way for those fighting Allah is himself a fighter who must be fought until he stops his harm.
Third, taking the fighters as allies. The paper introduces Al-Ma'idah 5:51-52 as Allah's statement forbidding alliance with the nation's enemies among the Jews and Christians. Whoever allies with those who fight Allah and His Messenger is in their ranks, one of them. Al-Zamakhshari says: do not take them as allies, supporting them or seeking their support. He adds that they are allies of one another because their creed is united and they are gathered in disbelief. The paper calls this Allah's command to shun those who fight the nation and lie in wait for it.
Fourth, propaganda for destructive thought and moral decay. The paper says war in this age is not limited to military battles; media and psychological war, spreading moral decay and casting doubt on Allah's religion are among the disbelievers' main means of fighting the nation and its creed. Those who spread vice and fight virtue are no less dangerous than the military fighters. Allah warned of them, saying An-Nur 24:19. The paper cites a hadith: whoever calls to guidance has a reward like that of his followers, and whoever calls to misguidance bears sins like theirs, without reducing theirs.
The recompense of those who fight Allah and His Messenger, and their helpers
The paper says Allah is angered when His sanctities are violated and when His allies are attacked. The fighters are wrongdoers and aggressors who violate every sanctity, and harm and kill those who command justice. Allah takes charge of His allies and repels their enemy's plotting, and has punished the fighters of His religion in this world and the Hereafter.
First, punishment and torment in this world. Part of Allah's support for His allies is that He decreed defeat and punishment for their enemy in this life, so that those who fight Allah and His religion are a lesson for those after them. Of Pharaoh, Allah says Yunus 10:92.
The paper says He made their punishment through three means. The first means is destroying them through the laws of the universe. Allah says Al-Ankabut 29:40. Allah's laws continue and remain with His enemies who fight His allies and His law, unchanging. Allah says Al-Ahzab 33:62. The second means is seizing them by the hands of the believers. The paper says Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to fight and confront the disbelievers and hypocrites and be harsh with them, and made fighting them among the greatest acts of worship by which one draws near to Him. The Quranic context on fighting those who fight Allah runs as follows.
- The command to fight those who fight Allah: Allah says At-Tawbah 9:5. Al-Samarqandi explains in his tafsir that this verse abrogated seventy verses of the Quran on truce, covenant, restraint and patience with the harm the aggressing disbelievers caused the believers, and commanded the believers to pursue and capture them, be harsh with them and watch for them on every road. Allah commanded the believers to fight them in order to defeat them and disgrace them in this world. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:14.
- A command to fight all the fighters who lie in wait for the nation: Allah says At-Tawbah 9:36. He also says At-Tawbah 9:123. The paper says the Prophet ﷺ did this effort, fighting Allah's enemies, and the Companions carried the banner after him until Allah's religion became mighty, and Ali 'Imran 3:110 came true of this nation.
- Allah's undertaking to defeat the fighters: Allah undertook to defeat the disbelievers and to ruin their lives and wealth, making them a regret to them, as He says Al-Qamar 54:45. The paper then quotes Al-Anfal 8:36 and Ali 'Imran 3:12. It concludes that defeat and regret befall those who fight Allah and His Messenger despite their abundant wealth, numbers and equipment. It also quotes Ali 'Imran 3:196-197.
- Carrying out the prescribed punishment on the fighters: Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:33. The paper calls this a deterrent punishment for anyone who declares war on Allah and His Messenger, by killing, banishment and cutting off as a prescribed punishment for their crimes, their attack on sanctities and their terrorizing of the safe.
Second, punishment on the Day of Resurrection. Just as Allah threatened His enemies with seizure in this world, He threatened them with punishment in the Hereafter, and the paper summarizes some of the many verses on this.
- A great punishment: Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:33.
- A painful punishment: Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:21. He also says Al-Hajj 22:25. And An-Nur 24:19.
- A humiliating punishment: Allah says Al-Mujadilah 58:5.
- Eternity in the Fire: Allah says At-Tawbah 9:63.
- An evil end: Allah says An-Nisa 4:115.
- Regret and remorse: Allah says Al-Anfal 8:36.
Preparing for war
From the paper: «الإعداد للحرب»
Allah commanded us to prepare and equip with all the material and moral strength we can, to frighten His enemy and be severe toward the disbelievers and hypocrites; He urged consultation among ourselves and reliance on Him, and victory comes only from Allah.
Preparing moral and material strength
The paper says the human soul and its sound natural disposition incline to peace and calm, shrink from fighting and war, and feel their weight and hardship. The Quran reveals the soul's hidden depths, its good and evil, and does not deny it this feeling, as Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:216. The Quran began preparing the soul for fighting in the following steps.
First, psychological preparation of the fighters. It has two issues. The first is encouraging jihad.
- Jihad is the best of deeds by which Allah's face is sought. The paper reports that the Companions said that, had they known the deed most beloved to Allah they would give their wealth and lives for it, and they were told of it in As-Saff 61:4. It also cites Al-Ma'idah 5:35. The verses show that jihad is the best way to win Allah's pleasure and His honors.
- Allah commanded His Prophet to urge the believers to fight. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:65. The paper glosses this as urging them strongly to fight so they are not destroyed by the disbelievers' aggression when they see them weak and submissive, a benefit the nation must pursue.
- Allah preferred the mujahidin over those who stay behind. Allah says An-Nisa 4:95. The paper says the verse plainly shows the mujahidin's merit.
- Jihad as the path to victory and establishment: Allah says As-Saff 61:10-13.
- Jihad ends polytheism and wars: Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:193. The paper explains this as: until there is no polytheism and the religion is purely Allah's; if they stop, do not attack those who stopped, for it is not good to wrong one who has repented and turned back. It says the nation today lives in humiliation because it abandoned jihad, calamities have befallen it, and only jihad will repel them.
- Jihad as the path to eternity and winning the Gardens: Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:169-170. The paper cites a report in Muslim, from Masruq, in which Abdullah said they asked about this and were told their spirits are in green birds roaming Paradise at will and sheltering in lanterns hung from the Throne. Asked three times by their Lord if they desired anything, they asked to be returned to their bodies to be killed in His cause again, and when He saw they had no need, they were left.
- Jihad with self and wealth is the price of the Gardens: Allah says At-Tawbah 9:111. The paper says the verse encourages the believers to jihad by stating its merit, after describing those who stayed behind from it, and conveys acceptance of what they give of self and wealth in His cause.
The second issue is warning against staying behind from jihad.
- Warning against sitting back and not marching out: Allah says At-Tawbah 9:38-39. The paper explains that if they sit back from carrying out Allah's commands, foremost supporting Allah and His Messenger, He will destroy them with punishment and bring other people after them, not of their loins. This confirms the threat and intensifies the warning by indicating a difference in attribute and in essence, which requires uprooting and shows the intensity of displeasure.
- Warning against neglecting weapons: Allah says An-Nisa 4:102. The paper explains that the disbelievers wish for a moment when the believers neglect their weapons and baggage, so they can assault them at once while busy praying, killing them and plundering their camp. Allah warns against being so occupied with prayer, when it is due, that one drops caution and leaves the weapons. The paper says the nation's enemies today are keen to strip Muslims of all strength; having neglected our weapons, we were attacked, our lands torn, our sanctities and honor violated, all because of abandoning jihad and neglecting weapons.
- Warning against weakness, frailty and submission: Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:146. The paper quotes a gloss: they did not falter and their army was not broken by what befell them, the killing of their prophet or some of them; they did not weaken in fighting their enemy or in their religion; and they did not submit, meaning yield to their enemy. The paper adds that it is as if Allah says to the believers that this was the state of those before them, so they should not be less than them in weakness and submission.
- Sitting out of fighting is submission to Satan, as Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:155. The paper quotes a comment that it is said to mean those who turned back from the polytheists on the day of Uhud, whom Satan induced to slip by whispering in their hearts because of the ill effect of some sins they had earned, among them disobeying the Messenger ﷺ.
Second, material preparation for fighting.
Physical preparation of soldiers
Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:247. The paper says the physical strength of military men, commanders and soldiers matters greatly, for the ability to carry out their field tasks and break the enemy's might. Al-Samarqandi explains that Allah gave Talut an advantage in knowledge and body, being a large man learned in the arts of war and fighting, which made him fitter to lead the army.
The next issue is preparing the army's plans for battle. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:121. The paper says planning varies with the means of fighting, geography and more, but always requires preparation. At Badr the Prophet ﷺ stopped at one site and al-Hubab ibn al-Mundhir saw a better one, so he took his view. At the Trench he took Salman al-Farisi's view to dig a trench as a defensive plan for Medina. At Uhud he walked on foot and lined up his Companions for battle, pushing back anyone who stuck out his chest, camped at the side of the valley with his back and army toward Uhud, and appointed Abdullah ibn Jubayr over the archers. He told the archers to repel the enemy with arrows so they would not come from behind, and told his Companions to hold that position and, if the enemy turned their backs, not to pursue them.
Preparing the weapons of fighting
Allah says Al-Anfal 8:60. The paper explains that preparation means readying, and that "whatever you are able" includes whatever lies within people's ability of equipment. Strength means the soundness of the organs for their work, and figuratively the intensity of a thing's effect and its cause; an army's strength is its impact on the enemy and also its weapons and equipment, which is meant here, a figurative usage (majaz mursal) through two intermediaries. So swords, spears, bows and arrows were strength in past armies, and tanks, cannons, planes and rockets are strength in the armies of our time.
The paper says the nation is today required to harness its resources to acquire the material strength that qualifies it to face the dangers around it from every side and repel aggression from its sons, its sanctities and its creed, acting on the Book and taking the means.
Consultation
The paper says Allah's law came to establish the best human values, harmony of souls, closing ranks and rousing latent human energies, and consultation (shura) is among its rules and firm rulings. The Prophet ﷺ practiced it in many matters of the nation requiring ijtihad, since there is no consultation on what revelation brought down; he consulted his Companions on many issues touching their lives, a legacy the nation takes pride in. He consulted them most on matters of fighting, for its great effect on the nation's course and the need to mobilize energies, close ranks and soothe souls.
Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to consult his Companions, saying Ali 'Imran 3:159. The paper says this honors the nation and shows its merit with its Lord, for a great king consults only the elite of his court. Consultation is part of preparation, good management and planning before entering wars and campaigns, and the paper draws evidence from the following.
First, Musa's consultation with his people about entering the holy land. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:21-26. The paper says Musa dialogued and argued with his people about holding to Allah's command and entering the holy land, which would entail fighting and jihad, but the gap is great between the answer of Musa's people to their prophet and the answer of Muhammad's Companions ﷺ.
Second, the consultation of a prophet of the Israelites with his people before meeting the enemy. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:246. The paper says the verse tells of a generation of the Israelites conferring with one of their prophets about fighting in Allah's cause and meeting the enemy to recover their land and wealth.
Third, the Queen of Saba's consultation with her people about Sulayman. Allah says An-Naml 27:29-33. The paper says the matter was grave: it was a message declaring war from Allah's prophet Sulayman on the kingdom of Saba, demanding obedience, submission and surrender, so she gathered her counselors to settle it.
The paper says jihad and fighting need much expertise in the arts of fighting and facing the enemy, and a great mobilization, which is done only through consultation and use of the mind. It adds that the command to consult them came as a comment on the events of Uhud, confirming this principle despite the wounds the Muslims had suffered. Some exegetes hold that consultation applies only to matters of war, and that the definite article in "the matter" denotes a known matter, not all matters. The paper says this at least shows that consultation is part of planning for fighting.
Arab chiefs were distressed when not consulted, so the paper explains that Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to consult his Companions so that his deciding alone would not weigh on them. Consultation is an important pillar for unifying the ranks and gathering the word, and human nature is the same through time.
Resolve and reliance on Allah
Warning the believers against dispute, Allah says Al-Anfal 8:46. The paper defines dispute (tanazu') as differing opinions and the cowardice, defeat, loss of the state and enemy takeover that follow.
War needs firm leadership, and the gravest danger a leader faces is hesitation and lack of resolve in decision before and during battle. After psychological preparation and consultation, the Prophet ﷺ and the commanders after him had to be directed to resolve (al-azm) and then reliance on Allah, which is his guidance in all his affairs. The paper quotes Qatada: Allah commanded His Prophet, when he resolves on a matter, to proceed and rely on Allah, not on their consultation; resolve is the considered, refined matter, and riding one's opinion without deliberation is not resolve.
First, his resolve at Badr. Al-Mubarakfuri mentions in al-Rahiq that before Badr the Prophet ﷺ gathered his men for a consultative military council. Abu Bakr, Umar and al-Miqdad advised him to proceed, but he kept asking for advice until Sad ibn Muadh, the Ansar's standard-bearer, spoke. Sad answered that they would follow him even into the sea, none would stay behind, and they were steadfast in war. He was pleased and began arranging the ranks and planning the encounter. Al-Thalabi mentions something similar on Al-Anfal 8:6.
Second, his resolve at Uhud. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:159. When the Prophet ﷺ heard Quraysh were coming to fight him at Uhud, he consulted his Companions, and opinion split between fighting outside Medina and fortifying within; he inclined to fight in Medina. A large group of young Companions who had missed Badr advised going out and pressed him. He went in, put on his armor and came out; they said that if he preferred to stay he should, and he said it is not fitting for a prophet who has put on his armor to take it off until Allah judges between him and his enemy.
The paper draws the lesson that consultation has its time; when resolve and reliance on Allah are due, there is no room for hesitation, repeating consultation or wavering; matters go to their ends, and Allah then does what He wills.
Third, warning against abandoning resolve. The believers wished for a surah urging fighting in Allah's cause; when it came, some became sluggish and sat out resolve, so Allah rebuked the sluggish, saying Muhammad 47:21. The paper says this reproaches those sluggish in jihad after being commanded, and the great corruption that results: lands ruined and people scattered. It adds that the threat in the third-person style alerts to the extreme of Allah's anger.
On the battlefield
From the paper: «في ميدان الحرب»
The paper says battlefields are many, and the Quran set out matters for Muslims on the battlefield so that the army stays cohesive and is not caught unawares, which would be a disaster for the Muslims. These were set out by Allah and clarified by the Prophet ﷺ, as the points below show.
Praying with caution
The paper says the Quran guided the nation, individuals and group, to all that improves its affairs, serves its interests and preserves its standing, making it a lordly nation (ummah rabbaniyya) that nothing distracts from remembering Allah: not wealth, children, family, nor fighting.
Allah addresses His Prophet and the leaders after him in An-Nisa 4:102. The paper explains that when you are among your Companions in fear, at home or traveling, and begin the obligatory prayer, one group stands in prayer with you while the other faces the enemy, patrolling every place from which he might attack those praying. Those praying need protection, and the one praying carries his weapon, taking the means and caution.
The paper gives as the reason for the fear prayer a report in Muslim from Jabir: in a raid on a people of Juhayna who fought fiercely, the polytheists said after the noon prayer that had they attacked they could have cut the Muslims off; Jibril told the Prophet ﷺ, who told them, and when the afternoon prayer came he had them form two rows.
The paper says Allah, in training the nation by His guidance, does not neglect guiding it to preserve its security in decisive moments. Prayer is the believers' spiritual provision, and the Prophet ﷺ was keen to pray in congregation even when the ranks clashed. So a plan was needed for it in fighting that secures the ranks and denies the lurking enemy the chance of the believers' neglect of baggage and weapons. Allah therefore commanded His Prophet and the leaders after him to pray in congregation as the Quran described, with urging of the utmost caution.
Steadfastness with remembrance of Allah
The Quranic context sets out the real equipment that helps the fighters. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:45-46. The verses show four matters leading to victory.
First, steadfastness and not fleeing. It orders the believers to hold firm on meeting the enemy, without fear or weakness in their souls, and shows that steadfastness is the start of the road to victory, as the steadier side most often prevails. Allah warned against fleeing before the enemy, saying Al-Anfal 8:15-16. The Prophet ﷺ counted turning back on the day of the advance among the major sins, unless part of a plan of attack and retreat or to join another group or front. The paper cites a hadith from Abu Hurayra listing seven destructive sins, among them turning back on the day of the advance, with associating partners with Allah, magic, unlawful killing, an orphan's wealth, usury, and slandering chaste believing women.
Second, remembrance of Allah. Remembering Allah and sensing His company eases the greatness of the situation for the soldiers, steadies their hearts and feet, and brings victory; the command to remember Him much in fighting is the refuge of the one seeking help. Qatada said Allah made remembrance obligatory at the busiest moment, the striking of swords. It may mean remembrance by hearts and tongues, as Ibn Abbas said: Allah commanded His allies to remember Him in their severest state, so that a person never leaves his heart and tongue empty of it; or it may mean supplication for victory, since it comes only with Allah's help.
Both are required of the mujahid: remembrance by the tongue, glorifying Allah, and supplication, devotion and asking for victory are the best occupation at these decisive moments, which may be the last of his life, so his soul ascends while he remembers Allah. It cites the saying of the Prophet ﷺ that whoever's last words are the declaration of Allah's oneness enters Paradise. Armies must be raised on remembrance and supplication before wars, to accompany fighters in hardship and when ranks clash.
Third, obedience and not disputing. Soldiers must adopt obedience to leadership and not disputing; after commanding steadfastness and remembrance, Allah added the words quoted from Al-Anfal 8:46. Obedience is among the most important requirements of victory. Al-Maraghi explains that one should obey Allah in the means leading to success, and obey His Messenger, the explainer of his Lord's words and the greatest commander in fighting, whose obedience is the sum of discipline, a pillar of victory; dispute brings failure and loss of strength, so the enemy overcomes you.
Fourth, patience. It is treated under the fifth point.
Inflicting punishment so as to cast fear in others
Allah commanded the believers to call to Allah and enjoin right and forbid wrong, and praised the group that does so. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:104. He commanded fighting those who block the callers from their role. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:193. The paper says this was the way of the first conquerors: they gave nations the choice of Islam, the jizya, or fighting as a last remedy, to lift injustice from people and prevent interference with their religion and belief. The tyrants refused except to block Allah's religion and subjugate people, so the nation had to uproot them, as a lesson to all who block this religion and oppose its callers. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:55-57.
The paper explains tashrid as scattering with disorder. Ata said to kill heavily among them until others fear you. It is also said to make an example of them that scatters other treaty-breakers, so they may take heed. It is also said the address is to the Prophet ﷺ and, after him, to rulers: if you meet these disbelievers, do what seems fit as a deterrent to those who come after them or do the like. Ibn Abbas said the meaning is to make an example of them for those behind them and make them talked of.
Striking the necks of the enemy until they are weakened
The paper says the field of fighting is one field of calling to Allah, neither the first nor the last. The fighter in Allah's cause is a caller before being a fighter, for the call is mercy and guidance, not killing and bloodshed. Allah says Al-Anbiya 21:107.
If Iblis's soldiers refuse except to rebel against Allah and obstruct the callers, every illness has a cure, and for the obstinate, arrogant fighters it is that wounds be inflicted on them heavily. Allah says Muhammad 47:1-4.
The paper explains that the verses show two groups, Satan's party and the believing group, and that the believers must fight Satan's party. "Striking" is a verbal noun in the accusative, meaning strike the necks, which conveys intensity in aiming at their necks only; this implies killing them and being rid of their filth. There is great wisdom in targeting necks: in fighting the disbelievers the believer pushes rather than defends. This is unlike repelling an assailant or highway robber, where the aim of fighting is not to kill but to frighten and repel him.
The context goes on urging the believers to continue the battle until they inflict killing, exhaust the polytheists' strength, break their might and finish off their fighters, killed or captive, so that only a Muslim or a peaceful person remains in the field. Calling to Allah by the tongue is an eloquent field: the good word, argument met with argument, the best speech, in compliance with An-Nahl 16:125. The field of fighting, the paper says, must be no less eloquent in inflicting heavy casualties on the enemy, making an example of him, killing and scattering him, than the speech of preachers.
Patience
The paper says the nation's aim in fighting is to make an example of the disbelievers by killing and scattering, so terror settles in their hearts and they submit to Allah and enter the religion of mercy and guidance. This demands great effort and sacrifice from the believers, which only the prepared can endure. The best provision after Allah-consciousness is patience and perseverance, which the Quran urges at the enemy's meeting, showing their outcome.
Allah says Al-A'raf 7:128. The paper explains that when Pharaoh threatened the Israelites with killing the men, sparing the women and crucifixion on palm trunks, Musa saw that a fierce war led by Pharaoh would surely fall on his people, who were afraid. He commanded them to seek Allah's help and be patient, and told them of Allah's promise to destroy the Copts and give them their land. He urged this before meeting the enemy, to calm the soul at the encounter, with victory following.
Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:250. The best way to draw Allah's help is patience for Allah at the encounter and in bearing war's hardships, including advance and retreat, bloodshed, loss of loved ones, severed limbs and flying heads, in hope of His pleasure; this brings His help, and with it victory. When the small believing group knew that the enemy's numbers cannot stand against Allah's company, they made their supplication at the duel, whose request for patience the paper glosses as patience poured on them as water poured on cloth wets it. Allah answered because they did what warrants His company and brings victory: patience and steadfastness.
Many verses urge patience and steadfastness at the encounter; Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:125. The paper explains that if you are patient at the meeting and take Allah-consciousness as provision, Allah will be with you and aid you with help and with angels fighting the enemy alongside you. It then quotes Al-Anfal 8:45-46.
After the war ends
From the paper: «بعد انتهاء الحرب»
The paper says that as the Quran urges the nation to fight the disbelievers, it does not neglect the issues arising from wars; their consequences are many, and the Quran took care to address them. This section treats some of them.
Treatment of prisoners of war
Among the most important issues the Quran addresses from wars is that of captives. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:67. The paper says this verse was revealed after Badr and deals with the captives, the dispute over them, and the rulings: striking their necks, or release as a favor or for ransom. It was the first time the nation faced its enemy, with the aim stated in Al-Anfal 8:12. Killing the polytheists and striking necks was the goal, to humble them and break their might so they have no standing on earth.
When the Muslims were busy gathering captives and spoils, thinking seventy killed sufficed, Allah blamed them, saying Al-Anfal 8:67. The paper says that was not enough to humble the polytheists, and no ruling on captives had yet come. The Prophet ﷺ consulted his Companions and took the view of ransom; his Lord blamed him and showed the more correct course: thorough killing, subduing and breaking their might.
The paper draws the following from the verses on captives. First, Allah blamed His Prophet ﷺ because his Companions were busy capturing polytheists in the first battle; the priority was heavy wounding, breaking their might and psychological defeat. Al-Baydawi explains that it means until killing is thorough and disbelief humbled; Allah commanded thorough killing and forbade ransom when might was with the polytheists, and gave a choice of ransom or favor when the believers prevailed.
Second, the Quran did not forbid capturing and binding polytheists, but legislated it on condition that it follows thorough striking of necks and heavy killing, until the banner of disbelief falls and no might remains. Gathering captives before that is what Allah faulted. Third, Allah says Muhammad 47:4. The paper explains it as a command to the Prophet ﷺ to target their necks with swords in fighting, as more effective in killing. When their strength is exhausted, the remnant are bound firmly as captives so they do not return and kill the Muslims; when the battle ends, they are released as a favor or ransomed.
Fourth, the Quran treats the human soul as a compassionate, tender one would, not as a gloater lying in wait. When the Prophet ﷺ imposed ransom, some captives felt it, and al-Abbas said he had left him begging from Quraysh for as long as he lived, so Allah revealed Al-Anfal 8:70. The paper says Allah mentioned this verse to win them over and soothe their souls, since taking their wealth was hard on them.
Fifth, Allah commanded kindness to the captive even if he is not of our religion and is fighting us. He made obligatory good treatment, with food and clothing preserving a dignified life, for perhaps it will show him the true image of Islam and motivate him to join the believers. Allah says Al-Insan 76:8.
The paper explains this as feeding food despite great need for it; it is also said it is out of love for Allah, and captives are named among them. On this reading, feeding captives is permitted even if they are not of our religion and reward is hoped for, but they may not be given from obligatory charity such as zakat and expiation. It is also said that the captive means a slave, a woman, or your debtor. The paper holds the more likely view (and Allah knows best) is that the war captive is meant, since kindness to slaves and women comes in another context in the Quran.
Spoils of war and their division
Another issue the Quran addressed after the war is spoils and their division. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:41. The paper says the Quranic context took up this matter taking into account the nation's weakness and poverty and its need for material strength and equipment to strengthen the Muslims' might and fighting ability among nations.
First, Allah referred the ruling on spoils and fay' to Himself and His Messenger ﷺ. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:1. The paper says this is the Quran's nature and method in dealing with issues arising in the nation's life, referring the matter to Allah and His Messenger to judge. This verse was revealed after the Companions differed over the spoils of Badr. The paper summarizes the exegetes' long discussion of the cause of revelation: the Badr participants' souls grew apart, and what happens in human souls of wanting preference and exclusivity occurred; the verse referred the spoils to Allah and His Messenger to end the dispute, the Muslims accepted and submitted, and Allah put right the relations among them.
Second, Allah forbade spoils to previous nations and made them lawful for this nation, seeing its weakness and need for wealth and equipment. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:69. The paper cites a saying of the Prophet ﷺ that he was given five things no one before him was given: every prophet was sent to his own people while he was sent to all, red and black; spoils were made lawful for him and for none before; the earth was made pure and a place of prayer so a man prays wherever the prayer finds him; he was made victorious by terror a month's journey ahead; and he was given intercession.
Third, the Quranic context distinguished what was taken from the disbelievers by war from what was taken without war or battle. Allah says Al-Hashr 59:6-7. What Allah gave His Messenger without war is a pure gift from Allah to His Messenger, which he uses as he wills. What was taken by force in fighting is booty (ghanima), a fifth of which is for Allah and the Messenger and the rest for the fighters. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:41.
The aims of war as the Quran explains them
From the paper: «مقاصد الحرب كما بينها القرآن»
The paper says the aims of wars differ between nations according to their creeds. The believer seeks Allah's pleasure in every deed, and since war is among the greatest things one gives, its aims must be His pleasure. One who looks at the verses on war and jihad finds Islam's aims easily, as follows.
Creed-related aims
The most important motive for jihad is to preserve the creed of oneness (tawhid) in people's souls and repair its corruption. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:193. The paper explains this as fighting those who attack you and your religion until there is no polytheism, no one is worshipped besides Allah, and worship and obedience are for Him alone, not idols or polytheistic ideas.
The paper says the dominance on earth of any creed other than tawhid is a trial (fitna) and corrupts its people. The Islamic creed is the only one Allah accepts, and it must prevail, as in Ali 'Imran 3:85. Yet people are not forced to adopt it, as in Al-Baqarah 2:256. It adds Yunus 10:99. So compelling them is wrong once the clear proofs of Muhammad's ﷺ truthfulness have appeared; the choice is theirs.
Shariah aims
The paper defines the Shariah aim of war as fighting those who depart from Allah's law and binding them to the laws and rulings Allah revealed, and cites At-Tawbah 9:29. It explains this as fighting the People of the Book despite their belief in Allah, because they refused to obey Him in laws and rulings, and by this refusal it is as though they rejected the religion altogether.
Likewise Allah commanded fighting those who persist in dealing in usury despite believing in Allah, warning them of war from Allah and His Messenger in Al-Baqarah 2:279. The war of Allah is the Fire on the Day of Resurrection and the war of His Messenger is the sword in this world. Qatada said Allah threatened the people of usury with killing and made them bahraj wherever they are caught. The paper says fighting believers who depart from Allah's law is an obligation by the Book and the Sunnah, and the war of apostasy is not far from us.
Social aims
The paper defines the social aim as lifting injustice from the oppressed, weak and persecuted in the world, and from captives tortured and unjustly denied freedom, showing this religion's lofty humane dimension. It cites An-Nisa 4:75. Al-Dahhak said that Quraysh's disbelievers had captured seven Muslims and were torturing them, so Allah commanded fighting to rescue them. The paper quotes a comment that the verse covers the believers, the captives and the hawadir of polytheism until the Day of Resurrection, hadira meaning what is near, so cities near the polytheists' lands. It says supporting them was our duty, jihad being a means of nearness to Allah for lifting injustice from them.
Islam commands lifting suffering from the oppressed and freeing humans from servitude to humans to the honor of servitude to Allah, sparing no effort, even at the cost of wealth and lives, when tyrants prevent that goal.
Political aims
The paper defines the political aim as protecting people from subjugation, persecution and expulsion from their homes, political injustice and crimes that neither Allah nor the holders of man-made laws today accept, and also fighting those who break treaties. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:246. Ibn Atiyya comments on their reply, stressing that they had been wronged and expelled. This indicates that fighting to recover homes from which a believer was unjustly expelled is fighting in the cause of Allah.
Allah says Al-Hajj 22:39-40. The paper says the context also shows the right of the wronged who were driven from their homes for no sin except saying that their Lord is Allah, the truest thing said. This is Allah's permission for a force to defend the people of belief, to preserve the religious character on earth and its places of worship. Mentioning Allah's name in places of worship does not earn them the wrongdoers' protection, so belief and places of worship need defenders against tyrants, and for this Allah legislated jihad.
As for breaking treaties and pacts, Allah says At-Tawbah 9:12. The paper explains that if peaceful allies turn to treachery and break their pledge to honor the treaty, the Muslims fight those who kindle trials and break treaties, the disbelievers' chiefs and leaders.
Security aims
The paper defines the security aim of fighting as showing the nation's strength and always preparing available equipment, so the disbelievers reckon fully with meeting it. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:123. The paper explains that at the start of the surah Allah commanded fighting the polytheists everywhere, but here specified those near, since all cannot be fought at once. Fighting the nearer is preferable, because engaging the farther while leaving the nearer gives no safety from the nearer attacking the Muslims' children, women and lands when emptied of fighters. So the basis of relations with the near enemy is that he sees strength and force from us at any provocation, and finds no softness in our speech or dealing.
This view of the near enemy has a security significance: weakening them, preserving lands, securing children and wealth. The nation must likewise prepare all the equipment it can and exert its full energy to reach a strength that brings awe to Allah's enemies, remaining protector of the religion and the Muslims' heartland. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:60. The aim of preparation is to strengthen the nation to deter and repel aggressors, so the disbelievers see the Muslims' strength, equipment, fortresses and accurate aim, terror settles in their hearts, they keep fearing confrontation and return to peace.
The morals of the believers who fight, and others
From the paper: «أخلاق المؤمنين المحاربين وغيرهم»
The paper says nations' morals come from their beliefs, and the Quran trains the nation in the best morals in every area of life. Since war is a necessary social behavior, the Quran set values and morals the fighter must keep, to show the nature of this religion and the loftiness of its aims even in wartime.
Allah says An-Nisa 4:94. The paper says this verse set the general rule for the fighter's morals, based on not killing the peaceful and non-combatants. Al-Tabari explains: when you march against your enemies, be deliberate about killing anyone whose Islam or disbelief you do not know; kill only one you know with certainty to be at war with you; and do not deny the faith of one who submits without fighting, killing him for worldly goods, for with Allah there is provision better for you.
Since the aims of war in the Quran are lofty, the fighters' morals must be lofty. The Prophet's ﷺ guidance, the true translation of the Quran, and that of the Rightly-Guided Caliphs show the traits of the believing fighter, as follows.
Not molesting the peaceful
Allah says An-Nisa 4:90. The paper explains the passage on those who stay apart from the fighting: if they withdraw at the fighting, said also to mean the day of the conquest of Mecca, do not fight with their people and seek reconciliation, Allah gave no ground to fight them, and commanded His Messenger to refrain from them. Al-Zamakhshari states that refraining from fighting is why they deserve to be left alone. By the generality of the wording, a fighter who withdraws and wishes reconciliation is not to be fought.
Justice and tolerance
Allah says An-Nahl 16:126. After Uhud, seeing what the polytheists had done to his uncle Hamza, the Prophet ﷺ said that if Allah gave him victory he would mutilate seventy of them, so Allah revealed this verse. The paper says this religion has ethics to be kept free of emotional reaction: defense and retaliation in kind must stay within justice, without excess, to preserve the call's dignity. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:2. And Ash-Shura 42:40-42. The paper says Allah permitted the Muslim to take his right and treat the disbelievers in the field as they treat Muslims, yet encouraged patience and tolerance.
Avoiding hidden spoils, treachery and mutilation
The Prophet ﷺ forbade fighters from treachery (ghadr), meaning attacking a people without warning and a choice between Islam, the jizya or fighting; from ghulul, hiding the army's equipment and money taken from the enemy so it is not divided; and from mutilating the dead. The paper cites his saying to fight in Allah's name those who disbelieve, and not to hide spoils, betray, mutilate or kill a child. The hadith contains agreed benefits: the prohibition of treachery, ghulul and killing boys who do not fight, and the dislike of mutilation. His instruction to commanders and soldiers when banners were tied shows the leadership's concern for strict adherence to military teachings, which are morals and conduct, not slogans.
Not harming trees and crops
Allah says Al-Hashr 59:5. The paper reports that when the Prophet ﷺ camped at the fortresses of Banu al-Nadir, he ordered their palms cut and burned, to weaken them or make room. They objected, asking whether cutting palms and burning trees is reform. It was hard on the Prophet ﷺ, and the believers differed: some said not to cut what Allah gave them as fay', others to cut to anger them. The verse was revealed confirming those who forbade cutting, absolving those who cut, and stating that cutting or leaving was by Allah's permission.
The paper concludes that the basis in war is not to touch civilians' farms, trees and livestock. But if civilians join in fighting and entrench in their fortresses and farms, the army may use judgment in targeting these to free its movement and anger the disbelievers, weakening them, all by Allah's permission and decree.
Mercy to the child and woman
The paper says one of the Muslim army's most prominent morals is avoiding harming children and women. It reports from Rabah ibn al-Rabi that on a campaign a woman was found killed on the road in front of Khalid ibn al-Walid's vanguard; the Prophet ﷺ stopped, said she was not fighting, and sent word to Khalid not to kill offspring or a laborer (asif). His astonishment confirms that women, presumed not to fight, are not to be touched, and he also meant youths below puberty, and likewise slaves.
Care not to shed blood
The paper says the Prophet ﷺ was keen on sparing blood and accepted a person's Islam however aggressive he had been. It cites a report that in a clash, a polytheist kept killing the Muslims he targeted until a Muslim, said to be Usama ibn Zayd, came at him unawares, and when he raised the sword the man declared Allah's oneness and was killed. Asked by the Prophet ﷺ why, he said the man had killed several Muslims; the Prophet ﷺ asked what he would do with that declaration on the Day of Resurrection, and repeated it when asked to seek forgiveness for him.
The hadith shows his concern to teach the Muslim fighter to give the opponent any glimmer of hope to save himself and be neutralized from fighting. Killing in itself is not the fighter's aim; the honor of Islam is his highest aim. The paper adds that this hadith could be an international document for those who make the laws of war, binding armies not to be excessive in shedding blood, to seize the first chance to spare it, and to refrain from excessive killing.
Not forcing anyone to Islam
The paper says the Prophet ﷺ never forced anyone to Islam, clear in the case of Ghawrath ibn al-Harith. It reports that Ghawrath took the Prophet's ﷺ sword while he slept under a tree and stood over him asking who would protect him; the Prophet ﷺ said Allah, and the sword fell from his hand. The Prophet ﷺ took it and asked him the same; the man asked him to be the best of captors, refused to testify to Allah's oneness, but pledged not to fight him or join those fighting him; the Prophet ﷺ let him go, and the man told his people he had come from the best of people.
The paper says this shows the nature of the call, which came to bring happiness and reform and invited people in out of conviction, love and certainty, not coercion as its opponents claim. Otherwise, it says, it would not have won the hearts of fair-minded non-Arabs throughout history.
A call whose defenders are described with these traits deserves acceptance by the fair-minded, who become its most sincere soldiers after being its fiercest enemies. Because its soldiers had noble morals before bearing arms, Allah opened people's hearts to them before He opened lands, so they established justice and harmony prevailed between the Muslims and the people of the conquered lands.
Some principles of war in Surat al-Adiyat
From the paper: «من مبادئ الحرب في سورة العاديات»
War has principles set by military commanders, and the better their source, the better and faster the results. The Quran addresses many of them; the paper takes the first five verses of Surat al-Adiyat as a model of strategy. Allah says Al-Adiyat 100:1-5. The paper explains the oath as by the horses of the raiders and glosses its terms: the sound of their breath, sparks, the dawn raid, dust, and plunging into the enemy's midst. It reports a narration that the Prophet ﷺ sent cavalry and months passed without news, and the surah was revealed.
A reader of these verses finds himself in a fierce battle following a tight plan with the principles of war, set out as follows. First, surprise. It means attacking the enemy suddenly, in his home territory or gathering place; it depends on the commander's judgment in choosing the hour and appearing without warning, in a swift movement the enemy cannot detect early. It is essential in lightning wars: good choice of time and swift execution paralyze the opponent and achieve the most objectives. It has three pillars.
- The method used.
- Time.
- Place.
Applying these to the surah: the muffled sound of the horses' breath keeps the enemy from noticing, a surprise in method. Raiding at morning is surprise in time. Plunging into the midst of the gathering is surprise in place, since the opponent does not expect the battle in his heart.
Second, security. Since surprise is among the most important means of winning, concealment and secrecy are among the reasons for its success, and are purely a security measure. The first verse addresses this: charging horses neigh frighteningly, which could expose the plan, so raiding armies put something on their mouths to prevent neighing, making the sound of their breath strong.
Third, landing behind enemy lines. The paper defines it as special units entering behind the enemy's front lines to strike from behind, inflict harm, and cut communication between his vanguard and rear. It sees this in the words on plunging into the midst of the gathering, quoting the comment that they pierced the lines, leaving the enemy's vanguard exposed from behind.
Fourth, concealment and camouflage. Concealment means hiding the operating unit from the enemy's eye, necessary for special missions. It was known anciently: ship captains ordered blue sails to match water or sky and forbade fires on board. The paper sees it in the words about raising dust, which blinds the enemy's eyes from seeing the raiders. Today there are smoke bombs and special units exploit thick fog. The dust, swords' sounds, panting and speed of the horses, and sparks from their hooves cast such panic into enemy soldiers that each thinks only of saving himself, causing flight.
Fifth, confrontation from point zero. Contemporary armies, thanks to military technology, are used to confrontation from afar, with intercontinental rockets and warplanes, so wars are settled in days before armies overrun the land. Yet confrontation from point zero, when armies clash, remains decisive, for many well-equipped states have fled when ranks clashed. The paper says the American war in Vietnam and the recent war on the Gaza Strip are not far from us, and describes the Jewish state as fleeing the field, dragging the tails of failure and defeat before the heroes of the resistance, who confronted them with simple equipment in a heroic clash from point zero. It sees this in the words about plunging into the midst of the gathering, quoting the gloss that they scattered it, which means ranks clash and swords meet face to face.
The paper concludes that this short surah draws a model of a lightning battle: surprise, penetrating the enemy line, concealment, varied surprises and the clash of ranks. It shows the Quran's care to raise the believing ranks to the highest degree of training and military planning, just as it raises them in God-consciousness, piety and weeping in the depths of the night.
Takeaways
No one can fight Allah and prevail
The paper concludes that no individual, group or great state can ever fight a party with such strength. Whoever turns away from the command of Allah or His Messenger ﷺ exposes himself to a war declared by Allah, and is certainly defeated and subdued.
Prepare, consult, then resolve
The paper says the nation is required to harness its resources for the material strength to face the dangers around it and repel aggression from its sons, its sanctities and its creed. Consultation has its time; when resolve and reliance on Allah are due, there is no room for hesitation or repeating consultation.
Steadfastness, remembrance and obedience
The paper says steadfastness is the start of the road to victory. Armies must be raised on remembrance and supplication before wars, to accompany fighters in hardship and when ranks clash. Obedience is among the most important requirements of victory.
The fighter's morals
The paper gives the general rule of the fighter's morals as not killing the peaceful and non-combatants. It says killing in itself is not the fighter's aim; the honor of Islam is his highest aim. It says the Prophet ﷺ never forced anyone to Islam.
Kindness to captives
The paper says Allah commanded kindness to the captive even if he is not of our religion and is fighting us. It says the Quran deals with the human soul as a compassionate, tender one would, not as a gloater lying in wait would.
Reflect
- How do I prepare myself for hardship, in body, mind and faith, before it arrives?
- When I disagree with others in a shared effort, how do I balance consultation with firm resolve?
- What does it mean for me to keep good character when I am wronged or angry?
- Where in my life do I rely on my own means more than on Allah?
Every verse in the paper
All 140 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.
Warfare in Quranic usage «الحرب في الاستعمال القرآني»
Attributing war to Allah and His Messenger «إسناد الحرب لله تعالى ولرسوله»
The wisdom of attributing war to Allah and His Messenger «أولًا: حكمة إسناد الحرب لله تعالى ولرسوله»
51:58, 59:23, 85:12, 48:7, 74:31, 11:102, 7:97-99, 21:23, 6:18, 35:44, 65:12, 5:64, 6:6, 40:51, 2:278-279, 2:275, 5:33, 2:13, 63:8, 5:35, 6:129, 8:30, 27:50-52, 15:42, 59:2, 33:25, 30:47, 4:141
Those who fight Allah and His Messenger «المحاربون لله ولرسوله»
Those who fight Allah and His Messenger «أولًا: المحاربون لله تعالى ولرسوله»
Those who help the fighters «ثانيًا: المعاونون للمحاربين لله تعالى ولرسوله»
9:107, 28:8, 60:1, 5:51-52, 24:19
The recompense of those who fight Allah and His Messenger, and their helpers «ثالثًا: جزاء المحاربين لله تعالى ورسوله عليه السلام ومعاونيهم»
10:92, 29:40, 33:62, 9:5, 9:14, 9:36, 9:123, 3:110, 54:45, 8:36, 3:12, 3:196-197, 5:33, 3:21, 22:25, 24:19, 58:5, 9:63, 4:115
Preparing for war «الإعداد للحرب»
Preparing moral and material strength «أولًا: إعداد القوة المعنوية والمادية»
2:216, 61:4, 5:35, 8:65, 4:95, 61:10-13, 2:193, 3:169-170, 9:111, 9:38-39, 4:102, 3:146, 3:155, 2:247, 3:121, 8:60
Consultation «ثانيًا: الشورى»
3:159, 5:21-26, 2:246, 27:29-33
Resolve and reliance on Allah «ثالثًا: العزم والتوكل على الله تعالى»
On the battlefield «في ميدان الحرب»
Praying with caution «أولًا: الصلاة مع الحذر»
Steadfastness with remembrance of Allah «ثانيًا: الثبات مع ذكر الله تعالى»
Inflicting punishment so as to cast fear in others «ثالثًا: إنزال العذاب بالأعداء بما يلقي الرعب في قلوب الآخرين»
Striking the necks of the enemy until they are weakened «رابعًا: ضرب رقاب الأعداء حتى الإضعاف»
Patience «خامسًا: الصبر»
After the war ends «بعد انتهاء الحرب»
Treatment of prisoners of war «أولًا: معاملة أسرى الحرب»
Spoils of war and their division «ثانيًا: الغنائم وتقسيمها»
The aims of war as the Quran explains them «مقاصد الحرب كما بينها القرآن»
2:193, 3:85, 2:256, 10:99, 9:29, 2:279, 4:75, 2:246, 22:39-40, 9:12, 9:123, 8:60
The morals of the believers who fight, and others «أخلاق المؤمنين المحاربين وغيرهم»
4:94, 4:90, 16:126, 5:2, 42:40-42, 59:5
Some principles of war in Surat al-Adiyat «من مبادئ الحرب في سورة العاديات»
About this source
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
- Volume
- 6
- Research paper
- «الحرب» (Warfare)
Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.
This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.