Peoples, Places & Nations · Quran topic
People of the Scripture
أهل الكتاب · Ahl al-Kitab
The Quran on the Jews and Christians: their stances, deviations, false claims, and how Muslims deal with them
120 verses · 10 parts · 67 min read
Study guide based on
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
«أهل الكتاب» · Volume 3
At a glance
The paper defines the People of the Scripture as the Jews and Christians and those who follow their religion. It says the Quran speaks about them often, including their prophets, their books and the alteration of those books. Belief in Muhammad ﷺ is, in the paper's words, the central issue in calling them to the truth.
The paper says their stance toward the Muslims is not a single one. One stance is the peak of hostility. The other is affection. The paper says they deviated in the fundamentals of religion before its branches, and their scholars before their common people. It then lists false claims that the Quran mentioned and refuted.
The paper says the Quran set rules for dealing with them. It says the Quran distinguishes them from other disbelievers and gives each its due rank. It says Allah forbade allying with the Jews and Christians. It adds that this prohibition never contradicts the Quran's tolerance and kindness toward them.
Key verses
- Al-Ma'idah 5:82-83: The paper reports Qatada saying the verse praises people of the Scripture who were on the true law brought by Isa and, when Muhammad ﷺ was sent, believed in him and recognized the truth he brought. It adds that the believers among the Christians are more than among the Jews, since the Jews have the diseases of envy, lying and much disputing about the truth. Ibn Kathir says that those who call themselves Christians have affection for Islam and its people in general, because of the gentleness and mercy in their hearts. Ibn Kathir notes that fighting is not legislated in their religion. The paper also quotes that knowledge with asceticism softens the heart, so they lack the harshness of the Jews and the severity of the polytheists.
- At-Tawbah 9:31: The paper explains that the Jews took their scholars and the Christians their monks as lords by giving them the right to legislate and obeying them in it. It cites a hadith about Adi ibn Hatim in which the Prophet ﷺ said they did not worship them, but treated as lawful what their leaders declared lawful and as forbidden what they declared forbidden.
- Al-Baqarah 2:113: The paper cites it for the claim that no one else has any truth: each of the two groups said the other is on nothing. A quoted explanation links it to the visit of the Najran delegation, when the Jews and the Christians debated until they insulted each other. The paper says the verse likens their saying to that of the ignorant Arab polytheists, a great rebuke of those who had knowledge. It adds that Allah will judge between them on the Day of Resurrection, supporting the truth and its people.
- Al-Baqarah 2:79: Al-Shaʿrawi says that, after forgetting and concealing, they brought something of their own and said it was from Allah. The paper names weak religious restraint as the cause that made them write the book with their own hands and say it is from Allah, for a small price.
- Al-Ma'idah 5:51: The paper says Allah explicitly forbade allying with the Jews and Christians. It gives as the reason that they and other disbelievers are enemies of Allah, with whom He is angry and whom He cursed. It cites Ibn Hazm saying the words about whoever allies with them are literal: he is a disbeliever among the disbelievers. It also cites the verse among many that show the enmity of both Jews and Christians.
- Al-Ma'idah 5:18: The paper cites it for their claim to be Allah's sons and beloved ones. It says this claim is one link in a long chain of false claims about being God's chosen people. The paper explains the reply as: if they had a distinction with Allah, why does He punish them for their sins. It says they are human beings of His creation, with no advantage over others, and He forgives and punishes as He wills.
- Al-Baqarah 2:41: The paper says the Quran's interest in calling the People of the Scripture is partly because their guidance leads to the guidance of the polytheists who would follow them, and it cites al-Raghib on this verse. Al-Raghib explains it as: do not be among those who are followed in disbelief. Ibn Ashur says the prohibition rebukes them for being late to follow the call of Islam.
- Al-Isra 17:107-109: The paper says the Quran cites those among the People of the Scripture who believed as witnesses to the truth of Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood and of the Quranic revelation. Ibn Kathir says these are the righteous among the People of the Scripture, who held to their book and did not alter it, and who fall down in gratitude for being among those who could reach this Messenger. The paper says Allah mentions their humility and weeping when the Quran is heard, an emotion He often mentions of them.
- Ali 'Imran 3:199: Ibn Kathir says this kind of Christians are the ones mentioned in this verse. The paper explains that these believers believe both in what was sent down to the Prophet ﷺ and in what was sent down to them, which is the beneficial faith, unlike believing in some messengers and books and rejecting others. That faith brings humility before Allah, so its people never sell Allah's verses for a small price.
- Ali 'Imran 3:71: The paper cites it as a methodological deviation of the People of the Scripture: mixing truth with falsehood. It explains that they mix the truth Allah sent down in their book with the falsehood their rabbis and monks put into it, lies and false interpretations, until trust in the whole was lost.
- Al-Baqarah 2:174: The paper explains that it means the Jews who concealed the description of Muhammad ﷺ in their books, so that their leadership and the gifts they took from the Arabs would not go. It says that in return for concealing the truth they eat a fire that burns in their bellies on the Day of Resurrection. The paper says Allah is angry with them because they concealed it knowingly, and He will not praise them but will punish them.
- Al-Ma'idah 5:80: The paper quotes al-Manar saying that many of the Children of Israel took the disbelievers among the polytheists of the Prophet's ﷺ people as allies and urged them to fight him, though those polytheists did not affirm tawhid. It describes their deed as an evil one that brought Allah's anger on them, with the censure strengthened by an oath. It adds that the punishment surrounds them and they find no escape from it.
Words to know
- أهل الكتاب ahl al-kitab
In the technical sense, the Jews and Christians and those who follow their religion in its various groups. Disbelievers other than these are not People of the Scripture.
- اليهود al-yahud
In language it comes from "hada", to repent. In usage it is a title by which the Children of Israel became known.
Root: ه و د
- بنو إسرائيل banu isra'il
The descendants of Yaqub, who was given the title Israel, and they were twelve tribes.
- بني إسرائيل bani isra'il
The form used in addressing the Jews in the Quran; al-Kafawi reports some saying they are called "Children of Israel" and not "Children of Yaqub" because they are called to worship Allah and reminded of their forefathers' religion by a name that recalls Allah.
- النصارى al-nasara
The community of the Messiah Isa, son of Maryam. One view is that they are named after a village called Nasrana.
The Concept of People of the Scripture
From the paper: «مفهوم أهل الكتاب»
The linguistic meaning
A man's ahl are his clan and kin; the ahl of a school or of Islam are its followers; of a matter, its rulers; of a house, its residents. A man's ahl can mean his wife and closest people; the Prophet's ﷺ ahl al-bayt are his wives, daughters, son-in-law.
Al-kitab means writing, the inkwell, the Torah, the page, the obligation, the ruling and the decree. It means heavenly books. In the Quran, ahl al-kitab and "given the Book" mean the Torah and the Gospel. Ahl al-kitab: those gathered around the book, meaning Jews and Christians.
Other meanings follow, depending on the annexed term.
The technical meaning
Technically, ahl al-kitab are the Jews and Christians and those who follow their religion in its different sects. Other disbelievers are not ahl al-kitab, the paper says, citing Al-An'am 6:156. Al-Shahrastani says they are those outside the Hanif religion and Islamic law who follow some law, rulings and limits. Some have an established book, such as the Torah and the Gospel, and the revelation addresses them as ahl al-kitab; others have a semblance of a book, such as the Magians.
People of the Scripture in Quranic Usage
From the paper: «أهل الكتاب في الاستعمال القرآني»
The compound ahl al-kitab occurs 31 times in the Quran. The paper gives a table showing the single form, ahl al-kitab, 31 times, with an example at Ali 'Imran 3:64. It appears in three senses. The first is the Jews, as in Al-Ahzab 33:26. The second is the Christians, as in An-Nisa 4:171.
The third is Jews and Christians together, as in Al-Bayyinah 98:6.
Related Terms
From the paper: «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»
The Jews (al-yahud)
The Jews: linguistic meaning
The word derives from hada yahudu, to repent, taken from Al-A'raf 7:156. The paper says this was spoken by Musa and the seventy he chose to meet their Lord and apologise for their fools' worship of the calf; it means they repented and returned to Allah. Ibn Faris says they were named for repenting of worshipping the calf, and repentance brings ease and safety. Al-Raghib reports that some say the name was originally praise, from that saying, and stayed with them after their law was abrogated, just as the Christians (al-nasara) were originally named from As-Saff 61:14.
He adds that "hada fulan" is said of one who follows the Jewish way in religion.
The Jews: technical meaning
Al-yahud is a title by which the Children of Israel became known. The Torah uses the word only after Musa's time, in the Second Book of Kings. The Quran agrees: it calls Musa's contemporaries the Children of Israel or Musa's people, and uses "the Jews" (eight places) only in stages later than Musa.
Every time it occurs, it is in blame, showing the people's deviations and answering them, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:64. And as in Al-Ma'idah 5:82. The paper suggests the name points to the start of their deviation after the death of Sulayman, with corruption and the spread of magic and more.
Relation between People of the Scripture and the Jews
People of the Scripture is broader than the Jews; the Jews are one of the two communities sent a book, the Jews and the Christians.
The Children of Israel
The Children of Israel: linguistic meaning
Israel is the title of the Prophet of Allah Yaqub, a title that signals praise by its original meaning, which in Hebrew is chosen of Allah or servant of Allah.
The Children of Israel: technical meaning
Technically, Israel is a title given to Yaqub son of Ishaq. The paper cites Ali 'Imran 3:93. The Children of Israel are the descendants of Yaqub, who were twelve tribes, as in Al-Baqarah 2:211. Ibn Abbas says Israel means servant of Allah, since isra means servant and il is the name of Allah, a compound of two words.
Al-Kafawi reports that some say the Jews are addressed in the Quran only as "Children of Israel", not "Children of Yaqub", because they were called to worship Allah and reminded of their forefathers' religion as an admonition and a warning against heedlessness, so they were given the name that recalls Allah.
Relation between People of the Scripture and the Children of Israel
People of the Scripture is broader than the Children of Israel, who are mostly the Jews when addressed, while People of the Scripture includes Jews and Christians.
The Christians (al-nasara)
The Christians: linguistic meaning
The singular is nasrani, from nasara, to help and strengthen someone against his enemy; the helper is a nasir, plural ansar. Nasara are those who follow the religion of the Messiah, and the term came to cover everyone who worships by it. The paper also lists other forms, including a village in the Levant to which the Christians are ascribed, and tanassur, entering Christianity.
Al-Raghib al-Asfahani reports that some say they were so named because of the saying of the disciples in As-Saff 61:14. Others say they were named for a village called Nasrana, so a Christian is nasrani and the plural is nasara, as in Al-Baqarah 2:113.
The Christians: technical meaning
The technical meaning stays within the linguistic one: the Christians are the community of the Messiah Isa son of Maryam, the Messenger of Allah and His word.
Relation between People of the Scripture and the Christians
People of the Scripture is broader than the Christians; the Christians are one of the two communities sent a book, the Jews and the Christians.
The Quran's Frequent Discussion of the People of the Scripture
From the paper: «كثرة حديث القرآن عن أهل الكتاب»
The People of the Scripture are among the most important subjects the Quran uncovers in detail, the paper says, for the great wisdom and benefits in it and its deep effect on reality. The Quran speaks often of them, their prophets and their books. It speaks of their alteration of the books, and what they forgot or hid, especially the good news of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ. It also describes where they ended after long ages: hard hearts, misguidance, disbelief and distance from Allah's law, even ascribing a son and poverty to Allah.
The story of Musa, prophet of the Children of Israel to whom the Torah was sent down, is the most repeated story in the Quran. It covers his birth, nursing and youth, Pharaoh, the Samiri, al-Khidr, Qarun (a disbeliever vain with his wealth, from Musa's people), and Musa's private talk with his Lord and request to see Him.
The Quran also tells of Isa, prophet of the Children of Israel, who received the Gospel: his birth, miracles and call. Some surahs have names clearly tied to them. Examples: the Cow (the cow the Children of Israel were told to slaughter), Al Imran (Maryam's family), the Table (which they asked to be sent down, questioning Allah's power), Yusuf, the Children of Israel, and Maryam.
It covers their deviations and false claims, answering and refuting them. It warns of their enmity and resentment toward the Muslims. It speaks of the Jews contemporary with the Prophet ﷺ and his campaigns against them, such as Banu al-Nadir in Surat al-Hashr. In sum, Allah says An-Naml 27:76.
The paper gives wise purposes for all this, one being to win them toward Islam and belief in the Quran, which confirms what they have, all from one Lord who knows everything; the paper sees this in the surah names that carry symbolism for them.
The Quran's concern to call them comes first from being a book of guidance for humans and jinn. Also, their guidance leads the polytheists, who would follow them and say that if the People of the Scripture, with their knowledge and proofs, followed this Prophet ﷺ, he is on the truth, and the reverse. So al-Raghib al-Isfahani comments on Al-Baqarah 2:41.
He says it means do not be among those followed in disbelief. The Quran cites believers among the People of the Scripture as witnesses to the soundness of Muhammad's prophethood. They reported that the Prophet ﷺ was truthful, was foretold, and matches the description and signs in their books. The paper says this style suggests their testimony for him is the one awaited. As Allah says Al-Isra 17:107-109.
Ibn Kathir explains that the Quran is true in itself whether people believe or not, and that Allah honoured it in earlier books on His messengers. Those given knowledge before it are the righteous of the People of the Scripture, who keep their book unaltered. When it is recited they prostrate to Allah in thanks for making them fit for this, if they reach this Messenger. Their glorifying venerates Allah's power and His keeping the promise given through earlier prophets about the sending of Muhammad ﷺ. Their weeping is humility to Allah and faith in His book and Messenger, and their increased humility is increased faith and submission, as in Muhammad 47:17.
He adds that their falling is one description added to another, not prostration added to prostration. The paper says speaking of their deviations protects Muslims from being deceived by their falsehood and the doubts they raise to shake their religion. The Quran shows that it is from Allah, confirms earlier books and has authority over them, and that belief makes no distinction between Allah's messengers and books.
Exposing the errors of earlier nations, especially the People of the Scripture, also warns this nation against falling into them. Allah told the Children of Israel's stories, mostly deviation, as a model so this nation would learn and not reach their misguidance. Muslims recite Al-Fatihah 1:6-7 daily.
Seventeen times in the obligatory prayers they ask for the straight path, the clear path to Allah and His Paradise: knowing the truth and acting on it, the path of Islam and of the prophets, the truthful, the martyrs and the righteous. It is not the path of those who incurred anger, the Jews and their like, who knew the truth and left acting on it, nor of the astray, who act without knowledge, strive in worship without a law from Allah, and say about Him what they do not know.
Allah willed Muslims repeat it so often to seek refuge from following earlier nations in turning from His religion and neglecting His books. Yet although Allah warned against their way, His decree stands as His Messenger ﷺ reported. The paper cites Abu Said al-Khudri's report that the Prophet ﷺ said Muslims would follow those before them span by span and cubit by cubit, even into a lizard's hole; asked whether he meant the Jews and Christians, he answered "who else".
Al-Nawawi explains that these images illustrate very close imitation, in sins and violations, not disbelief, and that it is a clear miracle of the Prophet ﷺ because what he foretold happened. The hadith shows their prominent role in turning Muslims from their religion, which is why the Quran speaks of them so much. Envy and transgression have taken hold of their hearts; they are the fiercest enemies of this nation, plotting against it from the dawn of Islam until Allah inherits the earth. As Allah says At-Tawbah 9:32.
This verse concerns the People of the Scripture, and Abu al-Suud says the two groups of the book want to reject the Quran in what it says of tawhid, of Allah's freedom from partners and sons, and of laws, including lawful and forbidden. Allah says too As-Saff 61:8-9.
This too concerns the People of the Scripture, as the context shows.
The Wisdom of Addressing the People of the Scripture
From the paper: «حكمة النداء بأهل الكتاب»
The Quran has a wise manner of calling people; Allah says to His Prophet ﷺ An-Nahl 16:125. For example, it addresses the believers with the call of faith, to stir their faith and remind them of the pledge they took on entering this religion. The paper says the Quran gives several examples of this manner in its stories.
To Jews and Christians it uses several styles, such as "People of the Scripture", "Children of Israel" and "those given the Book", each aiming to move the listener. "People of the Scripture" reminds them of the great favour of those exalted books, with their laws, sent down on their prophets and for them.
This reminder also carries a sharp rebuke for their shortcomings and ugly deeds, since addressing them with a title of praise while they persist in falsehood is the greatest reproach. The paper sees this in Ali 'Imran 3:70. The verse opens with the call and then a question, rebuking their disbelief in the signs Muhammad ﷺ brought and expressing wonder at them. As people of the book and knowledge, they should have hurried to believe before others, given what they had that testifies to his truth and their knowledge of religion, rather than disbelieve.
Al-Tabari says this is Allah's rebuke of the two groups of the book for denying Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood though they find him in their books, while testifying that their books are true and from Allah. The call also reminds them that they are people of the book and of faith; the Quran calls up the hidden capacities in those it addresses, the paper says.
Allah also says Al-Ma'idah 5:15. Ibn Badis says Muhammad ﷺ was sent to all nations, so the Quran gives the general call in some places and a special call to some of them in others. People then were two groups, the People of the Scripture (Jews and Christians) and others, and the nobler was the People of the Scripture for the share they kept of the book despite forgetting part and altering part. They were also the group most fit to follow Muhammad ﷺ through what they knew before him of books and prophets, so the special call is directed to them.
He adds that calling them People of the Scripture honours them by linking them to the book and urges them to accept what he brought, since he came with a book. It also argues that belief in their book requires belief in his, being of the same kind.
The paper quotes a passage saying this is Islam's manner in calling those outside it: choose the best way of calling anyone, suited to what we call to. Calling a person by what he likes opens his ear and heart, while calling him by what he dislikes is the first barrier.
The Position of the People of the Scripture Toward the Messenger
From the paper: «موقف أهل الكتاب من الرسول»
Belief in Muhammad ﷺ, the seal of the prophets, is the central issue in calling the People of the Scripture to the truth and refuting their deviations. If they believe in him and his message, the paper says, they will reject every falsehood their rabbis and monks set for them, or that was written for them in their books of misguidance and lies.
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:31. And Al-Baqarah 2:79. So every knot of falsehood among them is undone from its roots if they believe in Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood, that his revelation abrogates every earlier law, and that he clarifies much they differed over. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:15. For this reason the Quran focuses on this issue in calling them, states their position on it and answers those who deny it.
The paper announces what follows: the call to believe in the messengers in general and in Muhammad ﷺ in particular, and the People of the Scripture's response, in three groups. The Quran made clear that belief in the messengers is a pillar of faith, not valid without it.
The paper cites Al-Baqarah 2:285. It explains that this establishes a plain truth of faith: no prophet is to be distinguished from another in belief. Belief in Musa does not contradict belief in Isa and Muhammad, or the reverse, since all are messengers from Allah to whom He revealed His law and command, truthful, protected and free of every fault and deficiency; the paper adds Al-An'am 6:124.
The Quran also shows that the prophets called their peoples to this and planted these principles in them, as in As-Saff 61:6. The paper explains that Isa, like the prophets, confirmed the earlier prophet and gave good news of the later one. He foretold the coming of Muhammad ﷺ and told the People of the Scripture, but when Muhammad came with clear proofs that he is truly Allah's messenger, they resisted the truth and denied it, which the paper calls strange of them.
The Quran argued against them for leaving belief in Muhammad ﷺ on the plain fact that his name, description and sign were known to them. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:89. The paper says that confirming what they have is a proof against them: this prophet came confirming what is in their books and what their messengers told them of his description and signs.
Allah also says Al-A'raf 7:157. The paper asks why, then, they disbelieve in him. It adds that before his sending they sought help against the idolaters by his coming when they fought them, saying a prophet would be sent at the end of time and they would kill the idolaters with him as 'Ad and Iram were killed. When Allah sent him from the Arabs they disbelieved in him and denied what they had said, from envy and injustice.
The Quran also called them plainly and clearly to believe in Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood in Al-Ma'idah 5:19. The paper quotes an explanation that Allah calls the People of the Scripture, because of the favour of His book, to believe in His Messenger and thank Him who sent him after a break (fatra) in the messengers, a cessation of prophets.
The paper says the break came after a long period since Isa, said to be six hundred years, in which religions changed and worship of idols, fires and crosses spread. The favour was thus the greatest and the need severe, as corruption covered all lands and tyranny and ignorance showed among all people, except a few holding to remnants of the earlier prophets' religion, some Jewish rabbis and Christian worshippers, until Allah sent Muhammad ﷺ to guide creation and bring them from darkness to light.
It explains the verse as meaning: lest you argue that no bearer of good news or warner came to you, one has come, meaning Muhammad ﷺ. The verse urges the People of the Scripture to believe in Muhammad ﷺ, who came after this break, when there was longing and tenderness for heavenly revelation and the sending of prophets.
Their attitude to this call differed, as the Quran shows, in three groups.
A group that believed in Muhammad and his message
This is the first group, described in Ali 'Imran 3:113-115. The paper explains that the People of the Scripture are not equal in ugliness and misguidance: some believe, though most are lawbreakers, as in Ali 'Imran 3:110. Allah then names some of this group's qualities and praises them, eight in all, each a merit that earns reward. The first is that they are an upright community, standing on the truth and following it; these are those among them who accepted Islam, such as Abdullah ibn Salam and others, and the verses were revealed about them.
Then He describes their night prayer, expressed as reciting through the night hours with prostration, which is clearer and stronger in praise. Four further qualities follow, the paper says: they believe in Allah and the Last Day with sound faith that requires belief in every book and messenger He sent, they enjoin what is right, forbid what is wrong, and hasten to good deeds Ali 'Imran 3:114.
Al-Baydawi says He described them with qualities that were not found in the Jews, who deviate from the truth, do not worship at night, associate partners with Allah, deviate over His attributes, describe the Last Day wrongly, compromise in enjoining right and are slow to good.
Allah then declares them righteous, rewarded with the best reward, with nothing of their deeds lost; as in Ar-Rahman 55:60. Thus Allah describes the believing group among the People of the Scripture, which the paper says draws them toward Islam and encourages them to enter it. Allah also says of them Al-Ma'idah 5:83-85.
The paper explains that this shows their submission to the truth and strong response, so that their eyes overflow with weeping when Allah's verses are recited. Al-Tabari explains that an eye's overflow is its filling and then flowing, like a river or a vessel overflowing from fullness.
This is from what they recognised of the truth, namely the good news they have of Muhammad's ﷺ sending, and they ask to be written with those who testify to its truth and believe in it. Ibn Kathir says this kind of Christian is the one meant in Ali 'Imran 3:199.
And they are those of whom Allah says Al-Qasas 28:52-55. He says that is why Allah says here Al-Ma'idah 5:85, rewarding them for their belief, affirmation and acknowledging the truth, with great gardens to stay in forever. The passage adds that He promised reward in the Hereafter only to those who believed in Muhammad ﷺ.
The paper says Ali 'Imran 3:199 shows that this believing group believes in both revelations, the one sent to the Muslims and the one sent to them. This is the beneficial belief, unlike believing in some messengers and books and disbelieving in others, and the true belief that brings humility before Allah; so its people never sell Allah's verses for a miserable price.
A group that disbelieved in the Prophet Muhammad's message and sending
The second group disbelieved in the message and sending of Muhammad ﷺ though they knew his noble descriptions and the truth of his message from their own book. Allah's warning to them is Al-Bayyinah 98:6. Allah reports the end of the disbelieving People of the Scripture, who denied his prophethood, together with all the idolaters: Hellfire forever, never leaving it, and they are the worst of creation, the paper explains. It says "from" in the verse is explanatory: those who disbelieve in Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood are two types, People of the Scripture (Jews and Christians) and idolaters, and both fall under the punishment.
The People of the Scripture are named first although the idolaters' disbelief is greater, because theirs occurs with knowledge of his prophethood and the good news of it in their books. Ibn Ashur adds that they come first because they led in this: they spread doubt among the idolaters and backed their denial with firmer arguments than the idolaters' nonsense. The idolaters were unlettered and knew nothing of messengers and laws, so when the call struck them they turned to the Jews for something to reject it with, especially after the Prophet ﷺ migrated to Medina, he says.
In this respect, the paper says, they are greater in guilt, which is what the surah discusses and fits its name, al-Bayyina. The pointer "those" is used for them for their ugly qualities and distant rank in evil. The paper holds that this group's ruling of punishment and loss is decisive and beyond dispute, however good some of their deeds, manners and systems, as long as they are not based on belief in this last message and last messenger. It says no appearance of goodness cut off from Allah's firm, upright way should make us doubt this ruling, and cites the end of Ali 'Imran 3:97.
Allah made this group's disbelief clear and sure in An-Nisa 4:150-151. Al-Baydawi explains that they are complete in disbelief, and their belief in some prophets and books but not others counts for nothing; "truly" means certain, established disbelief. Allah forbids this group their disbelief and ugly deeds in Al-Baqarah 2:41.
The Jews and Christians were not the first to disbelieve in his message; Quraysh and the Arabs were, at the start of his call in Mecca, the paper notes. Saying "first" is an allusion to the People of the Scripture: it befits them, as people of a book, to be the first to believe in him, given their knowledge of his truth and the good news of him.
Ibn Ashur says the prohibition aims to rebuke them for lagging behind in following the call of Islam. Al-Raghib says it means do not be among those who are imitated in disbelief.
A group that hid the description of the Prophet Muhammad
This is the third group, described in Al-Baqarah 2:146. The paper explains that the scholars of the People of the Scripture know the truth of what the Messenger ﷺ brought and his descriptions, among them that he prays toward the two qiblas, as one knows his own son, a comparison the Arabs used to prove a thing. Or they know him as they know their sons among all people's sons, which no one doubts. Yet despite this certainty, a party of them knowingly hide from people his description in their books.
Allah also says Ali 'Imran 3:71. Al-Alusi says the truth they hide is Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood and the description and good news of him in their books, which they know to be true. Allah took a covenant from the scholars of the People of the Scripture to explain to people what is in their books, the proofs, meanings, rulings, news and all they need, as in Ali 'Imran 3:187.
The verse rebukes them for casting aside the heavy, firm covenant to explain the truth in their books, including the good news of Muhammad ﷺ and his description. They hid it and bought with that hiding a small price: leadership and paltry wealth from their lowly followers who pursue whims.
What they buy is evil, for they bought Allah's punishment and wrath, when they should have been among the first to believe in this Prophet ﷺ, support and defend him, given the good news of him in their books. Reason requires them to back him and their religion to support him, and it is strange that they cast aside both reason and transmitted texts.
The paper says Allah threatened this party, who hid the truth knowingly despite the covenant, with the worst punishment, matching their disbelief and whims Al-Baqarah 2:159. He threatened them with His curse and the curse of all who can curse, angels and believers of humans and jinn, showing the curse is lasting and their crime great. The curse means supplication against them for expulsion from His mercy.
Allah also says Al-Baqarah 2:174. The paper explains that this means the Jews who hid Muhammad's ﷺ description in the books in their hands, so their leadership would not go and they would keep the gifts they took from the Arabs for honouring them. What they eat in return for hiding the truth is a fire blazing in their bellies on the Day of Resurrection, and the paper quotes the rest of the verse.
This is because Allah is angry with them for hiding what they knew; He does not look on them or purify them, meaning He does not praise them but punishes them painfully.
The Position of the People of the Scripture Toward the Muslims
From the paper: «موقف أهل الكتاب من المسلمين»
The Quran showed the position of the People of the Scripture toward the Muslims in many verses, uncovering their intentions and plans. The purpose is that Muslims be clear about them: wary if they are enemies, peaceful and close if they are friends. The paper says they have had the chief role in hostility to Islam and its people, as history up to today witnesses, so the Quran uncovered that hostility, its causes and forms, given the imminent danger. This is part of the Quran's way of guiding to all good and warning of all evil, as Allah says Al-Isra 17:9.
Their position is not limited to a single stance of hostility. A group among them carries no such enmity and is not too proud to accept, follow and submit to the truth. These good qualities led them to belief in Allah and all His messengers and to entering Islam.
Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:82-83. He told His Messenger ﷺ, and swore to him, of two positions of the People of the Scripture toward the believers. One is hostility at its peak, surpassing all other enmities, the most intense and firmest toward the believers. The other is affection and love, the nearest in affection to the believers.
The position of hostility toward the Muslims
This is the position of the People of the Scripture in general and the Jews in particular, shared by idolaters who are not People of the Scripture. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:82. This is a truth Allah establishes for His Prophet ﷺ and his nation, guiding them that the Jews are their worst enemies. Though People of the Scripture, they come ahead of the idolaters in this hostility, and Allah swore to confirm it. The oath consoles the Prophet ﷺ for their denial and harm. Al-Razi says the lam is of oath, and this rebellion is their old habit, so the Prophet ﷺ should not care about their scheming.
The idolaters' hostility has clear causes needing no explanation. For the Jews it is reversed, a quotation says: as People of the Scripture they were the most fit to support and love them, yet they lead the campaign against the believers, ahead of the people of shirk.
The Quran revealed the cause: their sick psyche, in which envy and whims overcame obeying Allah and following His messengers and books. The Jews envied the Prophet ﷺ because he came from the Arabs and not from them, so they left belief in him and said they believe only in what was sent down to them, as in Al-Baqarah 2:91.
Allah answered their claim to honour their books with a rebuking question. It asks why, if they believe in what was sent to them, they killed His prophets, when their own book forbids killing them and commands following, obeying and believing them. In another verse Allah says An-Nisa 4:54-55.
Ibn Kathir says it means their envy of the Prophet ﷺ for the great prophethood Allah gave him, which kept them from believing him because he was from the Arabs and not the Children of Israel. Allah then answered them in An-Nisa 4:54: giving prophethood and grace to Muhammad ﷺ is nothing strange to Allah's generosity, whose favour to His believing servants never ceased.
A quoted passage says envy alone lured the People of the Scripture, especially the Jews, to this sinful position and to hiding the truth knowingly, though they find him written in the Torah and Gospel. In the fire of envy in the Jews' breasts every mark of the truth about the Prophet melted, so they disbelieved and took misguidance as their mount to the punishment of Hell.
The Quran tells how Yusuf's brothers, fathers of the tribes of Israel, envied him and threw him in the well so their father's face would be free for them, yet their envy ended to his good, and he became ruler of Egypt. The paper sees in this a warning to the Jews who envy the Prophet ﷺ that the outcome of their envy and plotting is good for him and his nation.
A quoted passage says the word for "you will surely find" shows this ruling is not conditional or hidden but absolute, always occurring and clear, made certain by oath and emphasis: "this is the Jews' course in life and Allah's judgment on them". History clearly witnesses this ruling, the paper says, though it gives no detail here. The Jews are the cause of most strife in the Muslim world; they fought the Prophet ﷺ by every means, trying many times to bewitch, poison and kill him, but Allah protected him.
Their harm to the Muslims is still seen today, and what they do in Palestine, Jerusalem and Gaza is known, the paper says. Their hostility takes several forms. The first is striving to misguide the Muslims and cast doubt on their religion. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:72. It was revealed about Jewish leaders and rabbis who plotted to make the Muslims doubt their religion.
Ibn Abbas reports that Abdullah ibn al-Sayf, Adi ibn Zayd and al-Harith ibn Awf told one another to believe in what was sent to Muhammad ﷺ and his companions in the morning and disbelieve in the evening, to confuse their religion so they might leave it, and Allah revealed about them Ali 'Imran 3:71.
Up to the verse ending Ali 'Imran 3:73. The verse exposes their scheme to feign entering Islam and then leave it, to turn people away from it. This vile plan rests on a natural rule, that one who knows the truth does not leave it; Heraclius understood it when he asked Abu Sufyan whether anyone who entered the Prophet's ﷺ religion left it, and he said no.
They wished people to say they left Islam only after seeing its falsehood inside, since leaving the truth after knowing it without cause is not reasonable. Ibn Kathir says they agreed to show belief at the start of the day and pray the dawn prayer with the Muslims, then return to their religion at day's end, so the ignorant would say they found a fault in the Muslims' religion, hoping the Muslims would turn back.
The second form is disliking that good should come down on the Muslims. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:105. The paper first notes that idolaters are paired with the People of the Scripture here and in Al-Ma'idah 5:82. It is as though Allah reminds them that they resemble the idolaters in hostility to the believers, even in its form, hidden spite and hatred, which is rebuke for them.
Al-Saadi says the Jews and idolaters do not want any good, little or much, sent down on the believers from their Lord, out of envy and hatred that He singles them out with His grace. Part of that grace is sending the Book on their Messenger to purify and teach them, he says.
The verse uncovers the evil, spite and envy in their hearts for the grace Allah gave the Muslims. So Muslims should beware their enemies, hold to the faith they envy, and thank and keep Allah's grace. "From" in "any good" is all-inclusive, so they do not want believers to get any good at all.
Ending the verse with Allah's great bounty hints at the vastness of His giving, greatest in prophethood, faith and calling to it. The report before it stirs caution; both are needed against the Jews' campaign of doubt to weaken believers' faith. The verse indicates that the causes of conflict between the People of the Scripture and Muslims are at root religious.
So the Quran uncovers the feelings of those who disbelieved in Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood: hatred, envy and wishing evil, as in Ali 'Imran 3:69. Ibn Kathir says Allah reports the Jews' envy and wish to misguide the believers, and that the harm returns on themselves, unaware they are being plotted against. The paper adds that whoever faith has touched never leaves it, nor does who has seen the light return to darkness. By trying to misguide Muslims they only increase in misguidance and punishment, busy with it instead of the ways of guidance.
A quoted passage says they took misguidance as a mount, falsehood as a road and argument as a weapon against Islam; they lost themselves from the start, and even if they win they lose themselves twice. They do not perceive that they harm and destroy themselves before anything else.
The third form is many of them wishing the Muslims to renounce their religion. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:109. Many of them wish the Muslims to renounce their religion, envy drives them, and they did this only after knowing the truth. Ibn Kathir says Allah warns the believers from following the ways of the disbelieving People of the Scripture, telling them of their inward and outward enmity and envy though they know the believers' merit and their Prophet's. He says Allah commands the believers to pardon, overlook and bear until His command comes, of victory and conquest.
The fourth form is allying with the disbelievers against the Muslims. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:80-81. The author of al-Manar says the Messenger sees many of the Children of Israel allying with his people's idolaters and inciting them to fight him, though he believes in what was sent to their prophets, while those idolaters do not affirm Allah's oneness or believe in His books and messengers. He asks how they could ally with them against him if not for whims and Allah's wrath.
He says this is blame, confirmed by oath, of the Jews' deed that their souls sent ahead to meet Allah with, an ugly act that brought His wrath. He says the torment surrounds them and they find no escape from it. He explains that if those Jews allying with the Arab idolaters believed in Allah and Muhammad ﷺ, or in Musa, whom they claim to follow, and what was sent to him, they would not have taken idol worshippers as allies and supporters.
He says the alliance had no cause but both agreeing on disbelief in Allah, His Messenger and Book, and cooperating to fight the Messenger, nullify his call and make an example of his believers.
The position of affection toward the believers
The second position, of some of the People of the Scripture, is affection and love. It is the position of some Christians who kept something of the truth Isa brought and believed in Muhammad ﷺ when he came confirming it. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:82-83. Qatada says these were People of the Scripture on a law of truth from Isa, believing in him; when Muhammad ﷺ was sent they believed him and knew his message was the truth, and Allah praised them. So the paper takes the verse to mean the believing group of the People of the Scripture.
It says believers among the Christians outnumber those among the Jews, who are few because of their diseases of envy, lying and much disputing against the truth, whereas the Christians have compassion and mercy, and priests and monks. Ibn Kathir says those who claimed to be Christians, following the Messiah and his Gospel, have in general an affection for Islam and its people because of the gentleness and compassion in their hearts, as in Al-Hadid 57:27.
He cites from their book that whoever strikes you on the right cheek, turn to him the left, and fighting is not legislated in their creed. That is why, he says, Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:82: among them are qissisun, their preachers and scholars, and monks (ruhban), worshippers, from rahba, fear. Knowledge with asceticism, and worship, soften the heart and remove hardness and coarseness, so the Jews' harshness and the idolaters' severity are not found in them.
The verse singled out the Christians because many of them believe. The Companions who migrated to Abyssinia found good treatment and shelter from al-Najashi, its king, a Christian before he became Muslim. When he died, the Prophet ﷺ said, in Jabir's report, that a righteous man had died that day and they should stand and pray over their brother Ashama. Unlike this, the Prophet ﷺ and his companions found from the Jews in Medina plotting against his call and attempts to assassinate him.
Allah mentioned their humility and weeping on hearing the Quran, a reaction He often mentions of such believers among the People of the Scripture, as in Al-Isra 17:107-109. And Ali 'Imran 3:199. The paper says this shows that the trait is evident in them. Singling out this trait with humility alludes to other People of the Scripture whom Allah's words do not move, whose hearts are unaffected and eyes do not weep.
The verse says the nearest in affection are those who said they are Christians, but the paper says it does not mean all Christians, since some share the Jews' hostility, though the Jews are more intense. Allah showed the hostility of both Jews and Christians in many verses, such as Al-Ma'idah 5:51.
Ibn Kathir says Allah forbids the believers to ally with the Jews and Christians, enemies of Islam and its people, and he invokes Allah's fighting against them. He adds that Allah reports they are allies of one another, then threatens whoever does this. The paper says historical reality witnesses this hostility beyond doubt. The Prophet ﷺ sent a force against the Romans, who are Christians, at Mu'ta in the land of Sham, and went himself against them at Tabuk, and the Muslims' battles with the Crusaders are well known.
Deviations of the People of the Scripture
From the paper: «انحرافات أهل الكتاب»
The paper says the People of the Scripture deviated in the fundamentals of religion before its branches, and their scholars before their common people. They deviated in pure tawhid: they ascribed a son to Allah, said "third of three", and said that Allah is the Messiah, son of Maryam. Their scholars altered their books and religion, consumed people's wealth wrongly, and flattered the kings of the earth at the expense of their religion and creed.
The Quran set out their deviation in general and in detail, answered and corrected their errors, so that they would return, and not be deceived by outward religiosity or by their claimed link to the prophets. It keeps declaring all the prophets innocent of what they follow and ascribe to them.
Explaining these deviations, their causes and results is also a warning to this Muhammadan nation against following their path.
A child for Allah:
The Quran answered their deviation in tawhid in several places, such as Al-Ma'idah 5:72-75. And Al-Ma'idah 5:116. And At-Tawbah 9:30-31. And Al-Ma'idah 5:64, and the paper says there are many more such verses. The verses show their deviation in tawhid and their disagreement in it. Some believe that Allah is the Messiah, son of Maryam, some say he is the son of Allah, and some say "third of three". The paper explains that this means Allah, Isa and his mother, or Allah, Isa and the Holy Spirit; this is the view of their later people, including the Christians of this time.
The author of al-Manar says the later Christians say three persons (aqanim), each identical with the others: the Father is identical with the Son and the Holy Spirit, and since the Messiah is the Son, he is identical with them too. Others take the Messiah and his mother as two gods besides Allah. The paper judges all these sayings to be disbelief in Allah, ignorance of His religion, and failure to tell the Creator from the created and the Lord from the owned. It says they are of the kind of the sayings of pagans who worship idols, humans and stones, and are taken from them.
The paper says the verse's opening declaration that those who say this have disbelieved is a clear announcement of the Christians' disbelief and a warning of how serious the matter is. Those who say it leave the religion by its widest door, even if they claim to be People of the Scripture. Allah confirmed the declaration with an oath particle and a particle of emphasis.
The Quran shows that Isa is innocent of their worshipping him and of what they ascribe to him. Like the other messengers, he was only commanded to worship Allah and uphold tawhid; he made clear that no one enters Paradise at the outset except through it, and forbade shirk, which throws its owner into the Fire.
The Quran's answer includes commanding them to repent of their falsehood and warning them against continuing in it. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:73-74. The paper explains that the "lam" in "will touch" is an oath, and touching points to the severity of the pain, since the painful punishment keeps striking their skin, the place of feeling.
As Allah says in another verse An-Nisa 4:56. The question "will they not repent" is one of astonishment and denial. The verse urges them to repent, opening the invitation with an extremely gentle offer. Allah forgives the sins of the repentant, even if they reach the clouds of the sky.
Ibn Kathir says it is from Allah's generosity and mercy that, despite this great sin and fabrication, He calls them to repentance and forgiveness, and whoever repents to Him, He accepts. After refuting their falsehood, the Quran explains the truth: the Messiah is a messenger from Allah, and his mother Maryam is among the siddiqin, the highest of creation in rank after the prophets.
The Quran gives clear sensory evidence: Isa and his mother, whom the Christians claim to be divine, ate food. The paper explains that they were servants who hunger, need food and drink, and are subject to the necessities of eating. If they were gods they would need none of it; the god is the Self-Sufficient, the Praiseworthy.
The Quran also shows their audacity against the divine essence, as they ascribed to Allah deficiencies such as miserliness and poverty.
Scholars and monks as lords:
The Quran shows their deviation in the tawhid of worship and obedience, where Allah says At-Tawbah 9:31. The paper explains that the Jews took their rabbis (ahbar), their scholars, and the Christians took their monks, their worshippers, as lords besides Allah. They gave them the right of legislation and obeyed them in it, so that they permit and forbid what Allah did not legislate. The paper adds, in a quotation, that they also exaggerated about their shaykhs and worshippers, and made their graves idols worshipped besides Allah, sought with sacrifices, supplication and calls for help.
Hence Allah says At-Tawbah 9:31. The right to make things lawful and unlawful belongs to Allah alone. The paper cites a hadith from Adi ibn Hatim: he came to the Prophet ﷺ with a golden cross on his neck, and the Prophet ﷺ told him to throw off this idol and recited At-Tawbah 9:31. The Prophet ﷺ said they did not worship them, but when the rabbis and monks declared something lawful they treated it as lawful, and when they forbade something they treated it as forbidden.
The paper concludes that the Quran thus shows the Christians' deviation in this great part of the religion, which took them out of faith into disbelief, as Allah judged them.
Disbelief in, alteration and concealment of Allah's verses
Among their serious deviations, the paper says, are disbelief in Allah's verses, altering the books sent to them, and leaving belief in some of them. Their books are the vessel of their religion, so losing and altering them is losing the religion itself, a great calamity. Allah showed mercy to this nation when He said Al-Hijr 15:9.
The Quran shows their deviation regarding their books in many verses. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:85. And Al-Ma'idah 5:13. And Al-Baqarah 2:75. And Al-Baqarah 2:79. And Al-Baqarah 2:174. The paper says these verses show a deviation in a pillar of faith: believing in Allah's books, respecting them, acting by them and ruling by them. They believe only part of what the books bring, what suits their whims, and disbelieve the rest. They also threw the books behind their backs and stretched their hands to alter them. Mentioning this rebukes them, and consoles the Prophet ﷺ, since this is their way even with their own book, as in Al-Baqarah 2:75.
Al-Saʿdi says this cuts off the believers' hopes for their faith, because they used to alter Allah's words after understanding them, putting meanings Allah did not intend so that people would think they were from Him. If this is their state with their own book, which they see as their honor and religion, how can faith be hoped from them?
Al-Shaʿrawi comments on Al-Baqarah 2:75: it is a compound sin, since they heard Allah's words, understood them and knew the punishment, and then altered them. The paper says the Quran shows the forms of their altering their books. First they forgot part of them; what they did not forget they altered in wording and meaning, concealing from it the description of the Prophet ﷺ, and they added to it.
Al-Shaʿrawi cites Al-Ma'idah 5:14. He asks what they did with the part they did not forget, and cites Al-Baqarah 2:159. He says concealing is a voluntary act, while forgetting may have an excuse, yet they still bear a sin, since had they lived by the method they would not have forgotten it. What they did not forget they partly concealed, and what they did not conceal they twisted with their tongues; then they brought something of their own and said it was from Allah, as in Al-Baqarah 2:79.
So the paper says their altering takes four forms: forgetting, concealing, altering, and inserting things claimed to be from Allah that are not. The Quran shows causes of this deviation. Following their whims made them believe what suits them in their books and not what opposes it. Envy of the Prophet ﷺ and fear for their leadership made them conceal the good news of him. Weak religious restraint made them write the book with their own hands and say it is from Allah, for a small price, as in Al-Baqarah 2:79.
They sold their religion for worldly gain. "Small" means not worth regarding, since even a great sum is small against the painful, everlasting punishment it earned them. Breaking the covenant caused hardness of heart as a punishment, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:13. A hard heart is not moved by a sermon and does not fear the punishment of sin, so they dared to alter and to commit other deviations.
Barring from Allah's path and consuming wealth wrongly:
The paper says scholars are the safety valve for people when prophets are absent: people ask them for rulings and consult them, and they ward off the doubts of misleaders. When scholars become corrupt, they harm the common people. The Quran shows that many of the rabbis and monks consume people's wealth wrongly and bar people from Allah's path, as in At-Tawbah 9:34.
Allah exposed many of them and warned the believers. The paper explains that this came in the discussion of the People of the Scripture, who altered their religion, said the Messiah is the son of Allah, and wished to extinguish Allah's light, which Allah willed to complete, and did. So it fit to show the actual conduct of most of these religious leaders, so Muslims know what drives them to try to extinguish Allah's light, and that most worship their whims and desires.
Allah described them as consuming wealth wrongly because they took bribes to ease rulings and be lenient in the laws. They also claimed before the common people that no one can win Allah's pleasure except by serving and obeying them and spending money to please them.
This is the false way they consumed people's wealth, and the way of most ignorant people and forgers in every age. Ibn Kathir says the Jewish rabbis had standing among the people of the Jahiliyya, who paid them levies and gifts. When Allah sent His Messenger, they persisted in misguidance, disbelief and stubbornness, hoping to keep that leadership; Allah extinguished it with the light of prophethood, and replaced it with humiliation and poverty, and they incurred Allah's anger.
Allah then described them as barring from His path, because they went to extremes in preventing people from following the Prophet ﷺ by every kind of scheming and deceit. The paper says these verses teach the believers not to trust these people or the rituals and garments by which they inspire awe and trust. They also warn this nation and its scholars against their way. Ibn Kathir says the aim is to warn against evil scholars and misguided worshippers, and quotes Sufyan al-Thawri: whoever of our scholars becomes corrupt resembles the Jews, and whoever of our worshippers becomes corrupt resembles the Christians.
The quotation ends by asking whether anything has corrupted religion except kings and evil rabbis and monks. Allah showed how eager some of the People of the Scripture are to tempt the Muslims and bar them from their religion, saying Ali 'Imran 3:99. The paper explains that Allah ordered His Prophet ﷺ to declare openly his rejection of their barring believers from Allah's religion. He was ordered to address them as "People of the Scripture" to rebuke them and intensify the condemnation, since that title requires them to believe in what confirms what they have and to encourage people toward it, so barring from it is of the worst ugliness.
Their barring was in some forms by altering the book and disbelieving the verses that point to his prophethood.
Mixing truth with falsehood
Among their methodological deviations, the paper says, is mixing truth with falsehood, as Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:71. In the language, mixing (al-lubs) means putting one thing into another. The verse means they mix the truth Allah sent down in their book with the falsehood their rabbis and monks put into it, lies and false interpretations, until trust in the whole was lost. The address "People of the Scripture" adds to the rebuke, and the question is one of denial. The paper says they should have preserved these books, knowing their rank, not mixed falsehood into them.
They dressed their falsehood in the garment of truth by inserting it into their books and claiming it was from Allah, a clear deviation in Allah's religion.
Extremism in religion
The paper quotes a passage saying extremism is a dangerous deviation in the history of the heavenly religions and a major cause of leaving the straight path. It begins small and grows until it seems to be the origin. Christianity, it says, was pure of shirk in the Messiah's time, then extremism turned it from pure tawhid to pure shirk, and from a heavenly religion to a man-made one mixed with Indian paganism, Greek nonsense and Jewish falsehoods.
The paper says the Christians went greatly to excess, which ruined their religion and cost them the Hereafter. They exaggerated about the Messiah until they worshipped him besides Allah. They exaggerated about their righteous and worshippers, took them as lords, called on them, sought their help, and let them legislate. They also exaggerated in worship and invented monasticism.
The root of the word for extremism occurs in the Quran in two places, both about the People of the Scripture. The first is An-Nisa 4:171. The second is Al-Ma'idah 5:77. The Quran also shows their extremism in worship, their invention of monasticism, in Al-Hadid 57:27. It called them to leave extremism and return to the truth and moderation in belief.
The paper quotes the explanation that adding to religion is like subtracting from it, since both take it out of its place. It explains straying from the even path in Al-Ma'idah 5:77 as straying from Islam, the middle with neither extremism nor neglect. The Christians made Isa and his mother two gods besides Allah, while the Jews disbelieved in Isa and accused his mother of immorality, so they are at opposite extremes. Muslims say Isa is Allah's servant and messenger, His word cast to Maryam, and a spirit from Him, honored without being deified. They say Maryam is truthful, pure and chaste.
Allah says of her Ali 'Imran 3:42. The Quran forbade them extremism and imitating their forefathers in it. Those who strayed before misled many who followed their innovations, and misled others from the core of religion Al-Ma'idah 5:77. That core is a middle between blameworthy extremes: tawhid between shirk and denial of attributes, following revelation between innovation and blind imitation, generosity between miserliness and stinginess.
The paper quotes a passage saying monasticism in Christianity is an innovation, with a good intention, as in Al-Hadid 57:27. Its origin was the effect of the Messiah's sermons on asceticism. Then most of its followers became ignorant and lazy, and their worship formal, bringing showing off, conceit and the common people's veneration, hence the verse says they did not observe it properly.
The passage adds that when Christianity became organized in the fourth century, leaders made rules for monasticism and life in monasteries, and some of their freer people complained of its corruption. It resembles some Sufis of this nation who entered through extremism in worship into innovations, shirk, whisperings and fancies, like those Christians.
Showing their extremism and what it brought them warns this nation against extremism and teaches it the danger.
False Claims of the People of the Scripture
From the paper: «دعاوى أهل الكتاب الباطلة»
The Quran mentioned some false claims of the People of the Scripture and refuted them, so that they would give them up and be guided to the truth, and to protect the Muslims from being influenced by them.
The claim that guidance lies in following their creed
One of their false claims that the Quran mentioned and answered is that guidance lies in following their creed (milla). Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:135-138. The paper explains that both groups made the claim: the Jews said guidance is in Judaism, the Christians said it is in Christianity, and each claims its religion is the true one Allah legislated.
Allah ordered the Prophet ﷺ to answer them as in Al-Baqarah 2:135, which the paper explains as: we follow the way of Ibrahim. Milla is religion, and hanif means upright, or one who turns from every false religion to the true one. Ibrahim was so described for turning from the error of his time to the true religion revealed to him, which is Islam to Allah, submission and obedience to Him, the call to tawhid and the forbidding of shirk.
This is the true milla: whoever believes in it is guided and successful, as in Al-Baqarah 2:137, and whoever turns from it has wronged himself, as Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:130-132. The paper explains that he wronged himself by foolishness and poor judgment, leaving the truth for error and opposing the path of the one Allah chose in this world for guidance, from his youth until He took him as a close friend, who is among the righteous in the Hereafter. What greater foolishness is there than leaving the milla of Ibrahim for paths of misguidance?
Allah said that Ibrahim's milla is Islam, and that he enjoined it on his sons, and Yaqub (Israel) did the same. So the hanifiyya is the milla of all the prophets, who were all on tawhid, Islam and submission to Allah's command, and it is the best religion.
Allah says An-Nisa 4:125. It is the religion beside which Allah accepts none other, as He says Ali 'Imran 3:85. Part of Ibrahim's milla is believing in all of Allah's prophets and messengers without distinction, and in what was sent down to them and the miracles they were given. This is the true religion that leads to the straight path, not other religions, as in Al-An'am 6:161.
The paper says the Jews and Christians are not on the milla of Ibrahim, because they opposed it, strayed from it, and associated with Allah that for which He sent down no authority. The particle "bal" means turning away: we do not follow your milla but that of Ibrahim, which you opposed, as in Al-Baqarah 2:135. The closing words of the verse hint at the People of the Scripture, who claim to follow Ibrahim while persisting in shirk.
Qatada is reported to have said about Al-Baqarah 2:130 that the Jews and Christians turned away from his milla, made Judaism and Christianity an innovation not from Allah, and left the milla of Ibrahim, meaning Islam; this is why Allah sent Muhammad ﷺ with it. So the Prophet ﷺ was ordered to answer that guidance is not in their creed but in the milla of Ibrahim, tawhid and Islam to Allah. It is the true religion of all prophets and messengers, though their laws and methods differ, since all were Muslims and monotheists; Allah accepts nothing else.
After showing the true milla, Allah called the Jews and Christians to follow it and stated their case if they did not, in Al-Baqarah 2:137. Their affair is then limited to enmity and opposition. Allah will suffice the Prophet ﷺ against their harm and evil scheming, support his call and give him strong victory over them.
Allah then says Al-Baqarah 2:138. The paper quotes the explanation that "Allah's dye" is His religion, on which He created people, because its effect shows on its holder like dye on cloth. So the milla of Ibrahim, Allah's dye and the fitra, is more worthy of following because it is the religion of the fitra. The paper cites a hadith from Abu Hurayra: every child is born on the fitra, then his parents make him Jewish, Christian or Magian, as an animal gives birth to a whole animal; Abu Hurayra then recited Ar-Rum 30:30.
The claim that no one else enters Paradise
Another of their false claims is denying Paradise to anyone else. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:111-112. The paper explains that the Jews said only a Jew will enter Paradise and the Christians said only a Christian, so they ruled Paradise for themselves alone. This is mere wishing, not accepted without proof, so they are told to bring it if they are truthful, meaning something Allah sent down about it. Anyone who makes a claim must establish proof; otherwise, if the claim were reversed, there would be no difference between them, so since they had no proof, their lie in this claim is known.
Allah answered with Al-Baqarah 2:112, where "bala" (yes) is a word that affirms after a negation, so it voids their claim Al-Baqarah 2:111. Those who are not Jews or Christians do enter it, because Allah's mercy is not limited to one people, but is given to all who seek it and do its work. "Submits his face to Allah" means turning to Him alone and singling Him out for worship; it is put as the face because one who seeks something faces it, not turns his back, as is said of Ibrahim in Al-An'am 6:79.
"Doer of good" means in action, and the Quran's way is to pair belief with righteous deeds in many verses, since together they are the causes of success and entering Paradise, as in An-Nisa 4:123-124. The Quran thus refuted their false claim, showing it is mere wishing with no reality and no proof in the law. Entering Paradise is not conditioned on being a Jew or a Christian, but on true faith and righteous deeds.
The claim that they are Allah's sons and beloved ones
The People of the Scripture claimed to be Allah's sons and beloved ones, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:18. The paper says this is one link in a long chain of similar false claims about being God's chosen people, that no one else enters Paradise, and that guidance is limited to their creed. Their altered Torah is full of such false wishes, by which they delude themselves and look down on others, and the paper cites Deuteronomy there as calling them children of the Lord, His holy and special people above all peoples on earth.
The verse again Al-Ma'idah 5:18. The exegetes differed over the sonship that Allah relates they claimed. One view is that it is the sonship the Jews claimed for Uzayr and the Christians for the Messiah, and then they claimed those two were of them, as if saying we are sons of Allah.
It is like the relatives of a king who boast that they are kings of the world, meaning they are linked to the king; here, they are linked to His prophets, who are His sons, and He loves them. Another view is that it is a sonship of connection and love, a special connection to Allah beyond others, singled out for more compassion and care.
Then "His beloved ones" is an explanatory addition, so it is a figurative sonship. The title "sons of Allah" occurs in their altered books, as cited from the Torah. Ibn Kathir says they took it to a meaning other than its interpretation and altered it. More than one of their sensible people who became Muslim answered that among them it is said for honor and esteem. They did not claim for themselves the sonship claimed for Isa, but meant their dearness and favor with Allah.
Allah answered with the words "why does He punish you for your sins", which the paper explains as: if you had a distinction with Allah above His creatures, why does His way with them, punishing the wrongdoer, apply to you. He punished some of them, the Sabbath-breakers, by turning them into apes and swine, and set their enemies over them to torment them, violate their temples and kill their scholars. In the Hereafter too He punishes them for their sins, by their own admission.
As Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:80. Hence the verse says they are human beings of His creation, with no advantage over others. He forgives whom He wills, those who believed in Him and His messengers and did righteous deeds, and punishes whom He wills, those who disbelieved. All dominion is His, and the return to Him points to recompense in the Hereafter, which falls on them like other people.
Allah also says Al-Jumu'ah 62:6-7. Allah thus gave the lie to their claim to be His friends apart from other people, proving it by their dislike of death and meeting Him. Ibn al-Qayyim says this debate contains a dazzling miracle of the Prophet ﷺ: opposing him most eagerly, they were told definitively that they would never wish for death. They were humbled and knew his words were true. What kept them from wishing it was knowing the disgrace and painful punishment awaiting them for disbelieving the prophets, killing them and their enmity to Allah's Messenger ﷺ.
Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:94. The paper explains it as: wish for the death that brings you to that pure, lasting bliss with none to dispute it; if you do not, you are not truthful, since a person would not shun happiness and choose misery. Allah informs in another verse of their intense eagerness for life, which will not save them from punishment, in Al-Baqarah 2:96.
Claim that Ibrahim and his sons were Jews or Christians:
Another false claim is that Ibrahim and his sons were Jews or Christians, as in Al-Baqarah 2:140. Out of ignorance of the history of their laws they claimed this, and Allah called them liars, then confirmed their lie in other verses such as Ali 'Imran 3:67. A nation sunk in ignorance, whose beliefs are delusion without reflection, believes what does not fit the evidence, and contradictions gather in its beliefs.
They said this because they know Ibrahim's leadership in religion and Allah's praise of him in their books, so they ascribed themselves to him and argued with the Muslims. Even the Arab polytheists claimed to follow him. The paper cites a hadith from Ibn Abbas: when the Prophet ﷺ came to Makkah he refused to enter the House with idols in it and had them removed, and an image of Ibrahim and Ismail holding divining arrows was brought out. The Prophet ﷺ said: may Allah fight them, they know the two never divined with them; then he entered, said takbir in its corners, and left without praying in it.
The paper quotes the meaning of the verse: Allah told us this, and told you in your own scriptures, so do not conceal the truth written there; none is more wrong than one who conceals a truth he knows from his book, and Allah will repay them for the falsehood they persist in.
Allah also says Ali 'Imran 3:65-68. Allah mentioned their argument about Ibrahim and their claim that he was on their creed, then refuted them in several ways.
- Rebuking them for arguing about Ibrahim though the Torah and Gospel were sent down after him, as in Ali 'Imran 3:65.
- The quoted explanation says the Jews cannot claim he was Jewish when he lived before the Torah, nor the Christians that he was Christian when Christianity arose long after his time.
- Rebuking them for arguing about what they have no knowledge of.
- Denying that Ibrahim was a Jew or Christian and affirming that he was a Muslim hanif, not a polytheist, which refutes those who claim to follow his milla, tawhid, while persisting in shirk.
- Stating that the people closest to Ibrahim are those on his milla, including the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ and those who believed in him.
The claim that no one else has any truth
Another false claim the Quran refuted is that no one but themselves has any truth, as Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:113. A quoted explanation says they said this openly when the delegation of Najran, with notables of the Christians, came to the Prophet ﷺ. The Jews came while the delegation was with him and debated until they insulted each other. The Jews disbelieved in Isa and the Gospel and told the Christians they were on nothing, and the Najran delegation disbelieved in Musa and the Torah and told the Jews the same. "On anything" means on nothing worth regarding, that is, no truth, a way of saying the other's scripture is invalid.
The words "while they recite the Scripture" heighten astonishment at their saying it. Each side recites a book that contains truth if its people follow it as they should. Abu Hayyan says these words reproach them, since the book speaks against what they say. Their Torah testifies to the good news of Isa and Muhammad and the truth of their prophethood, and their Gospel to that of Musa and Muhammad ﷺ, for Allah's books confirm one another. He adds a lesson for the nation of Muhammad ﷺ: whoever knows the Quran should stand by it and act by it, not contradict it, lest he be like the Jews and Christians.
Allah added to the rebuke that those who do not know said the same, so their state resembles that of the Arab polytheists, who had no book. Abu Hayyan says "those who do not know" are the Arab polytheists in the majority view, a great rebuke of the People of the Scripture, who set themselves, with knowledge, among those who do not know.
The paper explains that the closing words are Allah's comment on this dispute: He will judge between them on the Day of Resurrection, supporting the truth and its people and forsaking falsehood and its people.
Dealing with the People of the Scripture
From the paper: «معاملة أهل الكتاب»
The paper says the Quran set several rules for dealing with the People of the Scripture, because it is a legislation covering every part of life, including how Muslims deal with others, whether People of the Scripture or other disbelievers. These rules show the divine origin of the Quran and the justice and greatness of its legislation, as in Al-Isra 17:9.
The Quran distinguished between the People of the Scripture and the other disbelieving nations, giving each its due rank. All are disbelievers and astray, but the People of the Scripture keep a rank above the others: they believe in Allah, some of His books (despite their alteration) and His messengers. Their faith is corrupt and deficient and does not benefit them in the Hereafter, but it sets them apart from polytheists, idol-worshippers and atheists. So it is just to distinguish them in some worldly rulings, such as permitting marriage to their women and eating their slaughtered meat.
First: calling them to Islam and arguing in the best way:
Islam is Allah's religion, which He legislated and approved for His servants; He accepts no other and no one is saved except by it, as He says Ali 'Imran 3:85. Allah also says Ali 'Imran 3:19. The paper explains that the origin of the religion their messengers brought is Islam, which they changed out of injustice among themselves, so they strayed.
The Quran called them in many verses and ways, including the explicit call in Ali 'Imran 3:64. It refuted their beliefs, showing that they contradict the fundamentals of their sound religions that Musa and Isa brought, along with other wise methods. It also explicitly forbade arguing with them except in the best way, which a quotation explains as good manners, gentleness and soft speech, calling to the truth and making it appealing, and with wisdom, as that is more effective and likelier to win a response, as in Al-Ankabut 29:46.
The paper notes that the verse begins with a prohibition rather than saying argue in the best way, which is stronger and more emphatic in commanding courtesy in discussion and debate.
Not compelling them to leave their religion
Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:256. Islam does not force the People of the Scripture to leave their religion or embrace Islam by threats; the choice is left open. If they stay, Islam keeps them in it in return for submitting to its general rule, which guarantees rights for them and others.
A quoted passage says this principle shows Allah's honoring of the human being: respecting his will, thought and feelings, leaving him in charge of his own guidance or error in belief, and responsible for his deeds, as in Al-Baqarah 2:256. The text only touches the conscience to awaken it and draw it to guidance.
Faith is the right guidance a person should seek, and disbelief the error he should shun. The paper says history shows this principle absent from many nations, and that the inquisition courts and cruel treatment of those who differed in creed, even in opinion, bear witness. By contrast, Jews, Christians and others lived among the Muslims for hundreds of years in safety for self, wealth and family, until many entered Islam with full conviction because of its justice and the Muslims' character.
Perhaps this is the wisdom of keeping those who differ in creed in the lands of Islam. They see Islam up close, learn its greatness, and see Muslims keeping their religion in congregational prayers and avoiding the forbidden, unlike followers of other religions who neglect theirs.
Fairness to the trustworthy among them
Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:75. The paper explains that Allah distinguished the trustworthy among the People of the Scripture from the treacherous. Of the trustworthy, the one who returns a qintar, meaning a great deal of money, shows excess in fulfilling the trust. Unlike the second kind, no standing over him is mentioned: he returns even a great trust without being pressed.
Al-Razi says the qintar and the dinar stand for a large and a small amount. Among them are those so trustworthy that they return a trust of much wealth, and those so treacherous that they would betray a trust of little.
Forbidden to ally with them, and permitted food and marriage
The paper says a fundamental of Islamic creed set by the Quran is loyalty and disavowal (al-walaʾ wal-baraʾ). Loyalty is to the people of tawhid and Islam, by love, sincerity and support; disavowal is from the people of shirk and disbelief, by hatred and enmity. This is from the milla of Ibrahim and those with him, whom we are ordered to follow, as in Al-Mumtahanah 60:4.
Allah explicitly forbade allying with the Jews and Christians: Al-Ma'idah 5:51. The reason, the paper says, is that they and other disbelievers are enemies of Allah, with whom He is angry and whom He cursed. How could a Muslim who loves Allah and His Messenger love those who opposed them and defied His command, the paper asks; therefore we should hate them.
Al-Tabari says Allah forbade all believers to take the Jews and Christians as supporters and allies against the people of faith. Whoever does so is one of them in siding against Allah, His Messenger and the believers, and Allah and His Messenger are free of him.
Ibn Hazm says it is established that the words "whoever allies with them is one of them" are literal: he is a disbeliever among the disbelievers, a truth about which two Muslims do not differ Al-Ma'idah 5:51. There are many such verses, training the Muslims to know the scheming of the People of the Scripture and cutting off any loyalty some feel toward them, so loyalty is only to Allah, His Messenger and the believers.
This prohibition never contradicts the Quran's tolerance and kindness toward them. A quoted passage says Islam's tolerance with them is one thing and taking them as allies another, and some Muslims confuse the two. They confuse the call to tolerance and kindness toward the People of the Scripture, who live in the Muslim society with their rights guaranteed, with loyalty, which belongs only to Allah, His Messenger and the Muslim community.
They forget what the Quran establishes: the People of the Scripture are allies of one another in war on the Muslim community, and this is their fixed state; they resent the Muslim for his Islam and will not be pleased until he leaves his religion; and hatred shows from their mouths, with what their breasts hide being greater. The Muslim must be tolerant but is forbidden loyalty, meaning mutual support and alliance. The Muslim's path cannot meet theirs, and no tolerance he shows will make them accept his staying on his religion or stop them from allying against him.
Fifth: slaughtered meat and marriage:
Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:5. "The food of those given the Scripture" means their slaughtered meat, permitted to the Muslims because they mention Allah's name on it. By the converse meaning, the food of followers of other religions is not lawful, since they do not mention Allah's name, nor require slaughter, but eat carrion. "Your food is lawful for them" means the Muslims may feed them from their slaughtered animals, by way of reciprocity.
It permits marrying the free, chaste women of the People of the Scripture if the Muslims pay their dowries intending marriage. "Not committing fornication" means not openly committing zina, and not taking girlfriends with whom they secretly commit it. A quoted passage says Islam permitted this marriage to remove the barriers between them and Islam, since marriage brings companionship and closeness of families. So it is a method of practical rapprochement.
Subjecting them to the rule of Islam
This means the general rule of Islam, which guarantees the People of the Scripture their rights while leaving them to their religion. If they submit to the Islamic state, owe it loyalty and pay the jizya, they are given a covenant of protection (ahd al-dhimma).
A quoted definition says the ruler lets some People of the Scripture or other disbelievers stay on their disbelief on two conditions: they accept the rulings of Islam in general, and pay the jizya. Then fighting them is forbidden, and their wealth, honor and freedoms are protected.
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:29. The paper explains that Allah commands the believers to fight the People of the Scripture who deviate from His religion until they pay the jizya by hand, in a state of submission. Truce treaties are no longer accepted from them except on this basis, and then they have the rights of the covenanted dhimmi and peace holds. A quoted passage adds that coexistence between Allah's way and the other ignorant ways is impossible except under special conditions, so that Islam stays above the false religions.
The jizya benefits them, since it protects their lives and lets them stay on their religion. They live in a believing society where the Muslims guarantee their safety in themselves, families and wealth. As the Muslim pays zakat for the needs of the poor and Muslims, they benefit from Islam's services too, so they should pay something for them.
Seventh: tolerance, kindness and fairness:
Allah says Al-Mumtahanah 60:8. The paper explains that this is permitted and is not the forbidden loyalty: to be kind to those who did not fight them, repay them with good, and deal justly with them. Ibn Ashur says kindness (birr) is good dealing and honoring; it is also a word for every good, as in Al-Ma'idah 5:2.
The exegetes differed over who is meant. The sound view, as Al-Tabari and others preferred, is that the verse is general for all religions, so it covers the Jews, Christians and others. This is under its conditions: they did not fight us for our religion, did not expel us from our homes, and do not help an enemy in any way, even by advice.
The closing words encourage the believers to be just even with disbelievers, showing Islam's greatness in distinguishing the aggressor from others. A quoted passage says this is outside the prohibition of allying with the disbelievers. That prohibition means supporting them against the Muslims, which harms the Islamic entity, and being pleased with their disbelief, which is disbelief. But peaceful relations, good company, good treatment, exchange of interests and cooperation in righteousness and piety are what Islam calls for.
Takeaways
Learn from their deviations
The paper says explaining the deviations of the People of the Scripture, their causes and results, is a warning to this nation against falling into them.
In the same way, showing their extremism warns this nation against it and teaches it the danger.
Argue in the best way
The Quran explicitly forbade arguing with the People of the Scripture except in the best way.
The paper also says Islam does not force them to leave their religion, and leaves the choice open; if they stay on their religion, Islam keeps them on it in return for their submitting to its general rule, which guarantees rights for them and for others.
Tolerance is not allegiance
The paper says Islam's tolerance with the People of the Scripture is one thing and taking them as allies another, though some Muslims confuse the two.
The Muslim is required to be tolerant with them but forbidden loyalty to them, meaning mutual support and alliance.
Faith and righteous deeds, not a label
The paper says entering Paradise is not conditioned on being a Jew or a Christian, but on true faith and righteous deeds.
Do not contradict the Quran you know
Abu Hayyan says whoever knows the Quran should stand by it, act by it and say what it contains, and not contradict it, lest he be like the Jews and Christians.
Reflect
- Where in my own practice might I be treating a person's word as having the right to make things lawful or forbidden in place of Allah's?
- Do I keep a clear difference in my own heart between kindness toward people of other faiths and allegiance, as the paper describes it?
- How do I engage in disagreements about religion, and does my manner match the best way the Quran asks for?
- Which parts of what I know from the Quran do I only know, and which do I act on?
Every verse in the paper
All 120 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.
The Concept of People of the Scripture «مفهوم أهل الكتاب»
The technical meaning «ثانيًا: المعنى الاصطلاحي»
People of the Scripture in Quranic Usage «أهل الكتاب في الاستعمال القرآني»
Related Terms «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»
The Jews: linguistic meaning «اليهود لغة»
The Jews: technical meaning «اليهود اصطلاحًا»
The Children of Israel: technical meaning «بنو إسرائيل اصطلاحًا»
The Christians: linguistic meaning «النصارى لغة»
The Quran's Frequent Discussion of the People of the Scripture «كثرة حديث القرآن عن أهل الكتاب»
27:76, 2:41, 17:107-109, 47:17, 1:6-7, 9:32, 61:8-9
The Wisdom of Addressing the People of the Scripture «حكمة النداء بأهل الكتاب»
The Position of the People of the Scripture Toward the Messenger «موقف أهل الكتاب من الرسول»
9:31, 2:79, 5:15, 2:285, 6:124, 61:6, 2:89, 7:157, 5:19
A group that believed in Muhammad and his message «أولًا: طائفة آمنت بمحمد صلى الله عليه وسلم ورسالته»
3:113-115, 3:110, 55:60, 5:83-85, 3:199, 28:52-55
A group that disbelieved in the Prophet Muhammad's message and sending «ثانيًا: طائفة كفرت برسالة النبي محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم ومبعثه»
A group that hid the description of the Prophet Muhammad «ثالثًًا: طائفة كتمت صفة النبي محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم»
2:146, 3:71, 3:187, 2:159, 2:174
The Position of the People of the Scripture Toward the Muslims «موقف أهل الكتاب من المسلمين»
The position of hostility toward the Muslims «أولًا: موقف العداء من المسلمين»
5:82, 2:91, 4:54-55, 3:72, 3:71, 3:73, 2:105, 3:69, 2:109, 5:80-81
The position of affection toward the believers «ثانيًا: موقف المودة من المؤمنين»
5:82-83, 57:27, 17:107-109, 3:199, 5:51
Deviations of the People of the Scripture «انحرافات أهل الكتاب»
5:72-75, 5:116, 9:30-31, 5:64, 4:56
Disbelief in, alteration and concealment of Allah's verses «ثانيًا: الكفر بآيات الله وتحريفها وكتمانها»
15:9, 2:85, 5:13, 2:75, 2:79, 2:174, 5:14, 2:159, 9:34, 3:99
Mixing truth with falsehood «رابعًا: تلبيس الحق بالباطل.»
Extremism in religion «خامسًا: الغلو في الدين.»
False Claims of the People of the Scripture «دعاوى أهل الكتاب الباطلة»
The claim that guidance lies in following their creed «أولًا: دعوى أن الهدى في اتباع ملتهم.»
2:135-138, 2:130-132, 4:125, 3:85, 6:161, 30:30
The claim that no one else enters Paradise «ثانيًا: دعوى نفي دخول غيرهم الجنة.»
The claim that they are Allah's sons and beloved ones «ثالثًا: دعوى أنهم أبناء الله وأحباؤه.»
5:18, 2:80, 62:6-7, 2:94, 2:96, 2:140, 3:65-68
The claim that no one else has any truth «خامسًا: دعوى نفي الحق عمن سواهم.»
Dealing with the People of the Scripture «معاملة أهل الكتاب»
Not compelling them to leave their religion «ثانيًا: عدم إكراههم على ترك دينهم.»
Fairness to the trustworthy among them «ثالثًا: الإنصاف للأمناء منهم.»
Forbidden to ally with them, and permitted food and marriage «رابعًا: النهي عن موالاتهم.»
Subjecting them to the rule of Islam «سادسًا: إخضاعهم لحكم الإسلام.»
About this source
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
- Volume
- 3
- Research paper
- «أهل الكتاب» (People of the Scripture)
Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.
This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.