Peoples, Places & Nations · Quran topic

Christians

النصارى · Nasara

What the Quran says about Christians: their beliefs and claims, their standing, and Islam's tolerance

109 verses · 9 parts · 64 min read

Study guide based on

موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم

مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية

«النصارى» · Volume 17

At a glance

The paper defines the Christians as the community of the Messiah Isa son of Maryam. It says they were named for helping him and one another. It explains that the Christians are one of the People of the Book, together with the Jews. The Quran often pairs Jews and Christians, and the paper says this pairing has a wisdom or many reasons. One is their shared scripture. Another is their descent from Banu Israel. Another is some shared deviant beliefs.

On belief, the paper says the oneness of Allah is the basis of the People of the Book's religion, yet the Christians made the Messiah and his mother gods. It says the doctrine came from the first Christian council, at Nicaea, and was imposed by force and authority. It treats the Trinity as a basic part of their deviant beliefs, and says the Quran refutes it. It then lists further false claims of the Christians that the Quran answers. One is that no one else enters Paradise. Another is that guidance lies in following their religion.

Before Islam, the paper says, there were believing monotheist Christians, such as Salman al-Farisi and the Christians of Abyssinia. Others who called themselves Christians broke the covenant they took. After Islam, the paper presents Islam as the last heavenly religion, completing Judaism and Christianity. It says some Christians believed and were praised, and others were censured for denying and altering their religion. It describes the Christians who fought Islam as plotting against it. It says they envied the Muslims and concealed the Prophet's description. It also says they tried to misguide the Muslims. It also lists the Quran's warnings to the Muslims against imitating, obeying and allying with them.

The paper ends with examples of Islam's tolerance toward the Christians. They include not compelling them to enter Islam. They also include raising the standing of Isa and his mother, and protecting their blood by the choice between Islam and the jizya. The paper adds justice toward them.

Key verses

  1. Al-Baqarah 2:111: The paper cites it as the false claim of the Jews and Christians about who will enter Paradise. Al-Tabari takes the call to bring proof as Allah's denial of their claim, since they could never produce proof.
  2. As-Saff 61:14: The paper cites it for the view that the Christians were named for helping Isa. It also names the disciples as Isa's companions and helpers in this verse.
  3. Al-Baqarah 2:113: The paper cites it as the Jews and Christians each denying that the other has any standing. Qatada says the early Jews and early Christians had been on something, but they innovated and divided. The paper adds that Allah answers them in the same verse.
  4. Al-Baqarah 2:135: The paper cites it as the Christians' false claim that guidance lies in following their religion. Al-Tabari explains the answer as following the religion of Ibrahim, which all of them witness to be Allah's chosen religion. The paper says the verses deny that Ibrahim was a Jew or a Christian and refute their claim.
  5. Al-Ma'idah 5:18: The paper cites it as the claim of the Christians, with the Jews, to be Allah's children and beloved ones. For the Christians it gives two reasons: their reading of a saying in the Gospel, and their words about the Messiah as son of God. It says Allah then refuted their claim.
  6. Al-Baqarah 2:140: The paper cites it as the claim that Ibrahim, Ismail, Ishaq, Yaqub and the tribes were Jews or Christians. It explains that each side claimed them, and Allah answered that He knows better, meaning they were neither. It reads the concealed testimony as Allah's witness to Ibrahim's upright religion and his freedom from Judaism and Christianity, with a hint at their hiding the testimony of Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood in their books.
  7. Al-Qasas 28:54: The paper reports Qatada saying the doubled reward is for believing in the first book and the last book. It also reports that the verses came down about forty men of the People of the Gospel who believed in the Prophet ﷺ before his mission. In its section on tolerance it explains the doubling as once for their own book and once for the Quran.
  8. Al-Baqarah 2:105: The paper cites it for the dislike of a group of the People of the Book, Christians among them, that good be sent down to the Muslims. It explains Allah's answer as His choosing for prophethood whom He wills. From it the paper draws the duty to beware of the People of the Book.
  9. Al-Baqarah 2:109: The paper cites it for the wish of many of the People of the Book to turn the Muslims back from faith out of envy. Al-Razi says they do this by casting doubts, worldly ones and religious ones. In its section on tolerance the paper cites the verse for the command to pardon them. A quoted explanation says this pardon was abrogated by making fighting them an obligation.
  10. Al-Baqarah 2:145: The paper cites it for the refusal of the Jews and Christians to follow the Muslims' qibla. A quoted explanation says they asked the Prophet ﷺ for a sign, and even with every sign they would not follow his qibla. It says they opposed him out of arrogance and stubbornness. It adds that the Jews face the Rock and the Christians the sunrise, so their agreement cannot be hoped for.
  11. At-Tawbah 9:30: The paper gives it as an example of the plural form of the word for Christians in the Quran. It cites it among the verses on the claim that Isa is Allah's son. It counts the attribution of a son to Allah among the deviant beliefs shared by the Jews and Christians.
  12. An-Nisa 4:171: The paper cites it as the Quran's answer to the Christian claim of the Trinity. It says the verse forbids exaggeration in their religion and saying about Allah anything but the truth. A quoted explanation says the Christians speak of Father, Son and Holy Spirit, and calls this pure disbelief.
  13. Al-Ma'idah 5:14: The paper cites it for those who called themselves Christians, who broke the covenant and forgot what their messenger brought. It explains that the Christian sects remain hostile to one another, each denouncing the other, such as the Malakiyya and the Yaqubiyya. Later it says their alliance with one another rests on enmity to Islam, not purely on Allah.
  14. Al-Ma'idah 5:82: The paper cites Ibn Ashur on the Quran's wording for the Christians. It explains that Allah here describes the Christians' gentle nature and inclination to Islam, while pairing the Jews with the polytheists in hostility. Later it quotes the verse as praise of a group of believing Christians.
  15. Ali 'Imran 3:199: The paper cites Ibn Kathir that a group of the People of the Book truly believe in Allah, in what was revealed to Muhammad ﷺ and in their earlier books, and do not conceal the good news of him. Al-Shawkani says the verse shows some of them have a share of religion, unlike the rest. Ibn Abbas said it was revealed about al-Najashi.

Words to know

النصارى al-nasara

The community of the Messiah Isa son of Maryam, Allah's messenger and His word.

Appears 158 times in the Quran.

Most common forms: نَصَرَ (59), نَصِير (35), نَصْر (22), نَصْرانِيّ (15), ناصِر (11)

Root: ن ص ر

أهل الكتاب ahl al-kitab

The people of religions with a heavenly book, the Jews as people of the Torah and the Christians as people of the Gospel, so the Christians are some of the People of the Book.

الحواريون al-hawariyyun

The companions and helpers of Isa son of Maryam.

إسرائيل Isra'il

A title given to Yaqub son of Ishaq. Ibn Abbas says it means servant of Allah.

بني إسرائيل Banu Isra'il

The descendants of Yaqub, who were twelve tribes. The Christians are among them.

The concept of Christians

From the paper: «مفهوم النصارى»

Linguistic meaning

Al-naṣārā (singular naṣrānī) is from naṣr, aiding and strengthening against an enemy; related forms are nāṣir, naṣīr, anṣār, tanāṣur (mutual aid), intiṣār (revenge) and istinṣār (seeking aid). Al-naṣārā follow the Messiah's religion, and naṣrānī then meant anyone worshipping by it; naṣrān and naṣrāna are sometimes said. Christians are attributed to Naṣrā, Nāṣira or Naṣūriyya, a village in al-Sham; tanaṣṣur is entering Christianity, and naṣṣarahu, making someone Christian.

Technical meaning

The paper says the technical meaning does not depart from the linguistic one: the Christians are the community of the Messiah ʿIsa son of Maryam, Messenger of Allah and His word, peace be upon him. Al-Raghib al-Isfahani reports two views on the name: it is said they were so called because of Allah's words As-Saff 61:14, and it is said it comes from a village called Naṣrāna, giving naṣrānī, plural naṣārā. Al-Raghib's passage then cites Al-Baqarah 2:113.

Christians in Quranic usage

From the paper: «النصارى في الاستعمال القرآني»

The root n-ṣ-r occurs 158 times in the Quran, 15 of them relevant to this topic. The singular naṣrānī occurs once, for example Ali 'Imran 3:67, and the plural naṣārā 14 times, for example At-Tawbah 9:30. The Christians are the followers of ʿIsa, peace be upon him; it is said they were so named for aiding him and aiding one another, as in Allah's words As-Saff 61:14. The paper adds that the name first belonged to the believers among them, and was then applied to all of them by predominance (taghlīb).

Related terms

From the paper: «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»

People of the Book (ahl al-kitāb)

People of the Book: linguistic meaning

Ahl is a man's clan and kin, adherents of a school or of Islam, an affair's rulers, a house's dwellers, a man's wife and intimates; the Prophet's ﷺ household is his wives, daughters and son-in-law. Kitāb, from kataba (to write), is what one writes in, and also inkwell, Torah, sheet, obligation, ruling, decree. It also means revealed scripture: the Quran's ahl al-kitāb and being given the Book refer to the Torah and Gospel. One cited definition: those gathered around it, the Jews and Christians.

People of the Book: technical meaning

The People of the Book are the Jews and Christians and all sects following their religion; other disbelievers are not, as Allah's words Al-An'am 6:156 show. Al-Shahrastani divides those outside the ḥanīfī religion and Islamic law who hold to a law, rulings, limits and landmarks into those with a genuine scripture, like the Torah and Gospel, whom revelation thus calls People of the Book, and those with a semblance of scripture, like the Magians.

The link between the People of the Book and the Christians

From both meanings, the paper defines the People of the Book as followers of religions with a revealed scripture: the Jews, people of the Torah, and the Christians, people of the Gospel; so Christians are part of the People of the Book.

The disciples: linguistic meaning

Ḥawārī (plural ḥawāriyyūn) is a companion, helper and supporter, or a man's close circle; al-Zubayr is the Prophet's ﷺ ḥawārī. Al-Zajjaj calls them the prophets' sincere ones, a usage that spread. Some trace the name to white clothes; ḥawārī also means pure, close friend, sincere, well-wisher, intimate, striver, favoured, a great man's companion, one fit for great succession.

The disciples: technical meaning

One cited definition: the chosen ones of the prophets, pure and sincere in believing them and aiding them. Al-Raghib al-Isfahani says they are the helpers of ʿIsa, peace be upon him.

The link between the disciples and the Christians

The disciples are the companions and helpers of ʿIsa son of Maryam, and are so named in As-Saff 61:14.

Israel: technical meaning

Israel is a title given to Yaʿqub son of Ishaq, peace be upon them. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:93. Banu Israel are the descendants of Yaʿqub, and they were twelve tribes. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:211. Ibn ʿAbbas says Israel means servant of Allah, since isra means servant and il is Allah's name, so it is made of two words, as people say bayt il.

The link between Banu Israel and the Christians

The Christians are of Banu Israel, the descendants of Yaʿqub, peace be upon him.

Pairing the Christians with the Jews in the Quran

From the paper: «اقتران النصارى باليهود في القرآن»

The Quran speaks of the Jews and the Christians in many verses, mostly pairing them, whether to report, to blame, to praise or otherwise. The paper says this pairing seems to have a wisdom or many reasons, among them the following.

  • They are both People of the Book, as Allah names them; the scripture uniting them is the Torah sent down to Musa, binding all Banu Israel by its rulings and law, then the Gospel sent down to ʿIsa to complete the Torah.
  • They are of Banu Israel, descendants of Yaʿqub and his sons; Musa and Maryam are among the sons of Israel, and the messages of Musa and ʿIsa were to Banu Israel in particular. Of Musa, Allah says Al-Isra 17:2. Of ʿIsa, He says Ali 'Imran 3:49.
  • They share some deviant beliefs, such as ascribing a son to Allah, as in At-Tawbah 9:30. They also share taking their rabbis and monks as lords besides Allah, as in At-Tawbah 9:31.
  • A group of them share qualities the Quran mentions. One is hiding the truth while knowing it, including hiding the Prophet's ﷺ description and name in the Torah and Gospel despite fully knowing that what he brought is true, as in Al-Baqarah 2:146. Another is disbelieving in Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood and not following and accepting the truth, as in Al-Baqarah 2:120.

Anyone who reflects on the Quran finds many more qualities shared by the Jews and Christians.

The creed of the Christians

From the paper: «عقيدة النصارى»

The divinity of ʿIsa son of Maryam and his mother

The paper says Allah's oneness is the root of the People of the Book's religion, and every prophet's first call was to His oneness and to worshipping Him alone. It says the Christians claimed a partner with Allah, making the Messiah and his mother gods worshipped besides Him. It says this belief has no root except in earlier pagan religions, which the Christians followed when they distorted and lost their true religion's fundamentals. ʿIsa came calling them to Allah's oneness, like the prophets before and after.

The paper places its origin in the first Christian council, the Council of Nicaea in 325, which affirmed the Messiah's divinity. It says the belief was imposed by the sword and authority, and has stayed firmly held to the present. They argued with doubts and texts from their distorted books, such as the Messiah's attributes and miracles. The Quran answered every false Christian claim about the divinity of the Messiah and his mother in more than one verse.

The paper quotes Al-Ma'idah 5:17. Ibn Kathir says Allah judges the Christians disbelievers for claiming that the Messiah, one of His servants and creatures, is Allah, exalted far above their words. He explains that nothing could prevent Allah if He willed, since all that exists is His creation and dominion. He calls this a refutation of the Christians, with Allah's curses upon them until the Day of Resurrection. It says the verse shows the humanity of the Messiah and his mother, and his inability to ward off destruction from himself or her; inability is the opposite of power and is not an attribute of a god.

The paper then quotes Al-Ma'idah 5:72. It calls this explicit proof that ʿIsa called only to oneness and warned of the end of associating partners with Allah. Ibn Kathir says Allah judges those Christian sects, Melkites, Jacobites and Nestorians, who say the Messiah is Allah, to be disbelievers. He adds that the Messiah told them he is Allah's servant and messenger, and his first words as a baby in the cradle were Maryam 19:30. He never said "I am Allah" or "son of Allah", and said Maryam 19:36.

Al-Zamakhshari explains that ʿIsa did not set himself apart from them: he too is a servant under a Lord. He takes the verse as an argument against the Christians: whoever associates a partner with Allah in worship, or in His own attributes or acts, has Paradise, the home of those who affirm His oneness, forbidden to him. He says the final clause is Allah's own speech: they wronged and left the path of truth in what they say of ʿIsa, so ʿIsa did not side with them or support their saying but rejected and denied it, though they exalt him by it.

The paper then quotes Al-Ma'idah 5:116. Al-Razi observes that when Allah asked ʿIsa whether he said this, he answered neither that he said it nor that he did not, but that it was not for him to say what is not right. He did not deny it, since that would be like claiming purity, and the place calls for humility; nor did he affirm it, but left it to Allah's all-encompassing knowledge. Al-Razi calls this the utmost courtesy, showing lowliness before Allah's majesty and handing every matter to Him.

Ibn Kathir says, as Qatada and others said, that this is a threat and reproach to the Christians before all witnesses, and Qatada argued from Al-Ma'idah 5:119. Ibn ʿAbbas says Allah will say this on the Day of Resurrection before all creation, so the disbelievers see ʿIsa cleared of what they ascribed to him and know they were in falsehood. Al-Qushayri says the question shows ʿIsa's innocence of the call to the Trinity attributed to him; it is not an address of reproach but a question of honour.

The paper concludes that the Quran established the disbelief of whoever believes in the divinity of the Messiah and his mother, and declared both innocent of what was falsely ascribed to them. It says ʿIsa's call was purely to worship Allah and cast off partners, warning his people against it while stressing his and his mother's humanity, in their inability to ward off destruction from themselves.

The paper cites Ibn Hisham's biography on the Najran delegation who came to dispute with the Prophet ﷺ about ʿIsa. Their bishop Abu Haritha ibn ʿAlqama, leader ʿAbd al-Masih and scholar al-Sayyid al-Ayham spoke to him. They followed the king of Rome's religion, though differing, and said of ʿIsa that he is Allah, Allah's son, and the third of three. When the two scholars spoke, the Prophet ﷺ told them to submit; they said they had submitted before him; he said they lied: claiming a son for Allah, worshipping the cross and eating pork kept them from Islam. The paper says this shows they believed in ʿIsa's divinity, that the Prophet ﷺ called them to Islam and to drop those errors, and that they still disbelieved the truth that came to them.

The sonship of the Messiah

Some verses point to the claim of those Christians who say ʿIsa is a son. Among them is At-Tawbah 9:30. Al-Razi finds Allah's report of this claim clear but strongly difficult. The Messiah and his companions were surely innocent of calling people to fatherhood and sonship, the most heinous disbelief. How could all Christians who love ʿIsa agree on it, and who ascribed this corrupt doctrine to the Messiah? Al-Razi relays the exegetes' answer: after ʿIsa was raised, his followers stayed on the truth until a war with the Jews, in which a brave Jew, Paul killed a number of ʿIsa's companions.

Paul told the Jews that if the truth was with ʿIsa, they had disbelieved and the Fire was their end, so he would mislead the Christians. He hamstrung his horse (printed "was punished"), showed regret, put dust on his head, and said he had been told from heaven that his only repentance was to become Christian. The Christians admitted him to the church, where he stayed a year learning the Gospel, and they believed and loved him.

He left Nestor as successor at Bayt al-Maqdis, teaching him that ʿIsa, Maryam and the god were three. In Rome he taught divinity and humanity (al-lāhūt wa-l-nāsūt), saying ʿIsa was neither human nor a body but Allah. He taught a man named Yaʿqub the same, and told a man named Malka that the god has always been, and always is, ʿIsa. He told each of the three to call people to his own Gospel, said he saw ʿIsa in a dream, pleased with him, and that next day he would slaughter a soul for ʿIsa's pleasure; he then slaughtered himself in the altar. Each of the three called people to his own doctrine, which al-Razi gives as the cause of this disbelief among the groups.

The paper reports two views on why they said "son of Allah". One is that ʿIsa was created without a human male. The other is that it was because of the dead he revived and the sick he healed. Al-Samarqandi says they reasoned that since the Messiah healed the blind and leper and revived the dead by Allah's permission, he could only do it as Allah's son.

The paper says sonship because of ʿIsa's creation without a father is no more wondrous than Adam's creation without father or mother. ʿIsa's miracles are of the kind Allah brought at the hands of earlier prophets, which did not show their divinity. Many verses refute the claim and show it is impossible for Allah to take a child, whether ʿIsa or anyone else.

Allah says Al-An'am 6:101. He says Al-Mu'minun 23:91. He says Maryam 19:35. The paper says the verses clearly show Allah cannot have a child, since the whole universe is subject to Him and worships Him. Allah says Maryam 19:93. He alone created the heavens, the earth and what is between them, and when He wills a thing He says Be and it is, so needs no child. So Allah warns those who claim a child for Him Al-Kahf 18:4.

The Sunna also denies it. A sound hadith from Ibn ʿAbbas has Allah saying the son of Adam denies Him by claiming He cannot restore him as he was, and reviles Him by saying He has a child, while He is far above taking a consort or child. The paper concludes their claim is false.

The Trinity among the Christians

The paper says the Trinity is a root of the Christians' deviant beliefs, with no source except ancient pagan religions. Yet all their sects agree on it, saying Allah is one substance (jawhar) with three hypostases (aqānīm), each a god. By these they mean existence, life and knowledge, sometimes expressed as Father, Son and Holy Spirit: the Father is existence, the Spirit life, and the Son the Messiah. This is no different from the divinity of the Messiah and his mother; both are false, and the Quran's proofs against that divinity also refute the Trinity, since in their claim the two are among the three. Two verses nonetheless state its falsehood explicitly.

The paper quotes An-Nisa 4:171. The address covers all the People of the Book, but the context shows the Christians are primarily meant, as it gives proofs against what they claimed about ʿIsa. Allah forbids excess and exaggerated praise, common among Christians: they went beyond believing in ʿIsa and raised him above his rank, from prophethood to a god worshipped besides Allah. They are addressed as People of the Book as a hint they contradicted their book. Saying "three" means saying the gods are three, since the Christians say Father, Son and Holy Spirit. It is also said they hold Allah to be three hypostases in substance, but since they allow that essence to dwell (ḥulūl) in ʿIsa and Maryam, they affirm three separate essences, pure disbelief. So Allah says An-Nisa 4:171, meaning that desisting from it is better for them than saying three.

The Prophet ﷺ therefore warned his community against excess and exaggerated praise, as happened with a group of Christians. A sound report from Ibn ʿAbbas has ʿUmar saying on the minbar that the Prophet ﷺ told them not to praise him excessively as the Christians did the son of Maryam: he is only Allah's servant, so say servant of Allah and His messenger. The paper explains this as not making him a god as the Christians did; it does not forbid honouring and revering him, a duty on the community.

The paper quotes Al-Ma'idah 5:73. It explains their saying that Allah is the third of three: what people know as Allah is the sum of three things, and one of them deserves the name. They call these hypostases: existence, the essence called Allah and also the Father; knowledge, also the Son, which united with ʿIsa so that he became a god; and life, the Holy Spirit.

Al-Razi says the Trinity means either three attributes or three essences. The first is false, because being knowing differs in meaning from being powerful and living, and affirming these is necessary to Islam, so they could not be declared disbelievers for it. So Allah declared them disbelievers because they affirmed three eternal, independent essences. They allow the hypostasis of the Word to dwell in ʿIsa and that of life in Maryam, which they would not unless these were self-subsisting essences; this is polytheism and affirming gods.

Rahmatullah al-Hindi says no prophet brought the Trinity and no heavenly scripture contains it. Its absence from the Torah needs no proof, as the present Torah has no explicit mention or hint of it. Jewish scholars from Musa's time to now neither acknowledge it nor accept its attribution to their books. If true, Musa and the other prophets of Banu Israel, the last being ʿIsa, would have had to explain it fully, since they were commanded to act on all the Torah's rulings in law and creed. Trinitarians hold salvation depends on it, so how did all Israel's prophets leave the world without stating it clearly? Yet they explained less important matters, repeated some rulings, stressed keeping them and required killing for neglecting some. It is astonishing that ʿIsa, last of Israel's prophets and one of the Trinity's pillars for Christians, was raised to heaven without explaining it in clear words needing no interpretation, for example that Allah is three hypostases and how the Son, the second god, relates to him.

The paper concludes that the Quran refuted and invalidated the Christian claim of the Trinity. It called them to truth, faith and oneness, forbade excess and saying about Allah anything but the truth, whether that He is one in three, three in one, or three hypostases. It told them to desist from a claim that contradicts Allah's oneness and leads to plain disbelief, warned of the threat if they do not return, and said desisting is good for them. Allah then declared Himself far above the Christians' Trinity An-Nisa 4:171.

The false claims and sayings of the Christians

From the paper: «دعاوى النصارى وأقوالهم الباطلة»

The Quran spoke of the Christians' beliefs and showed how they departed from ʿIsa's religion. They were not content with those false beliefs but added false claims and sayings, which the Quran refuted, and the paper explains them in the points that follow.

The claim that no one else enters Paradise

The paper says a group of the Christians claimed that no one else enters Paradise, with no proof except asserting that they are its people, and some Jews said the same. The Quran spoke of this false claim when Allah reported it of the Jews and Christians Al-Baqarah 2:111.

The words "they said" mean the Jews and the Christians. The Jews said only a Jew enters Paradise and there is no religion but Judaism, and the Christians said the same of Christians and Christianity. So each ruled Paradise for itself alone, mere wishes unaccepted without proof, and they are told to bring it if truthful. Anyone who makes a claim must bring proof; otherwise the opposite claim would be just as good, since proof confirms or denies claims. As they had no proof, their lie was known.

It is said the verse was revealed about the Najran delegation, Christians who met the Jews in the Prophet's ﷺ gathering and each denied the other's claim. Allah answered that these are their wishes, which the paper explains as false desires they wished upon Allah without right. The Prophet ﷺ is told to ask for their proof of the claim, if they are truthful. Then Allah answered that it is not as they claim: whoever submits his face to Allah while doing good enters Paradise and enjoys it. Submitting the face is explained as being sincere in one's religion to Allah, or sincere in worship, or submitting and humbling oneself, since the root of Islam is submission.

Al-Tabari asks how the Jews and Christians are combined in this report when they differ, each denying the other any share in Allah's reward. He answers that the Jews said only Jews enter and the Christians only Christians, but since the meaning was clear to those addressed, the two were combined in the report. The Quran also answered their false claim in Al-Baqarah 2:94.

Al-Razi calls this another kind of their vileness, claiming the afterlife home is theirs alone, and points to several indications, among them Al-Baqarah 2:111. Another is their belief that they alone are right because abrogation is not permitted in their law and the other groups are falsifiers, and that descent from great prophets, Yaʿqub, Ishaq and Ibrahim, saves them from Allah's punishment and brings them to His reward. Because of this they exalted themselves and boasted over the Arabs. Al-Razi adds that they perhaps took it as proof that the prophet foretold in the Torah was from them, not the Arabs, and so turned people from following Muhammad ﷺ. Then Allah argued against their claim with Al-Baqarah 2:94.

A quoted explanation raises an objection: in denying others' entry they claimed entry for themselves, so proof should be demanded only for what they claimed, not what they denied. It answers that they did not state their own entry outright, only denied others', like one who says only so-and-so enters this house, which says nothing of those two entering but denies others. Or, it says, they denied others' entry outright and claimed their own by inference, and proof is demanded of what they stated, not their inference. Allah's reply rejecting them came on what they denied of others' entry Al-Baqarah 2:112. Likewise their saying in Al-Baqarah 2:111 does not outright affirm their own entry but denies others', and Allah knows best.

The paper concludes that the Christians claim to be people of truth, more entitled to Paradise, and everyone else belongs to the Fire. It calls these false wishes with no proof, so Allah ordered His Messenger ﷺ to demand their proof and showed their total inability to give it. Al-Tabari says that although this seems a call for proof, it declares their claim false, since they could never produce it.

The next verse shows who will enter Paradise Al-Baqarah 2:112. The paper explains it as the one sincere in deeds and intention in obedience and faith. The face is singled out as the noblest and most sacred of the members, so if it submits, the rest are more fit to. So Allah declared their claim false, mere wishes not reached by wishing; Paradise is open to everyone who works for it, not one group, but all who do good and submit their face to Allah while doing good.

The claim that guidance lies in following their creed

The Quran spoke of this false claim when Allah reported it from the Christians Al-Baqarah 2:135. Al-Tabari says Allah gave His Prophet ﷺ the most complete argument. He is to tell those who say to become Jews or Christians that instead we follow Ibrahim's creed, which all agree is the religion Allah chose and ordered. Ibrahim's religion was hanifiyya muslima; we leave the disputed creeds, which we cannot unite on as we can on his.

Al-Wahidi reports Ibn ʿAbbas saying it was revealed about the Jewish leaders of Medina, Kaʿb ibn al-Ashraf, Malik ibn al-Sayf and Abu Yasir ibn Akhtab, and the Christians of Najran. They disputed with the Muslims, each group claiming to be more entitled to Allah's religion. The Jews called their prophet, book (the Torah) and religion the best, and disbelieved in ʿIsa, the Gospel, Muhammad ﷺ and the Quran. The Christians said the same of their prophet, book (the Gospel) and religion, and disbelieved in Muhammad ﷺ and the Quran. Each told the believers to follow their religion, as there is no other.

Allah rejected the Christians' claim in the same verse, telling the Prophet ﷺ to answer them Al-Baqarah 2:135. The paper gives the sense: we follow Ibrahim's creed as a ḥanīf. Ibn Durayd says the ḥanīf turns from one religion to another, and Islam is called ḥanīfiyya because it turned from Judaism and Christianity. Al-Asmaʿi says whoever turns from the religion of the Jews and Christians is a ḥanīf to the Arabs. Al-Akhfash says the ḥanīf is the Muslim, and in the Jahiliyya a circumcised pilgrim was called ḥanīf. Ibn ʿAbbas says it is one who turns from all religions to Islam. Mujahid says ḥanīfiyya is following Ibrahim in the law that made him an imam for people.

Then Allah ordered the believers to answer those who make this claim Al-Baqarah 2:136. The paper concludes that this claim is false; guidance is in Ibrahim's creed, though they know and acknowledge his prophethood. The Quran showed true guidance is not Judaism or Christianity but following Ibrahim's creed as a ḥanīf. If they truly wanted guidance they would believe in Muhammad ﷺ, who is on Ibrahim's creed.

The claim that they are the sons and beloved ones of Allah

The Christians claim to be Allah's sons and beloved ones, as Allah said of them and of the Jews Al-Ma'idah 5:18. Al-Tabari says this is Allah's report of what a group of Jews and Christians said. The paper quotes an unnamed explanation. By "sons" they meant those near to Allah as children to a father, and "beloved" means lovers or loved ones. They may have meant the elite, as in "sons of this world", or followers of one called a son: the Jews of ʿUzayr, the Christians of the Messiah. "Sons" would then be figurative, by likening followers to sons in nearness of rank.

For the Christians there are two reasons. One is their interpretation of a saying in the Gospel about going to "my Father and your Father". The other is that they call the Messiah Allah's son and go back to him, so they made themselves His sons and beloved. The paper notes it already discussed their claim of ʿIsa's sonship and its refutation.

On the reason for revelation, Ibn ʿAbbas says the Prophet ﷺ warned some Jews of punishment and they said they feared not, being Allah's sons and beloved. Ibn Ishaq says Nuʿman ibn Adha, Bahri ibn ʿAmr and Shas ibn ʿAdi came to him; he called them to Allah and warned them of His retribution, and they said they were Allah's sons and beloved, like the Christians.

Allah then invalidated their claim with Al-Ma'idah 5:18. Al-Razi objects: the gist is that if they were Allah's sons and beloved He would not punish them, but He did; yet is this punishment worldly or in the Hereafter? If worldly, it does not damage their claim, since Muhammad ﷺ claimed he and his community were Allah's beloved, yet they had worldly trials, such as Uhud and the killing of al-Hasan and al-Husayn. If the Hereafter, they deny it, and his bare report is not enough, or his report that they lied would suffice and the argument be wasted.

Al-Razi answers in several ways. First, the point is worldly punishment, and Uhud does not bind, since Muhammad ﷺ claimed to be Allah's beloved, not His son. Second, the point is the Hereafter, which they acknowledged, as Allah reported they said Al-Baqarah 2:80. Third, the question means why He transformed them, so those actually punished were earlier Jews, and the attribution to those addressed fits as they are of the same kind. He prefers it, since a strong proof uses what has already happened, not something not yet existing. Then Allah said Al-Ma'idah 5:18, meaning no one has a right over Him obliging Him to forgive or preventing Him from punishing; the dominion is His.

The question, besides denouncing their saying, has two further indications. One is informing them that He will punish them for their sins and that they are held to account. The other is that good deeds have reward and evil deeds punishment, and whoever denies it is wrong. They had no right to claim His love and sonship while disobeying Him and spreading corruption; the question carries a threat to the disobedient and good news to the obedient.

The paper concludes that the Jews' and Christians' claim, and their belief in distinction and superiority over others, are false. Allah belied them, denied them to Himself in their claim, and stated their punishment. He favors no group over another; the paper asks how He would favor the Christians who claim the Messiah's divinity, that Allah is third of three, and that the Messiah is His son, and then not punish them.

The claim that Ibrahim and his descendants were Jews or Christians

The Christians claimed that Ibrahim was one of them, and that Ismaʿil, Ishaq, Yaʿqub and the tribes were on their creed too; the Jews said the same of themselves. The Quran mentions this claim in Al-Baqarah 2:140. The tribes are the twelve tribes from Yaʿqub's descendants, a tribe (sibṭ) being a group returning to one father. The Jews claim these figures were Jews and the Christians claim Christians, and Allah replied that He knows them better, so they were neither.

Al-Razi gives four reasons Allah denied this. First, Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood is established by his miracles, and he reported their lie. Second, the Torah and Gospel testify that the prophets held to oneness and the ḥanīf religion. Third, the Torah and Gospel were sent down after them. Fourth, they claimed it without proof, so Allah rebuked them with a question of denial, to censure them and make them know they were lying. The question "do you know better, or Allah" is an affirmation and rebuke of their claim. The paper says this calls for complete faith that Allah is the All-Knowing, and that no one should describe himself by what Allah described Himself with.

The paper explains the words on who is more unjust than one who hides testimony from Allah as Allah's testimony that Ibrahim was a ḥanīf and free of Judaism and Christianity. No one is more unjust than the People of the Book for hiding it, or than us if we hid it. It also hints at their hiding Allah's testimony of Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood in their books, and the closing words warn them. Al-Hasan al-Basri says they read in Allah's book that religion with Allah is Islam, that Muhammad ﷺ is Allah's messenger, and that Ibrahim, Ismaʿil, Ishaq, Yaʿqub and the tribes were free of Judaism and Christianity. Allah testified to this, they acknowledged it against themselves, yet hid it.

Allah also told that they were neither Jews nor Christians, as in Al-Baqarah 2:133. He says Ali 'Imran 3:65. He says Ali 'Imran 3:67. These verses deny that Ibrahim was a Jew or Christian and refute the saying in Al-Baqarah 2:135.

They also refute the claim that Yaʿqub was a Jew who willed Judaism to his sons, binding his descendants to it. His will is given in detail to refute the People of the Book's baseless belief. The Torah and Gospel came only after Ibrahim, Ismaʿil, Ishaq, Yaʿqub and his sons, and if they have other knowledge, are they more knowing than Allah? Ibrahim and his sons were on Islam and willed their descendants to hold fast to it and die in it.

The claim is also false because the Torah and Gospel came only after Ibrahim. What counts is following and emulating him well, not lineage, as in Ali 'Imran 3:68. The Christians, though they acknowledge Ibrahim's prophethood, did not follow his ḥanīf religion built on oneness and casting off partners. They associated partners with Allah by calling the Messiah a god and Allah's son, which contradicts their claim about Ibrahim.

The claim that others have no share of truth

This claim is each group of the People of the Book saying the other is on nothing. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:113. Each claimed the other has nothing and that it is more deserving of Allah's mercy. Ibn Kathir says this implies each group was right about the other, but the context blames them for saying it while knowing otherwise. They know the Torah's and Gospel's law, each prescribed in its time, yet denied each other out of stubbornness and disbelief.

It is said the verse was about people of the two Books who disputed before the Prophet ﷺ. Those before them who did not know did the same, but these said it while finding their own lie in their books, since each one's book orders belief in the other and in the one who brought it. "Those who do not know" are earlier nations or, it is said, the Arabs of the Jahiliyya who said Muhammad ﷺ was on nothing. Al-Wahidi says it was about the Jews of Medina and Christians of Najran: when the Najran delegation came to the Prophet ﷺ, Jewish rabbis came and they debated until voices rose. The Jews said the Christians were on nothing, disbelieving ʿIsa and the Gospel, and the Christians said the same of the Jews, disbelieving Musa and the Torah.

Al-Maturidi asks how Allah rebuked them for this when He ordered His Prophet ﷺ in another verse to say to them Al-Ma'idah 5:68. He answers that they were to be told they are on nothing only if they do not uphold the Torah; if they uphold it, it orders them to Islam and to follow Muhammad ﷺ, and they are on something. Qatada says the early Christians were on something but then innovated and split, and so were the early Jews. The paper concludes that they are on something when they uphold the Torah and Gospel and obey Allah in what He ordered in their books, which is following the Arab Prophet ﷺ. Whoever does not follow the Prophet ﷺ and the Quran is on nothing.

Allah answered them in the same verse Al-Baqarah 2:113. He will show them plainly who enters Paradise and who the Fire. He also answered through His Prophet ﷺ Al-Ma'idah 5:68. They could uphold them only by upholding the Quran and following the Prophet ﷺ, but refused and disbelieved, so humiliation was struck upon them, as in Ali 'Imran 3:112.

The paper concludes that the People of the Book's claim is invalid: each group claimed to be on something, though they know their religion and recite the Torah and Gospel. They distorted their religion's fundamentals and lost what the Torah and Gospel brought, so they became on nothing. Had they wanted the truth they would have been right in what they said, since each group denied Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood knowing he is a prophet and finding him in its book, while earlier nations said it without knowing.

The Christians before Islam

From the paper: «النصارى قبل الإسلام»

The believing monotheists before Islam, the paper says, believed in Allah's religion, all His messengers and prophets, and the books sent to them, whether Jews or Christians. They kept their prophets' laws in word and deed, believed what the Torah and Gospel say of the Prophet's ﷺ sending, and awaited his coming and the duty to believe in and support him, without arrogance. A covenant to this effect was taken from the prophets, as Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:81-82. Ibn ʿAbbas says Allah sent no prophet without taking his covenant to believe in Muhammad ﷺ and support him if sent in his lifetime.

The first Christian to see the Prophet ﷺ before the mission was the monk Bahira. The Prophet ﷺ, with Abu Talib's trading caravan to al-Sham, passed a monk in his hermitage in Busra, Bahira, to whom Christian knowledge reached. Bahira advised Abu Talib to take the Prophet ﷺ back, fearing for him from the Jews.

The most prominent Christians who believed in the Messiah's true religion before Islam were Nastura, the man of Busra, the bishop of al-Sham, al-Jarud al-ʿAbdi, Salman al-Farisi, the Christians of Abyssinia, the bishops of Najran, and ʿAddas. So the Quran praised a group of believing Christians, describing their qualities, character and correct creed, and blamed those who disbelieved in many verses, as the next sections show.

Believing monotheist Christians

Many verses speak of the People of the Book, who are the Jews and Christians, so the Christians are included in every such verse. Some verses concern Jewish rabbis, but most mean both. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:121. The paper explains it as the believers among the People of the Book, who recite their Book as it deserves, without distorting or changing its description of the Messenger ﷺ. They believe in their Book, unlike the distorters, and those distorters who disbelieve in it are the losers, having bought misguidance for guidance.

The paper quotes Ali 'Imran 3:113-115. It explains that those earlier blamed among the People of the Book are not equal to those who submitted: not all are alike, for some believe and some are criminals. The upright community stands by Allah's command, obeys His law and follows Allah's prophet. Its people pray much at night and recite the Quran in their prayers, and the paper goes on to the qualities in Ali 'Imran 3:113 and Ali 'Imran 3:114.

The paper then quotes Al-Qasas 28:52-54. The verse has two explanations: those given the Torah and Gospel before the Quran believe in the Quran (Yahya ibn Sallam), and those given them before Muhammad ﷺ believe in him (Ibn Shajara). There are two views on whom it was revealed about. One, from Qatada, is ʿAbdullah ibn Salam, Tamim al-Dari, al-Jarud al-ʿAbdi and Salman al-Farisi, who became Muslim, with this verse and the next revealed about them. The other is forty men of the people of the Gospel who believed in the Prophet ﷺ before his mission, thirty-two from Abyssinia who came with Jaʿfar ibn Abi Talib and eight from al-Sham, among them Bahira, Abraha, al-Ashraf, ʿAmir, Ayman, Idris and Nafiʿ. Qatada says their double reward in Al-Qasas 28:54 is for believing in the first Book and the last.

The paper then quotes Al-Isra 17:107-109. It explains the people given knowledge before it as those before the Quran's descent and the Prophet's ﷺ coming, the believers among the People of the Book, according to Ibn Jurayj and others. Ibn Jurayj says what is recited to them is their book, and it is also said the Quran. It is said, regarding Al-Isra 17:107, that those who fall prostrating are people of Ismaʿil's descendants who held to their religion until Allah sent the Prophet ﷺ, among them Zayd ibn ʿAmr ibn Nufayl and Waraqa ibn Nawfal.

The paper concludes that the Quran praised the believing monotheists of the People of the Book, Christians included, so not all of them are astray; some believe in Allah, His angels, messengers and books.

Those who changed their religion and their end

A group of Banu Israel called themselves Christians (naṣārā), and Allah took a covenant from them to believe in ʿIsa, who came to complete Musa's message, being of one community, as Allah says As-Saff 61:6. But they broke the covenant and neglected what their messenger brought, as Allah says of them Al-Ma'idah 5:14.

An unnamed quotation says they claimed to follow the Messiah, son of Maryam, but did not. Allah took covenants from them to follow and support the messenger and believe in every prophet He sends, and they did as the Jews did and broke them. So Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:14, meaning He cast enmity and mutual hatred among them until the Hour. Christian sects of all kinds are still hostile to one another, each declaring the other disbelievers and cursing them. Each bars the other from its place of worship; the Melkites declare the Jacobites disbelievers, and so do the others, with the Nestorians and Arians, in this world and on the Day the witnesses stand. Qatada says they forgot Allah's book, covenant and command.

The paper notes Allah spoke of them as those who said "we are Christians", not "of the Christians". Al-Hasan al-Basri says this shows they invented Christianity and named themselves by it, and are not on the way of the disciples who followed the Messiah in his time, who were truly Christians. Some exegetes point to this meaning.

Ibn ʿAshur notes this description here and in Al-Ma'idah 5:82. It records against them that their religion's name points to its root, that followers be helpers of what Allah commands As-Saff 61:14. This includes supporting those who uphold the religion after ʿIsa, such as Paul and Peter and other callers to guidance, and above all the Prophet foretold in the Torah and Gospel, who comes after ʿIsa before the world ends and saves people from misguidance. All followers of messengers are bound by what their prophets committed to, the Christians especially, so their title is a standing proof against them all.

The paper concludes that a group of Banu Israel claiming to be Christians took Allah's covenant to follow their messengers, then the Torah's and Gospel's glad tidings of the Prophet ﷺ, and to support him. They forgot it and broke the covenant, so Allah cast enmity and hatred upon them until the Day of Resurrection.

Christians after Islam

From the paper: «النصارى بعد الإسلام»

The paper presents Islam as the last heavenly religion, completing Judaism and Christianity: as Isa came to complete Musa's religion, the Prophet ﷺ came to complete the whole religion, so all are one religion calling to worship of Allah alone, except that Islam abrogates the earlier laws, as Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:19.

Hence, the paper says, Christian scholars of the People of the Book know this religion's truths from the unaltered Torah and Gospel, which mention the Prophet's ﷺ mission, the good news of his coming, his name and attributes, unlike earlier nations lacking this knowledge. Some Christians believed and followed the Prophet ﷺ, and Allah praised them in many verses and stated their reward; others Allah censured for denying, altering and changing their religion, and stated their end, as the following points explain.

Those who believed in the Prophet ﷺ

In many verses Allah praised those People of the Book, Christians among them, who believed in Allah and His Messenger ﷺ. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:199. Ibn Kathir says Allah tells of a group of the People of the Book who truly believe in Allah, in what was revealed to Muhammad ﷺ and in their earlier scriptures, humbly obedient to Allah, who do not conceal the good news of Muhammad ﷺ, his description, mission and his community's description; these are the choicest of the People of the Book, Jews or Christians.

Al-Shawkani says the verse shows some People of the Book have a share of religion, unlike the rest in the scandals Allah related of them: humble before Allah, they believe in Him and in what He revealed to our Prophet ﷺ and to their prophets, and rather than altering His signs for a small price like the rest, they relate Allah's books as they are; so this righteous group has the reward Allah promised in Al-Qasas 28:54.

Ibn Abbas said the verse was revealed about al-Najashi, king of Abyssinia, named Ashama (Arabic for "gift"). When he died, Jibril told the Prophet ﷺ that same day, and he told his Companions to pray over a brother who died in another land; he went out to al-Baqi, Abyssinia was unveiled to him so he saw al-Najashi's bier, and he prayed over him with four takbirs and asked forgiveness for him.

Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:82-85. The paper explains that Allah here describes the Christians' gentle nature, readiness to turn back and inclination to Islam, while pairing the Jews with the polytheists in intense hostility to the believers, naming the Jews first to signal their lead in it. He explains the Christians' closeness by the fact that among them are priests and monks, meaning scholars and worshippers, and that they are humble, unlike the Jews.

Al-Wahidi reports that Jafar ibn Abi Talib came from Abyssinia with his companions and seventy men in wool whom al-Najashi sent as a delegation to the Prophet ﷺ: sixty-two from Abyssinia and eight from Syria (Bahira the monk, Abraha, Idris, Ashraf, Tamam, Qaytam, Durayd, Ayman). The Prophet ﷺ recited all of Surah Ya-Sin to them; they wept, believed, and said how like it was to what was revealed to Isa, so Allah revealed these verses about them.

Reportedly, when the emigrants to Abyssinia and the polytheists, upon whom the paper invokes a curse, met in al-Najashi's court as the polytheists incited him against the emigrants, al-Najashi asked Jafar whether their Book mentioned Maryam; Jafar recited the surah named after her up to Maryam 19:34. He also recited Surah Ta-Ha up to Ta-Ha 20:9, and al-Najashi wept.

Allah says Al-A'raf 7:157. Fakhr al-Din al-Razi gives two senses of following in this verse:

  • First, believing in his prophethood, having found his description in the Torah, as following his laws before his mission is impossible; and the Gospel's mention means they will find him written there, as finding him before its revelation is impossible.
  • Second, it means those Children of Israel who lived in the Prophet's ﷺ time, who receive the mercy of the Hereafter only if they follow him. Al-Razi prefers this, as following him before his mission is impossible; so this mercy is won, among the Children of Israel, only by those in Musa's time who were mindful of Allah, paid zakat and believed in His signs. And by those so described in the Prophet's ﷺ days who follow his laws; on both senses, those meant here are specifically of the Children of Israel.

Ibn Kathir says the well-known view of many exegetes, as Muhammad ibn Ishaq and others mention and al-Awfi narrates from Ibn Abbas, is that these verses concern the rabbis of the People of the Book who believed, such as Abdullah ibn Salam, Asad ibn Ubayd, Thalaba ibn Saʿya and Usayd ibn Saʿya.

The paper cites an authentic hadith that three are given their reward twice, among them a man of the People of the Book who believed in his prophet, then lived to see the Prophet ﷺ and believed in, followed and affirmed him. The paper says it urges the People of the Book to follow the truth the Messenger ﷺ brought, since this faith does not conflict with what Isa brought, with doubled reward for believing Jews and Christians.

The paper concludes that these verses show believing Christians' standing and reward with Allah, and that Christians are not all evil. Some believed in their Book and the Quran, having lived to see Islam's law, or were upright and died before it; among them are humble priests and monks, not arrogant toward the truth, who weep at the truth they recognize.

Those who fight Islam

The paper says the enemies of the Muslims, Christians and others, never stop plotting against Allah's religion and attack it whenever they can, to turn Muslims from it, as in Al-Baqarah 2:120. Among those who fight Islam it counts Christians who did not believe in the Prophet's ﷺ message and opposed it openly or secretly.

Not wanting good for the Muslims

A group of the People of the Book, Christians among them, do not love the Muslims, Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:105. The disbelievers among the People of the Book are the Jews of Medina and the Christians of Najran, and the polytheists are the Arab polytheists; they dislike that revelation and Islam's laws be sent down to the Prophet ﷺ, wanting everyone to be disbelievers like them, as in An-Nisa 4:89.

Allah answers that it is not as they wish: He chooses for prophethood whom He wills, one fit for it, honors with Islam whom He wills, and is Possessor of great favor to those He chooses. The verse shows, the paper says, the duty to beware of the People of the Book, Christians included, since many hate that good comes down to the Muslims from their Lord, and not to listen to their advice, as Allah knows what they hide though their tongues say otherwise. The greatest good is that Allah sent the Prophet ﷺ, from Ismail's descendants, as bearer of good news, warner and guide to the worlds.

Allah answered their dislike by choosing His Prophet ﷺ by His wisdom and will Al-Baqarah 2:105.

Wishing the Muslims would turn back from their faith

A group of the People of the Book wishes and strives to turn Muslims from their religion despite knowing the truth. As Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:109. Al-Razi says they want believers to leave faith after seeing it is right, and one who knows another is in the right cannot want to turn him back except by a doubt he casts. The doubts are worldly, reminding the Muslims of their expulsion, hardship and constant fear, so they abandon the faith that led to it; or religious, doubting the miracles or distorting the Torah.

The paper quotes an explanation that the truth had become clear to them and they were ignorant of none of it, but envy drove them to denial; Allah blamed them severely and prescribed for the Prophet ﷺ and believers their belief in what was sent down to them and before, with His honor, great reward and help.

The reason for their envy is known, the paper says: they read in their books of his coming and description, and threatened the Arabs with killing at his coming, because they claimed they would not follow him, expecting him from Banu Israel. When Allah sent him from Ismail's descendants, they envied the Arabs and denied what they knew; Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:89.

Allah warns the believers against the ways of the disbelieving People of the Book, telling them of their enmity inwardly and outwardly and their envy, though they know the believers' merit. He commands them to pardon, forgive and bear until His command comes, with victory and conquest.

Al-Wahidi reports Ibn Abbas saying it concerned some Jews who told the Muslims after Uhud that had they been on the truth they would not have been defeated, so they should return to the Jews' religion.

It is also said that some People of the Book told Hudhayfa ibn al-Yaman and Ammar ibn Yasir after Uhud that had they been on the truth they would not have fled, so they should return to their better-guided religion. Ammar asked how severe breaking a covenant was among them; very, they said; he said he had pledged never to disbelieve in Muhammad ﷺ, and the Jews said he had left his religion. Hudhayfa said he was content with Allah as Lord, Muhammad ﷺ as Messenger, Islam as religion, the Quran as guide, the Kaaba as qibla and the believers as brothers; the Prophet ﷺ said they had succeeded, and Allah revealed this verse.

The paper concludes this shows their enmity and rancor and wish for Muslims to leave Islam, since they disliked following the Prophet ﷺ for being of Ismail's descendants and wished he were from Banu Israel. Telling the Companions to return to their religion, it says, proves their fanaticism and ignorance of religion.

Concealing the Messenger's description

Many scholars of the People of the Book know that what Muhammad ﷺ brought is the truth yet conceal it, as many verses report. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:146. They know the Messenger ﷺ plainly, by his specific description, as they know their sons. Umar asked Abdullah ibn Salam about him; he answered that he knows him better than his own son, having no doubt Muhammad is a prophet, while perhaps his son's mother was unfaithful; Umar kissed his head. It is also said the verse means they know the Sacred House is the qibla, the view of Qatada, Ibn Abbas and others.

Allah also says Ali 'Imran 3:71. It means disbelieving in Allah's signs, what the Torah and Gospel state of Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood, while witnessing they are Allah's; or in the Quran, while witnessing his description in the two books; or knowing by miracles it is true. Al-Tabari says the truth they concealed is Muhammad's ﷺ description, mission and prophethood in their books.

Allah then detailed their mixing truth with falsehood Ali 'Imran 3:72. It means telling one another to affirm his prophethood outwardly, without belief in the hearts, and deny it all at the end. They also urge one another to believe only those who follow their religion, and Allah commands the Prophet ﷺ to answer them Ali 'Imran 3:73.

Allah also says Al-Baqarah 2:89. The Book is the Quran, confirming the Torah, which confirms Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood since his description is established there. Before his mission the Jews sought help through him against the Arab polytheists, praying for help by the prophet of the end of time whose description they find in the Torah, and were helped; they told the polytheists they would kill them with him as 'Ad and Iram were killed. When the one they knew came, not from Banu Israel, they denied him out of transgression and envy.

Ibn Abbas says the People of the Book sought victory through his coming against the Arab polytheists; when he was sent and they saw he was not of them, they disbelieved and envied him.

Hadiths show the People of the Book knew of a prophet to come at the end of time, with his attributes and followers. One is from Abdullah ibn Amr ibn al-As, that the Torah has the address of Al-Ahzab 33:45. It also calls him Allah's servant and messenger, named al-Mutawakkil, a protection for the unlettered, not harsh, coarse or clamorous in markets, pardoning rather than repaying evil with evil. Allah will not take him until through him the crooked community is straightened by people saying there is no god but Allah, opening blind eyes, deaf ears and sealed hearts. Aisha reports that the Gospel describes him as not harsh, coarse or clamorous in markets, not repaying evil with its like but pardoning. Books of biography and history hold many evidences of this.

The paper concludes that his description is in the earlier books, and that a group of the Children of Israel among the Christians denied what the Messenger they awaited and gave good news of brought. Pride seized them though sure of his coming, his description being in the Gospel, so they deserved Allah's curse.

Striving to misguide the Muslims

After showing some trying to turn Muslims from their religion, Allah reports their attempt to misguide them in it. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:69. Al-Tabari explains that a group of the People of the Book, the Torah's people among the Jews and the Gospel's among the Christians, wish to turn the believers from Islam back to disbelief, destroying them.

The paper gives several senses of their misguiding only themselves; one is destroying themselves by deserving punishment for seeking to misguide others, as in Al-Baqarah 2:57. Another is that they remove themselves from knowing guidance, since one who strays from it is called astray; another, that after striving to misguide the believers, who ignored them, they became disappointed losers, having believed one thing and seen it was otherwise. Not perceiving means not knowing this harms them and not the believers.

On their doubts, al-Razi says they strive to misguide those who believed in the Messenger by casting doubts. Examples: Muhammad acknowledges Musa and Isa yet claims prophethood himself; Musa said in the Torah his law would never pass away; abrogation leads to al-bada'; the aim, he says, is to warn believers not to be deceived by the Jews' talk, and he compares Al-Baqarah 2:109. It also cites An-Nisa 4:89.

The paper concludes that a group of the People of the Book wish to misguide the Muslims by wicked methods and misleading doubts, raising suspicions and illusions about Islam, doubting the Prophet's ﷺ call and disturbing the Muslims' creed, yet Allah affirmed they misguide only themselves and do not perceive it.

Preventing those who want Islam

The People of the Book turn the believers from His path Ali 'Imran 3:99. The paper explains it as turning believers from Allah's religion by casting doubts and denying Muhammad's ﷺ description in their books. Seeking crookedness means deviating from the truth by casting doubts in the hearts of the weak, while witnessing that his description is in the Torah and that the religion Allah accepts is Islam; it is also said they witness the miracles at his hands. The closing words are a warning and threat, since they schemed to turn people from Allah's path.

Qatada says they witness in what they read that Muhammad is Allah's Messenger and Islam the religion He accepts, written in their Torah and Gospel.

Al-Zamakhshari says they tempted the believers, schemed to turn them away, and blocked anyone wanting to enter Islam; it is also said the Jews reminded al-Aws and al-Khazraj of their pre-Islamic enmities and wars, so they would return to them. Asked how they could seek crookedness in what is impossible, he gives two senses: first, they confuse people into thinking Islam has crookedness, by saying Musa's law is not abrogated and changing the Messenger's description; second, they wrong themselves by hiding the truth and seeking what cannot come to them, while witnessing that it is Allah's path, which only a misguided misguider turns from, or witnessing among their own people, being trusted in great matters, namely the rabbis.

The paper concludes that some disbelieving People of the Book try to turn Muslims to apostasy by casting doubts, denying the Prophet ﷺ and his description in their books, and stirring up strife, enmities, division and wars among Muslims to harm Islam. They seek crookedness though witnessing that what Muhammad ﷺ brought is true, so Allah rebuked the obstinate among them and warned them.

Casting doubt on the Muslims' qibla

By Allah's wisdom the Muslims' qibla was changed from Bayt al-Maqdis to the Sacred Mosque, and they obeyed and all turned to it; this displeased the foolish among people, among them the Jews and Christians of the People of the Book, as in Al-Baqarah 2:142. Ibn Kathir says that when this happened, some hypocrites, doubters and disbelieving Jews fell into doubt and confusion and asked what had turned the Muslims from their qibla; Allah answered that judgment, disposal and all command are His, wherever they turn is Allah's face, and Ibn Kathir cites Al-Baqarah 2:177.

He adds that all that matters is obeying Allah's commands, so wherever we are directed we turn, even several times a day, for we are His servants. Allah cares greatly for Muhammad ﷺ and his community, guiding them to the qibla of Ibrahim and making their facing the Kaaba, built on His name alone with no partner, the noblest of His houses on earth, built by Ibrahim; hence Al-Baqarah 2:142.

Although the Christian People of the Book know the change to the Kaaba is true and Ibrahim's qibla, the paper says, they are stubborn, follow their desires and ask the Messenger ﷺ for a sign. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:144-145. The Kaaba qibla is the truth and Ibrahim's, the paper explains; Allah is not unaware of their denial, and the Jews and Christians told the Prophet ﷺ to bring a sign confirming it. Then Al-Baqarah 2:145 came; a quoted explanation: even with every sign they would not pray toward his qibla, nor he toward theirs, nor each other's; it is said this means he cannot hope they follow him when they do not follow one another.

Every sign means proof that the Kaaba is the qibla; they opposed him out of arrogance and stubbornness, not over a doubt proof would remove. His not following their qibla cut off their hopes, for they said that had he stayed on it they hoped he would be the companion they await, to beguile him (printed "support") and hoping for his return.

Their qiblas, though many, are alike in falsehood: the Jews face the Rock and the Christians the sunrise; their agreement cannot be hoped for, nor with him, each party being firm in its stance. Were he to follow their desires after the knowledge came to him, said as a supposition, he would be among the wrongdoers, a stressed threat.

The paper concludes this shows some Christians' and others' enmity toward Islam, and their attempt to shake the Muslims' belief by doubting their qibla and demanding a sign. The paper adds that, even if he brought every sign they would not follow his qibla, nor he theirs, nor they one another's.

Harming and mocking the believers

Allah reported some People of the Book's harm and mockery toward the Muslims. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:57-59. The paper explains that Allah warned believers not to take Jews and Christians as allies (awliya), describing them as taking Islam as mockery and sport, though given the Torah and Gospel before us; this means believing then disbelieving and showing the opposite of what they conceal, as in Al-Baqarah 2:14. Fear Allah in taking them as allies, if you are believers, meaning those who affirm Allah.

After the first verse says they mock the Muslims' religion, the next mentions some of what they mock. It is said that a Christian man in Medina, whenever he heard the muezzin say Muhammad is Allah's Messenger, said: may the liar be burned; one night his servant brought fire, a spark flew, and the house burned with him and his family.

It is also said that when the Prophet's ﷺ caller called to prayer and the Muslims stood, the Jews mockingly said they stood, may they not stand, and prayed, may they not pray, and the verse came down. It is said the hypocrites laughed when rising to prayer, to put people off it. It is also said they told him he had invented something unheard of, contradicting all the prophets, and asked where he got a cry like a donkey's; Allah revealed this verse.

Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:59. A quoted explanation has the Prophet ﷺ ask the Jews and Christians whether they find fault in the Muslims, while mocking their religion and call to prayer, only for believing in Allah, affirming His oneness and the Book sent to the Muslims and those sent before, and because most of them are defiant of Allah's command and lie about Him.

The paper concludes this shows some Christians' enmity toward Islam and their continuing attempts, past and present, to harm it and its followers by harm, mockery and lying. They do so though they know from their books that Islam is the truth, persisting in stubbornness and pride.

The Quran's warning to Muslims about Christians

Many verses warn the Muslims against the errors of earlier nations, Christians and others. The paper warns against imitating them in their conditions and words. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:104. The verse shows strict prohibition and threat against resembling the disbelievers in words, deeds, clothing, festivals, worship and other matters not legislated for us.

Allah warns the believers against obeying a group of those given the Book. They envy the believers for Allah's favor in sending His Messenger and wish them disbelievers, as in Ali 'Imran 3:100. Allah warned the believers against the disbelievers' seduction and misguidance, addressing them as believers to stress the difference between them. He did not use the word 'say', so the address came directly from Him as a comfort, and framed the prohibition of obeying them as a condition, since such obedience had not occurred.

Qatada says Allah has warned them and told of their misguidance, so do not trust them with your religion or take their advice, for they are envious, misguided enemies who disbelieved in their book, killed their messengers, were bewildered in their religion and helpless regarding themselves; by Allah, they are people of suspicion and enmity.

The paper warns against the disagreement and division the Christians fell into in their religion. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:105. It forbids this community to be like past nations in division, disagreement and abandoning enjoining right and forbidding wrong, though proof had been established against them. It also calls to unity and holding to Allah's rope, citing Ali 'Imran 3:103. Ibn Abbas says Allah commanded the believers to keep together and forbade disagreement, telling them those before them perished through disputing and quarreling in religion.

The paper warns against concealing the truth while knowing it. This is a trait of the Christians, as Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:187. Those given the Book are the Jews and Christians, specifically their scholars; it is also said the Jewish scholars and rabbis specifically. The covenant obliges them to make the Book plain and not hide it, since Allah obliged the scholars of the Torah and Gospel to explain their evidences of Muhammad's ﷺ prophethood. They cast the Book, or it is said the covenant, behind their backs, meaning neglected it and abandoned acting on it, and took a small price; Allah blamed them. Allah also cursed them Al-Baqarah 2:159.

Although these verses apparently concern the People of the Book's scholars, it is not far that this community's scholars are included, being people of a book, the Quran, the noblest of books. The Quran warned the Muslims against allying with the Christian People of the Book. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:51.

It means do not rely on them for help, show them affection, or take them as allies whom you help, ask for help, befriend and live with as believers do. The reason given is that they are allies of one another through unity of creed and disbelief, so one whose religion differs has no place among them. One who allies with them is of them and has their ruling, a severe emphasis on the duty to avoid one who differs in religion.

Umar ordered Abu Musa al-Ashari to submit an account of what he took and gave on a single hide, and Abu Musa's Christian scribe did so; Umar marveled and called him a good keeper of records. Umar asked about reading a letter from Syria in the mosque; Abu Musa said the scribe could not enter it; Umar asked if he was ritually impure, and Abu Musa said no, he was a Christian. Abu Musa reports that Umar rebuked him, struck his thigh, said to take the scribe out, and recited Al-Ma'idah 5:51.

Although Jews and Christians are allies of one another, the paper says, Allah showed elsewhere, as covered earlier regarding the Christians who altered their religion, that their alliance is not purely for Him but rests on enmity to Islam. So He stated that the enmity among them lasts until the Day of Resurrection Al-Ma'idah 5:14.

The paper warns against allying with them and resembling them in mocking the religion. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:57. One of them would show the believers faith while staying in disbelief, then return to declared disbelief after a short time, having hidden it while professing faith, playing with and mocking the religion, as Allah reported of some of them Al-Baqarah 2:14-15.

The paper warns against resembling them in committing wrongdoing. Allah blamed them Al-Ma'idah 5:79. It means not forbidding one another to repeat a wrong they did, or a like of it, or one they intended; or not abstaining from it. The closing words express amazement at the badness of their deed, stressed with an oath.

The paper then calls to enjoining right and forbidding wrong, citing Ali 'Imran 3:104. This is achieved only by returning to Allah, holding to His law and obeying His Messenger ﷺ. Aisha reports that the Quraysh, troubled by the Makhzumi woman who stole, asked who would speak to the Messenger ﷺ, and said only Usama ibn Zayd, whom he loved; Usama spoke to him. The Prophet ﷺ asked whether he interceded about one of Allah's prescribed punishments, then told the people those before them were destroyed because they left a noble who stole but punished a weak one, and that were Fatima daughter of Muhammad to steal he would cut her hand.

Many other verses warn the Muslims against Christians and others and describe their traits, character, enmity and rancor toward Islam.

Islam's tolerance toward Christians

From the paper: «سماحة الإسلام مع النصارى»

After the Christians' beliefs, false claims and attempts to harm Islam, the paper turns to examples of Islam's tolerance toward them. Islam, it says, is the religion of tolerance, mercy, pardon, kindness, justice and fairness toward Muslims and non-Muslims alike. The Quran shows how Islam dealt fairly with the Christians, stated the correct principles of their religion and Isa's standing without exaggeration. Islam does not conflict with what Isa brought, so it gave the Christian People of the Book their rights.

Pardoning them and bearing their harm

Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:109. The paper quotes an explanation: overlook their wrongdoing and mistaken opinion offered about your religion, meant to turn you from it and make you leave faith, and what they said before to your Prophet ﷺ An-Nisa 4:46. Forgive their ignorance in this until Allah brings His command, producing what He wills for you and deciding what He wills for them; He then decided and brought His command, telling His Prophet ﷺ and the believers At-Tawbah 9:29.

So Allah abrogated pardoning and forgiving them by making fighting them an obligation on the believers, until their word and the believers' is one, or they pay the jizya in humility. The paper adds that fighting them is not vengeance: it calls them to belief in Allah and His Messenger ﷺ, and if they believe they are saved from punishment and win great reward, so fighting becomes mercy for them, not punishment.

Not compelling them to enter Islam

Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:256. Yet Allah invited the People of the Book to faith and Islam, as in Ali 'Imran 3:110. A quoted explanation says that if the Jews and Christians, people of the Torah and Gospel, believed in Muhammad ﷺ and what came to them from Allah, it would be better for them with Allah in this world and the next. Faith, the paper adds, is without doubt better for them than disbelief.

Isa as a prophet

All Muslims believe Isa is a messenger and prophet whom Allah sent to Banu Israel after Musa. His case is that of the prophets and messengers before him, with no distinction between them, all being Allah's prophets and noble messengers, together with belief in the Gospel sent down with him, as in Al-Baqarah 2:285. A quoted explanation says they declare belief in all the messengers, disbelieving in none and making no distinction between them, as the Jews and Christians did. The paper cites a hadith from Abu Hurayra in which the Prophet ﷺ says he is the closest of people to Ibn Maryam, that the prophets are brothers from one father, and that no prophet came between him and Isa.

Inviting them to worship Allah alone

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:64. A quoted explanation: a word common between us and you, on which the messengers and books do not differ, that we worship only Allah, single Him out in worship with sincerity, associate nothing with Him, and see nothing else fit to be worshipped.

Honoring them by calling them People of the Book

Among this is Ali 'Imran 3:98-99.

Eating their food and marrying their women

Islam permits eating the food of the People of the Book and marrying their women. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:5.

Warning them against disbelief

The Quran warned the Christians against falling into disbelief, to show them they are not on the right path. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:72-76.

Praise for believing Christians

The Quran praised a group of believing Christians as the nearest people in affection to the Muslims. Allah says Al-Ma'idah 5:82-85. The paper says those meant are the Christians who became Muslim, and the verse's context shows it, namely Al-Ma'idah 5:85.

Raising the standing of Isa and his mother

Part of Islam's tolerance toward Christians is that it raised the standing of Isa and his mother. The Quran named a surah after Maryam and told Isa's story completely and without distortion, from his birth to Allah's raising him to Himself.

Good dialogue with them

Islam calls for good dialogue and arguing in the best way. Allah says Al-Ankabut 29:46. It means believers should not argue with the Jews and Christians, the People of the Book, except in the best way, with good speech, which is calling to Allah through His signs and pointing out His proofs.

Doubled reward for those who believe

Allah says Al-Qasas 28:52-54. A quoted explanation says they are given their reward twice, once for believing in their book and once for the Quran, for their steadfastness in both beliefs; or for believing in the Quran before and after its revelation; or for bearing the harm of the polytheists and of those of their religion who shunned them. They repel evil with good, meaning disobedience with obedience.

The Byzantines' victory over the Persians

The Quran bore witness to the Byzantines' victory over the Persians, which the paper calls a victory for Allah, since the Christians are People of a Book, unlike the idolatrous Magians. Allah says Ar-Rum 30:2-5. Abu Hayyan al-Andalusi says the Messenger ﷺ was pleased when the Byzantines defeated Persia, the People of the Book prevailing over fire worshippers, and the greater enemy, a threat to Islam's people, being destroyed by the lesser.

Protecting their blood

Islam protects their blood by giving them the choice between Islam and the jizya. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:29. This is unlike the disbelievers and polytheists, whose blood was made lawful. Allah says Muhammad 47:4. The paper explains that they pay the tax for their persons, which they give the Muslims to protect their necks, if they do not become Muslim; if they do, no jizya is due and their state is that of the Muslims.

The mercy in the hearts of their believers

The Quran describes the hearts of the believers among them as having compassion and mercy. Allah says Al-Hadid 57:27. These are the disciples who followed Isa's way and law, who have affection for Islam and its people, because of the gentleness and compassion in the hearts of those on the Messiah's religion, compassion being the strongest mercy, so they loved one another. It is also said this indicates they were commanded in the Gospel to make peace and avoid harming people, so Allah softened their hearts, unlike the Jews, whose hearts hardened and who distorted words from their places.

Justice toward Christians

Allah says Al-Mumtahanah 60:8. It means Allah does not forbid kindness and justice toward disbelievers who do not fight you over religion, such as their women and weak. Al-Zamakhshari says Allah does not forbid kindness to these, only allying with the others. He adds that this too is mercy, given their intense and earnest enmity, preceding His mercy of easing their people's acceptance of Islam, since He permitted ties with those of them who did not openly fight the believers or drive them from their homes.

The Quran has many verses showing Islam's tolerance toward Christians and others, the paper says, and this tolerance is the core of Islam's teachings, which protect human dignity and rights even for non-Muslims. The Prophet ﷺ confirmed it when he wrote to the people of Najran in the peace agreement. Najran and its dependents have Allah's protection and Muhammad's covenant over their persons, religion, land, wealth, absent and present, churches and prayers; no bishop, monk or church attendant is to be moved from his post, and all they hold stays theirs. There is no usury or pre-Islamic blood-debt, disputes between them are settled fairly, and none answers for another's wrong; one who takes usury from now on loses his protection. The protection stands until Allah brings His command, if they are sincere and set right what is theirs, not burdened by injustice.

Takeaways

  1. Not all Christians are alike

    The paper concludes that the verses show the standing and reward with Allah of believing Christians, and that Christians are not all evil. It adds that the Quran praised the monotheist believers among the People of the Book, so they are not all astray.

  2. Pride and envy deny a known truth

    The paper says the People of the Book's envy led them to deny what they knew. It says pride seized a group of Christians who were sure of the new Messenger's coming, with his description in the Gospel, so they deserved Allah's curse.

  3. Do not imitate or ally with them

    The paper says the Quran gives strict prohibition and warning against resembling the disbelievers in their words, deeds, clothing, festivals and worship. It says the Quran also warns against taking the Christians as allies.

  4. Do not fall into division

    The paper says the Quran forbids this community to be like past nations in their division and disagreement. Ibn Abbas says those before them perished through disputing and quarreling in religion.

  5. Tolerance and justice

    The paper holds that Islam is the religion of tolerance, mercy, pardon, kindness, justice and fairness toward Muslims and non-Muslims alike. It says Allah does not forbid kindness and justice toward disbelievers who do not fight the Muslims over religion.

Reflect

  • When have envy or pride made it hard for you to accept something you knew was true?
  • How do you balance caution about outside influences with kindness and justice toward people of other faiths?
  • What can you do in your own community to avoid the division the paper warns about?
  • How do you respond when someone mocks or doubts what you hold sacred?

Every verse in the paper

All 109 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.

The concept of Christians «مفهوم النصارى»

Technical meaning «ثانيًا: المعنى الاصطلاحي»

61:14, 2:113

Christians in Quranic usage «النصارى في الاستعمال القرآني»

3:67, 9:30, 61:14

Related terms «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»

People of the Book: technical meaning «أهل الكتاب اصطلاحًا»

6:156

The link between the disciples and the Christians «الصلة بين الحواريون والنصارى»

61:14

Israel: technical meaning «إسرائيل اصطلاحًا»

3:93, 2:211

Pairing the Christians with the Jews in the Quran «اقتران النصارى باليهود في القرآن»

17:2, 3:49, 9:30, 9:31, 2:146, 2:120

The creed of the Christians «عقيدة النصارى»

The divinity of ʿIsa son of Maryam and his mother «أولًا: إلوهية عيسى ابن مريم وأمه عليهما السلام»

5:17, 5:72, 19:30, 19:36, 5:116, 5:119

The sonship of the Messiah «ثانيًا: بنوة المسيح عليه السلام»

9:30, 6:101, 23:91, 19:35, 19:93, 18:4

The Trinity among the Christians «ثالثًا: التثليث عند النصارى»

4:171, 5:73

The false claims and sayings of the Christians «دعاوى النصارى وأقوالهم الباطلة»

The claim that no one else enters Paradise «أولًا: دعوى نفي دخول غيرهم الجنة»

2:111, 2:94, 2:112

The claim that guidance lies in following their creed «ثانيًا: دعوى أن الهدى في اتباع ملتهم»

2:135, 2:136

The claim that they are the sons and beloved ones of Allah «ثالثًا: دعوى أنهم أبناء الله وأحباؤه»

5:18, 2:80

The claim that Ibrahim and his descendants were Jews or Christians «رابعًا: دعوى أن إبراهيم وبنيه كانوا هودًا أو نصارى»

2:140, 2:133, 3:65, 3:67, 2:135, 3:68

The claim that others have no share of truth «خامسًا: دعوى نفي الحق عمن سواهم»

2:113, 5:68, 3:112

The Christians before Islam «النصارى قبل الإسلام»

3:81-82

Believing monotheist Christians «أولًا: النصارى المؤمنون الموحدون»

2:121, 3:113-115, 28:52-54, 17:107-109

Those who changed their religion and their end «ثانيًا: المبدلون لدينهم وعاقبتهم»

61:6, 5:14, 5:82, 61:14

Christians after Islam «النصارى بعد الإسلام»

3:19

Those who believed in the Prophet ﷺ «أولًا: المؤمنون بالنبي صلى الله عليه وسلم»

3:199, 28:54, 5:82-85, 19:34, 20:9, 7:157

Those who fight Islam «ثانيًا: المحاربون للإسلام»

2:120, 2:105, 4:89, 2:109, 2:89, 2:146, 3:71, 3:72, 3:73, 33:45, 3:69, 2:57, 3:99, 2:142, 2:177, 2:144-145, 5:57-59, 2:14

The Quran's warning to Muslims about Christians «ثالثًا: تحذير القرآن المسلمين من النصارى»

2:104, 3:100, 3:105, 3:103, 3:187, 2:159, 5:51, 5:14, 5:57, 2:14-15, 5:79, 3:104

Islam's tolerance toward Christians «سماحة الإسلام مع النصارى»

2:109, 4:46, 9:29, 2:256, 3:110, 2:285, 3:64, 3:98-99, 5:5, 5:72-76, 5:82-85, 29:46, 28:52-54, 30:2-5, 47:4, 57:27, 60:8

About this source

موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم

مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية

Volume
17
Research paper
«النصارى» (Christians)

Read the full paper (Arabic)

Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.

This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.

Browse all Quran topics