Governance & Politics · Quran topic
Fighting
القتال · Qital
Fighting in the Quran: its meaning, stages, fighters, rulings and results, as the paper sets them out
129 verses · 7 parts · 76 min read
Study guide based on
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
«القتال» · Volume 14
At a glance
The paper begins by distinguishing fighting from killing, saying that the permissibility of fighting is wider than that of killing. In the jurists' usage, the word fighting is used with the sense of jihad, fighting the disbelievers in person. Jihad is broader than fighting and has four levels.
The paper traces how fighting was legislated in stages. It was forbidden at first, then permitted to repel aggression, then permitted in self-defense, and then commanded in general and without restriction. The first verse on jihad gave permission to fight to repel aggression, with no obligation or command. The last stage is fighting the idolaters at large, since they fight the Muslims at large. The paper says this is the stage jihad settled on, since Surat al-Tawba is among the last revealed.
It then sets out the kinds of fighters. It begins with the disbelievers and their leaders. The People of the Book are a further kind. Apostates are a third kind. A group refusing one of the pillars of Islam must be fought until it returns to compliance. A believing group that attacks another is dealt with in a section of its own. Rebels (bughat) are the last kind.
On the ruling, the paper says fighting the disbelievers is in general obligatory on Muslims, though they have latitude until they are needed. Most jurists hold it a communal obligation when mobilization is not general. When mobilization is general, most scholars agree it is an individual obligation on every capable person. The paper also covers fay, war spoils, jizya and captives.
Finally it describes the results of fighting in the individual and the community, among them honor, breaking the enemies' power and repelling persecution.
Key verses
- At-Tawbah 9:5: The paper cites it as the command to fight once the sacred months end. Ibn Taymiyya, as quoted, says Allah ordered the release of such people only after repentance from every kind of disbelief and the establishing of prayer and zakat. The paper also reports a view that it abrogates the rule allowing captives to be freed or ransomed.
- Al-Anfal 8:39: Al-Baghawi reports a view that it abrogated the ban on beginning fighting in the sacred land. The paper says it is a command by which Allah obliged believers to fight disbelievers to prevent persecution. Ibn Abbas and others said persecution here means shirk.
- Al-Baqarah 2:193: The paper says the aim of fighting in Allah's way is not shedding the disbelievers' blood or taking their property, but that Allah's religion prevail over what opposes it, such as shirk. Once that is achieved there is no killing or fighting, except punishment of the wrongdoer in measure of his wrong. Al-Tabari explains persecution here as shirk, with worship and obedience for Allah alone.
- At-Tawbah 9:12-15: The paper cites these verses as part of the last stage, fighting without restriction. It says they give three motives for fighting the disbelievers. The first is the breaking of the oaths of their covenant with the Prophet ﷺ. It also draws from them that fighting breaks the enemies' power through worldly punishment, and that it heals the believers' breasts.
- At-Tawbah 9:29: The paper says that by this verse Allah commanded the believers to fight a kind of disbelievers, the People of the Book, who have the qualities that justify fighting them until they become Muslim or pay jizya. It says the verse came as the first command to fight the People of the Book, after the affairs of the idolaters were settled and the Arabian Peninsula was upright, in the ninth year. It cites the verse for the legitimacy of jizya under the covenant of protection (dhimma), for disbelievers who accept it.
- Muhammad 47:4: The paper explains that after striking and overcoming the enemy, the captives are bound, and the Muslims may then free them without compensation or accept a ransom. It adds that the Muslims are given this choice once the enemy is overcome. Al-Baghawi says scholars differed on its ruling, some holding it abrogated. Others held it firm.
- Al-Hujurat 49:9: The paper says its teaching is directed to a third party, who must not stand as a spectator but hurry to end the fighting and reconcile the Muslim fighters, who are brothers. If one party aggresses and refuses to accept the judgment of Allah and His Messenger, the others are to fight it until it returns. Al-Jassas, as quoted, says it shows that holding the views of rebels does not make them liable to fighting unless they fight others.
- Al-Baqarah 2:191: The paper cites it as forbidding fighting at the Sacred Mosque unless they fight there. Al-Baghawi reports differing views on whether it is abrogated or firm. The paper explains that persecution through shirk and obstructing Allah's religion is a greater corruption than killing, which shows the rule that the lesser harm is committed to avert the greater.
- At-Tawbah 9:41: The paper cites it among the verses showing that fighting is obligatory. Said ibn al-Musayyib held on the strength of it that jihad is an absolute individual obligation on every Muslim. The paper says many verses, among them this one, show that when mobilization is general fighting is an individual obligation.
- Al-Hashr 59:7: The paper explains that the property is that of the disbelievers of the villages, which Ibn Abbas names as Qurayza, al-Nadir, Fadak, Khaybar and the villages of Urayna. Scholars differed on whether a fifth of fay is taken; Umar recited this verse and said the verses include all Muslims. The explanation given in the paper is that fay should not circulate among the chiefs and the strong, as in pre-Islamic times the chief took a quarter of the spoils.
- Al-Hajj 22:40: The paper says the passage containing it was the first revelation permitting fighting, to repel aggression, with no obligation or command. It came when the idolaters' stubbornness and aggression increased. The paper later cites it for punishment by the people of truth deterring falsehood, and for victory being in Allah's hand.
- At-Tawbah 9:36: The paper reports that scholars differed on whether the ban on fighting in the sacred months was abrogated by it. It cites the verse as part of the last stage, fighting the idolaters at large. It is also among the verses cited to show that fighting is obligatory.
Words to know
- القتال al-qital
The root of the word for fighting indicates humbling and causing death. The paper says the permissibility of fighting is wider than that of killing. In the jurists' usage it is used with the sense of jihad, fighting the disbelievers in person.
Appears 170 times in the Quran.
Most common forms: قَتَلَ (83), قاتَلَ (54), قِتال (13), قَتْل (10), اقْتَتَلَ (4)
Root: ق ت ل
- الجهاد al-jihad
Exerting one's utmost effort in war, speech or whatever one is able to do. It is exerting one's utmost in repelling the enemy, and some add that in legal usage it is mostly used for calling to the true religion. It is broader than fighting and has four levels: against the self, Satan, the hypocrites and the disbelievers.
Root: ج ه د
- الحرب al-harb
War, the opposite of peace. The paper says fighting may be attack or defense, unlike war, which it calls an administrative tactic requiring intense repulsion.
Root: ح ر ب
- البأس al-baʾs
Severity, used for punishment and for intensity in war. In usage it is severity against the enemy and prevailing in war. It is a product of war, which is an integral part of the concept of fighting.
Root: ب ا س
The Concept of Fighting
From the paper: «مفهوم القتال»
The linguistic meaning
The root (q-t-l) indicates humbling and causing death, two close meanings. Al-Raghib says killing is removing the soul from the body, like death. Considering the doer's act, it is called killing; considering the loss of life, death. Qitla (kasra) is the manner of killing; qatla (fatha) is a single occasion; qatla (the slain, with a long final a) is the plural of qatil.
The technical meaning
The paper notes a difference in meaning and ruling between killing (al-qatl) and fighting (al-qital), which Shaykh Muhammad al-Salih al-ʿUthaymin explained clearly. In his words, killing is more specific than fighting, so not everyone who may be fought may be killed. For example, we fight one of two warring parties until it returns to Allah's command, though it is believing and may not be killed. Killing does not require fighting everyone, since one person may deserve it. So fighting is permitted more widely than killing.
The paper says this distinction shows the precision of Abu Bakr Ibn al-ʿArabi's definition: barring from something by means that lead to killing. In the jurists' usage, "fighting" carries the sense of "jihad", fighting the disbelievers with the body; jihad, used without qualification, means only this to them.
Fighting in Quranic Usage
From the paper: «القتال في الاستعمال القرآني»
The root (q-t-l) occurs 170 times in the Quran, of which 71 relate to the topic of this paper. The forms in which it occurs are:
- The past tense verb, 16 times, for example Al-Fath 48:22.
- The present tense verb, 28 times, for example At-Tawbah 9:13.
- The imperative, 14 times, for example Al-Ma'idah 5:24.
- The verbal noun, 13 times, for example Al-Ahzab 33:25.
Fighting in the Quran comes in the sense of mutual combat and warring between two sides.
Related Terms
From the paper: «الألفاظ ذات الصلة»
Jihad
Jihad in language
Jihad is going to the utmost and spending one's full capacity in war, in speech, or in whatever one can bear; ijtihad and tajahud mean exerting one's capacity and effort.
Jihad in technical usage
Jihad and mujahada mean spending one's full capacity in repelling the enemy. Some add that, in the Sharia, it is mostly used for calling to the true religion.
The relation between jihad and fighting
Jihad is broader than fighting in several respects. Jihad is mostly the cause of truth against falsehood, whereas fighting may be by truth against falsehood or the reverse. Jihad has four ranks: against the self, against Satan, against the hypocrites and against the disbelievers. Fighting is with weapons against the disbelievers.
War in language
War (al-harb)
War is the opposite of peace. A muharib is a brave man. "He is so-and-so's harb" means he fights him. Harrabtuhu means I incited him against someone, so he grew hostile.
War in technical usage
The paper gives this definition: repelling with force for the extent of the defender, against what is demanded of him, so he refuses it and defends it as strongly as he can.
The relation between war and fighting
Fighting may involve attack, or defence, and both are muqatala. War differs: it is an administrative tactic when strong repelling is needed for the extent of the defender against what is demanded of him.
Severity in language
Severity (al-baʾs)
The word is used for punishment and for hardness in war. The verb is said as bu's, like karum.
Severity in technical usage
It is severity against the enemy and prevailing over him in war.
The relation between severity and fighting
Severity results from war, which is an inseparable part of the concept of fighting.
Stages in the Legislation of Fighting
From the paper: «مراحل تشريع القتال»
Fighting was legislated by Allah's wisdom, in stages, suited to the reality the Prophet ﷺ and his Companions faced, the Muslims' capacity and their relations with enemies. The command came in graded educational steps for this nation, charged with conveying the religion to the worlds. Fighting was first forbidden, then permitted to repel aggression, then for self-defence, then commanded generally and absolutely.
Ibn al-Qayyim summarised them in Zad al-Maʿad, in a chapter on his course with disbelievers and hypocrites.
- The first revelation told him to read, not yet to convey; the next sent him as a messenger. He was to warn his closest kin, his people, the surrounding Arabs, all Arabs, then the worlds. For over ten years he called without fighting or jizya, commanded to refrain, be patient, forgive.
- Then he was permitted to emigrate and fight, then commanded to fight whoever fought him and refrain from whoever kept away and did not fight him.
- Then he was commanded to fight the idolaters until all religion is Allah's.
- After jihad was commanded, disbelievers were three kinds: people of peace and truce, people of war, and people of protection (dhimma).
- He was to complete the covenant of covenant-holders while they kept it; if he feared treachery, he renounced it to them, did not fight until he informed them, and fought covenant-breakers.
- Surah Bara'a ruled on all of them: fight the People of the Book until they give the jizya or enter Islam, and wage jihad against disbelievers and hypocrites, with harshness. He fought disbelievers with sword and spear, hypocrites with argument and the tongue.
The paper sums these up in four stages.
First stage: refraining from fighting
Revelation began to come to the Messenger of Allah ﷺ when Jibril came upon him suddenly with Allah's words Al-Alaq 96:1. He was not then commanded to convey the message. Then he was commanded to convey it and warn his people, with Al-Muddaththir 74:1-2. He began by calling his household, then his kin and people, kindly. He was also commanded to forgive and turn away from the idolaters, as Allah says Al-Hijr 15:94. Allah also says Al-Hijr 15:85-86.
Then Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to call to the religion by admonition and arguing in the best way, saying Al-Ankabut 29:46. He also said An-Nahl 16:125. In this stage, or these two linked stages in Mecca, there was no command to fight, whether in defence or attack. Al-Jassas says the Muslim community did not differ that fighting was forbidden before the Hijra. This is shown by Al-Ma'idah 5:13. Also by Al-Furqan 25:63. Also by Ali 'Imran 3:20. Also by Fussilat 41:34-35.
But the idolaters found what he called them to hard to bear, so they made themselves his enemies and devised many kinds of harm and trial for the believers, until they plotted to do away with the Prophet ﷺ physically. Throughout, the Quran told him to be patient, forgive and refrain, without permission to fight, as in An-Nisa 4:77.
When ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn ʿAwf and some companions said they had been honoured as idolaters and became humiliated when they believed, the Prophet ﷺ replied that he had been commanded to pardon, so they should not fight. Some Muslims longed for permission to fight, to strike the idolaters at once and repel aggression. On the night of the pledge of al-ʿAqaba, al-ʿAbbas ibn ʿUbada ibn Nadla offered to attack the people of Mina next day with their swords; the Prophet ﷺ said they were not commanded to, and sent them back to their camps.
Ibn Kathir says the believers in Mecca at the start of Islam were commanded to forgive and be patient for a time, and burned to be commanded to fight, to heal themselves of their enemies. The situation did not suit it, for many reasons, one being their small number against the enemy's large number. Another was that they were in their own city, a sacred land, the noblest on earth, where starting a fight was unfitting. So jihad was commanded only in Medina, with a home, strength and supporters.
The command to refrain, pray, pay zakat and be patient came while some Muslims met unbearable torture; some were pushed beyond endurance and tempted from their religion, and some died under it. A believer, the paper says, avoids certainty where none is possible, lest he speak about Allah without knowledge; it is enough to point to a wisdom he sees and leave true knowledge to Allah.
As for the wisdom of this, the paper says we may not be certain of it, for we would be imposing on Allah's commands reasons that may not be the real ones, or have other undisclosed reasons behind them, while He knows the good in them. With this manner, the paper offers what appears to it as the wisdom of jihad not being obligatory in Mecca but obligatory in Medina, as mere possibilities, leaving the rest to Allah. They are reasoned causes that may be right or wrong, meant only to reflect on Allah's rulings as events show. Its possible reasons follow.
- The Meccan period was one of upbringing and preparation, in a particular environment, for particular people, in particular circumstances.
- Peaceful calling was more effective on Quraysh, proud and noble, whom fighting then might push to more stubbornness and new blood feuds.
- It avoided a battle and killing inside every house, since no general authority tortured the believers; their own guardians did. Permission to fight would have meant killing in every house, and people would say this is Islam. Even so, Quraysh's propaganda at the pilgrimage season said Muhammad separates father from son; the paper asks what they would say had he ordered son to kill father.
- Allah knew that many of the stubborn who tempted and tortured the early Muslims would become sincere soldiers and even leaders of Islam; the paper asks whether ʿUmar ibn al-Khattab was not one of them.
- Arab chivalry in a tribal setting rises for the wronged who endures harm without retreating, especially if it falls on their noble ones. Ibn al-Dughunna refused to let Abu Bakr, a generous man, leave Mecca, saw shame for the Arabs in it, and offered him protection.
- The Muslims were few and confined to Mecca; the call had not reached the rest of the Peninsula, or news came scattered, with tribes neutral in an internal fight between Quraysh and some of its sons until they saw the outcome.
- There was no pressing necessity to override all this, as the essential matter, the call's existence, was achieved.
Second stage: permission to fight
Allah permitted His Prophet ﷺ to emigrate to Medina, where he began founding the new Muslim society and a glorious era for Islam began. Even so, fighting was not legislated at first in Medina; there was still a command to refrain and be patient. The Prophet ﷺ made a treaty, known as the Sahifa of Medina, with its Jews and the Arabs still idolaters in it and around it.
The paper suggests the wisdom of not fighting at first in Medina appears, besides what came before, in two things.
- First, there was room for conveying and explaining, with no political authority to stop it. All recognised the new Muslim state and the Prophet's ﷺ leadership in its political affairs. The treaty stipulated that none of them make peace, stir up war or form foreign relations without his permission. Real authority in Medina was in Muslim hands, the field was open for the call, and freedom of belief stood.
- Second, in this stage the Prophet ﷺ wanted to devote himself to Quraysh, whose opposition was a stumbling block for the other tribes, waiting to see how matters between Quraysh and some of its sons would end.
But this stance only increased the idolaters' stubbornness, scheming, aggression and plotting. Then Allah permitted the Muslims to fight in defence, saying Al-Hajj 22:39-41. As more than one scholar said, this was the first verse revealed about jihad. It gave permission to fight to repel aggression from the believers, with no obligation or command.
Al-Baghawi reports from the exegetes that the idolaters of Mecca harmed the Prophet's ﷺ Companions, who were beaten and wounded and complained to him. He told them to be patient, as he was not commanded to fight, until he emigrated and Allah revealed this verse, the first permitting fighting, in Medina. Mujahid said it was revealed about specific people who left Mecca as emigrants for Medina and were prevented, so Allah permitted them to fight the disbelievers who prevented their emigration.
Third stage: fighting in defence
Then Allah made fighting obligatory on the Muslims if the beginning came from the disbelievers: fighting those who fought them, not those who did not. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:190. Al-Tabari says the interpreters differed on this verse. Some said it was the first verse commanding the Muslims to fight the idolaters, those who fought them, and refrain from those who held back, then abrogated by Bara'a. Al-Rabiʿ said it was the first verse on fighting revealed in Medina, and the Prophet ﷺ fought those who fought him and held back from those who held back, until Bara'a.
Others said it is a command to fight the disbelievers that was not abrogated, and the transgression forbidden is killing women and children, still in force. Yahya ibn Yahya al-Ghassani asked ʿUmar ibn ʿAbd al-ʿAziz, who replied that it concerns women, offspring and those who did not set up war against you.
Al-Tabari says the sounder view is ʿUmar ibn ʿAbd al-ʿAziz's, since claiming abrogation of a verse that may not be abrogated, without evidence, is arbitrary, and anyone can do that. Allah did not command fighting those who sought peace or made a truce, as He says Al-Anfal 8:61.
This stage includes fighting at some times and places only. Allah commanded fighting once the sacred months have passed, as He says At-Tawbah 9:5. The scholars differed on the prohibition of fighting in the sacred months. Some said it was grave and then abrogated by At-Tawbah 9:36. This is the view of Qatada, ʿAta al-Khurasani, al-Zuhri and Sufyan al-Thawri, who said the Prophet ﷺ fought Hawazin at Hunayn and Thaqif at al-Taʾif, besieging them in Shawwal and part of Dhu al-Qaʿda. Others said it was not abrogated; Ibn Jurayj reports that ʿAta ibn Abi Rabah swore it is not lawful to fight in the Haram or the sacred months unless they fight there.
Allah also forbade fighting at the Sacred Mosque, saying Al-Baqarah 2:191. Al-Baghawi says that at the start of Islam it was not lawful to begin fighting them in the sacred land, then abrogated by Al-Anfal 8:39. This is Qatada's view. Muqatil ibn Hayyan said the words on killing them wherever found, in the lawful land or the sacred one, were abrogated by the words on not fighting them at the Sacred Mosque until they fight there Al-Baqarah 2:191, and that the sword verse in Bara'a then abrogated that. Mujahid and a group said the verse is not abrogated, and beginning fighting in the Haram is not permitted.
Fourth stage: fighting without restriction
Then Allah commanded the Muslims to fight the idolaters absolutely, all of them, since they fight the Muslims all together. Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:191-193. He also says Al-Baqarah 2:244. And At-Tawbah 9:12-15. And At-Tawbah 9:29. And At-Tawbah 9:36. This was the last stage on which the matter of jihad settled, since Surah al-Tawba, which has the sword verse or jizya verse, was among the last revealed. Al-Tahawi says Allah commanded fighting all who oppose the religion of Islam, until there is no religion but Allah's.
Ibn al-Qayyim reached the same conclusion after tracing the history of the Prophet's ﷺ course with the disbelievers and hypocrites. He says that after Bara'a the disbelievers stood in three kinds: those at war with him, people of covenant and people of protection. Then the people of covenant and peace came to Islam, leaving two kinds, those at war and people of protection. Those at war fear him. So the people of the earth with him were three: a Muslim who believes in him, a peaceful one safe from him (people of protection), and a fearful one at war.
The paper says this view of the stages through which fighting and jihad were legislated shows that the staged rulings are not final rulings that abrogate or conflict with others, for Islam meets each stage with what suits it. Surah al-Tawba is Medinan, among the last revealed, if not the last, so it contains final rulings on relations between the Muslim nation and other nations. The paper says this gives it special importance in showing the nature of Islam's movement, its stages and steps, when its final rulings are reviewed against the staged rulings of earlier surahs; the review shows the method's flexibility and its decisiveness.
Without that review, the paper says, these pictures, rulings and rules get confused, as happens whenever verses with staged rulings are taken as final, and verses with final rulings are then interpreted to fit them, especially on Islamic jihad and the relations of the Muslim society with other societies.
Types of Fighters
From the paper: «أصناف المقاتلين»
The paper recalls that fighting is a social phenomenon that humanity has known since its earliest days. Fighting in Islam, which is jihad in the way of Allah, has an aim and a goal, so fighting varies by the types of fighters, as briefly set out in the points that follow.
First: the disbelievers and their leaders
The first thing that comes to mind with "fighting" is fighting the disbelievers and idolaters generally, on which the verses are many. Allah shows that the disbelievers fight the believers, so fighting them is obligatory, to repel aggression and ward off persecution (fitna) from the Muslims, saying Al-Baqarah 2:191-193.
The paper explains that this is a command to fight them wherever they are found, at every time, both defensive and offensive fighting. An exception is made for fighting them at the Sacred Mosque, which is not permitted unless they begin fighting; then they are fought as recompense for their aggression. This continues until they give up disbelief and become Muslims, when Allah accepts their repentance, whatever disbelief and shirk they committed at the Sacred Mosque and in barring the Messenger and believers from it; this is His mercy and generosity.
Since fighting at the Sacred Mosque might be imagined to be a corruption in the sacred land, Allah tells us that the corruption of persecution there, through shirk and barring people from His religion, is worse than the corruption of killing, so the Muslims are not at fault in fighting them. The verse is evidence for the known principle that the lesser of two harms is committed to ward off the greater.
Allah then states the aim of fighting in His way. It is not shedding the disbelievers' blood and taking their wealth; it is that religion be Allah's, so His religion prevails over other religions and everything that opposes it, such as shirk, which is what persecution means Al-Baqarah 2:193. Once achieved, there is no killing or fighting. If they stop fighting you at the Sacred Mosque, the paper explains, there is no aggression against them except against the wrongdoer, who deserves punishment in proportion to his wrong.
Al-Tabari explains that believers are to kill those idolaters who fight them wherever they find their fighters and are able to kill them. The command to drive them out from where they drove you out refers to the emigrants driven from their homes in Mecca, and Allah tells them to drive out those who fight them from their homes as they were driven out, since shirk is worse than killing.
Verses confirm this, as Allah says Al-Anfal 8:39. He also says Muhammad 47:4. The paper explains that when the believers meet the disbelievers of the people of war, they are to strike their necks until they overcome them; those who become captives are to be bound firmly, so they do not kill the believers or escape. After capturing them, the believers either show grace by releasing them without exchange or ransom, or the captives ransom themselves by giving something in return.
Al-Baghawi says the scholars differed on the ruling of this verse. Some said it is abrogated by Al-Anfal 8:57, and by At-Tawbah 9:5. This is the view of Qatada, al-Dahhak, al-Suddi and Ibn Jurayj, and of al-Awzaʿi and the people of opinion (ashab al-raʾy), who said that neither grace nor ransom is permitted for disbelievers who fall captive. Others said it is not abrogated, and the imam may choose, for sane adult male disbelieving captives, between killing them, enslaving them, releasing them without compensation, or ransoming them for money or for Muslim captives. This is the view of Ibn ʿUmar, al-Hasan, ʿAta, most of the Companions and scholars, al-Thawri, al-Shafiʿi, Ahmad and Ishaq.
Ibn ʿAbbas said that when the Muslims became many and their authority strong, Allah revealed about the captives Muhammad 47:4. Al-Baghawi adds that this is the soundest and preferred view, since the Prophet ﷺ and the caliphs after him acted on it. The verses go on commanding the fighting of disbelievers when they turn away from the religion and from keeping safety and peace, and when they break covenants and pledges, as Allah says An-Nisa 4:89. He also says At-Tawbah 9:5.
Other verses state these meanings and single out the leaders of disbelief and their chiefs, the leaders in disbelief who revile the religion of the Merciful and support the religion of Satan. The paper says they are singled out for the gravity of their crime, because others follow them, and to show that whoever reviles the religion and sets out to refute it is among the leaders of disbelief. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:7-13.
Second: the People of the Book
The command to fight likewise directs the believers to fight one type of disbelievers, the People of the Book, who combined attributes that justify fighting them until they become Muslim or pay the jizya. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:29.
This verse was the first command to fight the People of the Book, after the idolaters' affairs were settled and the Peninsula was upright. It came in the ninth year, so the Prophet ﷺ prepared to fight the Romans and summoned the Arab clans around Medina. About thirty thousand gathered; some people of Medina and its surroundings, hypocrites and others, stayed behind, in a year of drought and fierce heat. He set out toward Syria and camped at Tabuk.
"Until they give the jizya" means if they do not become Muslim, "by hand" means in subjugation, and "humbled" means lowly and despised. So the people of protection (dhimma) may not be honoured or raised over the Muslims; rather, the paper says, they are abased and lowly.
They do not believe in Allah or the Last Day, though they show belief in the resurrection; the paper gives several readings.
- They do not believe in the Last Day as Allah's ruling operates in it, the People of the Book abiding forever in the Fire and the believers forever in Paradise, as one says they do not believe in the Prophet, meaning his prophethood.
- It was said in censure, as they are like those who do not affirm it in the gravity of their crime, and like idolaters in their disbelief. Or, since their affirmation is without knowledge it is not belief, and most are so.
The religion of truth is Islam, as Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:19. It is submission to Allah's command and what His messengers brought, and acting on it. Their religion is not it, since they deny our Prophet's ﷺ prophethood. If asked whether they follow the Torah and Gospel, the paper answers in three ways.
- Those books mention our Prophet ﷺ and command belief in him; they abandon this.
- Their law is abrogated, and acting on it after abrogation is misguidance.
- They distorted the meanings to what their souls desire.
In summary, the verse commands fighting those Jews and Christians who do not believe with sound belief confirmed by deeds, nor forbid what Allah forbade, nor follow the correct religion. Their religion is either altered, never legislated by Allah, or abrogated by the law of Muhammad ﷺ.
Allah urged fighting them because they call to what they follow and harm people much. It lasts until they give the jizya, money in return for the Muslims leaving off fighting them and their living secure in person and wealth, taken yearly, each according to his means, rich, poor or middling, as ʿUmar ibn al-Khattab and others did.
"By hand" means they pay it in person in their humiliation, not sending it with a servant. If they ask to be kept on the jizya under Muslim rulings, safe from their evil, and accept conditions that remove their pride and require their humbling, the imam or his deputy must conclude it for them. Otherwise it is not permitted to keep them on the jizya, and they are fought until they become Muslims.
Third: apostates, and fourth: groups refusing a pillar of Islam
A third type: fighting them is jihad in Allah's way, to raise His word, and may even be preferable to fighting original disbelievers. On the state of apostates Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:217. Ibn ʿAtiyya explains apostasy in commenting on it. It is returning from Islam to disbelief. A group said he is asked to repent, and killed if he does not.
ʿUbayd ibn ʿUmayr, Tawus, al-Hasan (the report differs) and al-Shafiʿi in one view said he is killed without being asked to repent; the like is reported from Abu Musa and Muʿadh. On their view he is told at once to return, else killed. ʿAta said that if born to Muslims he is killed without repentance, but if he became Muslim then apostatised he is asked to repent, as, unlike a son of Muslims, he is ignorant of Islam's merit.
Those requiring repentance differed. ʿUmar said three days, as do Malik, Ahmad, Ishaq, the people of opinion and al-Shafiʿi in one view. Al-Zuhri said he is called to Islam, else killed. ʿAli reportedly gave an apostate a month to repent; he refused, so ʿAli killed him. Al-Nakhaʿi and al-Thawri said he is asked to repent while imprisoned indefinitely, and Ibn al-Mundhir said ʿUmar's reports differ.
Abu Muhammad says ʿUmar acted by the gravity or slightness of the crime accompanying the apostasy. A fourth type is the group refusing to perform one of the pillars of Islam. Tracing the rulings on fighting groups that refuse an apparent ruling or leave one of its rites yields a general rule. Such a group must be fought until it returns to acknowledgment, obedience and commitment, and then it has protection (ʿisma), or regains the protection it lost by refusing.
Ibn Taymiyya explained this best, with clear verses. He says the scholars agree that every group refusing a manifest, mass-transmitted law of Islam must be fought until all religion is Allah's. His examples: those who pray but do not pay zakat; pray the five prayers but not Friday or congregational prayer; keep the five pillars but do not hold Muslims' blood and property forbidden; will not give up usury, wine and gambling; follow the Quran but not the Messenger ﷺ or his hadiths; hold Jews and Christians better than most Muslims and the people of the qibla disbelievers; will not fight disbelievers with the Muslims; or oppose the Messenger's ﷺ law and sunna otherwise. All must be fought, as the Muslims fought the zakat-refusers, the Khawarij and their kinds, and the Khurramiyya, Qaramita, Batiniyya and other people of whims and innovations outside the Sharia.
Because Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:193. If part of the religion is Allah's and part is another's, they must be fought until all of it is Allah's. He also says At-Tawbah 9:5. He ordered freeing their way only after repenting from every kind of disbelief, establishing prayer and paying zakat.
Allah says Al-Baqarah 2:278-279. A refusing group that will not stop usury has fought Allah and His Messenger; usury is the last thing forbidden in the Quran, so what was forbidden before it is more emphatic. He also says Al-Ma'idah 5:33.
Everyone with power who refuses obedience to Allah and His Messenger has fought them, and whoever acts in the land other than by Allah's Book and the Messenger's sunna has striven to spread corruption. So the salaf applied the verse to disbelievers and the people of the qibla, and most imams included highway robbers who draw weapons for wealth only, though they hold it forbidden and affirm faith. One who holds Muslims' blood and property and fighting them lawful is more deserving of the description than these; so too the belligerent disbeliever, than the sinner who holds it forbidden.
Allah says An-Nisa 4:65. Allah swore that whoever departs from the Messenger's ﷺ sunna and law does not believe until he accepts his judgment in all disputes of religion and world, with no discomfort in his heart; the Quran's evidence for this is plentiful.
The sunna of the Messenger ﷺ and his rightly guided caliphs shows it. The paper cites the two Sahihs, from Abu Hurayra: when some Arabs apostatised after the Prophet's ﷺ death, ʿUmar asked Abu Bakr how he could fight people when the Prophet ﷺ had said those who testify protect their blood and property except by its right. Abu Bakr answered that zakat is of its right, and he would fight them even over a young goat they gave the Messenger ﷺ. ʿUmar said he then knew it was true. So the Companions agreed to fight peoples who pray and fast if they refuse part of what Allah obligated, namely the zakat of their wealth.
This is explicit in the two Sahihs, from ʿAbdullah ibn ʿUmar, that the Prophet ﷺ said he was commanded to fight people until they testify, establish prayer and give zakat, then they protect their blood and property except by its right. This matches Allah's Book. It is mass-transmitted through many routes; the Sahih compilers took ten, which Muslim mentions, and al-Bukhari more than one. Ahmad said the hadith on the Khawarij is sound through ten routes.
Fifth: the group that transgresses against another group of believers
Islam built the relation between believers on creed, faith and brotherhood, which rules out fighting between them, since each is protected in blood, property and honour by his faith. So fighting between two Muslim groups, or two Muslim states, is not permitted. But Islam deals with the possibilities that may drive some believers to transgress against others; then one must hasten to reconcile and remove the aggression. Allah says Al-Hujurat 49:9-10.
The verses give wide-reaching teaching on fighting between two parties of believers. It is addressed to a third party not in the fight, which must not be a spectator but hasten to reconcile the Muslim fighters, who are brothers. It must establish right without favouritism and support the wronged, even by arms, if the wrongdoer is not deterred and does not stop at right, justice and Allah's limits.
Exegetes report the verses came down over a dispute between two families or clans that led to fighting, but the ruling is wider, since what counts is the generality of the wording, not the specific cause, as our scholars say. So the verses aim to set a wider general rule. It includes fighting between two Islamic governments, or a fighting strife between an Islamic government and its subjects, with another Islamic government not a party. The guidance is that such a government must intervene between the fighters to settle the matter and stop the fighting on the basis of right and justice, and support the wronged, if the transgressor refuses to submit to Allah's ruling, until he submits.
In general meaning, if two groups of believers fight, the believers reconcile them by calling both to accept the judgment of Allah's Book and His Messenger's ﷺ sunna. If one transgresses and refuses, it is fought until it returns to that ruling. If it returns, they reconcile them fairly and judge justly, not exceeding Allah's and His Messenger's judgment. The believers are brothers, so they reconcile two who fight and fear Allah in all affairs, hoping for mercy.
Al-Tabari says the believers reconcile them by calling to the ruling of Allah's Book and accepting what it gives for and against them, which is reconciliation with justice. If one refuses the Book's ruling and exceeds what Allah made just, while the other accepts, the transgressor is fought until it returns to Allah's ruling. If the rebellious group returns after the fighting, they reconcile it with the other fairly, as Allah judged in His Book.
Sixth: the rebels
A group of Muslims may hold an opinion or take up a ruling by its own interpretation, be fanatical for it and defend it with violence until it transgresses against others. Its members bind together until their might is feared, or reach a state that splits the word and divides the ranks, perhaps tempting the enemy against the Muslims, after openly renouncing obedience to the ruling imam. These are the rebels (al-bughat), and fighting them is permitted, in what our scholars called "wars of interests". Allah says Al-Hujurat 49:9.
In Arabic, baghy is seeking something. An example is Allah's report of Musa Al-Kahf 18:64. By usage it became transgression and seeking what is unlawful of injustice, though the language does not rule out baghy by right. An example is Al-A'raf 7:33. The jurists differ on its technical definition, because they differ on the conditions rebels must meet and want a definition both inclusive and exclusive. Keeping to the essential elements, a definition common to all schools is: rising against the imam by overpowering. A rebel (baghi) is one who rises against the just imam, and rebels combine three things.
- Rising against the just imam: opposing him and working to depose him, or refusing duties owed by those who rise.
- Rising by overpowering: the rising is accompanied by force; without force it is not baghy, such as refusing to pledge allegiance after the majority did, even if they call for deposing the imam, disobeying him or withholding what the state stands on.
- Criminal intent (intent of baghy): the intent to rise against the imam by overpowering; if he lacks either the intent to rise against the imam or the intent to overpower, he is not a rebel.
If a group with strength and protection refuses obedience to the just imam by a plausible interpretation (taʾwil) and appoints an imam, the imam sends to them and calls them to obey him. If they show a grievance he removes it; if they name none and persist, he fights them until they return to his obedience.
In fighting them, those who flee are not pursued, a captive is not killed and a wounded man is not finished off, as ʿAli's herald called on the Day of the Camel. What one party destroyed of the other's lives or property in the fighting carries no liability. Al-Zuhri said that in that strife there were killings and much property destroyed, until the war subsided and the ruling applied; he knew of no one retaliated against or made to pay.
Those who lack these three conditions, being few and without protection, or without interpretation, or without an imam, are left alone if they do not fight or confront the Muslims; if they do, they are like highway robbers. It is reported that ʿAli heard a man in the mosque say judgment belongs to Allah alone, and called it a true word meant for falsehood. He told them they had three rights with him: not to be barred from Allah's mosques, nor from the spoils (fayʾ) while their hands were with his, and not to be fought first.
Al-Jassas says the verse requires fighting the rebel group until it returns to Allah's command, in all kinds of fighting. If it returns through fighting with sticks and sandals, one goes no further; if not, it is fought with the sword. No one may limit himself to sticks while it persists in baghy; this is enjoining right and forbidding wrong, as in the Prophet's ﷺ hadith on changing a wrong by hand, tongue, then heart. Removing wrong by hand makes no distinction between weapons and less, so it requires whatever is possible.
Some held that rebels are fought only with sticks and sandals, not the sword, arguing from the reported cause of revelation, where people fought with those. Al-Jassas replies this proves nothing: Allah commanded fighting the transgressor without restricting us to less than weapons, so we meet a group fighting in baghy with weapons or less until it returns. He adds that the wording is general, and that ʿAli ibn Abi Talib fought the rebel group with the sword.
He explains the imam's duty: when fighting appears, Allah commanded reconciliation, which is calling them to what the Book and sunna require and to return from baghy Al-Hujurat 49:9. If one group returns to the right while the other persists and refuses, the transgressor is fought until it returns. So the call comes before fighting, as ʿAli did, first calling and arguing with them, and fighting them when they refused.
He also says the verse shows that holding the rebels' doctrines does not require fighting them until they fight, since fighting is commanded when they transgress by fighting Al-Hujurat 49:9. ʿAli did so with the Khawarij: when they withdrew from his camp he sent Ibn ʿAbbas to call them, then went and argued with them; one group returned and another persisted. When they said from corners of the mosque that judgment belongs to Allah alone, he again gave them the same three rights.
Rulings on fighting
From the paper: «أحكام القتال»
Verses, hadiths and events of the Prophet's life set out the rulings on fighting and who must fight. The verses and hadiths then paint a wretched picture of those who hang back without excuse, or look for false excuses. They then turn to the effects of fighting on persons and property: fay, war spoils (ghanima), the jizya taken from disbelievers, and captives.
The ruling on fighting and its conditions
The ruling on fighting
The general rule is that fighting the disbelievers, or jihad in its specific sense, is obligatory on Muslims, though they have latitude until they are needed. Many verses and hadiths show the obligation.
The Prophet ﷺ also said he was commanded to fight people until they testify to the faith, establish prayer and pay zakat; then their blood and property are protected from him except by the right of Islam, and their reckoning is with Allah. The unqualified command in them makes it binding. So fighting and jihad is a firm obligation, whose denier becomes a disbeliever, established by the Book, the Sunna and consensus.
Scholars have agreed on this obligation since the earliest times, but later differed on whether it is an individual obligation (fard ʿayn) or a communal obligation (fard kifaya). There are two cases: mobilization is general, or it is not, because the disbelievers stay in their lands and have not begun fighting us.
When mobilization is not general
Most jurists hold that jihad is then a communal obligation. If enough of those charged carry it out, the obligation falls from the rest and they are free to leave it, since what is required is that it be achieved by the body of those charged. If none does, the address stays on everyone, and every capable person who does not fight is sinful. A communal obligation falls when some do it; an individual obligation does not fall from anyone because another did it.
The proof is from the Quran, the Sunna and reason. From the Quran, the paper cites An-Nisa 4:95. If jihad were an individual obligation on everyone, those who sit would not be promised the good reward; they would be blameworthy and deserve punishment, since sitting out an obligation is forbidden.
It also cites At-Tawbah 9:122. The paper says this shows jihad is communal, for if all went out their dependents would be lost. One party goes out to fight, while another stays to gain understanding of the religion and guard the families, then teaches the returning party what it learned and what was newly revealed to the Prophet ﷺ.
From the Sunna, the paper cites a report from Abu Saʿid al-Khudri that the Prophet ﷺ sent a force to Banu Lihyan of Hudhayl and said one of every two men should go, with the reward shared between them. Had jihad been an individual obligation here, he would not be imagined to stay behind from it or permit anyone else to.
From reason, the aim of jihad is to repel the disbelievers' harm, break their power, raise the word of the religion, strengthen Islam and the Muslims, and let them be secure and attend to their religious and worldly interests. It is sought in itself, not with regard to who does it. Making it obligatory on every individual at all times would undo this aim: if everyone were busy with jihad, its supplies (mounts, weapons, provisions, trade) would be cut off. So some should wage jihad and others do trade, farming and crafts, which makes it a communal obligation.
Imam Malik says jihad is an obligation with wealth and with persons; if harm or infirmity prevents them in person, the obligation by their wealth is not lifted. Imam al-Shafiʿi, as quoted, says the obligation of jihad could be general and individual like prayer, or could be non-general. The Book and the Sunna show it is that those who suffice carry it out, until two things are met. One is that someone stands against the enemy who threatens the Muslims, and the other is that enough Muslims wage jihad. Then those who stayed behind are free of sin, and the merit belongs to those who took up jihad.
He quotes An-Nisa 4:95. In promising the good reward to the sitters without harm, Allah made clear they are not sinful for staying back. It is promised if they are believers who did not stay back out of doubt or bad intention, even though they left the merit of the campaign.
He points to the command of mobilization in At-Tawbah 9:41. He cites At-Tawbah 9:39. He cites At-Tawbah 9:122. Allah thereby informed them that the obligation of jihad is communal, met by some of those who fight. He knows of no campaign of the Prophet ﷺ in which some people did not stay behind. At Badr known men stayed behind, and likewise in the year of the conquest and his other campaigns. For Tabuk and the force against the Romans, the Prophet ﷺ said one man of every two should go out and the one who stays should look after the fighter's family and property.
The Prophet ﷺ sent armies and detachments and stayed behind himself, despite his eagerness for jihad, and made clear that if they all stayed behind they would all be sinful, citing At-Tawbah 9:39. Al-Shafiʿi takes the meaning, and Allah knows best, to be: He will punish you only if all of you leave off mobilization. So the obligation frees those who stay back from sin when enough carry it out, and they are all sinful if they all stay back.
Saʿid ibn al-Musayyib held that jihad is an absolute individual obligation on every Muslim, citing At-Tawbah 9:41. He also cited Al-Baqarah 2:216, and the saying of the Prophet ﷺ that whoever dies without having fought or resolved to fight dies on a branch of hypocrisy. He took all the majority's proofs for communal obligation to indicate individual obligation. The sitters promised the good reward in the verse of al-Nisa, he said, were guards in the way of Allah, so they too were performing jihad.
Al-Dawudi said it is an individual obligation on those who border the disbelievers. It is reported from Ibn Umar, Sufyan al-Thawri, Ibn Shubruma, ʿAta and ʿAbdullah ibn Hayy that jihad is voluntary, not obligatory, and that those who carry it out are helpers of Allah. Sahnun, among the Maliki scholars, said it became voluntary after the conquest of Mecca.
Some argued that the ordaining of fighting is only a recommendation (nadb), like the ordaining in Al-Baqarah 2:180. That, they said, is a recommendation. They also argued that the verses indicating obligation are particularized, since the Prophet ﷺ excluded groups it is not permitted to kill, such as women and children, so the verses no longer indicate obligation.
When mobilization is general
Most scholars agree that fighting is then an individual obligation on every capable person charged with it, because its aim, repelling the disbelievers, is achieved only through all of them. The able fights in person; a charged person who is unable goes out with the fighters to swell their numbers and frighten the enemy. A son goes out without his parents' permission and a wife without her husband's, because going out is an individual obligation on everyone.
What he loses by abandoning this obligation cannot be made up, while what he loses by going out without his parents' permission can be made up later, so he busies himself with the more important. The harm of not going out is also wider, reaching him, his parents and other Muslims. His parents may not forbid him, and they are not to be obeyed in what they are disobeying in.
Many verses show this, among them At-Tawbah 9:41 and Al-Baqarah 2:216.
The conditions of fighting
The conditions are the general conditions of legal responsibility (taklif), with some particular to fighting. In sum they are Islam, puberty, freedom, being male, physical and financial ability to cover the cost, or the absence of an excuse. Islam. The Quranic address is directed to the Prophet ﷺ and his Muslim followers. Allah says An-Nisa 4:84. He also says Al-Anfal 8:65, and At-Tawbah 9:122.
Puberty and sanity. These are conditions of responsibility. A child who has not reached manhood and a madman whose mind is impaired are not addressed, for they lack the capacity, and a madman cannot wage jihad either. The paper cites the hadith that the pen is lifted from three: the insane person until he recovers, the sleeper until he wakes, and the boy until puberty.
Freedom. The Prophet ﷺ took the pledge of free men on Islam and jihad, and of slaves on Islam without jihad. A slave owns no money for jihad and is occupied with his master's affairs, so fighting is not obligatory on him. The paper notes slavery has in general ended in our time, so this is only a historical discussion.
Being male. Fighting is obligatory only on men, not on women, unless they volunteer out of need, or it is an individual rather than communal obligation. The paper cites a hadith from ʿAisha that she asked the Prophet's ﷺ permission for jihad and he said their jihad is Hajj.
Ability and bodily soundness. Fighting is not obligatory on one who lacks ability through illness, blindness or other things that make it impossible or beyond him, such as the infirm, the very old, the weak in build, the crippled and the lame. The paper cites At-Tawbah 9:91 and Al-Fath 48:17.
Having the cost. Fighting is not obligatory on one who cannot find or afford the expense of jihad. Fighters used to go out spending on themselves and buying their own weapons, but when the state covers expenses, equipment and weapons, losing this condition does not affect the ruling. The verses point to this condition, citing At-Tawbah 9:91-93.
The ruling on excuses and staying behind from fighting
The paper has already pointed to verses that raise the standing of jihad, the peak of Islam's hump and one of its great pillars, and a way to honor and dignity. It now turns to the opposite: many verses warn against staying behind from fighting, or making excuses, when one has no real excuse, in varied Quranic styles.
The paper quotes Ali 'Imran 3:166-168.
It says that nothing but hypocrisy, lying and evasion made these people hang back from fighting in person. When they were told to fight, or at least, if they lacked a sound intention, to defend their families and city, they refused and excused themselves by saying they would have followed had they known there would be fighting. The paper says they were lying. Everyone knew the idolaters were full of rage against the believers, had spent their wealth, gathered men and equipment, and come in a great army against the believers in their own city, and that the Muslims had come out to face them, so it was impossible that no fighting would occur.
The hypocrites thought this excuse would pass with the believers. The paper explains Ali 'Imran 3:167: in that state, when they left off going out with the believers, they were nearer to disbelief than to belief. It adds that this is characteristic of the hypocrites, who show in word and deed the opposite of what they hide in their hearts.
The paper then gives further examples, needing no comment, of the ruling on those who stay behind and make excuses, and of what follows: threat, humiliation in this world and the punishment awaiting them in the Hereafter. It quotes At-Tawbah 9:81-84. It quotes Al-Ahzab 33:9-15. It quotes An-Nisa 4:77.
Rulings on fay, spoils, jizya and captives
When war breaks out and the Muslims prevail, this has effects on the property and persons of the enemy at war with them. Muslims take possession of property and conquered lands, which are the war spoils (ghanima). They may take property by peace settlement, such as jizya, or without war, which is fay. Persons become captives if they fall into Muslim hands through fighting.
Al-Kasani says that when the imam prevails over the lands of the people of war, what is taken is one of three kinds: goods, lands or persons. Ibn Rushd the grandson says harm to the enemy is in property, lives or persons, meaning enslavement and ownership.
Fay
Fay means "return" in language. In juristic usage it is property taken from the people of war by peace without fighting, or after the war lays down its burdens, such as kharaj and jizya. It is called fay because Allah returned it to the Muslims without fighting.
The paper quotes Al-Hashr 59:6-8 on the legitimacy and wisdom of fay.
Exegetes say the Muslims asked the Prophet ﷺ to take a fifth of the property of Banu al-Nadir when they were expelled. The revelation made clear it was fay, not gained by fighting but through the authority Allah gave His Messenger, so it was his alone to dispose of as he pleased. He divided it among the emigrants and gave the Ansar nothing except three in need: Abu Dujana, Sahl ibn Hunayf and al-Harith ibn al-Simma. The paper explains that the Muslims asked for the property to be divided as Khaybar's spoils were, but they had neither marched nor fought for it.
The paper cites a report in al-Bukhari that Umar, when ʿAbbas and Ali came disputing over what Allah gave His Messenger from Banu al-Nadir, had the Companions present confirm the Prophet's ﷺ saying that what he left was charity, not inheritance. Umar said Allah singled the Prophet ﷺ out in fay with something He gave no one else, citing Al-Hashr 59:6. The Prophet ﷺ spent a year's maintenance on his family from it and put the rest in the fund of Allah's property, and Abu Bakr then did the same. Umar did likewise for two years of his rule. He then handed it to Ali and ʿAbbas on condition that they act as the Prophet ﷺ, Abu Bakr and he had, and said he would give no other ruling until the Hour.
On Al-Hashr 59:7, the paper says the property is that of the disbelievers of the villages, which Ibn ʿAbbas names as Qurayza, al-Nadir, Fadak, Khaybar and the villages of ʿUrayna. In the Prophet's ﷺ lifetime fay was his to place as he pleased. Scholars differed on how fay is spent. Al-Baghawi says they differed on it after the Prophet ﷺ; some said it is for the imams after him. Al-Shafiʿi has two views: it is for the fighters, or for the Muslims' interests, beginning with the fighters and then the most important interests in turn.
On whether a fifth is taken, al-Baghawi says some held that a fifth is taken, for those entitled to the spoils' fifth, with four fifths for the fighters and interests. Most held that no fifth is taken, that all of it is spent in one way, and that all Muslims have a right in it. Umar recited Al-Hashr 59:7, Al-Hashr 59:8 and Al-Hashr 59:10 and said these cover all Muslims, and that every Muslim on earth has a right in this fay except those your right hands possess.
A dawla is something passed around among people, here among the chiefs and strong, who would overpower the poor and weak. In pre-Islamic times the chief took a quarter of the spoils, then chose what he wished, but Allah made fay the Prophet's ﷺ to distribute as he was commanded. What the Messenger gives is to be taken and what he forbids, such as stealing from the spoils, is to be abstained from. This is general for all the Prophet ﷺ commanded and forbade.
War spoils (ghanima)
Ghanima means profit and bounty in language. In juristic usage it is property taken from the people of war by force while the war continues. The verses deal with the rulings on spoils and their distribution to those who take them, tying this to faith in Allah and submission to His rulings. They make clear that spoils are not the original aim of fighting, but Allah made them lawful, as in Al-Anfal 8:41.
The paper explains that what is taken from the disbelievers by force and rightfully, little or much, has a fifth for Allah, and the rest is for those who took it, since the verse attributes the spoils to them and takes out only the fifth. It is divided as the Prophet ﷺ divided it: one share for a foot soldier, and for a horseman two shares for his horse and one for himself.
The fifth is divided into five shares.
- The share of Allah and His Messenger goes to the general interests of the Muslims, with none assigned, since they are free of need, so it is for Allah's servants.
- The second is for the Prophet's ﷺ kin from Banu Hashim and Banu al-Muttalib; since it is tied to kinship alone, rich and poor, male and female share equally.
- The third is for orphans, children whose fathers have died, given a fifth of the fifth out of mercy, as they cannot look after their interests.
- The fourth is for the poor and needy, young and old, male and female.
- The fifth is for the wayfarer (ibn al-sabil), the stranger cut off outside his land.
Some exegetes say the fifth does not go beyond these categories, and they need not share it equally; it follows the interest, and this is preferable. The jurists say that when Muslims overcome non-Muslim enemies at war and take their property, the imam must divide the spoils and take out the fifth for the categories Allah mentioned Al-Anfal 8:41. The four fifths are divided among the takers, and the imam has no choice in this, because of the texts and consensus.
So the imam may not return their bare movable property to them as a favor, since the law gives no ruling for it and it does not last. Nor may he show favor over persons alone without the land, since that ends with death and Islam, but only along with the lands, so that they are not busied with farming at the expense of jihad. If he does show favor over lands and persons, he gives them enough of the movables to enable them to work, as Umar left them that and is the model here.
Most scholars agree on this, and al-Tabari says all authorities agreed, without dispute, that four fifths of the spoils belong to the fighters. Ibn Hazm and Ibn Hubayra report agreement that all property of the people of war except land has a fifth taken, and four fifths go to the takers. Ibn Hazm adds that this holds for animals other than humans and for furnishings, weapons and all goods owned by the enemy, after taking out the belongings of those killed and food that Muslims ate or carried off.
The paper says it cannot interpret all the related verses, and gives some for their guidance, such as Al-Anfal 8:69.
The verse begins with a particle that derives it from what precedes, in two ways. The first, which the exegetes follow, derives it from Al-Anfal 8:68. The meaning is that without the earlier permission of spoils, a great punishment would have touched them; since permission preceded, there is no blame in benefiting from the ransom. It is reported that when Al-Anfal 8:67 was revealed, they held back from benefiting from the ransom, and then Al-Anfal 8:69 was revealed. On this view the ransom is called ghanima in the linguistic sense, not the legal one, since legally ghanima is what Muslims seized from the enemy's property by riding hard against them.
The second way derives it as a warning against repeating this in future. The meaning is to be content with what is taken as spoils and not to ransom captives until the enemy is subdued. This suits the use of the word ghanima here, which should not be turned from its legal meaning. The paper adds that since the preceding statement implied a favor, that Allah turned the enemy's might away from them, the permission followed: to use the ransom for their interests and spend freely without hardship, a blessing with no harm in it. Benefit is expressed as eating because eating is the strongest way of benefiting from a thing.
The paper quotes Al-Fath 48:15. It explains that when the Prophet ﷺ and his companions set out for the Khaybar spoils Allah promised them, those left behind will ask to come, wishing to change Allah's promise. They are told they will not, because Allah said before the return to Medina that these spoils belong to those who witnessed Hudaybiyya. They will reply that the believers keep them out of jealousy, so as not to share the spoils. The paper says it was not as they claimed, and they understood little of what is for and against them in religion.
The paper quotes Al-Fath 48:20-21. Its overall meaning is that Allah promised many spoils at their appointed times, hastened those of Khaybar and held back people's hands, so that no harm reached the believers or those left in Medina. This is a sign that Allah protects and helps them and guides them to a straight path. Another spoil He promised is beyond their power but certain to come. Had Quraysh in Mecca fought them, they would have fled and found no ally or helper.
The paper closes the discussion of spoils by saying some contemporary scholars hold that the Quran does not state that war spoils, even movable ones, must be distributed among the conquering fighters. The verse specified only the recipients of the fifth; giving the four fifths to the takers came from the Sunna, as policy and public-interest measures the Prophet ﷺ took in his general authority of rule, so it is no fixed legislative right. Whoever succeeds him in that authority may adopt another arrangement when needed. If conditions call for a system in which the army's rights rest on maintenance and fixed pay rather than dividing spoils, with all spoils going to the state, as in our time, that is permissible in law, as a matter of public interest (istislah) in administration. Yet the distribution system in early Islam was the financially possible arrangement and the best for the policy of jihad toward the Arabs of that time, given their custom.
Jizya
Jizya comes from jazaʾ, meaning recompense for something, and its form indicates the manner of taking the money. In juristic usage it is money taken from disbelievers under a covenant of protection (dhimma), in return for protecting them and the sanctity of their blood, through their submission to the Islamic order and their residence in the abode of Islam. It is so named because it suffices for the dhimmi in place of being killed: once he accepts it, killing falls from him, since Allah made giving it, absent Islam, a cause of preventing killing.
Imposing jizya on conquered peoples was a familiar custom long before Islam. Muslims followed their predecessors in these financial means after Islam gave them a special character and made jizya a mark of general submission to the Islamic order, which outweighed the financial side. They settled with dhimmis on jizya, exempted some groups and took it from them as charity, like Banu Taghlib, and sometimes waived it for reasons.
For the legitimacy of jizya under the covenant, for disbelievers who accept it, the paper cites At-Tawbah 9:29. Scholars agree that jizya is taken from the free, adult, sane, healthy, well-off man, and differ afterwards on some details. Once due, it falls for four reasons: Islam, death, an affliction of the dhimmi that prevents its obligation, such as becoming blind or poor and unable to do anything, and the accumulation of jizya from several years.
The paper notes that jizya on dhimmis and the dhimma system the jurists studied ended in practice with the rise of the contemporary nation state, not based on religion and creed, and with the civil state and system of citizenship, from the late Ottoman period.
Captives
Captivity (asr) means imprisoning and holding, or binding with a fetter, and the captive (asir) is so called because he was bound with a strap. Use spread until anyone taken by force is called a captive even if not bound. Jurists define captives as the male combatants among the disbelievers whom the Muslims overcame in war. The term also covers an enemy fighter who entered the abode of Islam without covenant or safe-conduct and fell into Muslim hands before becoming Muslim. Jurists divide captives into kinds, each with its own rulings.
The paper confines itself to the verses on captives and their treatment, with quick notes from exegetes and scholars. The paper quotes Al-Anfal 8:67-69. These came down as a reproach from Allah to His Messenger and the believers at Badr, when they took the idolaters captive and kept them for ransom, making clear what was more fitting regarding captives and deciding their fate.
The paper gives al-Baghawi's report from Ibn Masʿud that at Badr, when the captives were brought, the Prophet ﷺ asked what they said of them. Abu Bakr said they are your people and family, spare them, perhaps Allah will turn to them in repentance, and take ransom, which would strengthen the Muslims against the disbelievers. Umar said they denied you and expelled you, so strike their necks, for they are leaders of disbelief. Abdullah ibn Rawaha said to put them in a valley with much firewood and set it on fire, and al-ʿAbbas said he had cut off his kinship. The Prophet ﷺ was silent and went in. People said he would take Abu Bakr's view, or Umar's, or Ibn Rawaha's.
The Prophet ﷺ then came out and said that Allah softens the hearts of some men until they are softer than milk and hardens the hearts of others until they are harder than stones. He said Abu Bakr's likeness is Ibrahim, who said Ibrahim 14:36. It is also like ʿIsa, who said Al-Ma'idah 5:118. He said Umar's likeness is Nuh, who said Nuh 71:26, and also Musa, who said Yunus 10:88. The Prophet ﷺ then said they were needy that day, so none of them was to escape except by ransom or by beheading.
Ibn Masʿud said that Suhayl ibn Bayda' was the exception, for he had heard him mention Islam. The Prophet ﷺ was silent, and Ibn Masʿud never feared stones falling from the sky more than that day, until the Prophet ﷺ said except Suhayl ibn Bayda'.
Ibn ʿAbbas reports that Umar said the Prophet ﷺ liked what Abu Bakr said and not what he himself said. The next day he found the Prophet ﷺ and Abu Bakr sitting weeping, and the Prophet ﷺ said he wept over what had been shown to him concerning the Companions' taking of ransom, as their punishment was shown to him nearer than a tree close by, and Allah revealed these verses.
The paper says Allah told them that, because of the good He knew in their hearts, He forgave them and did not punish them for hurrying to take captives for ransom without waiting for the Messenger's permission, and had mercy on them by making the spoils lawful. Hence the permission to eat of what they took, including the ransom, lawful and good. This holds on the conditions set before: no stealing from the spoils, no betrayal, no hoarding, and no greed leading to quarrels. They must fear Allah and not go ahead except as the Messenger permits. Allah forgives and is merciful to those He knows to be pious. After the reproach and the pardon for what fell short of the better course, the Quran touches the captives' hearts, reviving hope and tying them to a better future and a gain greater than what they lost, then forgiveness and mercy.
The paper quotes Al-Anfal 8:70. This verse also came down about the captives of Badr, among them al-ʿAbbas, the Prophet's uncle; when ransom was asked of him he claimed he had been Muslim before, and they did not drop his ransom, so Allah revealed this verse to console him and those like him. Allah fulfilled His promise to al-ʿAbbas and others, and he later received much wealth, so that when much money came to the Prophet ﷺ and he told him to take what his garment could hold, he took almost more than he could carry.
The good promised to them depends on their hearts becoming sound and open to the light of faith, so that Allah knows there is good in them, and the good is faith. Islam keeps the captives only to touch the sources of good, hope and righteousness in their hearts and awaken their nature to guidance, not to humiliate them in vengeance or exploit them, as the conquests of the Romans and others did. From al-Zuhri, Quraysh sent to ransom their captives, and each group ransomed its captive for what they agreed.
Al-ʿAbbas said he had been Muslim, and the Prophet ﷺ answered that Allah knows best about his Islam and will reward him if it is as he says, but his outward state was against the Muslims, so he should ransom himself, his two nephews Nawfal ibn al-Harith and ʿAqil ibn Abi Talib, and his ally ʿUtba ibn ʿAmr. Al-ʿAbbas said he had nothing to pay. The Prophet ﷺ asked about the money he and Umm al-Fadl had buried for their sons in case he were killed. Al-ʿAbbas said he knew the Prophet ﷺ was Allah's Messenger, for no one else knew of it, and asked him to count the twenty ounces already taken from him. The Prophet ﷺ said that was what Allah had given them from him, so he ransomed himself, his nephews and his ally, and Allah revealed the verse. Al-ʿAbbas said Allah gave him in Islam twenty slaves in place of the twenty ounces, each with money to trade with, besides the forgiveness he hoped for.
After these verses, Surah Muhammad, also called the surah of fighting, came down on the procedures of fighting and fixing the fate of captives once fighting ends. The paper quotes Muhammad 47:4. It says the address is to the Muslims, commanding them to be true in fighting, until after heavy slaughter they have overcome the disbelievers and made sure of victory, then to take the rest captive, until the war ends. It also lays down a rule for captives: the Muslims then choose between showing favor and releasing them without ransom, or releasing them for ransom.
Al-Baghawi says scholars differed on the ruling of this verse. Some said it is abrogated by Al-Anfal 8:57 and At-Tawbah 9:5. This was the view of Qatada, al-Dahhak, al-Suddi and Ibn Jurayj, and of al-Awzaʿi and the people of opinion (ahl al-raʾy), who said no favor or ransom is allowed for a captive taken from the disbelievers.
Others held the verse to be firm (muhkam), and that the imam chooses, for sane adult male captives among the disbelievers, between killing them, enslaving them, showing favor and releasing them without compensation, or ransoming them for money or for Muslim captives. This was the view of Ibn Umar, al-Hasan, ʿAta and most of the Companions and scholars, and of al-Thawri, al-Shafiʿi, Ahmad and Ishaq. Ibn ʿAbbas said that when the Muslims became many and their authority strong, Allah revealed Muhammad 47:4 concerning the captives. The passage adds that this view is the sounder and preferred, since the Prophet ﷺ and the caliphs after him acted on it.
The paper says that after deciding the captives' fate, verses call for treating the captive with high Islamic morals, justice and kindness in all forms, especially in material and livelihood matters. Allah pairs kindness to the captive, even if not Muslim, with kindness to the needy and the orphan, each deserving care by creed and faith in Allah.
This comes in a bright picture of sincere hearts resolved to fulfil the duties of the creed, merciful to His weak servants, preferring others over themselves, fearing Allah and seeking His approval. The paper quotes Al-Insan 76:8-10. It says the verses depict kindness shown in feeding food despite loving it because of need. Such hearts prefer the needy, seeking Allah's approval and no reward or thanks from people, with no arrogance toward the needy, and guarding themselves against a grim Day they fear.
As for the captive, scholars differed, and what suits the context is the view of Ibn ʿAbbas, al-Hasan and Qatada: the captive of the idolaters. It is reported that the Prophet ﷺ would send idolater captives to be guarded and given their due, since they must be fed until the imam decides on killing, ransom or enslavement. Killing in one case does not prevent feeding in another, nor must one punished in one way be punished in another, so it is not proper to do to someone liable to retaliation anything short of killing.
The imam must feed him, and if he does not, it falls on the Muslims. Al-Biqaʿi says it is reported that at Badr some Companions preferred their captive over themselves with bread, which was then scarce, until the captive marveled at their generosity and this was among what called him to Islam. The Prophet ﷺ had told them, when he gave the captives to them, to treat them well. They did this while saying, in word or in state if needed, that they fed them only for Allah's sake, to remove any thought of favor or expected reward. Al-Biqaʿi says this stresses that sincerity is a rare thing.
Results and consequences of fighting
From the paper: «نتائج القتال وعواقبه»
Fighting and jihad have results in the individual and in the community. They train the self to give and sacrifice, give the Muslim true honor (ʿizza), repel the danger of the enemies and break their power, repel persecution (fitna) and spread security in society, heal the believers' breasts and anger the disbelieving, oppressive aggressors.
Training the self to give and sacrifice
In jihad the Muslim fighter gives his utmost, his self, wealth and time for Allah, seeking neither reward nor thanks from people, nor exaltation in the land or corruption. He rises to high levels of giving for the good of humanity, guiding it and protecting it from aggression and injustice, so that it feels its true freedom in servitude to Allah. Thereby is realized the goodness with which Allah described this community in Ali 'Imran 3:110.
Abu Hurayra explains that they are the best of people for people, bringing them in shackles and chains until they enter Paradise, spending wealth and selves in jihad for people's benefit. Creation is Allah's dependents, he says, and the dearest to Allah is the most beneficial to them. The paper says this is the aim of enjoining right and forbidding wrong, and part of the sense in which Muhammad ﷺ was sent as a mercy to the worlds, even to those who deny him.
Some verses train the believer in giving, naming one result or gathering all in one context. The paper quotes Al-Baqarah 2:195. Exegetes differed on its interpretation.
Some said it concerns miserliness and leaving off spending: do not throw yourselves into destruction by not spending in Allah's way. This is the view of Hudhayfa, al-Hasan, Qatada, Ikrima and Ata. Ibn Abbas said to spend even if one has only an arrow or an arrowhead, and let none say he has nothing. Al-Suddi said to spend even a hobbling-rope. Said ibn al-Musayyib and Muqatil ibn Hayyan said a man, told to spend, replied that if they spent their wealth they would be poor, and so this verse was revealed. Mujahid said fear of poverty must not stop you spending rightfully. Abu Ubayda heard the Prophet ﷺ say that whoever spends surplus in Allah's way gets seven hundredfold, and spending on one's family is rewarded tenfold.
It is also said the verse was revealed about leaving jihad. Abu Ayyub al-Ansari said it was about the Ansar: once Allah had strengthened His religion, they said among themselves that they had left their families and wealth until Islam spread, and should return to them and repair what was lost. So the destruction is staying with family and wealth and leaving jihad. Abu Ayyub kept fighting until his last campaign at Constantinople in Muawiya's time, died there and was buried at the foot of its wall, and people seek rain through him.
The paper says the two views go together: leaving jihad is throwing oneself into destruction, and leaving spending is leaving jihad with wealth, busy with crops and wealth instead. This is a difference of variety in interpretation, not of contradiction. Other verses in Surah al-Baqara guide those who spend in Allah's way, seeking Allah's face. Fighting to raise Allah's word accustoms the fighter to giving: self and wealth are twins, and whoever gives himself will not be miserly with his wealth.
The paper quotes Al-Baqarah 2:262-263. They come in the setting of economic building and social solidarity, where the call to spend is repeated. The context draws up the constitution of charity, with manners that make it a refining act for the giver and a profitable one for the receivers, and turn society into a family of cooperation, affection and mercy.
These directions are a permanent constitution, not tied to a time, yet they met real cases in the Muslim community then, as they may in any later one. There were stingy souls needing strong appeals and parables. Some withheld wealth and gave only with usury (riba), some spent grudgingly or to show off, some followed spending with reminders and hurt, and some gave the poor quality and kept the good. Beside them were those who spend sincerely for Allah, give their best, and spend secretly or openly as fits.
Al-Baghawi reports from al-Kalbi that the verse was revealed about Uthman ibn Affan and Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf. Abd al-Rahman brought four thousand dirhams as charity, saying he had eight thousand, kept four thousand for his family and lent four thousand to his Lord, and the Prophet ﷺ said may Allah bless what he kept and gave. Uthman equipped the army at Tabuk with a thousand camels with their saddles and blankets.
Abd al-Rahman ibn Samura said Uthman poured a thousand dinars into the Prophet's lap for the army of hardship, and the Prophet ﷺ turned them over and said nothing would harm Ibn Affan whatever he did after that day, and Allah then revealed Al-Baqarah 2:262. The paper explains reminders of favor as making the receiver feel obliged by saying I gave you such a thing, spoiling the gift. Hurt is reproaching him, such as asking how long he will ask. It is also said that hurt includes mentioning his spending on him before someone he would not want to know it.
Hence the warning against miserliness in spending, for a believer is not miserly with wealth while he gives himself. The paper quotes Muhammad 47:38. It explains that believers are called to spend in fighting Allah's enemies and supporting His religion, and some are miserly. Whoever is miserly is so only against himself, for Allah is free of need and they are the needy. If they turn away from faith and obedience, He will bring others who will not be like them in turning away, but will obey Him and His Messenger and wage jihad with wealth and selves.
The divine directions then come in light of events in the lives of earlier prophets, urging believers to fight and to spend in the way of Allah, giver of life and wealth, who can take both.
The paper quotes Al-Baqarah 2:250-251. When the people asked for patience, took the means to victory and went out to Goliath and his troops, Allah answered them because they took the causes, and gave them victory by His leave. David killed Goliath, the disbelievers' king, with his own hand, through his courage, strength and patience, and Allah gave him kingship together with wisdom, meaning prophethood containing the great law and the straight path. He taught him religious and political sciences, joining kingship and prophethood, though earlier prophets had kingship held by others. Once victorious they settled in their homes and worshipped in security, all from the effects of jihad.
In other verses, in several surahs, the effect of fighting on giving and sacrifice is indicated together, joining jihad with self and with wealth. This is an effect of the creed of jihad, for example At-Tawbah 9:20. The paper quotes At-Tawbah 9:121. The paper quotes As-Saff 61:10-13.
Honor and empowerment for the Muslim community
Among the results of fighting is that Muslims keep the honor and dignity they draw from the might of Allah, the Strong, the Almighty, as in Fatir 35:10.
The paper says this verse comes among verses showing the proof of faith from scenes of life in dead land, then moves to honor and loftiness. It ties this to the good word that rises to Allah and the righteous deed He raises, pointing to what kept the disbelievers from it. That was the apparent honor they imagined, since they obeyed no one; they carved idols, called them their gods and carried them along. They sought honor by not humbling themselves to the Messenger or following him. But all honor is Allah's: whoever humbles himself to Him is honored, and whoever seeks to be mighty against Him is humbled. Whoever wants honor should seek it from Allah, its only source.
This is a basic truth of the Islamic creed, able to correct values, judgments, conduct and means. Once it settles in a heart, it makes that heart stand before the whole world honored and steady, bowing its head to no tyrant, storm, event, regime, state, interest or earthly power, since honor is wholly Allah's and no one has any of it except by His approval.
Other verses stress that true honor is Allah's in reality and essence: Yunus 10:65. And An-Nisa 4:139. Honor belongs to Allah in reality and essence, to His Messenger through nearness to the Almighty, and to the believers through nearness to the Messenger, since the believers' honor comes through the Prophet ﷺ, as in Al-Munafiqun 63:8.
Allah made fighting in His way, and jihad to raise His word, a path to this honor and to empowerment of this religion and of the community exalted by its faith and its Lord, as in Ali 'Imran 3:139. He also says An-Nisa 4:104. Jihad is the peak of Islam's hump and one of the paths of honor and dignity, the path nations have always taken to preserve themselves and repel aggressors. No people left it but Allah gave their enemy power over them, and none held to it but Allah honored and helped them.
The paper says our history is the truest witness. When the community held to jihad, with a person performing Hajj one year and fighting the next, it was strong, honored and feared, fruits were brought to it from everywhere, and the caliph could tell the cloud to rain wherever it wished, for its tribute would reach him.
When it held back, sought excuses and called for cheap, humiliating peace, its course in history began to go backwards. Nations assailed it from every side, its prestige faded and it began to forget its message. The Prophet's ﷺ words, reported by Thawban, came true in it: nations will soon summon one another against you as eaters to their dish; you will be many, but scum like the scum of a flood; Allah will remove fear of you from your enemies' hearts and cast weakness (wahn) into yours, which is love of the world and dislike of death.
The paper adds that some go further, distorting words from their places, misinterpreting verses and cutting them off from their context and causes of revelation to suit reality, and distorting historical events, all to justify sitting out. Such a person then claims wisdom and rationality, arguing that we are in a stage of weakness and cannot fight. Instead of removing the causes of that weakness and calling to take up strength, he calls to leave jihad.
Breaking the enemies' power and healing the believers' breasts
Allah sent messengers, books and laws so that people uphold justice, and sealed them with the message of Muhammad ﷺ, named Islam, the perfect religion and complete favor, dominant over other religions and addressed to all people. The paper says it embraced humanity with its call to tawhid, restored man's freedom and dignity, and set the foundations of a civilization built on faith and morals, knowledge and action, truth and justice.
But the disbelieving peoples, idolaters, People of the Book and others, took a stance of hostility and plotting against this call, its prophet and followers from its dawn, says the paper. Allah related this and their alliance in His Book, and history confirms it. The paper cites the Crusades; in the present age, savage aggression on Muslims in Bosnia, Chechnya, the Philippines, Thailand, India, Kashmir, Somalia, Afghanistan and Iraq; genocidal wars before that in the Soviet Union, Yugoslavia, Abyssinia and elsewhere; and in earlier ages the Inquisition in Spain, the Tatar attack on the caliphate, and the conspiracy of Crusaders and Mongols.
In the modern era, the paper says, the People of the Book cooperate with atheists in the communist camp to confront Islam and strike every sincere Islamic movement, forgetting their differences, while trying to deceive with false slogans. This struggle between truth and falsehood, faith and disbelief, is an old way (sunna). When enemies prevail they enslave people and spread corruption, so it is better for humanity to break their power by fighting, which also heals the believers' breasts.
The paper quotes At-Tawbah 9:13-15. They urge fighting the disbelievers and give three motives. First, they broke the oaths of their covenant with the Prophet ﷺ at Hudaybiyya, helping their allies Banu Bakr against Khuza'a, the Prophet's ﷺ allies. Second, they plotted to expel the Prophet ﷺ and the believers from Mecca so he would not convey his Lord's call. Third, they began the persecution (fitna), worse than killing, and the fighting, attacking at Badr with no necessity but hatred of the believers' religion.
The verses command fighting the disbelievers decisively, with a true promise that the believers will prevail completely. This is a detailed unseen report in a specific situation, unlike the general promise of help to messengers and believers, and it does not rule out war going back and forth before, to train the believers. The command means: engage in fighting, and Allah will punish them by your hands, with despair following in their hearts.
Al-Biqaʿi says to fight them for Allah and not for another aim. Allah punishes them by your hands, as you kill, capture and defeat them, and disgraces them in this world and the next. Since that does not entail victory, Allah adds a promise of victory, so you please your Lord by humbling His opponents through you.
The verses mention fruits of fighting.
Breaking the enemies' power
Fighting breaks the enemies' power through worldly punishment by killing. It repels their aggression. The paper explains At-Tawbah 9:14 as meaning by overwhelming them, and says hands show the believers carry out the punishment themselves, hands standing for persons, since hands carry the weapons. Punishment by the people of truth deters falsehood and breaks its power, so evil does not spread, vices do not rise and virtues are not lowered, as in Al-Hajj 22:40. For them there is also a great punishment in the Hereafter.
Disgrace and humbling of their pride
The paper explains At-Tawbah 9:14 as disgracing them by captivity, enslavement and pursuit, loss of their might, the Arabs' casting off their yoke, and loss of their material and moral authority, so physical and moral punishment gather on them.
Victory for the believers
Fighting brings victory to the believers, which is in Allah's hand, as in Al-Hajj 22:40. A servant supports Allah by obeying His commands, including fighting and making Allah's word the highest. Victory comes only if the servant takes its causes and has a sincere intention.
Healing the believers' breasts and removing their rage
When believers' hearts see disbelief raising its head with none to repel it, doubt or hesitation may overtake them, or a search for the wisdom of leaving it in its arrogance and harm. When Allah gives the believers victory, their breasts are healed of this bewilderment, grief and resentment, as in At-Tawbah 9:14.
The removed rage, the paper says, is that of those whose breasts need healing by a mighty victory. Rage (ghayz) is the soul's pain at seeing falsehood high and truth submissive; when truth wins, it goes. Rage is a passing state, so its going is called removal, while hesitation, bewilderment and doubt are diseases of faith, so their going is called healing, which is Allah's doing.
War tests souls and removes the conceit of those deluded by their idols. It makes them think about their state and their enemies', discern truth from falsehood, learn how the true God helped His believing friends, and be guided. So among its effects Allah turns in mercy to whom He wills and guides him to Islam, as He did with Abu Sufyan, Ikrima ibn Abi Jahl and Suhayl ibn Amr, as in At-Tawbah 9:15. The paper says this repentance is an overflow from Allah, reached after their conceit vanished.
Allah closes the verse with two of His names, the Knowing and the Wise, who knows what guides souls and places matters in their places.
Repelling persecution and spreading security in society
Among the fruits of jihad is repelling persecution (fitna) and preventing corruption in the land, which brings security and stability to society. Fitna indicates trial and testing. It comes from putting gold in fire to show its good from its bad, and was used for putting a person in fire.
Allah says Adh-Dhariyat 51:13. At times it is used for what leads to punishment, as in At-Tawbah 9:49. At times it is used for testing, as in Ta-Ha 20:40. Fitna is like affliction (balaʾ) in being used for hardship and ease alike, though more clearly and commonly for hardship. The Quran's uses of fitna can be summed up as follows.
- Oppressing the weak, taking their lawful rights and homes, and harming them, as in An-Nahl 16:110. Also Al-Baqarah 2:217.
- Domination by force and tyranny, preventing people from accepting truth and obstructing Allah's religion, as in Yunus 10:83. Also Al-Anfal 8:36.
- This is fitna to be prevented by fighting the disbelievers who persecute the believers, as in Al-Anfal 8:39.
- Trying to lead people astray with deception, fraud, greed and coercion against truth, as in Al-Isra 17:73. Also Al-Ma'idah 5:49.
- The dominance of falsehood and its people over the followers of truth, as in Al-Anfal 8:73.
These meanings include corruption and spreading corruption in the land, and obstructing Allah's religion, which He sent down to free man from servitude to man, desire and Satan, so that he serves Allah alone. Hence Allah commanded fighting and jihad to uproot these by force and establish His religion on earth, so that humanity enjoys goodness and stability, with rights and freedoms protected.
What indicates this is Al-Baqarah 2:193. Al-Tabari says Allah tells His Prophet ﷺ to fight the idolaters who fight them until there is no fitna, meaning no shirk and no one worshipped besides Him, with worship and obedience for Allah alone. Qatada, Mujahid, al-Suddi, Ibn Abbas, al-Hasan and Ibn Zayd said the same, and "religion" here is worship and obedience to Allah.
Al-Baghawi held this and added that they are fought until they become Muslim, as nothing but Islam is accepted from the idolater, and if he refuses he is killed. Nafi reported that in the fitna of Ibn al-Zubayr a man asked Ibn Umar what prevented him from going out, and he said Allah had forbidden his brother's blood. The man asked whether he had not heard Al-Hujurat 49:9. Ibn Umar replied that he would rather be reproached for that verse and not fight than be reproached for the one about the deliberate killer of a believer, An-Nisa 4:93.
The man asked whether Allah had not said to fight until there is no fitna. Ibn Umar said they did that in the Prophet's ﷺ time, when Islam was few and a man was persecuted in his religion, killed or tortured, until Islam grew and religion was all for Allah. He said the man's side wanted to fight until religion was for other than Allah. Said ibn Jubayr reported that Ibn Umar told a man asking about fighting in fitna that Muhammad ﷺ fought the idolaters, for entering upon them was fitna, unlike fighting over kingship.
If they cease from disbelief and become Muslim, there is no recourse against them except the wrongdoers, said Ibn Abbas. This is shown by Al-Qasas 28:28. The people of meanings said hostility is injustice, so if they become Muslim there is no plunder, captivity or killing except against the wrongdoers who stay in shirk. What is done to idolaters is not injustice, and is called hostility by way of correspondence, as in Al-Baqarah 2:194. It is like Ash-Shura 42:40. The disbeliever is called a wrongdoer because he puts worship in the wrong place.
The same meaning came in al-Anfal, Al-Anfal 8:39. By this command Allah obliged believers to fight disbelievers to prevent fitna. Ibn Abbas and others said fitna means shirk. Ibn Ishaq said it means that no one is persecuted for his religion, as Quraysh did in Mecca to Bilal and others, and this fits what Urwa ibn al-Zubayr told Abd al-Malik ibn Marwan about the Prophet's ﷺ leaving Mecca. Qatada said it is until the word of sincerity is established.
Ibn Atiyya said all these meanings go together. Al-Hasan said it means until there is no affliction (balaʾ), which requires fighting the rebellious party in Muslim strife; on the other views the one who withdraws has latitude. On this basis Ibn Umar said that they fought until there was no fitna, while the others wanted them to fight until there was fitna.
Ibn Atiyya said Ibn Umar held fitna here to be shirk, the apparent meaning. The Prophet's ﷺ saying that he was commanded to fight people until they say there is no god but Allah, after which their blood and property are protected except by its right and their reckoning is with Allah, explains the verse.
Takeaways
Stage rulings are not final rulings
The paper says the rulings of the stages of fighting are not final rulings that abrogate or conflict with others, since Islam meets each stage with what suits it. It warns of confusion when verses with stage rulings are made final, and verses with final rulings are interpreted to match the stage ones.
The aim of fighting
The paper says fighting in Allah's way is not for shedding the disbelievers' blood or taking their property, but for Allah's religion to prevail. The verses also make clear that spoils are not the original aim of fighting, though Allah made them lawful.
Obligation depends on conditions
Most jurists hold that jihad is a communal obligation when mobilization is not general, and when enough carry it out the obligation falls from the rest. The paper lists the conditions as Islam, puberty, freedom, being male, ability and means, or the absence of an excuse.
Kindness to captives
The paper says verses call for treating the captive with high Islamic morals and kindness in all forms, and Allah pairs kindness to the captive, even if not Muslim, with kindness to the needy and the orphan.
Honor comes from Allah
The paper says all honor belongs to Allah, and that once this truth settles in a heart it stands before the whole world honored and steady. Allah made fighting in His way a path to this honor.
Reflect
- Why might the paper say the permissibility of fighting is wider than that of killing, and what does that distinction ask of those who fight?
- How does knowing that fighting was legislated in stages change the way you read a single verse about it?
- What does the paper's link between giving oneself and giving one's wealth ask of you in your own spending?
- Where in your own life do you look for honor, and what does the paper say about its source?
Every verse in the paper
All 129 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.
Fighting in Quranic Usage «القتال في الاستعمال القرآني»
Stages in the Legislation of Fighting «مراحل تشريع القتال»
First stage: refraining from fighting «أولًا: مرحلة الكف عن القتال»
96:1, 74:1-2, 15:94, 15:85-86, 29:46, 16:125, 5:13, 25:63, 3:20, 41:34-35, 4:77
Second stage: permission to fight «ثانيًا: مرحلة الإذن بالقتال»
Third stage: fighting in defence «ثالثًا: مرحلة القتال دفاعًا»
2:190, 8:61, 9:5, 9:36, 2:191, 8:39
Fourth stage: fighting without restriction «رابعًا: مرحلة القتال مطلقًا»
2:191-193, 2:244, 9:12-15, 9:29, 9:36
Types of Fighters «أصناف المقاتلين»
First: the disbelievers and their leaders «أولًا: الكفار وأئمتهم»
2:191-193, 8:39, 47:4, 8:57, 9:5, 4:89, 9:7-13
Second: the People of the Book «ثانيًا: أهل الكتاب»
Third: apostates, and fourth: groups refusing a pillar of Islam «ثالثًا: المرتدون.»
2:217, 2:193, 9:5, 2:278-279, 5:33, 4:65
Fifth: the group that transgresses against another group of believers «خامسًا: الطائفة المعتدية على الأخرى من المؤمنين»
Sixth: the rebels «سادسًا: البغاة»
Rulings on fighting «أحكام القتال»
The ruling on fighting and its conditions «أولًا: حكم القتال وشروطه»
9:5, 9:12, 8:39, 2:216, 9:36, 9:41, 4:95, 9:122, 9:39, 2:180, 4:84, 8:65, 48:17, 9:91-93
The ruling on excuses and staying behind from fighting «ثانيًا: حكم الاعتذار والتخلف عن القتال»
3:166-168, 9:81-84, 33:9-15, 4:77
Rulings on fay, spoils, jizya and captives «ثالثًا: حكم الفيء والغنيمة والأسر والجزية»
59:6-8, 59:10, 8:41, 48:15, 48:20-21, 9:29, 8:67-69, 14:36, 5:118, 71:26, 10:88, 8:70, 47:4, 8:57, 9:5, 76:8-10
Results and consequences of fighting «نتائج القتال وعواقبه»
Training the self to give and sacrifice «أولًا: تربية النفس على البذل والتضحية»
3:110, 2:195, 2:262-263, 47:38, 2:250-251, 9:20, 9:121, 61:10-13
Honor and empowerment for the Muslim community «ثانيًا: العزة والتمكين للمجتمع الاسلامي»
35:10, 10:65, 4:139, 63:8, 3:139, 4:104
Breaking the enemies' power and healing the believers' breasts «ثالثًا: كسر شوكة الأعداء وشفاء صدور المؤمنين»
Repelling persecution and spreading security in society «رابعًا: دفع الفتنة وانتشار الأمن في المجتمع»
51:13, 9:49, 20:40, 16:110, 2:217, 10:83, 8:36, 8:39, 17:73, 5:49, 8:73, 2:193, 49:9, 4:93, 28:28, 2:194, 42:40
About this source
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
- Volume
- 14
- Research paper
- «القتال» (Fighting)
Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.
This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.