Prophetic Biography · Quran topic
Expedition of Tabuk
غزوة تبوك · Ghazwat Tabuk
The Prophet's last expedition: its causes, the believers, the hypocrites, those left behind, and lessons
60 verses · 7 parts · 52 min read
Study guide based on
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
«غزوة تبوك» · Volume 13
At a glance
The paper introduces the Expedition of Tabuk through its several names, each with the reason it was given. It dates the expedition to Rajab of the ninth year of the Hijra. It says the expedition fell in the season of intense summer heat. The paper gives several reasons why the destination was announced openly. It also gives several causes that the biographers mention for the expedition. The paper's own view is that the expedition was the Prophet's ﷺ obedience to Allah's command to fight.
The paper presents the expedition as a hard test in which the believers' sincerity showed. It then lists the stances of the hypocrites together with the Quranic comment on each. It sets out four kinds of those who stayed behind, following Ibn Kathir. The paper then turns to the Prophet's ﷺ leadership in the expedition. It ends with lessons, noting that the Muslims did not fight at Tabuk.
Key verses
- At-Tawbah 9:81: The paper uses this verse to show the expedition fell in the severe heat of summer, since it reports what the hypocrites said. Ibn ʿAbbas explains that this was when the Prophet ﷺ ordered the people to set out in summer and some men said the heat was too severe.
- At-Tawbah 9:117: The paper says the name Hardship occurs in this verse, and that the time of hardship means the whole time of the expedition, not one particular hour. It explains that Allah turned to the Emigrants and Ansar who went out and did not lag, though the hearts of some, such as Abu Khaythama, almost swerved, and that He protected them and accepted their repentance.
- At-Tawbah 9:91: The paper says the verse lifts blame from three kinds of believers. It explains that they bear no sin as long as they are sincere to Allah and His Messenger. It adds that blame is lifted from them because they are then people of excellence.
Words to know
- غزوة تبوك ghazwat Tabuk
The Expedition of Tabuk, named for Tabuk, the place where the Muslims' march ended. It is also called the Expedition of Hardship, a name the paper says was well known among the Companions.
Introducing the Expedition of Tabuk
From the paper: «التعريف بغزوة تبوك»
Its names
The biographies give this blessed expedition several names, which the paper lists with the reason for each.
1. The Expedition of Tabuk
The name occurs in sound hadiths: Sahih Muslim reports from Muʿadh ibn Jabal that the Prophet ﷺ told them they would reach the spring of Tabuk the next day. Tabuk is where the Muslims' march ended, a main city of the northern Hijaz, now the seat of the Tabuk emirate, 778 kilometres from Medina via Khaybar and Tayma, then in the lands of Qudaʿa under Roman (al-Rum) rule.
2. The Expedition of Hardship (al-ʿUsra)
Hardship (al-ʿusra) means severity, straitened circumstances and want, as in Al-Baqarah 2:280. The name occurs in Surat al-Tawba, where Allah says At-Tawbah 9:117, and the paper explains that the "hour" means the whole time of the expedition, not one particular hour. The Prophet ﷺ used the name, saying whoever equipped the Army of Hardship would have Paradise.
Companions used it too, among them Abu Musa al-Ashʿari, sent to ask the Prophet ﷺ for mounts for his companions in the Army of Hardship, which is Tabuk. Yaʿla ibn Umayya counted his going out in the Army of Hardship among the deeds he trusted most.
The paper concludes the name was well known among the Companions, since it came in the Quran and from the Prophet ﷺ, and they saw the hardship with their own eyes. ʿUmar ibn al-Khattab said they set out in fierce heat and grew so thirsty that a man would slaughter his camel and drink the squeezed contents of its stomach.
Muhammad ibn ʿAbd Allah ibn ʿAqil adds that two or three men shared a camel, and it was a hardship of water, of provisions and of mounts.
3. The Exposer (al-Fadiha)
Al-Zurqani says it is called the Exposer because the hypocrites were exposed in it, and Ibn ʿAbbas called Surat al-Tawba the Exposer, which kept naming them until they thought none would be left unmentioned. Surat al-Tawba was revealed with commentary on the expedition, exposing the hypocrites' hidden evil.
When the expedition took place
The biographers agree that Tabuk was in Rajab of the ninth year after the Hijra. Ibn ʿAbbas said the Prophet ﷺ stayed six months after leaving al-Taʾif, then Allah commanded him to march on Tabuk, the expedition of hardship. Ibn Hajar says this fits Rajab once fractions are dropped, since the Prophet ﷺ reached Medina from al-Taʾif in Dhu al-Hijja.
He set out on a Thursday, and Kaʿb ibn Malik said he liked to set out on Thursdays. Al-ʿAmiri dates it to the fifth of Rajab, and the Prophet ﷺ stayed in Tabuk twenty nights. In the solar calendar it was certainly in the fierce summer heat, as Allah's report of the hypocrites in At-Tawbah 9:81 shows.
Some biographers said November, but the paper holds April more likely, and Allah knows best. The Muslims numbered thirty thousand, ten thousand of them horsemen; Sibaʿ ibn ʿUrfuta was left over Medina, and ʿAli ibn Abi Talib over the Prophet's household.
Why the Expedition of Tabuk is told in Surat al-Tawba
Surat al-Tawba is a late Medinan surah; al-Baraʾ even said the last verse revealed was An-Nisa 4:176 and the last surah Baraʾa. It holds much unabrogated law, including the rulings of jihad, and the paper finds it gives the final position toward every group. Ibn al-Qayyim says that after the command to jihad the disbelievers were people of truce, people of war or people of protection (ahl al-dhimma); treaties were honoured while kept, openly repudiated before fighting if betrayal was feared, and breakers fought.
He adds that Baraʾa ruled on all of them: fight the People of the Book among his enemies until they paid the jizya or entered Islam, and strive against disbelievers with the sword and hypocrites with argument and tongue. So the surah holds the final rulings of jihad and a practical example in the Prophet's last expedition, with what believers and hypocrites did and the recompense they earned from Allah.
Al-Biqaʿi gives its aim as enmity toward those who turned from what earlier surahs called to, following the caller to Allah in His oneness and what pleases Him, and allegiance to those who accepted it. As a late surah it gave the final word on the polytheists' covenants and the position toward the People of the Book and the hypocrites, both linked to Tabuk.
Tabuk was against the Christian Romans, and the surah's passage on the People of the Book prepares for its account of the expedition, which dwells on the hypocrites before, during and after it. Their treatment here is the longest and harshest of any surah, because this was the last test of the Muslim ranks before the Prophet ﷺ joined the Highest Companion, so the bad would be sorted from the good and hypocrisy fully exposed.
The surah is severe with them, leaving no room for gentleness after Tabuk, and its names carry this: Baraʾa (disavowal), the Exposer, the surah of punishment, al-Muqashqisha that cures the believer's heart of hypocrisy, al-Muthira and al-Hafira that uncover their secrets, al-Mubaʿthira, al-Mukhziya, al-Munakkila, al-Musharrida, al-Mudamdima, al-Kashifa, al-ʿAsifa, al-Fariqa and al-Muharrida.
Yet alongside this severity in striving against the hypocrites, which relies on the word rather than force, it is called Repentance (al-Tawba) and uses that word more than any other surah, so forgiveness stays open to whoever turns back, as in At-Tawbah 9:74. It pairs striving with wealth and self in five verses and sets out the merit of spending, the punishment of hoarders and the recipients of zakat, all linked to Tabuk, the expedition of hardship. As it exposed the hypocrites, it honoured the believers and their spending in Allah's way.
Why the Prophet ﷺ announced the march to Tabuk openly
The Prophet's ﷺ custom was to conceal his destination (al-tawriya) to take the enemy by surprise before they could prepare, in every expedition except Tabuk. Kaʿb ibn Malik said that until Tabuk he rarely intended an expedition without hinting at another, but this one was in fierce heat, over a long desert journey, against a numerous enemy, so he made it plain so they could prepare, and told them his destination.
Concealment is a praiseworthy stratagem in war, and al-Muhallab explains the open announcement of Tabuk by its long duration, so they could prepare, and by his being safe from news reaching it ahead of him, given its distant, barren route. Major General Mahmud Khattab adds that the long summer march needed full supplies and transport beforehand, lest administrative shortfalls defeat the aim, and equipping the large army needed the wealthy, who then gave generously and willingly.
The paper sums up the reasons for the announcement:
- So the Muslims could prepare, as Kaʿb said, given the distant road and scant provisions.
- So the wealthy believers could spend heavily on the army's needs; many equipped the needy, as in the hadith of ʿUthman promised Paradise for equipping the Army of Hardship.
- Because it was, in the paper's words, a final test: as the Prophet's ﷺ last expedition, Allah's wisdom made it reveal the truthful believers and the hypocrites, so only full openness and a direct call on everyone to go out, whatever their state, would serve.
- The paper finds support for this in there being no fighting: the true believers went and returned without pursuing or fighting anyone, seeking Allah's pleasure, and came back with repentance, His good pleasure and a Lord not angry.
Causes of the expedition
From the paper: «أسباب الغزوة»
The biographers give several causes for the Expedition of Tabuk. Ibn Saʿd says word reached the Prophet ﷺ that the Romans had massed great forces in Syria (al-Sham), Heraclius had paid his men for a year, allied tribes had joined him and their vanguards had reached al-Balqaʾ, so he called the people to go out.
The paper notes this report has no chain, but sound hadith shows the Companions expected the Romans' tribes to come to Medina: ʿUmar said they feared a king of Ghassan reported to be marching on them. Al-Yaʿqubi says the Prophet ﷺ campaigned to Tabuk against a large force in Syria, seeking redress for the blood of Jaʿfar ibn Abi Talib.
Others see the direct cause in the killing of Farwa ibn ʿAmr al-Judhami, a Roman commander and governor over the nearby Arabs, whom the Romans seized, imprisoned and killed on learning of his Islam. Jaʿfar was killed at Muʾta in the eighth year; the paper says this may be among the causes but is not enough on its own, and the same holds for Farwa, and Allah knows best.
Ibn ʿAsakir narrates from ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn Ghanm that Jews told the Prophet ﷺ that if he were truly a prophet he should go to Syria; he believed them and campaigned to Tabuk, and there Allah revealed verses of Surat Bani Israʾil, Al-Isra 17:76-77. The paper says the chain is weak and the report apparently unsound, since the Prophet ﷺ did not go out because of what the Jews said, and the verse is Meccan.
Al-Tabari narrates from Mujahid that the believers spoke of the profit they used to make from the polytheists' trade, and that Allah promised to enrich them from His bounty; this verse, At-Tawbah 9:29, comes early in Baraʾa in recitation but late in interpretation, when Muhammad and his Companions were ordered to Tabuk.
Prophetic texts do present jihad as a door of provision, as in his saying that his provision was placed beneath the shade of his spear. Yet the paper holds that the verse is better taken generally: Allah opened provision to the Muslims in more ways than spoils, for they gained little from Tabuk, and their chief aim was bringing people to worship their Lord.
The paper's view is that the expedition was the Prophet's ﷺ obedience to Allah's command to fight them, as Allah says At-Tawbah 9:123. Al-Tabari explains it as a command to fight those nearest first, and those nearest to its addressees were then the Romans, who lived in Syria.
The paper says the verse shows the wisdom of fighting the Romans: that they find harshness (ghilza) in the believers, and so fear them and take them seriously; this happened, as the Romans did not come out or face the Muslims, and the fear extended to the Christianized tribes allied with them.
The paper notes that this expedition, like Muʾta before it, turned against the Romans after Arabia came under Islam, Mecca was conquered, many Arabs entered Islam, and the Jewish danger ended with Khaybar cleared. This new stage, the paper says, prepared for conquests that would break Roman strongholds in and around Arabia, in response to Allah's command At-Tawbah 9:29.
Al-Tabari reports that the verse was revealed commanding the Prophet ﷺ to make war on the Romans, and after it he campaigned to Tabuk. Another cause was to strike fear into the Arab tribes not yet Muslim and the Christianized tribes under Roman influence, and to make them think seriously about Islam, that it was no passing thing but had a bright future, which might open their way into it.
The believers' stance in the expedition
From the paper: «موقف المؤمنين في الغزوة»
The expedition was a field of rivalry and a hard test in which the believers' faith was refined and their sincerity shown; the paper summarizes the great stances of faith that appeared in it.
Responding to the call to march
People differed in rank in this expedition; some raced ahead in good deeds by Allah's leave, the sincere believers who went out in answer to the divine command to march. The paper quotes At-Tawbah 9:38. It says the verse urges the believers to go out to fight, and the question in it carries rebuke and blame for whoever was sluggish about jihad; the word used pictures a limp body with a pull toward the ground.
The paper adds that the question is one of denial and reproach: how can one content with Allah as Lord be content with this world, whose enjoyment beside the Hereafter is like a finger dipped into a stormy sea. Then Allah says At-Tawbah 9:39. The paper gives al-Tabari's explanation: this is a warning to the believers among the Prophet's ﷺ Companions about leaving the march against the Romans; Allah would punish them painfully and replace them with a people who answer when called, and they cannot harm Him by withholding their support, since He has no need of them and they are the ones in need of Him.
The paper then says the verse reminds them of an event nine years old that the Quran had not commented on before, against its habit of commenting at once; it kept the comment until its time because the causes are alike: human means weak and circumstances hard, yet these never broke the believers' resolve.
The paper says the divine support given when the Prophet ﷺ and his companion, two with only Allah as third, were driven out of Mecca can recur at Tabuk; so, if they lag, they should remember the cave At-Tawbah 9:40. The paper explains that in the cave the Prophet ﷺ reassured Abu Bakr, Allah sent down tranquillity and security, strengthened them with confidence and certainty, and made the word of the disbelievers lowest, while the word of Allah is always highest, and He is the Overcomer who orders matters with wisdom.
The verses then order the believers to march to Tabuk in every condition, light or heavy; the paper quotes that the words are figurative for those who can travel easily and those who can only with difficulty, so they include the rich and poor, the old and young.
They command jihad with wealth and lives given cheaply in Allah's way, wealth first because it is what the fighter needs first in preparation; then they stir longing for the reward and its great merit. Elsewhere in the same surah the believers are praised for answering the Messenger's call, as Allah says At-Tawbah 9:88-89.
The paper explains that this verse follows the account of the hypocrites, who did not fight; the Messenger and those with him, who never lagged behind, spent their wealth and gave their lives for Allah's pleasure, and theirs are all good things in this world and the next, true success, and gardens in which they abide forever, a great triumph.
Another of their good rewards in the surah is At-Tawbah 9:117. The paper explains that Allah turned (tawba, meaning return) to His Prophet ﷺ, which for him means a return from one state of obedience to a fuller one, from before bearing the expedition's hardships to after; it may also be a renewal without any slip, like asking for guidance while already guided, or a return from heedlessness to remembrance.
He likewise turned to the Emigrants and Ansar who went out without sluggishness or disobedience in this severe, hard expedition, after the heart of some, such as Abu Khaythama, almost swerved; Allah protected them, then accepted their repentance, for He is the Lord of past and future mercy, and He made repentance a thanks for their earlier deeds and jihad.
If the excuse-makers made excuses to be given leave, the believers could never have stayed behind from the Messenger ﷺ. As Allah says At-Tawbah 9:120-121. The paper explains that the people of Medina and the Bedouin around it were not to lag behind the Messenger ﷺ at Tabuk, seeking their own safety and ease while leaving him in the heat and hardship.
Al-Zamakhshari says they were commanded to accompany him through hardship willingly and gladly, and to expose themselves to what he faced, knowing his soul is the dearest and most honored to Allah; so holding back from him is a strong prohibition, with rebuke of them and a spur to follow him with zeal.
The paper says the prohibition is explained by the fact that no thirst, bodily weariness or hunger in Allah's cause, no step that angers the disbelievers, and no harm to them in person or property, small or great, goes unrecorded as a good deed, nor any spending or valley crossed; so that Allah repays them by their work and increases it until the reward is better than their deeds, or repays them the best of their deeds.
The expedition gives fine examples of the Companions' eagerness not to lag behind. Abu Khaythama Abu Khaythama tells how he lagged behind, then entered an orchard, saw a sprinkled shelter and his wife, and felt it unfair that the Messenger ﷺ be in scorching heat while he was in shade; he took a camel and some dates and set out, met ʿUmayr ibn Wahb al-Jumahi on the way and asked him to hang back while he faced the Prophet ﷺ as a sinner; when the army came into view, the Prophet ﷺ said to be Abu Khaythama, and after hearing his story spoke well of him and prayed for him.
The paper draws out his quick return, his blaming himself for the delay, his endurance of the road with little provision and a long distance, and the Prophet's ﷺ knowledge of his Companions and sound insight into them. Abu Dharr The paper cites Ibn Masʿud: as the Prophet ﷺ marched to Tabuk, men kept lagging and people told him, and he answered that if there was good in them Allah would bring them to the army, and if not, Allah had relieved them of him; when told Abu Dharr lagged because his camel was slow, he said the same.
Abu Dharr waited on his camel, but it stayed slow, so he took his baggage on his back and followed on foot; when a Muslim saw a man walking and the Prophet ﷺ said "Be Abu Dharr" and the people recognized him, the Prophet ﷺ said may Allah have mercy on Abu Dharr, who walks alone, dies alone and will be raised alone.
The paper draws out the Prophet's ﷺ decisive approach in this expedition: he gave no one a guarantee of goodness, for goodness depended on going out and nothing else, and whoever did not go, Allah relieved His servants of him and entrusted jihad to a people He loves and who love Him; it also shows Abu Dharr's resolve and fine patience in walking with his baggage on his back, a hardship eased by the Prophet's ﷺ glad tidings.
Hastening to spend in Allah's way
Wealth is put before lives in jihad in five verses of Surat al-Tawba, the first being At-Tawbah 9:20. The second is At-Tawbah 9:41. The third is At-Tawbah 9:44. The fourth is At-Tawbah 9:81. The fifth is At-Tawbah 9:88. The paper explains this by the importance of wealth, the sinew of jihad: giving wealth leads to giving one's life, and whoever finds his wealth light finds his life light, as Muslim ibn al-Walid says.
His verse says he gives his life when the miser withholds it. The paper adds that jihad by wealth may have a wider circle than jihad in person, since it is open to every man and woman, with little or much, and a small gift is recorded and its reward not lost.
The expedition was full of fine examples of spending. Abu Bakr al-Siddiq ʿUmar relates that when the Prophet ﷺ ordered them to give charity he thought to outdo Abu Bakr and brought half his wealth, leaving the same for his family; Abu Bakr brought everything, leaving his family Allah and His Messenger, and ʿUmar said he would never outdo him in anything.
The paper takes this as practical proof of his rank as the truthful (siddiq), since charity proves perfect faith, all the more giving everything; it cites Ibn Taymiyya that ʿUmar's act was permissible rivalry and envy, but Abu Bakr's state was better, free of rivalry and looking at no one else.
ʿUmar From that report, the paper says, he gave half his wealth, which some narrations from Ibn ʿAbbas put at a hundred ounces. ʿUthman ʿUthman's spending in this expedition was the greatest. Ibn Ishaq says he spent a great sum, the like of which none spent.
The paper cites ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn Samura that ʿUthman brought a thousand dinars in his garment when the Army of Hardship was equipped and poured them into the Prophet's ﷺ lap, and the Prophet ﷺ turned them over and repeatedly said that nothing ʿUthman did after that day could harm him.
It also cites ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn Khabbab that when the Prophet ﷺ urged support for the Army in a sermon, ʿUthman pledged a hundred camels with their gear, then another hundred, then another hundred, and the Prophet ﷺ gestured in wonder that nothing ʿUthman did after this could harm him.
Other Companions ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn ʿAwf brought four thousand dirhams of his eight thousand to the Prophet ﷺ to put in Allah's way, keeping four thousand for his family, and the Prophet ﷺ blessed what he gave and what he kept. Each gave what he had, and women too took a strong part.
Al-Waqidi reports from Umm Sinan al-Aslamiyya that she saw a garment spread before the Prophet ﷺ in ʿAisha's house holding musk, bracelets, anklets, earrings and rings that women sent to help the Muslims equip themselves, while the people were in great hardship. The paper concludes that hard times show the worth of great people, and the hardship of Tabuk showed the true metal of those who count wealth light for Allah's sake.
The stance of the poor
Many Companions gave, but the numbers were large and the gifts few, so some stayed behind, held back only by excuse and poverty; they wanted jihad, found no means, and spent tears in sorrow, and Allah revealed Quran about them to be recited until the Day of Judgment.
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:91-92. The verse lifts blame from three kinds of believers. The first are the weak, those with chronic illnesses and those weak in their creation, like boys and women. The second are the sick, whose illness prevents them from going out. The third are those who find no provisions or mount; it is said they were from Muzayna, Juhayna and Banu ʿUdhra.
These and their like bear no sin as long as they are sincere (nasaha) to Allah and His Messenger, nasaha being seeking an act or word that benefits its doer. So there is no blame on them if they are sincere in faith to Allah and in obedience to His Messenger ﷺ, in deed and in the duty of counsel, which is central to religion, as the Prophet ﷺ said in a hadith that religion is sincere counsel.
The paper adds that the clause in At-Tawbah 9:91 lifts blame because they are people of excellence, and that reproach does not pass them, like a proverb. The verse ends with Allah's forgiveness and mercy, which neither the able nor the unable can do without.
Among them was ʿUlba ibn Zayd, who gave an unprecedented charity: he went out at night, prayed and wept, saying Allah had commanded jihad but left him nothing to equip himself, and gave as charity to every Muslim every wrong done to him in wealth, body or honor; the Prophet ﷺ asked who the giver was, and when he stood, told him glad tidings, that his charity was recorded as accepted zakat.
The paper says he was not content with tears but gave his honor as charity between himself and his Lord, who accepted it, and revelation came about it and the glad tidings reached him at daybreak.
The hypocrites' stance in the expedition
From the paper: «موقف المنافقين في الغزوة»
The hypocrites took several stances in this expedition, which the paper lists together with the Quranic comment on each.
Hypocrites asking leave to stay out of jihad
After commanding the believers and rebuking the sluggish, the address turned to the hypocrites in the third person, to avoid addressing them directly: At-Tawbah 9:42. The paper explains that if what he called them to were an easy gain or an easy journey, they would have hurried to follow him.
But they prefer safety and find the distance too far; their real calamity is their own selves, which made sitting back look good to them, and had they left their commanding self (al-nafs al-ammara) by one step, everything would have been easy. Only quick spoils move them; this type is common, many at greed, few and fleeing at fear, exposed only when hardship comes.
They make jihad depend on ability, and the Quran recorded this against them before they said it, At-Tawbah 9:42; they claim no wealth, health, provision or mount, any excuse to avoid fighting, not knowing that real destruction lies in abandoning jihad by a false oath, which the Prophet ﷺ said leaves homes desolate.
Allah knows they were able and that only the hypocrisy of their hearts held them back. Then the verses turn to the Prophet ﷺ gently, At-Tawbah 9:43; the paper says this shows his honor, since pardon comes before reproach, and it is also said to be only an opening of speech, like "may Allah set you right", with no reproach.
The paper's view is that the permission was not forbidden before the verse but left to choice, as al-Qadi ʿIyad relates; his act was independent judgment (ijtihad) where there was no text, which scholars allow for prophets, revelation correcting them. The verse makes clear the wisdom of not giving permission, At-Tawbah 9:43: he should have waited until the truthful were distinct from the liars.
Ibn ʿAbbas said the Prophet ﷺ did not know the hypocrites at that time. The paper explains At-Tawbah 9:45 as showing the difference between believer and hypocrite: the believer does not ask leave for jihad but always hastens, as in a hadith about the man holding his horse's rein in Allah's way, flying to every alarm.
The author of al-Kashshaf says the sincere Emigrants and Ansar said they would never ask the Prophet's ﷺ leave for jihad. If believers do not ask leave to fight, they would not ask leave to abandon it, all the more. The hypocrites, by contrast, are keen to ask leave to avoid jihad, and Allah describes them as lacking faith because faith is what moves the soul.
The verses show they had no real excuses, since they never intended to go out, or they would have prepared, first in soul, then militarily; among them, Mujahid reports, were ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy, ʿAbd Allah ibn Nabtal, Aws ibn Qayzi and Rifaʿa ibn al-Tabut, who had wealth and strength but did not want to go out.
Allah made going out heavy for them because He disliked their setting out, and they were told to sit; the speaker may be some of them, or the Messenger ﷺ in anger, or Satan by whispering, or Allah, or it is a forsaking He placed in their hearts.
The sitters are those with an excuse, like women and children, so the phrase adds blame by joining the hypocrites to them. The paper asks why the Prophet ﷺ was reproached for permitting them to stay, if their going out had no benefit anyway. It answers that harm would have come from their going out, but the reproach was for giving permission before their affair was fully exposed, since the interest lay in withholding it until the truthful were distinct.
Their going out had no benefit, as Allah says At-Tawbah 9:47. The first harm is that they would add no strength to the ranks but disorder, confusion of opinion and corruption in fighting. The second is that they would hurry to slander, split the ranks, discourage the fighters and spread rumors; and among the believers were weak ones who would listen and be influenced, as Qatada says, which most commentators take "hearing" to mean.
The verse ends with a warning that Allah knows their inner souls and will repay them; "the wrongdoers" appears to mean the hypocrites, perhaps also the hearers. This was not new for them, for they tried discouragement at Uhud: when the Muslims reached al-Shawt, an orchard between Medina and Uhud, ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy withdrew with three hundred hypocrites, saying the youths and the unwise were obeyed over him.
His aim was to shake the Muslim ranks, so that Banu Salima and Banu Haritha almost lost heart, and about them Allah revealed Ali 'Imran 3:122. The paper explains that "they turned matters over" means they schemed every way to make the Prophet's affair fail, but Allah disgraced them; the truth came, Mecca was conquered and His religion appeared while they disliked it.
After the general account, these verses detail their stances before and during the expedition, with examples of their false excuses. The paper cites Jabir that the Prophet ﷺ asked Jadd ibn Qays whether he would fight the Banu al-Asfar, and Jadd asked leave, saying he loved women and feared being tempted; the Prophet ﷺ, turning from him, gave leave, and Allah revealed At-Tawbah 9:49.
Jadd gave an excuse that was itself a sin, asking not to be made sinful by being ordered out. The Quranic reply to his feeble pretext, At-Tawbah 9:49, begins with an alerting particle, and "fall" carries the sense of dropping, perishing and being firmly caught. The image makes temptation an abyss in which they fall, with Hell behind them closing every exit, a figure for their complete sin and certain punishment for lying and staying behind.
His real temptation was not in going to the Romans as he claimed but in staying behind and his ugly excuse; then comes the threat to him and those like him that Hell surrounds the disbelievers, with no escape. Another stance showed their bad inner natures and love of harming the Muslims, At-Tawbah 9:50; the paper notes that "good" is indefinite in a conditional, so it is general.
The paper cites Jabir: the hypocrites who stayed in Medina spread news that the Prophet ﷺ and his Companions were ruined; when it proved false and they were well, it grieved them, and Allah revealed At-Tawbah 9:50. Allah then teaches His Prophet ﷺ how to answer: nothing will reach us but what Allah decreed in the Preserved Tablet, and it is for our good; "our Protector" means our helper who manages our affairs, so we rely only on Him.
The second answer taught is At-Tawbah 9:52; the question is one of affirmation and rebuke: the believers await only one of two outcomes, each better than any other, victory from Allah with honor in both worlds, or martyrdom and high rank with Allah. For the hypocrites the believers await one of two evils: punishment from Allah in this life, as He destroyed earlier peoples, or destruction by the believers' hands; al-Hasan says the hypocrites may wait for Satan's promises while the believers wait for Allah's promises to make His religion prevail.
Then the verses show that their spending is useless, since it comes from a flawed intention and will be only regret for them on the Day of Resurrection. The paper explains At-Tawbah 9:53: whether they spend willingly or unwillingly under their leaders' pressure, both are equal in not being accepted.
It was reported that Jadd ibn Qays said he could not resist women but would help with his wealth, and the verse was revealed about him; the paper says that reason is weak, and even if sound the verse is general. Not being accepted may mean the Messenger ﷺ will not accept it, or that Allah will not.
The verse then gives the reason, At-Tawbah 9:53; wrongdoing (fisq) is any going out, and means disbelief and disobedience. The paper's view is that disbelief is meant here, because of the detail in the next verse At-Tawbah 9:54. Three things prevented the acceptance of their spending in anything, in this expedition and others.
The first is disbelief in Allah and His Messenger; no deed is accepted without faith, and Allah accepts only from the mindful. The second is that they come to prayer only in laziness; the restriction shows this is their way in every prayer, since they hope for no reward and fear no punishment.
The third is that they spend only with unwilling souls, counting spending a loss. The word "unwilling" shows that the mere command to spend is a compulsion to them; mentioning improper prayer and insincere spending after disbelief, though disbelief alone suffices, indicates that their praying and spending show not faith but the depth of hypocrisy, prayer without spirit and spending without desire, and Allah knows best.
These hypocrites were wealthy, so the verse teaches the Prophet ﷺ and the community not to be impressed by abundant wealth and children, a source of misery for them in both worlds: At-Tawbah 9:55. Wealth and children bring them not happiness but misery and regret before the Hereafter; Allah has decreed that whoever loves something besides Him is punished by it in this world first, and whoever seeks honor from other than Allah is met by humiliation from what he sought.
The verses expose the falseness of their oaths that they are believers; fearing expulsion or being fought by the believers, they rush to swear they belong with them, while only pretending. The next verse details their terror: had they found a fortress, a cave or a tunnel, they would have fled into it in haste, out of dislike of the believers and fear of their hypocrisy being found out; the paper says it paints them hurrying to hide in panic and cowardice, as if seen before one's eyes.
Hypocrites discouraging others from going out
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:81-87. The paper cites Ibn ʿAbbas: the Prophet ﷺ ordered the people to set out in summer, and some said the heat was too severe, so Allah answered them, At-Tawbah 9:81, and ordered him to go out. The verses give practical evidence of the hypocrites' wrongdoing: their joy at sitting back and dislike of fighting, which kept them from going out with the Muslim ranks again.
The verses record three stances. The first is their joy at staying behind the Messenger ﷺ; calling them "those left behind" adds blame, since what held them back was their hypocrisy, their devil, weak will and weak faith, though it may be that Allah disliked their setting out, or that the Prophet ﷺ gave them leave; their joy shows the foulness of their inner selves.
The second is their dislike of jihad, which is strange, since the believer loves it as it raises his rank; the paper cites a sound hadith that standing an hour in Allah's way is better than a night of prayer in the Night of Power at the Black Stone, so one who dislikes jihad prefers only his body's comfort and his wealth.
The third is that they said, to discourage themselves and the believers, not to go out to fight in the heat, which shows their boldness and hard souls; the heat of Hell is many times greater. Any laughter from not going out is little in this world and followed by much weeping in the Hereafter.
The command form is a report of what they do, as most commentators say, and shows it is certain. The phrase about what they earned joins past and present, so they were and still are earning sin. Since their state is such, they must be cast far from the fighting ranks, for jihad is carried only by people of high resolve; so if he returns to Medina and some of them ask leave to go out, he should say the time has passed and they will never go out.
The paper explains At-Tawbah 9:83: the words about never fighting move from the hard to the harder, since fighting is harder than going out; or the second is plainer in emphasis; and it is said the two are general and specific, since they might fight the enemy without going out, as at the Confederates.
The reason for not giving them leave again is that they were called before and did not answer, when the need was greater, so they have no further share in good; only men can bear jihad, so their place is with those left behind.
The martyr is not prayed over as an honor to him, whereas those who fled the battle are not prayed over as an insult; so the divine prohibition came against praying over them or standing at their graves, since they disbelieved in Allah and His Messenger and died in rebellion; the verse is general though its cause was specific, covering those who died and those who will die.
If no material honor reaches them, neither will any moral honor, even admiration; a similar verse came earlier, so the repetition is either to stress the command and the danger of admiring them, since the trial of wealth and children is no small matter, or because it concerned other people.
Their wealth and children carry no weight in the believer's conscience, for they are like imitation men; when a surah ordering belief and jihad is revealed, the wealthy elite, mostly unguided to good because of their life of ease, ask leave. They were not content with asking leave but asked to stay with the women and other sitters, content with disgrace, so Allah sealed their hearts and no good reaches them; the first and last "with" differ: they had the Messenger's company in jihad but left it for the company of the sitters, so they do not understand Allah's commands or the wisdom of jihad.
Hypocrites mocking the believers
Surat al-Tawba mentions more than one case of the hypocrites mocking the believers, which Allah exposed; one is the reason for revelation of At-Tawbah 9:65-66. The paper cites ʿAbd Allah ibn ʿUmar: at Tabuk a man said he had never seen the like of these reciters of ours, greedier in belly, falser in tongue and more cowardly in battle; a man (in al-Tabari's narration, ʿAwf ibn Malik) said he lied and was a hypocrite, and would tell the Messenger ﷺ, and Quran came down; Ibn ʿUmar saw the man clinging to the Prophet's ﷺ camel rope, saying they were only jesting, while the Prophet ﷺ answered with the Quranic question and added nothing.
The paper explains that they would excuse it as jest, and the reply is rebuke: was there nothing but Allah and His rulings to mock; the excuse is worse than the offense, and what remains is disbelief after belief; whoever repents, Allah accepts his repentance, otherwise he is among the guilty.
Among their mockery in the expedition is At-Tawbah 9:79-80. The paper cites Abu Masʿud: when ordered to give charity they carried loads for hire, Abu ʿAqil brought half a measure and another brought more, and the hypocrites said Allah had no need of this one's charity and the other gave only to show off, so the verse was revealed.
The hypocrites were not content with withholding wealth but mocked those who gave, in this expedition, and the verses show their stance toward charity asked of them and charity others give freely. The Prophet ﷺ urged charity and each came with what he could: ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn ʿAwf brought much, and an Ansari named al-Habhab brought little, all he could; the hypocrites accused the large giver of showing off and sneered at the small giver; they did not know that, as the Prophet ﷺ said, a dirham can outstrip a hundred thousand: one man of great wealth gave a hundred thousand, and another with only two dirhams gave one.
Singling out those who find only their effort after the general group is specific after general, to soothe their hearts, since mockery of them was harsher; the mockers' punishment At-Tawbah 9:79 was that Allah dealt with them in kind, a mockery that loses them this world and the next.
Because the Prophet ﷺ, tender and kind, used to win hearts and ask forgiveness for people, his Lord told him that asking forgiveness for them or not is the same; the command is in the sense of a report, useless either way, and the Quran states this outright elsewhere, as in Al-Munafiqun 63:6.
The paper says the word "or" apparently allows choice. This is how the Prophet ﷺ understood it: in a sound hadith ʿUmar relates that when ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy died, his son asked the Prophet ﷺ for his shirt to shroud him, then to pray over him; ʿUmar asked whether he would pray when his Lord had forbidden it, and the Prophet ﷺ said Allah had given him a choice, At-Tawbah 9:80, and he would exceed seventy.
The verse then makes clear that even if he exceeded seventy, no forgiveness would reach them, because they disbelieved in Allah and His Messenger, and Allah does not guide the disbelievers to faith, since their deeds deserve this.
The Mosque of Harm
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:107-110. The paper cites Abu Ruhm al-Ghifari: those who built the Mosque of Harm (Masjid al-Dirar) came to the Prophet ﷺ as he prepared for Tabuk, saying they had built a mosque for the sick and needy on cold, rainy nights, and asked him to pray in it; he said he was about to travel; on his return Allah revealed At-Tawbah 9:107, and he sent Malik ibn al-Dukhshum and Maʿn ibn ʿAdi, or his brother ʿAsim, to demolish and burn it, and they did.
The verse may be linked to those practiced in hypocrisy, so that the mosque is part of their hidden scheming and its demolition part of their punishment in this world; or it may belong to the hypocrites' schemes in general. Some of Banu Ghanm ibn ʿAwf built a mosque to leave Quba mosque, near them, with false excuses that the verses exposed.
The verses show they built it for four aims. The first is to harm the believers, by building a mosque beside a mosque, with no benefit in it. The second is to bring or strengthen disbelief, by plotting against the Muslims; it may be disbelief in belief, and Ibn al-ʿArabi says building it for harm, believing Quba and the Prophet's mosque have no sanctity, was disbelief by that belief.
The third is to divide the believers, who gather in the mosque for prayer, growing in affection and unity of word, a great purpose of congregational prayer; mosques multiplied for no need divide the word.
The fourth is to prepare a place awaiting Abu ʿAmir the monk, one of the Christianized Arabs who hoped to lead his people; seeing the Muslims' victory he fled to the polytheists and incited them, tried at Uhud to make some Ansar slip, and fought the Muslims until Hunayn, when he despaired; he went to the king of the Romans, who promised troops, and told his people to build a stronghold; they built the mosque before the Prophet ﷺ left for Tabuk, a lying-in-wait for one who had fought Allah and His Messenger before.
Ibn ʿAbbas says some Ansar built a mosque and Abu ʿAmir told them to prepare strength and weapons, as he was going to Caesar to bring Roman troops to drive out Muhammad and his Companions; when finished they asked the Prophet ﷺ to pray in it, and Allah revealed At-Tawbah 9:108.
The Quran then says they will swear they intended only the best, which the paper takes as easing things for the Muslims, such as prayer for the weak when a flood cuts the road, or as meaning Paradise; this sounds good but is evil within, and the Quran recorded their lie.
Because it was not built on obedience, Allah forbade His Messenger ﷺ to pray in it, since his prayer would count as approval of the place and its people; leaving it does not delay prayer, as the mosque founded on mindfulness from the first day exists; the flow suggests it is Quba mosque, as Ibn ʿAbbas, ʿUrwa, Qatada and others hold, but Abu Saʿid al-Khudri reports that the Prophet ﷺ, asked which mosque it was, struck the ground with pebbles and said it was this mosque of his, the mosque of Medina.
The paper says the story favors Quba, but a sound hadith must be followed, and this is sound; scholars reconcile them, al-Suhayli saying both were founded on mindfulness and both are meant, as saying a righteous man is more worthy of company does not limit it to one person.
Allah then praised its people, men who love to purify themselves; some narrations say physical purity is meant, which shows inner soundness, so they purify themselves of sins outward and inward to win Allah's love. The comparison is between the builders of the two mosques; the question is one of affirmation: is one who founded his building on Allah's pleasure better than one who founded it on the weakest base, a crumbling brink, so the result must be collapse, ruin and shame; this parable reveals the hypocrites' weakest state.
The paper asks whether it is a parable of the hypocrites' state; it is possible, and the literal meaning is not excluded, so their building collapsed into the Fire; Jabir says he saw smoke rise from the Mosque of Harm when it collapsed in the Prophet's ﷺ time.
The same is reported from Qatada, al-Suddi, Sufyan, al-Dahhak and others; its people prayed in it only Friday, Saturday and Sunday, and some Companions demolished it on Monday after the divine command. The verse closes with Allah's way with the wrongdoers: He does not guide them to good, since they wronged themselves.
The disgrace of their act never leaves them; the building remains a doubt in their hearts, doubt when building it for fear of exposure, doubt at its demolition as their hypocrisy was shown to all, and a rancor that only the cutting of their hearts by death will remove; it is also said, by repentance, when their Lord accepts and pardons them.
The paper concludes that what is for Allah lasts and what is for other than Him is cut off; a sound intention is blessed, while a deed that looks good with an unsound intention turns against its doer, and the Mosque of Harm is the best witness.
Allah says Ar-Ra'd 13:17. The paper draws from the verses that one should not swell the numbers of the people of disbelief and hypocrisy or attend their gatherings even if they look good, for whoever swells a people's numbers is of them. Al-Qurtubi says every mosque built for harm, show or fame is in the ruling of the Mosque of Harm, and prayer in it is not permitted; the paper adds that it is recommended to pray in mosques founded on obedience and filled with people of goodness, and a mosque is praised not for its furnishings but for the men raised on its guidance.
The attempt to kill the Prophet ﷺ
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:74.
The paper says a group of commentators take the plan they did not achieve to be their attempt to kill the Messenger ﷺ, with sound narrations; it cites Ahmad from Abu al-Tufayl that when the Prophet ﷺ returned from Tabuk he had a caller announce that he was taking the mountain pass and none should take it, and while Hudhayfa led his camel and ʿAmmar drove it, masked riders came and crowded ʿAmmar, who struck their mounts' faces; the Prophet ﷺ told Hudhayfa to stop, and after descending asked ʿAmmar whether he knew the men, and ʿAmmar said he knew most of the mounts and the men were masked; he said they had wanted to stampede his camel and throw him down.
The hypocrites deliberately swear falsely, and they spoke the word of disbelief and planned to kill the Messenger ﷺ, a foul crime whose burden and shame the Quran recorded against them until the Day of Judgment; the paper finds it astonishing that they repaid his kindness with the worst harm, for they were poor and without means and Allah enriched them with spoils and His Messenger ﷺ with his gifts until they became well off, so is this what they resent about faith.
Those who stayed behind from the expedition
From the paper: «المخلفون عن الغزوة»
Kinds of those who stayed behind
Reasons for staying behind from Tabuk varied, and the stance toward each differed; Ibn Kathir sums up four kinds: those ordered to stay and rewarded, such as ʿAli ibn Abi Talib, Muhammad ibn Maslama and Ibn Umm Maktum; the excused, the weak, sick and poor, who are the weepers; sinful disobedient ones, the Three and Abu Lubaba and his companions; and others blamed and condemned, the hypocrites.
For the first kind, a sound hadith says the Prophet ﷺ left ʿAli in charge, and when ʿAli asked whether he was leaving him with the children and women, he said ʿAli was to him as Harun was to Musa, except that there is no prophet after him.
The paper details the other three kinds, as Quranic lessons came about them.
1. The excused
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:91-92. The paper notes the verse was covered earlier, and adds there is also no blame on those who had the means to spend but found no mount. They came to the Prophet ﷺ with eyes overflowing with tears of sorrow at finding nothing to spend.
Allah and His Messenger gave some of the needy a mount, among them the Ashʿaris, whose story Abu Musa tells: his companions sent him to ask the Prophet ﷺ for mounts in the Army of Hardship, which is Tabuk; the Prophet ﷺ swore he would not mount them on anything, and Abu Musa returned sad, fearing the Prophet ﷺ was displeased with him.
Soon Bilal called him; the Prophet ﷺ told him to take six camels and tell his companions that Allah, or His Messenger, mounts them on these. Others found the spending not enough and went back weeping at missing their share of good; from their grief they are known in the books as the Weepers (al-bakkaʾun), and the books preserved their names.
Ibn Ishaq says the Weepers were seven men of the Ansar and others of Banu ʿAmr ibn ʿAwf: Salim ibn ʿUmayr, ʿUlba ibn Zayd, Abu Layla ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn Kaʿb, ʿAmr ibn Humam ibn al-Jamuh, ʿAbd Allah ibn al-Mughaffal al-Muzani (some say ʿAbd Allah ibn ʿAmr al-Muzani), Harami ibn ʿAbd Allah and al-ʿIrbad ibn Sariya al-Fazari.
The second kind is believers who mixed a good deed with a bad one. Allah says At-Tawbah 9:102-103. This is another kind of those who stayed behind, and the verse is joined to what Allah says about the Bedouins around them At-Tawbah 9:101. The paper says they are not hypocrites but believers whom Satan made slip, so they sat out from fighting; they mixed the bad deed, leaving the fight, with the good, repentance, excuse and regret, and admitting the sin gives more hope of acceptance; Allah willing they are fit for Him to turn to them.
The paper cites Ibn ʿAbbas: ten stayed behind at Tabuk, and as the Prophet ﷺ's return drew near seven tied themselves to the mosque pillars; told they were Abu Lubaba and his companions, who had sworn that no one would free them but him, he swore he would not free or excuse them until Allah freed them, since they had turned from him and stayed back; they replied they would not free themselves until Allah did, and Allah revealed At-Tawbah 9:102, and then the Prophet ﷺ freed and excused them.
Then Allah ordered His Messenger ﷺ to take charity from their wealth to cleanse them of their laziness and purify their souls; the paper says this is a continuing Quranic remedy for everyone who mixes good and bad deeds, and the door of repentance is wide open in Surat al-Tawba.
3. The hypocrites who stayed behind
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:93-96. The earlier verses described the believers who found nothing to spend and are excused; the blame is on the well-off, who have no real excuse, so these verses cut off their excuse and compare them with the sincere believers. There is no way against the weak and those who find nothing, since they gave all they could; blame and punishment fall on those who ask leave while well-off, with nothing preventing them.
What drove them to cowardice was the lowness of their souls and content with humiliation, placing themselves with the infirm, women and children, through Allah's forsaking them, as He sealed their hearts so they did not know jihad's benefit, a result of laziness and love of safety.
Allah informs His Prophet ﷺ what they will do when the Muslims return, an unseen miracle: they will make excuses to form a public opinion that overlooks their shameful act; but he is told to say that their excuse is no excuse, they will not be believed, revelation has exposed them, and Allah and His Messenger will see all their coming deeds.
The paper says this gives them time and tempts them to repent, and afterward they will return to Allah, who will repay them for all their deeds; the Quran turns to the Knower of the unseen and the witnessed so they know He is aware of their hidden selves, a threat; some of their deeds may be hidden from them but not from the All-Aware.
What the Quran foretold happened: they came to make excuses. Kaʿb ibn Malik tells in his fine hadith that when the Prophet ﷺ returned from Tabuk he sat for the people, and those who stayed behind, about eighty-odd men, came making excuses and swearing; the Prophet ﷺ accepted their outward words, took their pledge, asked forgiveness for them and left their secrets to Allah; Kaʿb says that after guiding him to Islam, Allah gave him no greater blessing than his truthfulness to the Prophet ﷺ, so he did not lie and perish as those did who lied, about whom Allah said the worst, At-Tawbah 9:95-96.
They stressed their false excuses with oaths, which the Quran foretold before they swore, aiming that the believers stop harming them and overlook their act. The Quranic direction to the believers is to turn away from them; they wanted a turning away of overlooking, but got a turning away of hatred and contempt.
This is what they deserve because they are filth (rijs), so leave reproaching them, since reproach is for one whose affection you wish to keep; they are clothed in moral impurity, and their refuge is Hell; the meaning may also be not to come near them because their nature is contagious, but the paper prefers the first.
After trying with oaths to make the believers turn away, they swear their strongest oaths to please them; even if one imagines the believers will be pleased, does that mean Allah's pleasure, never. Another kind of hypocrites are the Bedouins, who also came to excuse themselves to the Messenger ﷺ.
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:90. The paper says the word for the excuse-makers shows their excuse was not real. Al-Farra says the one who excuses himself in this form is one who does so without an excuse. These made excuses and were excused, while the hypocrites sat back and some did not even excuse themselves; Abu ʿAmr ibn al-ʿAla says both groups did wrong: some forced a false excuse, those meant by At-Tawbah 9:90, and some stayed back without an excuse, in boldness against Allah, the hypocrites, whom Allah threatened with painful punishment.
This threat is to the disbelievers of both kinds, the excuse-makers and the sitters. The paper says Surat al-Tawba, among the last revealed, shows the classes of society, among them the Bedouins, whose desert life gives harshness of nature; they are worse in disbelief and hypocrisy than townspeople and most ignorant of Allah's limits; of their kind is a group who see their spending as a heavy fine, spending with no hope of reward or fear of punishment because compelled, and awaiting misfortune for the Muslims so as not to pay.
The verses return to the hypocrites of Medina and around it so the believers beware of them; some, among the Bedouins who accepted Islam too, are practiced in hypocrisy, hiding it so skillfully that even the discerning Messenger ﷺ did not know their state, but Allah knows them and will punish them.
The story of the three who were left behind
Allah says At-Tawbah 9:106. And He says At-Tawbah 9:118. Both verses were revealed about the Three who were left behind; the first is not explicit, but most commentators hold it was about them, while the second is plain text about them. The word for those deferred means put back, from the word for delay, as in Al-A'raf 7:111.
It is read with and without the hamza. They are deferred to Allah's decree, either to punish them or turn to them, their matter hanging between fear and hope; Mujahid, Qatada, al-Dahhak and Muqatil hold it was about the Three, as most commentators prefer. The second verse is joined to At-Tawbah 9:117.
The meaning is that Allah turned to the Prophet, the Emigrants and Ansar, and to the Three, whose earth and souls became narrow through regret and distress, and who were certain there is no refuge from Allah but in Him; then Allah granted them return to His pleasure.
It was revealed about Kaʿb ibn Malik, Hilal ibn Umayya and Murara ibn al-Rabiʿ, in an emphatic statement showing Allah's great favor on the truthful who were with the Prophet ﷺ, to whom the Three are then joined; "left behind" may mean left from the expedition out of laziness, not hypocrisy, or left from acceptance of repentance, unlike the excuse-makers the Prophet ﷺ accepted; the paper prefers the second, since the earth narrowed for them over that, not over their staying behind from the expedition.
Kaʿb himself says it is not their being left from the expedition but Allah's deferring their matter, unlike those who swore and excused themselves and were accepted. Because their repentance was delayed, three things came to them. First, the earth became narrow for them despite its breadth.
Second, their own souls became narrow for them. Third, they realized there is no escape from Allah but to Him; then Allah enabled them to repent and accepted it by His grace and generosity.
The two Sahih collections have Kaʿb's account, a long hadith rich in benefits, including: blame reaches every individual who stayed behind, the hypocrites were not killed, the gravity of disobedience, the strong in religion is held to account more than the weak, one may report his own shortcoming, one who sees a chance for obedience should hurry, the sinner's weeping in sorrow is recommended, rulings are applied to appearances, truthful speech is of great value, and rebuke by shunning is permissible.
The Prophetic leadership in the expedition
From the paper: «القيادة النبوية في الغزوة»
The Prophet's ﷺ leadership of the sincere believers at Tabuk was great, as the paper sums up in several matters. First, attention to places of warning when passing them. Ibn ʿUmar reports that passing al-Hijr, the Prophet ﷺ told them not to enter the dwellings of those who wronged themselves unless weeping, lest what struck them strike the Muslims, and covered his head on his mount.
This was so the people take a lesson from what befell the earlier deniers, fear worldly punishment, and grasp the wisdom of passing places of punishment. Second, care for the soldiers, living and dead. Ibn Masʿud tells of Dhu al-Bijadayn: at night he followed a flame at the edge of the camp and found the Prophet ﷺ with Abu Bakr and ʿUmar at the grave of ʿAbd Allah Dhu al-Bijadayn al-Muzani, who had died; the Prophet ﷺ stood in it as they lowered him and prayed that Allah be pleased with him; Ibn Masʿud wished he were in the grave.
It shows his care for all the soldiers and the sincere poor Companions, in life and death. Third, his concern for his Companions' safety. Abu Humayd reports that at Tabuk the Prophet ﷺ said a strong wind would blow that night, so none should stand in it and whoever had a camel should tie it; a man who stood was carried by the wind to the two mountains of Tayyiʾ.
The paper says this shows his prophethood, telling of the wind before it blew, and his great concern for their safety. Fourth, firmness and seriousness. It shows in several stances, among them firmness with whoever lagged and punishment of believers who stayed behind. Fifth, among the blessings of his leadership, multiplied water and food.
This is a sign of prophethood; Muʿadh ibn Jabal reports that the Prophet ﷺ told them they would reach the spring of Tabuk the next day, not before midmorning, and none should touch its water until he came; two men had got there first, and he rebuked them.
They scooped a little at a time into a vessel, he washed his hands and face in it and returned it, and the spring flowed abundantly until people drew their fill; he told Muʿadh that if he lived long he would see this place filled with gardens.
The paper says this shows his firm reproach of whoever disobeyed, a prominent mark of this expedition, his blessing, and his report of the unseen that came true; the same happened with food: he prayed at ʿUmar's request for blessing on the pooled provisions, and every container in the camp was filled, and some was left.
It also shows his mercy, his acceptance of ʿUmar's counsel, concern to supply the army, and a sign of his prophethood. Sixth, marching by night. The Muslims covered most stages to Tabuk at night to escape the heat, as modern armies do; the paper says Tabuk was a hard training to prepare them to protect the spread of Islam beyond Arabia and form a far-reaching state, and as it was his last expedition, he needed to be sure of his soldiers before joining the highest company.
Lessons drawn from the expedition
From the paper: «الدروس المستفادة من غزوةتبوك»
The Muslims did not fight at Tabuk; they stayed twenty days while rulers of the Syrian lands made peace and paid the jizya, among them the king of Ayla and the king of Dumat al-Jandal, whom Khalid ibn al-Walid captured and who ransomed himself with two thousand camels, eight hundred head and four hundred mail coats; Jarba and Adhruh also agreed to pay; though costless to the Muslims, it had great effects.
Outside, it showed the Muslims' strength, confirmed control of Arabia's northern borders, and made the Christianized Arabs under Rome reconsider their loyalty. Its benefits for the community were many; lessons include these.
Lessons
- Muslims were struck only by betrayal from within; the hypocrites harm the community more than its open enemy, being of our own people.
- The leader of the Muslim ranks must purge them; al-Shafiʿi drew this from Surat al-Tawba, saying the imam may not let one known by the hypocrites' description fight with him, since he seeks strife and may harm them more than their enemy; Ibn Qudama says the commander should not take a discourager, rumor-monger, spy or one who sows enmity, citing At-Tawbah 9:46-47.
- "Only the one susceptible is tempted" is true; what puts a person in temptation is only his own inner readiness for it.
- It revealed many traits of the hypocrites: cowardice, taking every cry to be against them; they want discord, make false excuses, mock the believers, swear falsely, mock Allah's verses and Messenger, rejoice in sitting back, hide their hypocrisy, and use mosques for their falsehood.
- Jihad is the touchstone distinguishing believer from hypocrite: the hypocrite may show some obedience but cannot sacrifice self and wealth, being attached to the world, whose near gains tempt him out.
- The liar is bound to be exposed, his hidden self showing in his tongue, face and deeds.
- The worst two traits are cowardice and miserliness, which the hypocrites combined.
- There is no blame on one who gives what he can, even if little, for Allah blesses it, and asked which charity is best, the Prophet ﷺ said the effort of the one with little; so believers must not be mocked or their deeds belittled, and whoever mocks a believer is repaid in kind.
- Asking forgiveness is not permitted for one whose hypocrisy is known from his words and deeds; whoever begins in wrongdoing will not reach guidance, and Allah makes the heart of one who swerves swerve.
- A sign of true faith is love of jihad and longing to give and be martyred, so that the weak kept back weep over losing their share.
- The Muslim strives against his self even if it makes sitting back look good; Abu Khaythama left his family and hurried off on comparing himself with the sincere fighters.
- Fighting in the sacred months is permissible.
- Mocking religion and the righteous is grave.
- Take warning from the remains of earlier peoples, remembering the fate of those who left guidance.
- Consultation matters: he accepted Abu Bakr's counsel to supplicate in severe thirst, and ʿUmar's not to slaughter the camels in famine and to return to Medina, not cross Syria's borders.
- When the imam calls the army out, going out is binding and none may stay behind without his leave, even if each is not named; this is one of three cases where jihad is an individual duty, the others being when the enemy is at the town and when the ranks meet.
- The Prophet ﷺ did not kill the hypocrites though word of their open disbelief reached him; some cite this to say a heretic (zindiq) who shows repentance is not killed, since they swore they had not said it, which is repentance if not denial.
- Places of disobedience may be burned and demolished, as the Prophet ﷺ did the Mosque of Harm, though prayer took place in it, since it was built for harm, dividing the believers and sheltering hypocrites; the imam must put any such place out of use, by demolition, burning or changing its form.
Takeaways
Betrayal from within
The paper says the Muslims were struck only through betrayal from within, and that the hypocrites harm the community more than its open enemy.
Jihad as the touchstone
The paper says jihad distinguishes believer from hypocrite, since the hypocrite cannot sacrifice self and wealth, being attached to the world.
Do not belittle small gifts
The paper says there is no blame on one who gives what he can, even if little, for Allah blesses it. It adds that believers must not be mocked or their good deeds belittled, whatever their size.
Consultation
The paper points to the importance of consultation, shown in accepting the counsel of Abu Bakr and ʿUmar during the expedition.
Learn from earlier peoples
The paper says one should take warning from the remains of earlier peoples and not pass them heedlessly.
Reflect
- When a duty feels heavy or costly, what pulls you toward staying where you are comfortable?
- How do you respond when someone gives less than others, or more, than you expected?
- When you have fallen short, do you hurry back as Abu Khaythama did, or put it off?
Every verse in the paper
All 60 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.
Introducing the Expedition of Tabuk «التعريف بغزوة تبوك»
Its names «أولًا: أسماؤها»
When the expedition took place «ثانيًا: زمان الغزوة»
Why the Expedition of Tabuk is told in Surat al-Tawba «ثالثًا: حكمة ذكر غزوة تبوك في سورة التوبة»
Causes of the expedition «أسباب الغزوة»
The believers' stance in the expedition «موقف المؤمنين في الغزوة»
Responding to the call to march «أولًا: الاستجابة للأمر بالنفير»
9:38, 9:39, 9:40, 9:88-89, 9:117, 9:120-121
Hastening to spend in Allah's way «ثانيًا: المسارعة بالإنفاق في سبيل الله»
The stance of the poor «ثالثًا: موقف الفقراء»
The hypocrites' stance in the expedition «موقف المنافقين في الغزوة»
Hypocrites asking leave to stay out of jihad «أولًا: استئذان المنافقين للقعود عن الجهاد»
9:42, 9:43, 9:45, 9:47, 3:122, 9:49, 9:50, 9:52, 9:53, 9:54, 9:55
Hypocrites discouraging others from going out «ثانيًا: تثبيط المنافقين للمؤمنين عن الخروج للجهاد»
Hypocrites mocking the believers «ثالثًا: لمز المنافقين للمؤمنين»
The Mosque of Harm «رابعًا: مسجد الضرار»
The attempt to kill the Prophet ﷺ «خامسًا: محاولة قتل النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم»
Those who stayed behind from the expedition «المخلفون عن الغزوة»
Kinds of those who stayed behind «أولًا: أنواع المخلفين»
9:91-92, 9:102-103, 9:101, 9:93-96, 9:90
The story of the three who were left behind «ثانيًا: قصة الثلاثة الذين خلفوا»
Lessons drawn from the expedition «الدروس المستفادة من غزوةتبوك»
About this source
موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم
مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية
- Volume
- 13
- Research paper
- «غزوة تبوك» (Expedition of Tabuk)
Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.
This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.