Prophetic Biography · Quran topic

Battle of Uhud

غزوة أحد · Ghazwat Uhud

The Battle of Uhud: its causes, scenes, Quranic guidance, the Prophet's leadership and lessons

47 verses · 7 parts · 61 min read

Study guide based on

موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم

مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية

«غزوة أحد» · Volume 13

At a glance

The paper studies the Battle of Uhud, named for the mountain beside which it was fought. It took place on Saturday, mid-Shawwal, in the third year after the Hijra. The Quran does not name it, but fifty-eight verses of Surat Al Imran speak of it. The paper says these verses describe the battle precisely and train the Muslim community.

The paper says the causes were many events accumulated over a long time, beginning with Quraysh barring people from Islam. After Badr, Quraysh needed to restore its standing. Its nobles agreed to equip an army from the caravan Abu Sufyan had brought back. The Muslims' raiding parties, which hurt Quraysh's trade, were another cause.

Before the battle the Prophet ﷺ learned of Quraysh's intent from a letter from al-ʿAbbas. His own view was to stay in Medina, but he followed the majority when they differed. On the way, Ibn Ubayy withdrew with a third of the army. The archers left the post the Prophet ﷺ had given them, and the polytheist horse entered from there. A rumor spread that the Prophet ﷺ had been killed. The next day the Prophet's ﷺ caller announced pursuit of the enemy. The paper says what happened at Uhud is not properly called a defeat, nor a victory for either side.

After the battle the Quran gave the believers guidance, including the prohibition of ghulul and the merit of martyrdom. The paper then lists signs of the Prophet's ﷺ leadership, from gathering information about the enemy to patience under harm. It closes with lessons drawn from the battle.

Key verses

  1. Ali 'Imran 3:152-154: Muhammad ibn Kaʿb al-Qurazi reports that when the Companions asked how the losses came despite the promise of victory, Allah revealed Ali 'Imran 3:152, and the archers are meant. The paper explains that the victory Allah showed them was the rout of the polytheists before the archers left the places the Prophet ﷺ had given them. For Ali 'Imran 3:154, the paper says Allah cast drowsiness over the believers after their distress, to make them forget it and renew their energy. It also says the hypocrites cleared themselves of blame for the Muslims' suffering and put it on others.
  2. Ali 'Imran 3:121: The paper says the passage on Uhud begins with this verse, which opens the first stage of preparing for battle. Allah used it to show how the Prophet's ﷺ leadership went from the start of the battle. The paper explains that he showed the believers their positions and straightened the lines himself.
  3. Ali 'Imran 3:144: The paper says verses came down after the rumor of the Prophet's ﷺ death, establishing that he is a human being who will die like others and is set apart only by the message. Ibn Kathir reports that the rumor brought weakness and holding back from fighting, and that the verse came down about it. Ibn al-Qayyim says Allah rebuked them for turning back, since their duty was to hold to the religion and die on it.
  4. Ali 'Imran 3:169: The paper says Allah praised the martyrs of Uhud, who fulfilled their pledge to Him. It cites Ibn ʿAbbas's report that their souls are in green birds in Paradise and that they asked for their brothers to be told they are alive. It explains that the verse forbids thinking the martyrs dead, since they are alive with their Lord.
  5. Ali 'Imran 3:167: The paper says Allah described the hypocrites and their role in the battle with this verse. Al-Tabari explains that it refers to ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy and his men, who turned back from the Messenger ﷺ at Uhud. The paper explains that before that day they showed faith, but by leaving the believers' army they moved nearer to disbelief. It adds that their excuse was untrue, since their hearts held hypocrisy.
  6. Al-Ahzab 33:23: Anas reports that they thought this verse came down about Anas ibn al-Nadr and his like, who was found with over eighty wounds at Uhud. The paper says the commentators mention that it came down about some martyrs of Uhud. It adds that the verse seems to apply to everyone killed in Allah's cause after striving with sincerity and steadfastness.
  7. Ali 'Imran 3:140: The paper says Uhud is not properly called a defeat or a victory, but may be called wounds for the Muslims, as the Quran named it in this verse. It calls the wording about taking martyrs a wondrous expression: martyrs are chosen by Allah, so their death is selection and honor, not loss. The paper also cites the verse among those that console the believers for what befell them.
  8. Ali 'Imran 3:146: The paper says that at the battle's end Allah told of earlier prophets whose followers did not weaken at wounds or killing in their Lord's cause. Al-Saʿdi explains that this consoles the believers and urges them to follow those people. He says their hearts did not weaken, nor did they humble themselves to the enemy, but they were patient and steadfast.
  9. Al-Anfal 8:36: The paper explains that these disbelievers spent their wealth to bar the way of truth by fighting the Messenger ﷺ and raising armies, as Quraysh did at Badr, Uhud and the Confederates. It says their spending turns into regret before they are finally overcome. The paper reports that Allah revealed this verse after the nobles of Quraysh agreed to fund the war.
  10. Ali 'Imran 3:156: The paper explains that believers are forbidden to take on the disbelievers' saying about their brothers who died or were killed traveling for trade or war, that had they stayed with them they would not have died or been killed. It says this brings those disbelievers distress and heartache, and that they do not know that Allah gives life and death, so neither travel nor fighting kills and staying home does not give life. It then quotes the verse. Al-Tabari adds that it is said those meant are ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy ibn Salul and his men. The paper says such sayings were used after Uhud to stir grief in the families of the martyrs.
  11. Ali 'Imran 3:165: The paper cites Anas that seventy of the Ansar were killed at Uhud, and says this fits the verse. It explains that the verse ends by telling the believers of Allah's power joined with His justice, after saying the blow came from themselves.
  12. Ali 'Imran 3:161: The paper says Allah denies ghulul of His Prophet ﷺ in this verse. It explains that this is not in his nature at all, so the denial is of the act's very possibility. It adds, citing al-Kalbi and Muqatil, that it came down when the archers left their post for spoils, and that the correct view is that it belongs to this battle.

Words to know

غزوة أحد ghazwat Uhud

The Battle of Uhud, named for Mount Uhud, a red mountain about a mile north of Medina, beside which it was fought.

Introducing the Battle of Uhud

From the paper: «التعريف بغزوة أحد»

Its name, time and place

The battle is named after Mount Uhud, where it took place: a red mountain, Uhud being a name coined for it alone, about a mile north of Medina. It is said it was called Uhud because it stands apart from the other mountains there, or because its people supported the oneness of Allah (al-tawhid). On this view Allah gave it a name derived from oneness (al-ahadiyya) to match its meaning, since its people, the Ansar, supported tawhid and the Prophet ﷺ, who settled beside it in life and death.

The passage adds that the Prophet ﷺ loved odd numbers as a sign of oneness and changed names that clashed with tawhid, and that Uhud's vowels express raising, pointing to the elevation of the religion of the One, so he loved it in name and substance.

The battle took place on Saturday, mid-Shawwal, in the third year after the Hijra.

Why it is recounted in Surat Al Imran

The Quran never names the Battle of Uhud, but refers to it implicitly in Surat Al Imran, where fifty-eight verses speak of it, beginning with the first stage of preparing for battle, Ali 'Imran 3:121. They end with a comprehensive comment on the battle's results and the wisdom Allah intended by it, Ali 'Imran 3:179.

The paper says these verses describe the battle precisely and train the Muslim community, with lessons for every time and place. Abu Yaʿla, Ibn al-Mundhir and Ibn Abi Hatim report that al-Miswar ibn Makhrama asked his maternal uncle ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn ʿAwf about their story at Uhud, and he told him to read Al Imran from Ali 'Imran 3:121 onward.

Ibn ʿAshur explains that the battle is mentioned here because it is among the clearest displays of the scheming of the hypocrites; since the hypocrites of the Jews and of Yathrib were alike and acted on what the Jews planned, Allah brought both groups' schemes together by recounting Uhud, and the surah came down after the battle.

The paper concludes that the Muslims suffered from the Jews and hypocrites working together, the Jews planning and the hypocrites carrying out, so the Quran's method was to warn against both together. Al-Razi explains that after Ali 'Imran 3:120, Allah followed with what shows His way with them in granting help and warding off the enemy when they persevere and fear Him, and the opposite when they do not, in Ali 'Imran 3:121: at Uhud they were many but were defeated when they disobeyed the Messenger, while at Badr they were few and unprepared but won when they obeyed.

So al-Razi sees the link as explaining the cause of the defeat, an inevitable result of abandoning perseverance and taqwa. Abu Hayyan comments on the passage that begins Ali 'Imran 3:121. The passage runs up to Ali 'Imran 3:154. He explains the link with what comes before: after forbidding them to take disbelievers as intimates and promising them safety from their schemes, Allah reminded them of a time when some readily followed hypocrites, when ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy ibn Salul withdrew from the Prophet ﷺ at Uhud, followed by three hundred men, hypocrites and some believers.

So Abu Hayyan sees these verses as a reminder that some believers followed the hypocrites at Uhud, doing what Allah warned against in Ali 'Imran 3:118. The paper judges that all these links fit, but that Ibn ʿAshur's view is the most likely, Allah knows best: the verses before Uhud warn strongly against the Jews, then the Uhud verses speak of the hypocrites led by ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy, completing the picture of the alliance between Jews and hypocrites.

The paper adds that Al Imran came down after al-Anfal, both treat Badr and Uhud in detail, and both share concepts such as the causes of victory and defeat, hypocrisy, blessing and triumph, and trial and purification (al-tamhis). So, the paper says, the picture is completed by Al Imran's account of Uhud.

Causes of the battle

From the paper: «أسباب الغزوة»

The paper says the causes of Uhud were many accumulated events over a long period: from the Prophet's ﷺ mission onward, Quraysh worked constantly to bar people from Allah's religion, keep them from Islam, and destroy the Muslims and their state. Allah says Al-Anfal 8:36.

The paper quotes an explanation that these disbelievers spent their wealth to bar the way of truth by fighting the Messenger ﷺ and raising armies, as the leaders of Quraysh did at Badr, Uhud and the Confederates; Allah foretold this unseen matter as a miracle, the wealth itself turning into regret before their final defeat, and the verse's closing warning concerns those who persisted in disbelief, since some of them later embraced Islam and practised it well Al-Anfal 8:36.

So among the chief causes of Uhud, the paper says, were barring people from Allah's way and from Islam, and fighting the Prophet ﷺ to end the call to Islam. This was especially so after Quraysh's heavy defeat at Badr, where its nobles were killed and its leadership lost; the Arabs prized victory and saw defeat as a disgrace to be washed away, so Quraysh had to restore its standing at any cost in effort, wealth and sacrifice.

When Abu Sufyan brought back their caravan, he left it untouched at Dar al-Nadwa, and their nobles agreed to equip an army from it to fight the Messenger ﷺ. ʿAbd Allah ibn Abi Rabiʿa, ʿIkrima ibn Abi Jahl, al-Harith ibn Hisham, Huwaytib ibn ʿAbd al-ʿUzza and Safwan ibn Umayya, with men who had lost fathers, sons and brothers at Badr, asked Abu Sufyan and the caravan's owners to fund the war for revenge, and Abu Sufyan said he would be the first to agree.

Another cause was the Muslims' raiding parties, which hurt Quraysh's trade, built on the winter journey to Yemen and the summer journey to Syria, and besieged them; Safwan ibn Umayya complained that Muhammad and his companions had blocked their trade routes along the coast, that staying home would eat up their capital, and that they lived by trading to Syria in summer and Abyssinia in winter.

The Messenger ﷺ sent Zayd ibn Haritha to al-Qarada: after Badr, Quraysh had taken the Iraq route to Syria, with traders including Abu Sufyan carrying much silver and a guide from Banu Bakr ibn Waʾil, Furat ibn Hayyan. Zayd met them at that watering place and seized the caravan and its goods while the men escaped, bringing it to the Messenger ﷺ at the start of Jumada al-Ula, twenty-eight months after the Hijra, six months after Badr.

The paper says this raid was a crushing loss that broke Quraysh's economy and filled it with grief, so it hastened to prepare a decisive battle, rallying a large army to destroy the Muslims and their call, avenge its dead at Badr, restore its standing, and curb the Muslims' raiding parties that tightened the siege around it.

Preparing for the battle

From the paper: «الإعداد للغزوة»

The preparation of the polytheists

After Badr, the paper says, Quraysh took direct practical steps: they prepared actively to fight the Prophet ﷺ and his Companions, sought to swell their ranks by influencing the clans, and began collecting vast sums to wipe away their disgrace. Abu Sufyan left the returned caravan at Dar al-Nadwa untouched, and Quraysh's nobles, among them men who had lost relatives at Badr, asked him and the caravan's owners to fund the war for revenge; he was the first to agree.

So Allah revealed Al-Anfal 8:36. Al-Tabari explains that the disbelievers give their wealth to fellow polytheists to fight the Messenger ﷺ and the believers and turn people from faith, but the spending becomes regret, for the wealth is gone and they fail to put out Allah's light; then the believers overcome them and they are gathered to Hell.

Al-Tabari continues that the regret is great for the living, who lost their wealth in vain and returned beaten, and for the dead, who were killed and hastened to the Fire forever; as reported, Abu Sufyan handled this spending. They asked Abu Sufyan to hold back the caravan, Quraysh's merchandise, to equip an army against Muhammad; he said he and Banu ʿAbd Manaf would be first, since his son Hanzala and his nobles were killed at Badr. The caravan stayed held until they prepared to march to Uhud, then was sold for gold, which stayed with Abu Sufyan.

It is also said they asked him to sell it and set aside profits; it was a thousand camels, the money fifty thousand dinars. Muqatil and al-Kalbi say the verse came down about the twelve men of Quraysh who fed the army at Badr, each slaughtering ten camels a day (the paper names them, from Abu Jahl to al-ʿAbbas ibn ʿAbd al-Muttalib).

Saʿid ibn Jubayr and Ibn Abza say it came down about Abu Sufyan, who at Uhud hired two thousand of the Ahabish to fight the Prophet ﷺ, besides the Arabs who answered him. Al-Hakam ibn ʿUtayba says Abu Sufyan spent forty uqiyas of gold on the polytheists at Uhud, and the verse came down about him.

Ibn Kathir says that in any case the verse is general, even if its occasion was specific: the disbelievers spend their wealth to bar people from the way of truth, and then it will be gone. Quraysh mobilized three thousand fighters with women, slaves, its Ahabish and followers from Kinana and Tihama.

When its forces were complete, on Saturday the seventh of Shawwal in the third year after the Hijra, they brought women along so the men would not flee: Abu Sufyan, the commander, brought Hind bint ʿUtba; Safwan ibn Umayya brought Barza; ʿIkrima ibn Abi Jahl brought Umm Hakim; al-Harith ibn Hisham brought Fatima.

The paper says these women played a prominent role, reciting poetry and rousing the men against the shame of defeat. Jubayr ibn Mutʿim told his Abyssinian slave Wahshi, a javelin thrower who rarely missed, that if he killed Hamza, Muhammad's uncle, in return for Jubayr's uncle Tuʿayma, he would be free.

The paper says Abu Sufyan also used cunning to make his men stand firm: he told the standard-bearers of Banu ʿAbd al-Dar that an army is attacked through its banners, so they should either guard theirs or leave it to others. They were stung and threatened him, which was what Abu Sufyan wanted.

The women wailed, recalled the dead of Badr and went among the fighters to urge them on. Hind and the women beat drums behind the men, urging them to fight, and Hind chanted verses. Hind urged Banu ʿAbd al-Dar on. She called them guardians of the rear.

She urged them to strike with every sharp blade. She also chanted that if they advanced the women would embrace them and spread out cushions. A quoted passage says that just before the battle Abu Sufyan sent word to the Ansar to stand aside and leave Quraysh to deal with "our cousin" (the Prophet ﷺ), and they would withdraw from them. It adds that this could not stand against a faith that mountains cannot withstand, and the Ansar answered him harshly.

As the armies drew close, Quraysh tried again through a treacherous agent, Abu ʿAmir ʿAbd ʿAmr ibn Sayfi, called the monk, whom the Messenger ﷺ named the corrupt one (al-fasiq); he had led al-Aws before Islam, openly opposed the Messenger ﷺ, and went to Quraysh to stir them up, promising his people would follow him. He came out first with the Ahabish and Mecca's slaves and called to al-Aws; they answered, may Allah give you no joy, corrupt one, and he fought them fiercely and pelted them with stones.

The paper says Quraysh thus failed again to divide the believers, which made them fear the Muslims more. The polytheists numbered three thousand in ranks, with Khalid ibn al-Walid over the right wing and ʿIkrima over the left, two hundred horses on the flanks, Safwan ibn Umayya over the cavalry (or, it is said, ʿAmr ibn al-ʿAs), a hundred archers under ʿAbd Allah ibn Abi Rabiʿa, and the standard given to Talha ibn Abi Talha.

The preparation of the believers

When Quraysh prepared, al-ʿAbbas, the Prophet's ﷺ uncle, sent word of their intent with a man of Banu Ghifar; Ubayy ibn Kaʿb read it to him at Quba, and he asked him to tell no one. The Prophet ﷺ stayed with Saʿd ibn al-Rabiʿ and told him of the letter.

Saʿd said he hoped there would be good in it. ʿAmr ibn Salim al-Khuzaʿi and a group who had parted from Quraysh at Dhu Tuwa brought him news. On Thursday night he sent Anas and Mu'nis, sons of Fadala, as scouts, who met Quraysh at al-ʿAqiq and reported back. He also sent al-Hubab ibn al-Mundhir, who counted their numbers and equipment; the Prophet ﷺ told them to say nothing of it, and said Allah is enough for us.

Following the principle of consultation (al-shura) that Allah commanded Ali 'Imran 3:159, the Prophet ﷺ consulted his Companions on going out to meet the enemy or staying in Medina. His own view was not to leave, and ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy and the senior Companions, Emigrants and Ansar, agreed. He told them to stay, put the women and children in the fortresses and fight in the alleys, which they knew better; the paper says this was the right view, as Medina was built up on every side like a fortress. But young men who had missed Badr, wanting martyrdom and the enemy, said, take us out to them.

Hamza, Saʿd ibn ʿUbada and al-Nuʿman ibn Malik, with some Ansar, feared the enemy would take their staying as cowardice and grow bold; they recalled Badr, and said they were now many and had long wished for this day. Hamza swore to eat nothing until he fought them with his sword outside Medina.

Malik ibn Sinan, al-Nuʿman ibn Malik and Iyas ibn Aws ibn ʿAtik also favored going out. With many urging it and no specific revelation, the Prophet ﷺ led the Friday prayer, exhorted them to jihad, and told them victory is theirs as long as they are patient. The people were glad; he disliked that course but agreed with them while no revelation came.

Medina stayed on alert, its men keeping their weapons even in prayer. Ansar including Saʿd ibn Muʿadh, Usayd ibn Hudayr and Saʿd ibn ʿUbada spent nights armed at the Prophet's ﷺ door guarding him. Detachments guarded Medina's entrances and passes against surprise. Patrols covered the likely routes to detect enemy movements.

After the Friday prayer the Prophet ﷺ put on his armor, and came out to people who regretted pressing him and offered that he stay. He replied that it is not fitting for a prophet who has put on his armor to take it off until he fights, and he set out with a thousand Companions.

He divided his army into three battalions.

  • The Emigrants, standard to Musʿab ibn ʿUmayr.
  • The Aws, standard to Usayd ibn Hudayr.
  • The Khazraj, standard to al-Hubab ibn al-Mundhir.

The army was a thousand, a hundred armored and fifty horsemen, though it is said there were no horsemen. Ibn Umm Maktum led prayer for those left in Medina; the army moved north, the two Saʿds running ahead of the Prophet ﷺ in armor. He urged his Companions to fight and endure steadfastly, stirring their zeal. He drew a sword and asked who would take it; some looked at it, and when he asked who would take it by its right, they held back. Abu Dujana Simak said he would, and split the heads of the polytheists.

Scenes from the Battle of Uhud

From the paper: «مشاهد من غزوة أحد»

The position of the hypocrites in the battle

The paper says the battle gave the hypocrites a chance to scheme against the believers, especially as the Prophet ﷺ did not follow the view of their leader ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy. When the Prophet ﷺ consulted his Companions, Ibn Ubayy's view to stay in Medina matched his own, but the Prophet ﷺ followed the majority; a true believer would have followed as the Companions did, who regretted pressing him, but Ibn Ubayy and his men took two positions.

The first was returning to Medina with his men after setting out; at a place called al-Shawt he went back with a third of the army, saying the Prophet ﷺ obeyed others and disobeyed him. ʿAbd Allah ibn ʿAmr ibn Haram of Banu Salima followed them, begging them not to abandon their people and Prophet before the enemy; they said they would not have given them up had they known there would be fighting, but saw none coming. When they refused, he said, may Allah keep you far, enemies of Allah, and Allah will do without you for His Prophet.

Despite the danger and the Muslims' need for numbers, the Prophet ﷺ left them and paid them no attention, content to expose them to the people. Allah described the hypocrites and their role in this battle Ali 'Imran 3:167-168. Al-Tabari explains that this refers to ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy ibn Salul and his men, who turned back when the Prophet ﷺ marched to fight the polytheists at Uhud; when the Muslims asked them to fight with them or at least swell their numbers to defend, they said they would have followed had they known there would be fighting.

So they revealed by their words the hostility to the Messenger ﷺ and the believers that they had been hiding. The paper explains that before that day they showed faith with no sign of unbelief; by abandoning the believers' army and speaking so, they moved away from the faith assumed of them and nearer to unbelief.

The paper says they were not truthful in their excuse that they did not know there would be fighting; their hearts held hypocrisy, which puts their own persons and interests above the creed. When wounds and martyrs afflicted the believers, the hypocrites cleared themselves of any blame for the Muslims' suffering and put it on others, and Allah described this group Ali 'Imran 3:154.

The paper explains that "they were preoccupied with themselves" means their souls brought them worry, from discontent with Allah's decree and eager regret over what they thought would have saved them. Their souls were thus in turmoil that kept them from calm and sleep, which the paper likens to a later verse Ali 'Imran 3:156.

The paper says the true faith was not complete in them; they felt lost in an unclear matter, thought they had been pushed into the battle with no will of their own, and still paid dearly in death and wounds without knowing Allah as He is. So they thought of Allah other than the truth, as the Jahiliyya did, imagining that He would abandon them in a battle they had no say in and leave them prey to their enemies.

Their question there is a denial, the paper explains; by it they wanted to clear themselves of blame for the Muslims' suffering at Uhud and put it on others. They thought ill of their Lord, His religion and His Prophet ﷺ, supposing Allah would not complete His Messenger's ﷺ work and that this defeat was decisive against His religion. When Ibn Ubayy was told which Khazraj had been killed, he said this, meaning the Prophet ﷺ had not accepted his advice not to leave Medina.

Allah ordered His Prophet ﷺ to answer those who thought of Him as the Jahiliyya did, that the matter belongs wholly to Allah; neither they nor their enemy have any share, for victory and success are from Him. Allah described the hypocrites as hiding in themselves what they could not show the Prophet ﷺ.

There are three views on what they hid.

  • Their own words, Ali 'Imran 3:154.
  • Their concealing unbelief and doubt about Allah's matter.
  • Regret at having come out with the Muslims at Uhud.

The paper says they wanted to clear themselves of the trial that befell the Muslims, claiming that had their view been followed they would have stayed in Medina. They also put the whole responsibility on the Prophet ﷺ and his Companions, who pressed to go out, and held that had they been in the right they would have won.

Allah answered them, that even in their homes those destined to be killed would have gone out to where they fell, for Allah's decree is not turned back. The paper explains that Allah tests them by what happened, separates the bad from the good, and makes believer and hypocrite clear in word and deed, and knows what lies in hearts.

So the hypocrites were exposed in this battle as never before; had they stayed in the Muslims' ranks the blow would have been greater, and they might have joined the polytheists at the height of fighting. By Allah's mercy their withdrawal purified the army of defeatism and hypocrisy, so the Muslims met their enemy as one solid structure.

The two groups that almost lost heart

When the army marched, the hypocrite leader ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy ibn Salul withdrew with a third of it, which affected some Muslims, and weakness crept into their hearts; Allah explained this Ali 'Imran 3:122. Al-Tabari says the interpreters agree the two groups are Banu Salima and Banu Haritha, and the biographers agree this was at Uhud.

Jabir ibn ʿAbd Allah reports that it came down about them, and that they would not wish it had not come down, because of what Allah says of them Ali 'Imran 3:122. Ibn Hajar explains that Banu Salima are of the Khazraj and Banu Haritha of the Aws; though the verse seems to censure them, its end is the highest honor.

The paper says their intent was to turn away from the Messenger ﷺ when Ibn Ubayy left, out of cowardice, with no doubt about Islam and no hypocrisy. Allah protected them, they went on with the Messenger ﷺ and left Ibn Ubayy, and Allah praised their steadfastness and said He is their ally and helper against the disbelievers.

So Allah took charge of them, and that intent did not take them out of His protection. Al-Zamakhshari says it seems to have been only a passing thought, as the soul in hardship is not free of some alarm before its owner restores it to steadfastness; had it been a firm resolve, the protection would not have held.

The paper explains that His being their ally is His special protection: kindness to His friends, guiding them to their good and shielding them from harm. So when they intended the grave sin of losing heart and fleeing from the Messenger ﷺ, He kept them from it because of their faith, as in another verse Al-Baqarah 2:257.

The paper says this verse trains the believers: Allah sees their deeds on the way to Uhud and guides them to rely on Him, since entering the battlefield needs patience, strength, resolve and trust in Allah.

The position of the believers in the battle

Allah explained what happened to the believers at Uhud: their victory over the enemy at the start, then their wounds because of their failing, disputing and disobeying their Messenger ﷺ. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:152. The paper explains that Allah fulfilled His promise of victory over their enemy at Uhud when they were killing them.

"By His permission" means by His ruling and decree, giving them power over the enemy. Muhammad ibn Kaʿb al-Qurazi reports that when the Prophet ﷺ returned to Medina after the losses, some Companions asked how this had struck them when Allah had promised victory; Allah revealed this verse Ali 'Imran 3:152, and the archers are meant.

When the battle turned, many Muslims fled the field, some withdrew and sat without fighting, and others chose death after news spread that the Prophet ﷺ was killed, among them Anas ibn al-Nadr. He asked Allah's excuse for what his companions had done and declared himself free of what the polytheists did, then advanced; he met Saʿd ibn Muʿadh and said he could smell Paradise from beyond Uhud. Saʿd said he could not match what he did; Anas was found with over eighty wounds, mutilated by the polytheists, and only his sister knew him by his fingertips. Anas said they thought this verse came down about him and his like Al-Ahzab 33:23.

The Prophet ﷺ called his Companions to gather around him, and the Quran records it Ali 'Imran 3:153. The paper distinguishes al-isʿad, going in level ground and valley bottoms, from al-suʿud, climbing mountains, rooftops and stairs. Al-Suddi reports that when the polytheists charged and routed the Muslims, some entered Medina and some climbed the mountain to the rock; the Prophet ﷺ kept calling people to him, and Allah mentions their climbing and his call Ali 'Imran 3:153.

The paper says the wording paints their physical and inner movement in few words: they fled up the mountain in panic, none turning to another or answering the caller, while the Messenger ﷺ called to reassure them of his life after a cry that Muhammad was killed.

The paper explains that the hidden pronoun in "so He repaid you with distress upon distress" refers to Allah, which fits what follows Ali 'Imran 3:154. Al-Qurtubi says "ghamm" in the language means covering. Mujahid, Qatada and others say the first distress was the killing and wounds and the second the rumor that the Prophet ﷺ was killed, when Satan cried out. Another view makes the first what they missed of victory and spoils and the second the killing and defeat.

Another makes the first the defeat and the second Abu Sufyan and Khalid appearing above them on the mountain, which made them forget their other trials, and the Prophet ﷺ prayed that they not overcome them. Al-Qurtubi adds that the particle means "upon", or else that they distressed the Prophet ﷺ by disobeying him and were repaid with distress over their dead.

The paper quotes the verse's closing Ali 'Imran 3:153. The paper says this closing clause is the stated reason for the pardon mentioned in Al-Baqarah 2:52. Some polytheists reached the Prophet ﷺ while he had seven Ansar and two Qurayshis with him; as they pressed him, he asked who would repel them for Paradise, and one Ansari after another fought until all seven were killed.

Talha ibn ʿUbayd Allah then fought for him; Qays reports Talha's hand was paralyzed from shielding the Prophet ﷺ at Uhud. Saʿd ibn Abi Waqqas fought before him as the Prophet ﷺ handed him arrows, saying, shoot, may my father and mother be your ransom. Abu Talha al-Ansari, an archer, defended him, begging him not to look out lest an arrow strike him, saying his own neck was before the Prophet's ﷺ.

The Prophet ﷺ told the man with the quiver to scatter the arrows for Abu Talha. Some women went with the army; Umm Sulayt carried water skins to give the Muslims drink. Hamna bint Jahsh gave drink to the thirsty and treated the wounded, as Muʿawiya reports.

It is sound that ʿA'isha and Umm Sulaym gave the wounded water after the Muslims fell back; Anas reports seeing them carrying water skins on their backs, pouring into the men's mouths, and returning to refill. By the Prophet's ﷺ great steadfastness and his Companions', they mastered the military situation against the polytheists' relative superiority, repelled the attacks and restored morale; the polytheists despaired of finishing the Muslims and withdrew.

The paper says steadfastness in battle is one form of steadfastness Islam trains Muslims in, a sign of strong resolve, will and certainty in the truth, which is why fleeing the battle is counted among the major sins.

The scene of drowsiness

Allah favored the believers at Uhud with great signs that helped them stand firm despite their few numbers and the many enemies. When distress and fear grew heavy and they were worn out, Allah cast drowsiness (al-nuʿas), the beginning of sleep, over them to make them forget their distress, remove tiredness and renew energy, a favor and tranquility from Him Ali 'Imran 3:154.

The paper says drowsiness lifts some hardship while the person is not truly absent; deep sleep would have let the disbelievers attack. Ibn Kathir says this is the tranquility and security Allah sent down, drowsiness over armed men in their worry, and drowsiness in such a state shows security, as at Badr Al-Anfal 8:11.

The paper calls it a wonder that shows Allah's mercy around the believers; even a moment of it on the exhausted and frightened works like magic, pouring calm and rest into their hearts in a way whose nature is unknown. Al-Razi says this drowsiness had benefits.

  • It came over all the believers beyond the usual measure, a clear miracle for the Prophet ﷺ, so their faith grew, their effort against the enemy increased and their trust that Allah fulfills His promise.
  • Sleeplessness brings weakness, while sleep restores strength and energy.
  • While the disbelievers were killing Muslims, Allah cast sleep on the eyes of the rest, so they would not see their dear ones killed and grow fearful.
  • The enemy was extremely eager to kill them, so their staying asleep and safe is among the clearest proofs of Allah's protection, removing fear and building trust in His promise.

Al-Zubayr ibn al-ʿAwwam said that at Uhud when fear grew heavy sleep came upon them, each man's chin on his chest. Abu Talha al-Ansari said drowsiness covered them in their ranks, and his sword kept falling from his hand and he kept picking it up.

In another report Abu Talha said each man was swaying under his shield from drowsiness, and this is what Allah means Ali 'Imran 3:154. ʿAbd Allah ibn al-Zubayr reports from his father that he was overcome by drowsiness at Uhud, and never forgot hearing Muʿattib ibn Qushayr's voice as if in a dream.

The descent of the angels

Among the signs Allah gave the believers at Uhud, the paper says, was that angels were present and defended the Prophet ﷺ; the two Sheikhs report from Saʿd that he saw two men in white at the Prophet's ﷺ right and left, whom he had not seen before or after, meaning Jibril and Mika'il.

The quoted comment says this shows the Prophet's ﷺ honor with Allah, in sending angels to fight with him, and that angels fight and not only at Badr, which is the correct view against those who limit it to Badr. The paper says the angels were there to guard the Prophet ﷺ, and Allah had promised that if the believers were steadfast and mindful of Him, He would aid them with five thousand marked angels; when they disobeyed and the archers left their posts, He lifted the angels' aid.

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:123-125. The paper says Allah set three conditions for the aid: patience, mindfulness of Him, and the polytheists attacking suddenly. Among the angels' deeds at Uhud, they washed Companions who were in a state of major impurity; the Prophet ﷺ said the angels were washing Hanzala ibn Abi ʿAmir, and his wife said he had gone out on hearing the call while impure.

Ibn ʿAbbas reports that Hamza and Hanzala were killed in that state and the Prophet ﷺ saw the angels washing them. The angels also shaded some Companions, such as ʿAbd Allah ibn Haram; his son Jabir reports the Prophet ﷺ said the angels kept shading him with their wings until he was lifted.

The position of the archers

The Prophet ﷺ set up a force of archers under ʿAbd Allah ibn Jubayr and ordered them not to leave their places even if the Muslims appeared to win. Al-Bara' ibn ʿAzib reports that the Prophet ﷺ put fifty men under ʿAbd Allah ibn Jubayr and told them to stay put whether the Muslims were being snatched up or were routing the enemy, until he sent for them. The Muslims routed the enemy, and al-Bara' saw the women fleeing; the archers urged one another to take the spoils, ʿAbd Allah ibn Jubayr reminded them of the Prophet's ﷺ order, but they went anyway, and their faces were turned.

They came back defeated, which is when the Messenger called them from behind; only twelve men were left with the Prophet ﷺ, and seventy of the Muslims were killed. Allah explains what truly happened Ali 'Imran 3:152. Muhammad ibn Kaʿb al-Qurazi again reports the Companions' question about the losses despite the promise of victory, and that this verse came down about the archers Ali 'Imran 3:152.

"You were killing them" means you were annihilating them. The meaning is that Allah fulfilled His promise of victory at the start of Uhud, so they were killing the polytheists heavily by His permission, ease and care. The paper quotes the next part of the verse Ali 'Imran 3:152.

It explains that they lost heart, differed over Allah's command, and disobeyed their Prophet ﷺ, leaving his order; this means the archers he had ordered to stay at the mouth of the pass against Khalid ibn al-Walid and the polytheist cavalry. The paper explains the phrase after the disobedience as the victory Allah showed them, the rout of the polytheists from their women and wealth, before the archers left their places and the polytheist horse came from behind.

Al-Razi asks what the point is of that phrase. He answers that it stresses the gravity of the sin: having seen Allah honor them by fulfilling His promise, they should have refrained from disobedience, so He took away that honor and made them taste the result.

The verse's wording is a rebuke: they saw the beginnings of victory and should have known its completion lies in steadfastness, not flight. Ibn Masʿud said he never thought any Companion loved this world until this verse came down Ali 'Imran 3:152. The paper then quotes the end of the verse Ali 'Imran 3:152.

Ibn ʿAshur explains that the turning away is stated to show it was by Allah's permission and decree, as the killing was, and its wisdom is the trial, so it appears who held to faith, with great secrets in accountability between servant and Lord, left general here to be explained later.

Following this blame with the pardon calms their hearts and is kindness in the Quran's way of rebuking believers. The closing about Allah's bounty confirms the pardon; Ibn ʿAshur thinks it was a pardon due to their interpretation, needing no repentance, or perhaps after their regret and repentance appeared.

The paper says the word "turned you away" shows Uhud was not a defeat, though not a victory either, since defeat means the Muslims turning their backs, enemies capturing some and taking their women and controlling them, and that did not happen. Ibn ʿAbbas reports that the Prophet ﷺ was never given victory in any place as at Uhud; when this was denied, he said the Book of Allah decides between them, citing the verse Ali 'Imran 3:152.

Ibn ʿAbbas explains that "al-hass" is killing, and quotes the verse Ali 'Imran 3:152. He says it means the archers: the Prophet ﷺ posted them and told them to guard the Muslims' backs, not to help if they saw them killed and not to share if they saw them take spoils. When the Muslims took the spoils and the polytheists' camp, the archers left their post and went in to plunder while the Prophet's ﷺ ranks were locked together, and when they left the gap, the horse entered there; the Muslims struck one another, were confused, and many were killed.

From this the paper draws the best way to correct a wrong and guide the one who erred: the Quran dealt gently in commenting on what befell the Muslims at Uhud Ali 'Imran 3:152. This is the opposite of what came down at Badr about the captives Al-Anfal 8:67-68. So the Quran's way of holding the victor to account for mistakes is stricter than with the defeated, as an advising teacher of his community should be.

The paper also draws the importance of obedience in Islam, extremely important in military matters; the Prophet ﷺ stressed to the archers the plain order to guard the rear and do nothing else whatever happened. A quoted passage says the consequences of disobeying orders in this battle teach Muslims the value of obedience, for a group not ruled by one command, or dominated by individual impulses, does not succeed in conflict and brings itself no honor in war or peace.

All nations, believing or not, know this, so soldiering rests on complete obedience and a nation at war makes its parties one front and one will and quells any rebellion; good soldiering is like good command, since giving orders needs wisdom and carrying them out needs restraint, but obedience brings the group great good.

The rumor that the Prophet ﷺ was killed

The paper says psychological warfare has great power to break the will, and the polytheists used it: the criminal Ibn Qamiʾa killed Musʿab ibn ʿUmayr, thinking him the Prophet ﷺ because he looked like him, and told the polytheists that Muhammad was killed. Satan cried out near Mount ʿAynayn, in the form of Jaʿal ibn Suraqa, three times that Muhammad was killed, and none doubted it. Some Muslims then said that if the Messenger ﷺ was killed they should fight for their religion until they met Allah as martyrs, while others wished for a messenger to Ibn Ubayy to get them safety from Abu Sufyan, and said to return to their people.

The Muslims became mixed up and struck one another in haste and confusion. Allah reminded the believers of what they did when it was rumored that the Messenger ﷺ was killed, and verses came down establishing the fixed truth that the Prophet ﷺ is a human being who will die like other humans, set apart only by the message Allah gave him Ali 'Imran 3:144-145.

Al-Tabari gives the general meaning: Muhammad is a messenger like those Allah sent before, who died when their terms ended. So Muhammad ﷺ is, in what Allah does with him, like the messengers who passed before him. Al-Tabari continues that Allah rebukes the Companions for their panic when told at Uhud that Muhammad was killed, and condemns those who turned from the enemy; turning back, he says, means apostasy from the religion into disbelief after the truth of the message was clear Ali 'Imran 3:144.

Ibn Kathir says that when some Muslims fled and some were killed at Uhud, Satan cried that Muhammad was killed, and Ibn Qamiʾa told the polytheists he killed him, though he had only struck the Prophet ﷺ and wounded his head. That fell into many hearts, bringing weakness and holding back from fighting, and about this Allah revealed the verse.

Al-Tabari reports that among those at the rock, some wished for a messenger to Ibn Ubayy to get safety from Abu Sufyan and said to return to their people. Anas ibn al-Nadr said that if Muhammad was killed, Muhammad's Lord was not, so they should fight for what he fought for; he asked Allah's excuse for what they said, charged with his sword and fought until killed.

A quoted passage says the verse guides Allah's servants to a state in which losing a leader, however great, does not shake their faith. That is by preparing in every religious matter several capable people, so if one is lost another takes over, and the believers aim at establishing Allah's religion and striving for it, not at one leader over another.

A group of the army returned to Medina when the killing of the Prophet ﷺ was rumored, and Allah spoke of this group and said He pardoned it Ali 'Imran 3:155. Ibn al-Jawzi says the reason given for their flight is that they heard the Prophet ﷺ was killed and allowed themselves to flee, as Ibn ʿAbbas said.

The paper explains that "Satan caused them to slip" means he invited them to the slip and carried them to it, and the verse announces that Allah forgave the Companions' flight at Uhud. In general, the paper says, it depicts the human soul when it commits a sin: it loses trust in its strength, its tie to Allah weakens, its balance fails and it becomes open to whispers, and Satan leads it from slip to slip, far from the safe refuge.

When the news spread, Anas ibn al-Nadr reached ʿUmar ibn al-Khattab and Talha ibn ʿUbayd Allah among men who had thrown down their hands; he asked what they were sitting for and they said the Messenger ﷺ was killed. He said, what will you do with life after him, rise and die on what he died on, then faced the enemy and fought until killed; seventy wounds were found on him and only his sister knew him by his fingertips.

The first to learn the Messenger ﷺ was alive was Kaʿb ibn Malik, who called out the good news to the Muslims, but the Messenger ﷺ ordered him to be silent so the polytheists would not notice. The paper quotes the verse again Ali 'Imran 3:144. It is clear evidence of the need to hold to the message and the sound way, and beware of attachment to persons; al-Qurtubi says Allah announced in it that messengers do not remain among their people forever and that one must hold to what they brought even if the messenger is lost by death or killing.

He adds that this completes the rebuke of those who fled, since they had no right to flee even if Muhammad were killed; prophethood does not ward off death, and religions do not vanish with the death of prophets.

The end of the battle

When the polytheists despaired of a decisive victory and tired of the Muslims' steadfastness, they stopped fighting in the passes of Uhud, and Abu Sufyan looked down and asked whether Muhammad, Abu Bakr and ʿUmar were among the people. The Prophet ﷺ told them not to answer; Abu Sufyan said they must have been killed, and ʿUmar could not hold back and called him a liar and enemy of Allah. Abu Sufyan cried the glory of Hubal, and the Prophet ﷺ told them to answer that Allah is higher and more majestic; he claimed al-ʿUzza, and they were told to answer that Allah is their protector and the disbelievers have none.

Abu Sufyan said it was a day for the day of Badr, war goes by turns, and they would find mutilation which he had not ordered and did not mind. The polytheists then withdrew, content with what they had gained, and the Prophet ﷺ sent a party headed by ʿAli ibn Abi Talib to see what they did. He said that if they had led off the horses and mounted the camels they were heading for Mecca, but if they rode the horses and drove the camels they meant Medina, and he would then march and fight them. ʿAli found they were heading for Mecca.

ʿAli reported this; the battle had been on Saturday mid-Shawwal, and the next day, Sunday the sixteenth, the Prophet's ﷺ caller announced pursuit of the enemy, and seventy volunteered. He allowed only those present the day before, and permitted Jabir ibn ʿAbd Allah to join. The paper says this march was to alarm the enemy and make them think what befell the Muslims had not weakened them; the seventy included senior Companions, and they answered Allah and His Messenger ﷺ, whom Allah praised Ali 'Imran 3:172.

Al-Bukhari cites the verse Ali 'Imran 3:172 and reports from ʿA'isha, to ʿUrwa, that his father al-Zubayr and grandfather Abu Bakr were among the seventy who volunteered when the Prophet ﷺ feared the polytheists would return. Al-Tabari reports through Ibn ʿAbbas that they included Abu Bakr, ʿUmar, ʿUthman, ʿAli, al-Zubayr, Saʿd, Talha, ʿAbd al-Rahman ibn ʿAwf, Ibn Masʿud, Hudhayfa and Abu ʿUbayda.

Al-Qurtubi mentions that two hundred believers set out with the Prophet ﷺ. Ibn Jarir says the verse means those who followed the Messenger ﷺ to Hamra' al-Asad, eight miles from Medina, in pursuit of Abu Sufyan, so people would see he and his Companions had strength against their enemy.

A caravan of ʿAbd al-Qays passed Abu Sufyan, who asked where they were going, and they said to Medina for supplies. He asked them to carry a message to Muhammad in return for raisins at ʿUkaz: that they had resolved to march on him and his Companions to finish off the remainder. The caravan passed the Messenger ﷺ at Hamra' al-Asad and told him, and he said Allah is enough for us and the best protector.

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:173. The paper says this shows Muslims must watch their enemies' plans keenly, learn their aims, stand ready to repel them, and show that they can, by Allah's permission, foil their schemes. At the end the Prophet ﷺ ordered the martyrs buried, seventy of them; Anas ibn Malik reports seventy Ansar were killed, which the paper says fits the verse Ali 'Imran 3:165.

Jabir reports the Prophet ﷺ put two of the dead in one cloth, asked which knew more Quran, placed that one first in the grave, and said he would be witness over them on the Day of Resurrection. He ordered them buried in their blood, without washing or funeral prayer.

No Muslim was captured; twenty-two of Quraysh were killed, and the poet Abu ʿIzza was captured and executed, because he broke his promise made when freed at Badr not to fight the Prophet ﷺ, and fought at Uhud. A quoted passage says calling what befell the Muslims a defeat does not fit the facts, for defeat would mean the believing army fled and the other pursued it to Medina.

The attackers ended the fighting, content with a killing of Muslims and unable to do more, having tasted the Muslim swords twice, which is why the Prophet ﷺ pursued them. If Uhud is not a defeat, it is not a victory for either side either; it may be called wounds for the Muslims, as the Quran named it Ali 'Imran 3:140.

Qur'anic guidance after the battle

From the paper: «التوجيهات القرآنية بعد نهاية الغزوة»

Prohibition of ghulul (stealing from the spoils)

Ghulul is stealing from the spoils before they are divided; the paper says it is forbidden by consensus and is a major sin. It cites a hadith from Abu Hurayra in which the Prophet ﷺ stood, spoke gravely of ghulul, and warned that a man would come on the Day of Resurrection carrying what he stole on his neck, begging for help, and the Prophet ﷺ would say he can do nothing for him, having conveyed the message.

In Surat Al Imran, Allah denies ghulul of His Prophet ﷺ Ali 'Imran 3:161. The paper explains that "it is not for a prophet" means it is not in his nature or character at all, so the negation denies that the act could occur, not merely that it is lawful; a prophet's trustworthy, just and chaste nature would never commit it.

It explains that the one who commits ghulul will come with it on his back on the Day of Resurrection, as the sound hadith reports, exposing him before creation. This confirms the prohibition and puts people off it, since the punishment is before all; the verse is general for anyone who earns good or evil, with the thief included first because the context concerns him.

Ibn al-Jawzi says there are seven views on why this verse came down.

  • A cloak was missing from the spoils at Badr, and some said perhaps the Prophet ﷺ took it, reported by ʿIkrima from Ibn ʿAbbas.
  • A man stole from the spoils of Hawazin at Hunayn, reported by al-Dahhak from Ibn ʿAbbas.
  • Some nobles asked the Prophet ﷺ to give them a special share of the spoils, also reported from Ibn ʿAbbas.
  • The Prophet ﷺ sent out scouts, then took spoils and did not give them a share, and they complained, said al-Dahhak.
  • Some people stole at Badr, said Qatada.
  • It came down about those who left their post at Uhud for spoils, fearing the Prophet ﷺ would say that whoever took something could keep it; he asked whether he had not made them promise to stay, and whether they thought he would steal, said Ibn al-Saʾib and Muqatil.
  • It came down about dishonesty with the revelation, said al-Qurazi and Ibn Ishaq.

The paper notes that the sixth view puts it at Uhud, and the verse appears in the discussion of Uhud. Muhammad Rashid Rida says the verse came down about the Prophet ﷺ within the rulings about Uhud, though Abu Dawud and al-Tirmidhi, who graded it hasan, report from Ibn ʿAbbas that it came down about a red cloak lost at Badr Ali 'Imran 3:161.

He adds that some commentators weakened that report, though al-Tirmidhi graded it hasan, because the whole context is Uhud, and preferred the report from al-Kalbi and Muqatil about the archers; the correct view is that the verse belongs to this battle, like the verses before it and many after.

Al-Alusi says the aim is to clear the Prophet ﷺ in the strongest way of what the archers thought of him at Uhud. He reports al-Wahidi from al-Kalbi and Muqatil that the archers who left their post for spoils feared he would say that whoever took something could keep it and would not divide the spoils, as at Badr, and the Prophet ﷺ said they thought he would steal and not share; for this the verse came down. Or it clears him of what some hypocrites accused him of at Badr, as in the report of the cloak, but the first report better suits the place, since the story is of Uhud.

The merit of martyrdom

Allah praised the martyrs and those who joined the highest company at Uhud, fighting in His cause in faithfulness to their pledge to Him; the praise is in several verses, including Ali 'Imran 3:169-171. Several hadiths are given on why these verses came down.

Ibn ʿAbbas reports the Prophet ﷺ said that when their brothers were hit at Uhud, Allah put their souls in green birds that visit the rivers of Paradise, eat its fruit and shelter in golden lamps under the Throne; they asked who would tell their brothers they are alive and provided for, so they would not lose zeal for jihad or shrink in war, and Allah said He would tell them. Then Allah revealed Ali 'Imran 3:169.

Masruq says they asked ʿAbd Allah about this verse Ali 'Imran 3:169. He answered that they had asked the Prophet ﷺ, who said their souls are in green birds with lamps hung from the Throne, roaming Paradise as they wish; their Lord looked on them and asked if they desired anything, and after three times they asked that their souls return to their bodies to be killed in His cause again, and when He saw they had no need, they were left.

Sa'id ibn Jubayr, in Ibn Abi Shayba's Musannaf, reports that when Hamza and Musʿab were killed at Uhud they said they wished their brothers knew the good they got, and Allah said He would tell them, and the following verses came down Ali 'Imran 3:170 Ali 'Imran 3:171. Jabir reports that the Prophet ﷺ found him downcast because his father was killed leaving dependents and debt, and told him what Allah met his father with: Allah spoke to him without a veil and asked him to wish for anything.

His father asked to be brought back to be killed in His cause again, and Allah said it was already decreed that they do not return; then this verse came down Ali 'Imran 3:169. The paper explains that the verse forbids thinking the martyrs dead and shows they are alive with their Lord and provided for; the Prophet ﷺ is told not to think of them as dead, feeling nothing, but as living in comfort, joyful at His honor and generous reward.

A verse in Surat al-Ahzab, the commentators say, came down about some of the martyrs of Uhud Al-Ahzab 33:23. There are reports on why it came down.

  • About Anas ibn al-Nadr, who missed Badr and told the Prophet ﷺ that if Allah let him witness a battle with the polytheists, Allah would see what he does; at Uhud when the Muslims broke, he asked Allah's excuse for his companions' act and cleared himself of the polytheists', and advanced; he met Saʿd ibn Muʿadh and said he smelled Paradise beyond Uhud.
  • Anas reports over eighty wounds were found on him, the polytheists had mutilated him, only his sister knew him by his fingertips, and they thought the verse came down about him and his like Al-Ahzab 33:23.
  • About Talha ibn ʿUbayd Allah: the Companions, in awe of the Prophet ﷺ, had a Bedouin ask him who the verse meant; he turned away three times, then saw Talha in green clothes and said this one is of them.
  • About Musʿab ibn ʿUmayr and his companions at Uhud: Abu Hurayra reports the Prophet ﷺ stood over the slain Musʿab on his way back, prayed for him, and recited the verse Al-Ahzab 33:23.

The Prophet ﷺ then said he witnessed that they are martyrs with Allah on the Day of Resurrection, so visit them, for no one greets them until the Day of Resurrection but they return it. The paper says the verse apparently applies to everyone killed in Allah's cause after striving with sincerity and steadfastness, since what counts is the generality of the wording, not the specific occasion.

General guidance for the believers

After Uhud, Allah gave His believing servants many directions, including the following.

Not imitating the hypocrites

Allah forbade the believers from taking on the traits of the disbelievers. One is the disbelievers' saying to their brothers in disbelief who traveled for trade or war and died or were killed by Allah's decree that had they stayed, they would not have died or been killed. The paper says that, by Allah's way, this saying brings them psychological distress and heartache that tear at them and may even kill them. Those ignorant disbelievers did not know that Allah gives life and death: neither travel nor fighting kills, and sitting at home in cowardice does not give life.

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:156. Al-Tabari explains that believers are told not to be like those who rejected the Prophet ﷺ and said this of their brothers who went out for trade or war and died or were killed. He adds it is said that those the believers are forbidden to imitate in this poor certainty of Allah are ʿAbd Allah ibn Ubayy ibn Salul and his men.

The paper says from the context that these were the words of the hypocrites who turned back before the battle and of the polytheists of Medina who had not entered Islam but still had ties and kinship with the Muslims. They used the deaths of the martyrs at Uhud to stir grief in their families over those lost by going out, which, the paper says, bleeds and leaves confusion in the Muslim ranks.

So this Quranic statement corrected values and views and turned the scheme back on its authors, warning the Muslims not to be like the disbelievers, struck with regret whenever a relative dies traveling for livelihood or is killed striving.

Not obeying the disbelievers

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:149-151. The paper explains it is addressed to those who believed in Allah's promise, threat, commands and prohibitions: if they obey those who rejected their Prophet's ﷺ prophethood, among the Jews and Christians, and accept their advice, they would push them into apostasy, so they would return from their faith ruined, losing themselves, their religion, this world and the Hereafter.

It is a prohibition on obeying the disbelieving hypocrites and polytheists, who wish them only harm and want to return them to disbelief, whose end is loss. Then Allah says He is their ally and helper, which is news and good tidings that He will manage their affairs with His kindness and protect them from all kinds of evil.

This also urges them to take Him alone as ally; part of His help is His promise to cast terror, a fear that blocks many aims, into their enemies hearts, and He did. One sign of the terror He cast in the polytheists' hearts is that, after beating the Muslims at Uhud, they could have pressed on in attacking and fighting them, but terror stopped them.

Encouragement to martyrdom in Allah's cause

Allah encouraged martyrdom in His cause and showed it to be a cause of forgiveness and mercy Ali 'Imran 3:157-158. The paper explains the believers are not to doubt, as the hypocrites did, that all matters are in Allah's hand, life and death included, so they should fight His enemies sure that none is killed in war or dies in travel except one whose term has come. He then promised forgiveness and mercy for their striving and said that death or killing in His cause is better than what they amass of this world's goods and comfort, for which they hold back from jihad and from meeting the enemy.

Taking counsel

The Prophet ﷺ consulted his Companions on staying in Medina and fortifying it or going out to meet the polytheists. His view was to stay, and he said he was in a shield (junna); Ibn Ubayy's view matched his, but men of the Muslims who missed Badr said to go out.

Ibn Kathir says many insisted on going out and did not defer to the Messenger's ﷺ view, and had they accepted what he ordered it would have been so, but the decree prevailed; most who advised going out had not been at Badr and knew the merit of Badr's men.

Allah commanded His Prophet ﷺ to take up the principle of consultation Ali 'Imran 3:159. Al-Tabari says Allah commanded him to consult his Companions on what troubled him of his enemy and war plans, to win over those whose insight into Islam was not yet secure against Satan's temptation, and to teach his community how to handle matters after him, so they take counsel as they saw him do. For the Prophet ﷺ, Allah showed the right course by revelation or inspiration, but his community, if they consult in following him, truthfully seeking the right, wanting what is correct with no inclination to desire or deviation from guidance, Allah will guide and grant success.

The paper calls this one of the greatest practical lessons from the Prophet ﷺ: his view was to fight in the city, but when the majority differed on a matter open to judgment, he yielded to them, a superb application of consultation.

Victory is in Allah's hand

When Allah writes victory for the believers, no power on earth can prevent it, and when He writes defeat, none can stop it. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:160. The paper explains that if Allah supports them with His help, none can overcome them even if everyone on earth with all their numbers and equipment gathered against them, for none can contend with Allah, who holds every creature by the forelock and nothing moves or stills but by His leave.

If He abandons them to themselves, the paper says, they must be defeated even if all creation helped them.

Patience

The believers are commanded to be patient, following the followers of earlier messengers. At the battle's end, Allah told of the many earlier prophets with large numbers fighting beside them, who did not weaken at the wounds or killing they suffered, since it was in their Lord's cause, nor give in to their enemy, but were patient.

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:146-148. Ibn Kathir says Allah used these verses and those before to rebuke those who fled at Uhud, left the fight or heard the cry that Muhammad was killed.

Prophetic leadership in the battle

From the paper: «القيادة النبوية في الغزوة»

The Prophet's ﷺ leadership showed itself at Uhud in several matters.

Gathering information about the enemy

The Prophet ﷺ learned early of Quraysh's preparation, when al-ʿAbbas sent an urgent letter with all the details of the army. The messenger covered the road from Mecca to Medina in three days and handed it to the Prophet ﷺ in the mosque of Quba. Ubayy ibn Kaʿb read it to him, he ordered secrecy, returned to Medina and exchanged views with the leaders of the Emigrants and Ansar.

He sent al-Hubab ibn al-Mundhir among the enemy, who estimated about three thousand, two hundred horses and seven hundred visible coats of mail. He also sent two scouts, Anas and Mu'nis, who reported that the enemy had let their camels and horses graze the crop at al-ʿAridh until no green was left.

The paper says this shows his concern for information, and he learned the enemy's strength and numbers.

Taking counsel

He asked his Companions for advice on learning Quraysh was coming, to reach a sound decision, ease their minds, learn their thinking, and make them eager to fight, knowing they shared the decision.

Security of Medina

He took several security measures to protect Medina, first appointing Ibn Umm Maktum over it. He sent ʿAli ibn Abi Talib to follow the enemy and see whether their mounts showed they were heading for Mecca or Medina, and ʿAli found them heading for Mecca.

The paper says a leader must care for his own inner security, so he is not caught unaware.

Choosing the right position

He camped facing Medina with his back to the Uhud ridges, so the enemy lay between the Muslims and Medina, a great benefit in protecting the army's rear. The fifth matter was preparing for battle, arranging the ranks and equipping the army. He chose fifty archers under ʿAbd Allah ibn Jubayr and ordered them not to leave their place whether the Muslims were snatched up or routing the enemy, until he sent for them.

He told them to hold their place even if the Muslims chased the enemy into their camp, not to help if they were killed, but to shoot arrows, for horses do not advance on arrows; the Muslims would keep winning while they stayed, and he called Allah to witness against them.

The paper says he thereby controlled the heights near the battle. Allah showed how his leadership went from the start of the battle Ali 'Imran 3:121. The paper explains it means he showed them their positions, right and left, walking to straighten the lines, telling men to move forward or back, even setting back a man whose shoulder stuck out.

"Al-ghudu" is going out in the morning, though he left after the Friday prayer; the paper says it can mean going out without regard to its original sense. It calls the verse the greatest praise of the Prophet ﷺ: he personally arranged their positions, from his full knowledge, sound view, high resolve and complete courage.

The sixth matter was organizing the night guard and choosing fifty men to guard the camp. At night where he had reviewed the army, he chose fifty men under Muhammad ibn Maslama to patrol the camp, while Dhakwan ibn ʿAbd Qays guarded him. The seventh was sending back the young who could not fight.

At a place called al-Shaykhan he reviewed the army and sent back those too young, among them ʿAbd Allah ibn ʿUmar, Usama ibn Zayd, Zayd ibn Thabit and Abu Saʿid al-Khudri. He let Rafiʿ ibn Khadij and Samura ibn Jundub join despite their age: Rafiʿ was a skilled archer, and Samura was stronger, throwing Rafiʿ in a wrestle before the Prophet ﷺ.

Ibn Ishaq says the Prophet ﷺ went on until he camped in the pass of Uhud on the valley's side by the mountain. The eighth was placing fifty archers on the archers' mountain. He chose fifty skilled archers under ʿAbd Allah ibn Jubayr ibn al-Nuʿman al-Ansari to take position on a hill on the southern bank of Wadi Qanat, about a hundred and fifty meters from the army, later known as the Archers' Mountain.

To stress that they not leave their places, he told their commander to drive off the horse with arrows so they would not come from behind, and to stay put whether it went for or against them.

Tactical withdrawal

When the archers disobeyed and the army was encircled, Companions gathered around the Prophet ﷺ, including Abu Bakr, ʿUmar, ʿAli, Talha, al-Zubayr and al-Harith ibn al-Simma. He led an orderly withdrawal to the mountain pass, cutting a way through the attacking polytheists for the rest of the army, so the encirclement meant to destroy it failed.

Making decisions

He decided to go out to meet his enemy, and made other decisions in the battle and after it. One was to execute the captive Abu ʿIzza al-Jumahi, whom he had captured at Badr and freed; Abu ʿIzza asked to be excused, but the Prophet ﷺ said he would not wipe his cheeks in Mecca claiming to have deceived Muhammad twice, and ordered al-Zubayr to strike his neck. Ibn Hisham reports from Saʿid ibn al-Musayyab that the Prophet ﷺ said a believer is not stung twice from the same hole, and ordered ʿAsim ibn Thabit to strike his neck.

Ordering the march to Hamra' al-Asad the morning after Uhud, he decided that only those who were with him at Uhud could go, and allowed Jabir ibn ʿAbd Allah, who asked, to come.

Not rebuking his Companions

When most chose to go out, he did not rebuke them despite their pains and wounds. The paper says the Prophetic leadership had the right to drop consultation after the battle, given the split in ranks and bitter results, but Islam was building a community to lead humankind. Allah knew nations are best trained for leadership by consultation, bearing responsibility and erring, however gravely, so they learn to correct mistakes and bear consequences. The paper says they learn what is right only by practicing error, and losses do not matter if the result is a trained community.

The twelfth was that he was a good example of patience for his Companions. He was badly hurt: he fell into a pit dug by Abu ʿAmir the corrupt, his face was cut, and two helmet rings entered his cheek. He was deeply hurt by the loss of his uncle and foster brother Hamza, yet bore it all with patience.

Lessons from the Battle of Uhud

From the paper: «الدروس المستفادة من غزوة أحد»

Allah described Uhud precisely, laying bare the hidden parts of hearts, and mentioned great lessons for the Muslim on the way to his Lord, including these.

Disobedience and dispute hold back victory

The first lesson, the paper says, is that disobedience and dispute hold back victory from the community: through the archers' disobeying the Prophet's ﷺ order and their disagreement over the spoils, victory left the community after its first signs had appeared. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:152. The paper notes that the Muslims won at first when they followed the Messenger's ﷺ orders, then were beaten when they disobeyed and the archers came down the mountain to gather spoils with the rest of the Companions.

Allah also says Ali 'Imran 3:153. And He says Ali 'Imran 3:165. The paper explains that the first verse ends with Allah's power after saying the blow is from themselves, to tell them of His power joined with justice, that He is just and able. Mentioning His power there carries a subtle point: the matter is in His hand, and had He willed He would have turned it from them, so they should not seek relief from others nor rely on anyone else; He made this plain in a following verse Ali 'Imran 3:166.

Then He told of the wisdom of this decree: to know the believers from the hypocrites by clear sight, so the two groups are plainly distinguished. The hypocrites spoke what was in their souls and the believers heard it and Allah's answer; the paper adds that this story holds many wisdoms, warnings and knowledge of the causes of good and evil and their outcomes.

Love of this world can creep into believers' hearts

The second lesson is that love of this world and attachment to it may creep into the hearts of the faithful and righteous, perhaps unnoticed; Allah described the believers when they saw the spoils Ali 'Imran 3:152. The Quran shines light on hidden parts of hearts that the Muslims themselves did not know were there.

Ibn Masʿud said he never thought any Companion wanted this world until the verse came down about them at Uhud Ali 'Imran 3:152. So Allah puts their hearts open before them and shows them where defeat came from, so they guard against it.

Taking martyrs

The third lesson is the taking of martyrs from among them. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:140. The paper calls it a wondrous expression of deep meaning: martyrs are chosen by Allah from among the fighters for Himself, so it is no calamity or loss when one is martyred, but selection and honor, singling them out for His nearness.

Paradise is costly

The fourth is that Paradise is precious and is reached only over the bridge of hardship and patience under trial; Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:142. The paper explains that the question strongly rebukes the idea that it is enough to say with the tongue that one has submitted and is ready to die; rather there is real trial, jihad, meeting hardship and patience under its burdens.

Purifying the believers

The fifth is the purification of the believers, distinguishing them from the hypocrites, and the destruction of the disbelievers, who deserve Allah's anger and punishment, all gathered by Allah in Ali 'Imran 3:139-141. Allah separated the true believer from the false hypocrite: after Badr, when His help gave the Muslims renown, some joined Islam outwardly without inner faith, so His wisdom sent a trial that told believer from hypocrite. The hypocrites showed themselves in this battle and spoke what they hid, their hints became open statements, people were clearly divided into disbeliever, believer and hypocrite, and the believers learned they had an enemy among them and guarded against him.

Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:179.

Taking the means

The sixth is the importance of taking the means: the Prophet ﷺ took all the material means that help to victory after Allah, to teach his community; he went into his house with Abu Bakr and ʿUmar, who turbaned and dressed him, and he armed himself with two coats of mail and a sword before going out.

When those who had pressed him to go out said they should not have opposed him and he could stay in Medina if he wished, he said it is not fitting for a prophet who has put on his armor to take it off until Allah judges between him and his enemy.

The fate of earlier nations

The seventh is reminding the believers of the fate of earlier nations that denied Allah's call, and how His way with them was destruction because of their disbelief, wrongdoing and defiance of His command. Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:137.

Consoling the believers

The eighth is consoling the believers for the killing and wounds at Uhud; Allah says Ali 'Imran 3:139. Al-Tabari says this is Allah's consolation to the Prophet's ﷺ Companions for the wounds and killing at Uhud. He explains it means they should not weaken from fighting their enemy because of what they suffered, nor grieve over the calamity, for they are the uppermost and have a good end in victory, if they believe the Prophet ﷺ in what he promises and tells of their outcome and theirs.

Allah also consoled His believing servants Ali 'Imran 3:140. Part of His consolation in this battle is Ali 'Imran 3:146-148. Al-Saʿdi says this consoles the believers and urges them to follow those people, as this is an earlier matter and Allah's way has not ceased; the verse means how many prophets had many groups of followers, whom the prophets trained in faith and good deeds, fight beside them and suffer killing and wounds Ali 'Imran 3:146.

He explains that their hearts did not weaken, nor their bodies, nor did they humble themselves to their enemy, but were patient, steadfast and encouraged themselves Ali 'Imran 3:146.

Death is written for everyone

The ninth is that death is written for everyone, and the Messenger will die like others, since every soul tastes death; his task was to convey what he was sent with, which he did, and staying forever with his people is not part of his message, so none is immortal in this world.

Ibn al-Qayyim says Uhud was a prelude to the Messenger's ﷺ death, so Allah steadied them and rebuked them for turning back Ali 'Imran 3:144. He says their duty was to hold to his religion and monotheism and die on it, for they worship Muhammad's Lord, who is living and does not die; Muhammad ﷺ was not sent to live forever, nor they, but that they die on Islam.

The grateful, he says, are those who knew the worth of the blessing and held to it until they died or were killed; the effect of this rebuke showed when the Messenger ﷺ died, some turned back on their heels, the grateful held to their religion, and Allah gave them victory, honor and the good end.

Takeaways

  1. Disobedience and dispute hold back victory

    The paper says that through the archers' disobeying the Prophet's ﷺ order and disputing over the spoils, victory left the community after its first signs had appeared.

  2. Love of this world can hide in believers' hearts

    The paper says love of this world and attachment to it may creep into the hearts of the faithful and righteous, perhaps unnoticed. It says the Quran shines light on parts of hearts the Muslims themselves did not know were there.

  3. Martyrs are chosen

    The paper says martyrs are chosen by Allah from among the fighters for Himself, so their death is selection and honor rather than loss.

  4. Taking the means

    The paper says the Prophet ﷺ took all the material means that help toward victory after Allah, in order to teach his community.

  5. Death is written for everyone

    The paper says death is written for everyone and the Messenger will die like others, because every soul tastes death. It says staying forever with his people is not part of his message.

Reflect

  • Where might love of comfort or gain be quietly pulling at my own sense of duty?
  • When I disagree with a decision and it goes against my view, how do I respond to those who decided?
  • How do I react when a hardship or a loss comes, and whom do I blame first?
  • What do I hold to when a person I look up to is no longer there?

Every verse in the paper

All 47 verses the research paper discusses, grouped under its own headings.

Introducing the Battle of Uhud «التعريف بغزوة أحد»

Why it is recounted in Surat Al Imran «ثانيًا: حكمة ورودها في سورة آل عمران»

3:121, 3:179, 3:120, 3:154, 3:118

Causes of the battle «أسباب الغزوة»

8:36

Preparing for the battle «الإعداد للغزوة»

The preparation of the polytheists «أولًا: إعداد المشركين»

8:36

The preparation of the believers «ثانيًا: إعداد المؤمنين»

3:159

Scenes from the Battle of Uhud «مشاهد من غزوة أحد»

The position of the hypocrites in the battle «أولًا: موقف المنافقين في الغزوة»

3:167-168, 3:154, 3:156

The two groups that almost lost heart «ثانيًا: موقف الطائفتين اللتين همتا بالفشل»

3:122, 2:257

The position of the believers in the battle «ثالثًا: موقف المؤمنين في الغزوة»

3:152, 33:23, 3:153, 3:154, 2:52

The scene of drowsiness «رابعًا: مشهد النعاس»

3:154, 8:11

The descent of the angels «خامسًا: تنزل الملائكة»

3:123-125

The position of the archers «سادسًا: موقف الرماة»

3:152, 8:67-68

The rumor that the Prophet ﷺ was killed «سابعًا: مشهد إشاعة مقتل النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم»

3:144-145, 3:155

The end of the battle «ثامنًا: نهاية الغزوة»

3:172, 3:173, 3:165, 3:140

Qur'anic guidance after the battle «التوجيهات القرآنية بعد نهاية الغزوة»

Prohibition of ghulul (stealing from the spoils) «أولًا: تحريم الغلول»

3:161

The merit of martyrdom «ثانيًا: فضل الشهادة»

3:169-171, 33:23

General guidance for the believers «ثالثًا: توجيهات عامة للمؤمنين»

3:156, 3:149-151, 3:157-158, 3:159, 3:160, 3:146-148

Prophetic leadership in the battle «القيادة النبوية في الغزوة»

3:121

Lessons from the Battle of Uhud «الدروس المستفادة من غزوة أحد»

3:152, 3:153, 3:165, 3:166, 3:142, 3:139-141, 3:179, 3:137, 3:146-148, 3:144

About this source

موسوعة التفسير الموضوعي للقرآن الكريم

مركز تفسير للدراسات القرآنية

Volume
13
Research paper
«غزوة أحد» (Battle of Uhud)

Read the full paper (Arabic)

Encyclopedia of Thematic Tafsir of the Noble Quran, published by the Tafsir Center for Quranic Studies.

This study guide summarizes the Arabic research paper. For full scholarly detail, refer to the original. This preview has not been reviewed yet.

Browse all Quran topics